BBC Presenter Shows Ed Miliband All The Times Ministers Defended The Winter Fuel Cut

John Kay and Ed Miliband.Ed Miliband was shown all the times Labour ministers backed the cuts to winter fuel payments just a day after Rachel Reeves performed a humiliating U-turn on the policy.The chancellor was among those senior frontbenchers who went on BBC Breakfast last year to defend the controversial decision.On the programme this morning, energy secretary Miliband repeatedly refused to apologise to pensioners who missed out on the payment last year after Reeves took it off 10 million of them.She confirmed yesterday that 9 million more will get the money this winter after the income threshold to qualify for it was raised to £35,000.Presenter John Kay said: “Millions of pensioners had a really anxious winter. They told us every morning in our inbox that they couldn’t afford to put the heating on. Some told us that their health and their wellbeing was affected by losing the winter fuel payment. Will you now apologise for this mistake?”Dodging the question, Miliband replied: “The chancellor took a decision last year when we came into office that she needed to stabilise the nation’s finances, and the principal that we should pay the winter fuel payment to all pensioners wasn’t correct. That’s why she made the decision she did.“Two things have happened since then: we’ve stabilised the nation’s finances and we’ve heard that strength of feeling that you talk about and that’s why she made the change she did. I think it’s the right thing.”But Kay told him: “Our viewers like it when politicians own mistakes and admit to mistakes, and they like it when politicians say sorry. Why won’t the chancellor, why won’t you this morning, just apologise – dead simple.”Miliband said: “The chancellor is not going to apologise for a series of measures she took to stabilise the nation’s finances when we came into office.”Kay hit back: “Time and time again, you all told us it was not going to change. Let’s just play a sample of clips we’ve got of various cabinet ministers telling us that there was going to be no alteration to this policy.”On July 30 last year, Reeves told the programme: “The decisions I made on winter fuel payment are not decisions I wanted to make, they are not decisions I expected to make. But when confronted by a £22bn black hole, I had to act.”On September 5, deputy PM Angela Rayner said: “We know this is a difficult choice, and we was left with very difficult circumstances because of the previous government and what they did.”Health secretary Wes Streeting said on September 12: “We are not prepared to duck the difficult decisions and leave everyone paying a heavier price down the line. That was the Conservative way, it’s not the Labour way.”And on July 31, housing minister Matthew Pennycook said: “This isn’t a change we wanted to make, this isn’t a change we expected to make, we did it with a heavy heart. But we do think it is the right decision.”Bizarrely, Miliband then insisted the clips were “absolutely consistent with that the chancellor announced yesterday”.An incredulous Kay replied: “What, you’re saying this is not a U-turn?”Miliband said: “No, it obviously is a change on the threshold, but what I’m saying to you is these are decisions she sad she didn’t want to make, and now she’s got the room for manoeuvre to raise the threshold while sticking to the overall principal.”'Time and time again you all told us it was not going to change?'On #BBCBreakfast Energy Secretary Ed Miliband was asked about the government's repeated defence of the decision to cut winter fuel allowance for most pensioners - before announcing a u-turn… pic.twitter.com/m4gDX84PZn— BBC Breakfast (@BBCBreakfast) June 10, 2025Related...Analysis: Rachel Reeves Has Been Left Humiliated By Winter Fuel U-TurnRevealed: Which Pensioners Will Get Winter Fuel Payments Again After Labour U-TurnRachel Reeves Confirms More Pensioners Will Get Their Winter Fuel Payments This Year

Comments

Breaking news

Bus lane and LEZ fine cash to fund 'greening' of city centre

The Herald

Comments

Similar News

Watch: Former Syria prison guard tells BBC he showed detainees 'no mercy'

BBC Verify examines tunnels footage after IDF says Hamas leader body found

Wimbledon to be aired on new TV channel for the first time after BBC covered action at All-England Club for 88 years

EastEnders Star Suspended By BBC Over 'Unacceptable' Language On Strictly Come Dancing Set

I Kissed A Boy's Female Counterpart Gets A New Series On BBC Three

Prince's iconic hits on the BBC

Treasure hunter finds huge silver coin hoard two months after being inspired by BBC comedy Detectorists to take up hobby

BBC star battling health struggles doubles his money in just four years by transforming and selling his London home for £2.75million

Teacher was upskirted by male student only for school to make him a prefect and order her to keep him in her class - as he is now given £5k BBC-backed bursary

Shocking moment Antiques Roadshow expert is BOOED by BBC crowd after 'low blow' joke fails to impress

BBC The Gold star Hugh Bonneville's tragic split from wife before meeting new girlfriend

BBC on the ground as National Guard set up in Los Angeles

Squirming Tory refuses FOUR times to apologise for Liz Truss chaos in excruciating BBC clash

Excruciating Moment Kemi Badenoch Struggles To Answer BBC's Fundamental Liz Truss Question

Notts knife attack victim’s mum slams ‘shameful’ BBC for failing to apologise for chat with killer’s family

'BBC show's interior designers wrecked my bedroom - it's like a horror film'

The BBC home renovation that left woman sobbing 'I hate it!' - and horrified viewers jeering 'it's like something from a horror film!'

