Analysis: Rachel Reeves Has Been Left Humiliated By Winter Fuel U-Turn

The chancellor explained her decision on Sky News.She tried to put a brave face on it, but there is no doubt that the U-turn on her decision to remove winter fuel payments from 10 million pensioners is a humiliation for Rachel Reeves.The chancellor confirmed today that she was raising the income threshold to qualify for the benefit, meaning millions more old folk will qualify for it this year.Her climbdown followed a furious public backlash to the policy – and mounting anger among Labour MPs.Reeves’ reputation as an “iron chancellor” has taken a battering from which it may never recover.What’s more, her explanation for why she has junked one of her signature policies does not stand up to a moment’s scrutiny.She told Sky News: “I had to make urgent decisions last year to put the public finances back on a firm footing. We inherited a £22 billion in-year black hole in the public finances.“I was always clear that the number one priority of this government was to return stability to the economy.“We did that with a number of difficult decisions, but because of those decisions our public finances are now in a better position, which means that this year we’re able to pay the winter fuel payment to more pensioners.”But it is misleading in the extreme to suggest that, after 11 months of a Labour government, everything in the Treasury garden is now rosy.Both the Office for Budget Responsibility and the OECD have downgraded their forecasts for the UK economy, not least because the impact of Donald Trump’s tariffs have yet to take effect.The idea that there is suddenly a load of spare cash to pay the £1.5 billion the winter fuel U-turn will cost is simply not true.Indeed, Downing Street has admitted that we’ll need to wait until the autumn Budget to find out how it will be paid for. How’s that for a fiscal black hole?If the Treasury’s calculations are to be believed, the new set-up will save the government £450 million. That doesn’t sound like an awful lot of money for all of the political pain the chancellor has had to endure.On Wednesday, Reeves will announce how much money each government department will have to spend over the next three years as she unveils the result of her spending review.She was already under huge pressure to explain how she plans to make the government’s sums add up. The winter fuel shambles means she has even less room for manoeuvre.Related...Revealed: Which Pensioners Will Get Winter Fuel Payments Again After Labour U-TurnRachel Reeves Confirms More Pensioners Will Get Their Winter Fuel Payments This Year'Cack-Handed': Laura Kuenssberg Slams Labour's U-Turn Over Winter Fuel Payments

Comments

Breaking news

Man arrested after 'potentially hazardous materials' found at property

The Herald

Comments

Similar News

ABC suspends reporter who interviewed Trump after devastating analysis of president – and Stephen Miller

Analysis: An outline is emerging of the US offer to Iran in their high-stakes nuclear negotiations

Trump’s trade policy is making China great again — at the US’s expense, new global analysis finds

Nifty50 Prediction: Analysis of Nifty Option Chain, Glowing Market Before June 5 2025 Expiry! Learn here

New DNA analysis uncovers shocking clues behind the Maya civilization's mysterious collapse

Another eight unanswered questions that could solve Jay Slater's disappearance once and for all: JAMES TOZER and NICK PISA covered every development - read fascinating analysis

Labour embarrassed over claims of 'massive increase' in NHS appointments as analysis reveals rise was smaller than under Tories

Analysis: Two Major Mexican Cartels Merge to Form 'Mega-Cartel'

Millions Could Lose Food Stamp Benefits Under Trump Tax Bill, Analysis Finds

Analysis Shows Trump's ‘Big, Beautiful Bill’ Would Take From Poor And Give To Rich

Obama Coalition 'Turned Into the Trump Coalition,' Analysis Says

Analysis of Gaza hospital attack contradicts Israel's evidence justifying airstrike

Analysis: Keir Starmer's Credibility Problem On Immigration Means He Can't Out-Farage Farage

Breaking news

Man arrested after 'potentially hazardous materials' found at property

Inside Amsterdam’s plan to build a five-storey ‘erotic prison’ in an affluent suburb

Husband ‘tracked down fleeing wife and killed her as she walked with their baby’

Family of teen who went missing left with ‘unanswered questions’ after body found

Father describes how son, 15, died during a kickboxing match: ‘It felt like a lifetime’

Measles outbreaks in Michigan and Pennsylvania end, while Texas logs just 4 new cases

What happened to Sade Robinson? How a teen’s murder is fueling demand for change

An adult dad posed as a high schooler for months — and even dated teen classmates. Here’s how his lie unraveled

Judge dismisses Justin Baldoni's lawsuit against 'It Ends With Us' costar Blake Lively

