Analysis: Rachel Reeves Has Been Left Humiliated By Winter Fuel U-Turn

The chancellor explained her decision on Sky News.She tried to put a brave face on it, but there is no doubt that the U-turn on her decision to remove winter fuel payments from 10 million pensioners is a humiliation for Rachel Reeves.The chancellor confirmed today that she was raising the income threshold to qualify for the benefit, meaning millions more old folk will qualify for it this year.Her climbdown followed a furious public backlash to the policy – and mounting anger among Labour MPs.Reeves’ reputation as an “iron chancellor” has taken a battering from which it may never recover.What’s more, her explanation for why she has junked one of her signature policies does not stand up to a moment’s scrutiny.She told Sky News: “I had to make urgent decisions last year to put the public finances back on a firm footing. We inherited a £22 billion in-year black hole in the public finances.“I was always clear that the number one priority of this government was to return stability to the economy.“We did that with a number of difficult decisions, but because of those decisions our public finances are now in a better position, which means that this year we’re able to pay the winter fuel payment to more pensioners.”But it is misleading in the extreme to suggest that, after 11 months of a Labour government, everything in the Treasury garden is now rosy.Both the Office for Budget Responsibility and the OECD have downgraded their forecasts for the UK economy, not least because the impact of Donald Trump’s tariffs have yet to take effect.The idea that there is suddenly a load of spare cash to pay the £1.5 billion the winter fuel U-turn will cost is simply not true.Indeed, Downing Street has admitted that we’ll need to wait until the autumn Budget to find out how it will be paid for. How’s that for a fiscal black hole?If the Treasury’s calculations are to be believed, the new set-up will save the government £450 million. That doesn’t sound like an awful lot of money for all of the political pain the chancellor has had to endure.On Wednesday, Reeves will announce how much money each government department will have to spend over the next three years as she unveils the result of her spending review.She was already under huge pressure to explain how she plans to make the government’s sums add up. The winter fuel shambles means she has even less room for manoeuvre.Related...Revealed: Which Pensioners Will Get Winter Fuel Payments Again After Labour U-TurnRachel Reeves Confirms More Pensioners Will Get Their Winter Fuel Payments This Year'Cack-Handed': Laura Kuenssberg Slams Labour's U-Turn Over Winter Fuel Payments

Comments

Breaking news

Domestic violence impact on women’s mental health can last almost 30 years

The Herald

Dailymail

32-HOUR flight to NOWHERE after flight to Crete suffers so many aborted landing attempts and puking passengers the captain gives up and returns home

about 1 hour ago

Frederick Forsyth dies: Day of the Jackal author and former MI6 agent passes away aged 86

Dailymail

Comments

Similar News

ABC suspends reporter who interviewed Trump after devastating analysis of president – and Stephen Miller

Analysis: An outline is emerging of the US offer to Iran in their high-stakes nuclear negotiations

Trump’s trade policy is making China great again — at the US’s expense, new global analysis finds

Nifty50 Prediction: Analysis of Nifty Option Chain, Glowing Market Before June 5 2025 Expiry! Learn here

New DNA analysis uncovers shocking clues behind the Maya civilization's mysterious collapse

Another eight unanswered questions that could solve Jay Slater's disappearance once and for all: JAMES TOZER and NICK PISA covered every development - read fascinating analysis

Labour embarrassed over claims of 'massive increase' in NHS appointments as analysis reveals rise was smaller than under Tories

Analysis: Two Major Mexican Cartels Merge to Form 'Mega-Cartel'

Millions Could Lose Food Stamp Benefits Under Trump Tax Bill, Analysis Finds

Analysis Shows Trump's ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’ Would Take From Poor And Give To Rich

Obama Coalition 'Turned Into the Trump Coalition,' Analysis Says

Analysis of Gaza hospital attack contradicts Israel's evidence justifying airstrike

Analysis: Keir Starmer's Credibility Problem On Immigration Means He Can't Out-Farage Farage

Breaking news

Domestic violence impact on women’s mental health can last almost 30 years

Children are clinging to moving trams for a ‘dangerous’ TikTok trend – here’s why

Impact of domestic violence on mental health ‘can last for decades’

Warning after mystery blue pills linked to three deaths in Devon

Latinas for Trump founder now condemns White House deportation agenda: ‘Not what we voted for’

US imposes sanctions on El Chapo's fugitive sons, offers $10 million reward for their capture

Canada plans to hit NATO spending target early and reduce reliance on US defense, Carney says

A New Orleans police officer who fatally shot a puppy will face a jury lawsuit trial