Garth Crooks gets driving ban: BBC football pundit blames hidden speed camera as he is ordered off the roads for six months for breaking 20mph limit

BBC Bargain Hunt expert jailed after failing to report sales to ‘Hezbollah financier’

BBC Bargain Hunt star is jailed for more than two years for terror offence after selling £140k of art to 'suspected Hezbollah terrorist financier'

Breaking news

Bus lane and LEZ fine cash to fund 'greening' of city centre

Award-winning chippy launches Scotland’s first ever 'chippy breakfast'

Mental health concerns grow for unpaid carers 'penalised' by social care system

'Disaster': Bid to stop taxpayer-backed gas power plant as pollution ratings soar

I tried the Edinburgh restaurant named as the 'Best in Scotland'

John Swinney creates new role for Mairi McAllan in cabinet reshuffle

400 Scottish jobs at risk as bus manufacturer plans England move

Road near Milngavie reopens after three-car crash

Minister refuses to confirm £100 million lifeline for Dundee University

Court hears Michelle Mone-linked firm must pay back £121m for ‘faulty’ PPE

Summer solstice sees searches spike for Scottish standing stones

Reeves's £9.1bn budget boost leaves Scottish Government short changed says Robinson

Work by one of Scotland's best loved contemporary artists goes on show

Glasgow's drug consumption room leads to reports of abandoned needles in the street

Boost for Kirkcaldy as Chancellor announces 'growth fund' for high street

New Loch Ness bus to meet 'unprecedented' demand from Nessie hunters

Acorn Carbon Capture project inches forward, but will it happen?

Revealed: ScotGov pulls plug on lifeline public finance of state ferry fiasco firm

Chair of Sheku Bayoh inquiry to consider calls to step down

'Farcical:' Ross criticised for chairing Holyrood committee meeting from Caribbean

John Swinney to hold modest Scottish cabinet reshuffle at Bute House

Explainer: Why has the Edinburgh International Book Festival moved in recent years?

Woman jailed for distributing monkey torture material in landmark case

Six of Glasgow's best street food eats and where to find them this summer

Flynn: Independent Scotland would cut ties with Israel

SNP rebels in secret plot to oust John Swinney after Hamilton by-election defeat

Tributes paid to drug policy reformer Peter Krykant after his sudden death

LIVE: Spending Review 2025: What Rachel Reeves’s plans mean for Scotland

ScotRail 'one of UK's best for passenger satisfaction'

Islanders facing financial ruin over cancellations to notorious ferry route

Probe into Cole Cooper disappearance continue as body remains unidentified

Scottish carbon capture project 'to be announced in spending review'

David Byrne announces Glasgow shows on new world tour

Girl, 11, taken to hospital after being hit by car near stadium

Petition launched to save historic Clyde ferry service

Warrant issued for woman accused of sex attack at city nightclub

Scottish Government to gain £2.9bn in 'game-changing' Spending Review

Man charged over 'disturbance' which closed Glasgow streets

Hospital formally granted university status by University of Glasgow

Why does Scotland require a new fossil fuel power plant?

Two women killed in fatal collision as police launch appeal for witnesses

Police probing gang violence recover firearm in Edinburgh

Edinburgh Festival Fringe street theatre shows under threat over funding crisis

Man caught with £1m of cocaine stashed in van jailed

Callum Beattie revealed as Tiree Music Festival's final headline act

The ferry scandal that could sink a government (but not the SNP)

First new public gardens in Edinburgh for 200 years get £2.85m donation

Councillors and businessman in court for disability health and safety concerns

Why we need safe baby courts in Scotland

One in five adults a victim of crime as violent offences in Scotland rise

Scientists who say there’s a ‘secret city’ under Giza pyramid have now ‘found a second one’

Student, 15, stabs teaching assistant to death during bag search at French school

This is where the UK plans to hide nuclear power waste for thousands of years

British couple ‘tried to smuggle £1,000,000 of cannabis into UK from Thailand’

This Longevity-Boosting Diet May Disrupt The Depression-Dementia Link

These Ginny And Georgia Deleted Scenes Are A Gift For Anyone Who Can't Wait For Season 4

Investments in UK tech sector will create hundreds of jobs, says Government