How the Mexican flag became the symbol of the LA protests

Judge orders managers for late Johnny Winter to pay $226,000 in damages in lawsuit alleging theft

Labour MPs call for benefit cuts to be scrapped after winter fuel payment U-turn

How Trump just made Gavin Newsom’s day by sending the National Guard to Los Angeles — politically, anyway

Matt Vogt once chose dentistry over golf. Back home at the US Open, he's learned he didn't have to

Spending review is ‘settled’, says Downing Street

Sly Stone, leader of funk revolutionaries Sly and the Family Stone, dies at 82

Wander Franco's attorney to ask court to exonerate his client in sexual abuse case

Tennessee prison riot contained after several hours; 3 inmates and 1 guard injured

US reports another arrest of Chinese scientist with no permit to send biological material

Trump is going after LGBTQ rights and big companies have responded by shunning Pride Month

Trump raising cash off Los Angeles protest mayhem with ‘attack on the homeland’ email

A convoy sets off for Gaza from North Africa to protest Israel's blockade

How unusual is it for the National Guard to come to LA? Here's what to know about the city's history

Trump neutered Justice Department watchdogs that were there to prevent politically motivated prosecutions

Screen time is creating a vicious cycle for kids. Here is the good and bad

Tired? Here’s five tips for a good night’s sleep

Lottery results LIVE: National Lottery Set For Life draw tonight, June 9, 2025

Six dead in San Diego plane crash as Cessna slams into ocean after pilot made haunting final call to air traffic control

Shocking number of sex offences reported in the military last year revealed as ‘little progress made’ stopping attacks

Bus driver who killed girl, 9, after smashing into her while high on drugs is jailed as father pays touching tribute

Furious neighbour who took fence row to court sees plan BACKFIRE as she is forced to rip up patio instead

Fury as BA calls Falkland Islands capital by its ARGENTINIAN name in ‘ludicrous and insulting’ blunder

Putin could attack Nato by 2030, alliance boss warns as ‘Europe needs to build its own Golden Dome defence system’

Brazilian beauty queen was ‘shot dead by hitman who got a tattoo on his hand of her face on fire’

Mystery over Maddie McCann suspect Christian Bruecker after ‘huge sum he spent after she disappeared’ is revealed

Moment cops dig up Channel migrant dinghies hidden deep under French beach in blow to smugglers

Tinkering with smartphone rules won’t save our kids – the damage they do means we must BAN them now

NHS Lanarkshire showcases bold reform at NHS Scotland Event

Elon Musk's father says his son and Donald Trump will patch things up after dramatic falling out

Justin Baldoni's defamation claim against Blake Lively dismissed

Dog owners in Lanarkshire warned of dangers of blue algae over the summer months

Council plan to install temporary classroom at Coatbridge school

Runner left covered in blood after being attacked by buzzard terrorising village

Scientists discover 6,000-year-old skeletons with no link to modern humans

Love Islander's spark retro-inspired swimwear trend - where to shop the exact looks

Premier League season tickets: Check your club as fans hit by more major price rises

Teacher upskirted by teen pupil inside school lives with PTSD after being filmed walking up stairs

Mum left 'torn apart' as newborn killed after being 'dragged out bed' by nurse

Police confirm body found in Hampshire is that of missing London woman

I was tickling my toddler when I realized a devastating truth that nearly killed me... always trust your gut

Horrifying moment 'distracted' lorry ploughs into pedestrian after mounting pavement - as driver avoids a prison sentence

Amanda Seyfried reveals the drug she did with pal Adam Brody when they were in their 20s

Japanese pop star Ayumi Hamasaki reveals truth about her 'secret love child' with Elon Musk amid claims he boasted about fathering baby with a Japanese singer

Scientists uncover SECOND 'hidden city' beneath Egypt's Giza pyramids in discovery that rewrites history

Revealed: The staggering amount of debt Gino D'Campo's restaurant empire racked up before going into administration in wake of lewd behaviour claims

Third time lucky? Our £50k Jeep Wrangler was stolen by keyless car thieves. We loved our wagon so much we bought another only for it to get nicked TEN DAYS later. We won't let that stop us snapping up another

Man who was spotted fleeing Heathrow airport staff on the tarmac was 'being deported from Britain on a commercial flight'

Father of kickboxer, 15, breaks down in tears at inquest as he reveals how 'beautiful son' suddenly collapsed moments after unsanctioned fight and died three days later

Love Island 2025 live updates: Launch show sees major twist while one islander is already dumped from villa

Domestic violence impact on women’s mental health can last almost 30 years