States sue US government over deal ending ban on triggers that make some rifles fire more rapidly

How high is your risk of dementia? It may depend on where you live

PHOTO ESSAY: Spain's wildest pilgrimage, El Rocío, brings together faith, nature and partying

Judge blocks administration from enforcing anti-diversity and anti-transgender executive orders

Sean 'Diddy' Combs' ex-girlfriend says she cried for three days after reading Cassie's lawsuit

Britons ‘better learn to speak Russian’ without major defence spending hike, Nato chief warns

For Sharon Van Etten, making her latest album was both spiritual and psychological

Trump seeks removal from a New Hampshire lawsuit challenging his order on transgender athletes

Florida agency tells newspaper to halt reporting angle on foundation associated with governor's wife

Police tear gas activists protesting the death in police custody of a Kenyan blogger

Elon Musk’s estranged dad Errol hails Russia as the ‘peak of civilisation’ & gushes over Putin at staged Moscow event

Explosive Sun Madeleine McCann doc reveals bombshell new evidence and why Christian Brueckner is prime suspect

Teacher’s secret racy OnlyFans exposed by ‘very excited’ kids who shared X-rated snaps around school

Scots flats locked down and man arrested after 'potentially hazardous materials' found

Scots OnlyFans teacher who sold x-rated pics struck off by watchdog

Hamilton by-election: Contrasting fortunes for parties who didn't win

Paisley rocker Davey Pattison back on stage after battling cancer and brain lesion

Armed officer sues Police Scotland over suspension after TikTok Tallia Storm incident

Frederick Forsyth dead: The Day of The Jackal author dies, aged 86

Hitman who shot beauty queen dead had grim tattoo of her burned face on his arm

Major Bellagio shooting update after two people killed outside Las Vegas casino

UK weather: New maps show exact date Brits to bask in 34C 'Spanish plume' heatwave

Rachel Reeves makes winter fuel payment vow to pensioners after major U-turn

Bus driver high on drugs who fell asleep at wheel and killed girl, 9, is jailed

San Diego plane crash: Six dead in takeoff horror mapped as wreckage litters sea

LIZZY BUCHAN: 'Rachel Reeves hopes public give her credit for listening to winter fuel anger'

Pensioners were living out twilight years in peace until 'resident from hell' arrived

Strictly star Oti Mabuse's baby heartache - 'I could only touch her through glass window'

Father of Nottingham attack victim complains after 'offensive' meeting with police watchdog which was started with a prayer

Jamie Laing admits his sex life with wife Sophie Habboo became 'clinical' when they started trying for a baby after couple shared they are expecting their first child

Tennessee plane crash survivor reveals how he emerged 'without a scratch' when aircraft fell from sky

Dua Lipa's lookalike sister sets internet ablaze as they twin in new photo: 'There's two?'

Rebekah Vardy puts her 'sanctuary' holiday home on sale for an astonishing price after being ordered to foot £4m Wagatha Christie legal bill

Final days of little boy with 'killer grandparents' before they 'murdered him while his mother was upstairs' is shown to jury

Woman on first date with man who put seven police officers in hospital after high speed chase 'wishes it had never happened'

Youngest girl in Britain to be charged with terror offences killed herself after being groomed by American neo-Nazis, inquest hears

Christine Lampard looks summer chic in all white as she joins shirtless husband Frank soaking up the sun on holiday in the south of France

Justin Baldoni's $400million countersuit against Blake Lively DISMISSED amid It Ends With Us drama

32-HOUR flight to NOWHERE after flight to Crete suffers so many aborted landing attempts and puking passengers the captain gives up and returns home

Frederick Forsyth dies: Day of the Jackal author and former MI6 agent passes away aged 86

Trump threatens to arrest Gavin Newsom and calls LA rioters 'insurrectionists'

Woke reporter denies there are riots and looting in LA while chaos unfolds behind him

Kartal wins and Raducanu & Boulter team up as women return to Queen's

Spending review now settled, says Downing Street

Frederick Forsyth: Life as a thriller writer, fighter pilot, journalist and spy

'Chances missed' to help groomed terrorism suspect

Doctor's failings in girl's sepsis case particularly grave, tribunal finds

Man City sign Wolves defender Ait-Nouri for £31m

Americanswers... on 5 Live! Why has Donald Trump sent the National Guard to protests in LA?

Mother killed in 'ferocious' attack, trial told

Teacher struck off after pupils saw her explicit OnlyFans page

Judge dismisses Justin Baldoni's $400m defamation lawsuit against Blake Lively