Exclusive: Pro-Abortion Campaigners Fear Medical Staff Could Be Prosecuted Under Law Changes

Abortion rights campaigners march in London.MPs are set to vote on changing the country’s abortion law on Tuesday but campaigners are split over just what alterations are needed.Two Labour backbenchers have proposed altering the government’s Crime and Policing Bill with rival amendments to the draft legislation.Both aim to decriminalise abortion, but the differences between their two policies have caused a major divide.What is the difference between the two amendments?1. Tonia Antoniazzi’s amendmentThis amendment put forward by the Labour MP for Gower would stop it being a criminal offence for a woman to end their own pregnancy.They would not be prosecuted for procuring or administering drugs, or using instruments, to cause an abortion.This amendment would not include protections for medical staff or activists who aid the abortion.2. Stella Creasy’s amendmentThe Labour MP for Walthamstow’s amendment would decriminalise abortion up to 24 weeks.Late-term abortions outside of the Abortion Act would also not result in custodial sentences. She wants to decriminalise abortion for any medical professionals who carry out the abortion with the explicit consent of the pregnant person too, as long as the pregnancy has not exceeded 24 weeks.Fears for medical staff and activistsThe charities BPAS (British Pregnancy Advisory Service) and MSI Reproductive Choices have publicly supported Antoniazzi’s amendment – and written to MPs calling on them to do the same.But activists fear that amendment will only lead to the prosecution of anyone who helps someone get an abortion, such as activists and medical staff.HuffPost UK understands that MSI have claimed it is “possible” medical staff or activists could be investigated under Antoniazzi’s amendment.However, Emma Campbell, co-convenor for Alliance 4 Choice, told HuffPost UK that Britain should be wary of what happened when a similar law was unveiled in Poland.“Once it was no longer legal to arrest the people [who were pregnant], they arrested the activists,” she warned.She said she was “mystified” by the fact that BPAS and MSI were not supporting Creasy’s amendment, calling Antoniazzi’s amendment “dangerous”.“It seems bizarre – they’re willing to play politics on abortion-seekers and their close ones’ lives,” she said.BPAS told HuffPost UK that Antoniazzi’s amendment “would change nothing about abortion provision or the laws around medical professionals and activists.”BPAS’ head of advocacy Rachael Clarke said: “All it would do is stop the prosecution of vulnerable women who end their own pregnancies outside the current law.“Every organisation that represents medical professionals working in abortion care support this amendment, including all abortion providers in England and Wales, the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, the Royal College of Nursing, the Royal College of Midwives, the Faculty of Sexual and Reproductive Healthcare, and the British Society of Abortion Care Providers.“The uniting issue for all these groups is that women must urgently be removed from the criminal law on abortion – and that wider reform including that around the law related to medical professionals needs proper consideration and input from medical bodies and abortion care providers.” MSI told HuffPost UK that Antoniazzi’s amendment “protects the person ending their own pregnancy from prosecution. It does not change the law in relation to medics or activists, and nor do we have reason to believe it would make prosecutions of medics or activists more likely.”Louise McCudden, MSI Reproductive Choices’ UK head of external affairs. added: “We would never support an amendment that criminalised medics or activists, or that made their prosecution more likely.”Confusion around campaignersThere’s also a clash between activists over Creasy’s amendment.MSI told MPs it was written without abortion providers’ input, and suggested it did not have enough support to pass.MSI has also warned campaigners it could set back the fight for full decriminalisation of abortion for a generation.The same organisation wrote to MPs last week calling for them to withdraw their support for Creasy’s decriminalisation bill.MSI’s Louise McCudden told HuffPost UK: “We strongly support full decriminalisation of abortion and we have long advocated for it with our partners, including the many pro-choice activists who have signed up to back NC1 as an important milestone. Abortion providers, pro-choice activists, and medics have already begun to reimagine abortion care for the 21st century.“This is a complex area and it’s important we get it right. In the meantime, we advocate for a simple reform to the law which will end the prosecution of women who have been investigated under our Victorian abortion laws. The women have who have been investigated so far include domestic abuse survivors, potential trafficking survivors, and women who have had stillbirths - this is a fundamental injustice and addressing it cannot wait.”Related...As Campaigners Condemn 'Shocking' Police Abortion Guidance, Here's What They Want To Happen Next2 Of Trump’s Court Picks Argued Abortion Pill ‘Starves The Baby To Death’ In WombI Had An Abortion While Working A Full Day. My Co-Worker's 'Feedback' Nearly Made Me Unravel.

Comments

Breaking news

'Flourish on our own two feet:' Swinney ramps up independence push amid SNP unrest

The Herald

Covid-19 and RSV head data scientist dramatically quits saying she doesn’t trust RFK Jr department to use it ‘objectively’

about 1 hour ago

MAGA’s ‘no more wars’ wing is at war ... with Donald Trump

Independent

Conspiracy of silence over grooming gangs' race doomed thousands of girls to abuse: Sickening evidence covered up 'for fear of appearing racist', damning report finds

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

More than 1million UK workers likely to resign in the next year due to illness or poor mental health

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

EPHRAIM HARDCASTLE: King Charles has suspended his bid to remove Prince Andrew from Royal Lodge - but is the Crown losing patience with the disgraced duke?

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

Isla Fisher shares touching Father's Day tribute to ex-husband Sacha Baron Cohen - just days after finalising their divorce

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

The 'abandoned' Brits trapped in Israel: Pressure on Foreign Office to evacuate UK nationals who say they are stranded in Middle East war zone while other countries rush to bring citizens home

about 1 hour ago

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews last night's TV: You have to admire the understaffed police solving this brutal gang killing

Dailymail

'Grovelling' Starmer was 'like a dog wagging its tail' after spawling at Trump's feet in trade deal press conference, body language expert claims

about 1 hour ago

Brad Pitt's girlfriend Ines de Ramon dons risque bridal-inspired ensemble at glitzy F1 premiere

Dailymail

Comments

Similar News

Tickets on sale for exclusive Superman screening at Vue Hamilton

Exclusive London restaurant beloved by A-listers including Tom Cruise and Prince Harry leaves people horrified over 'inhumane' window display

Inside Tom Cruise and Ana de Armas' intimate date nights at exclusive London club as romance heats up

Exclusive — Arizona Speaker Pro Tempore Neal Carter Cheers Passage of Balanced Budget

Exclusive: Mike Perry on Dirty Boxing Success and Partnering With Jon Jones

Exclusive—Seamus Bruner: Riot Inc. Exposed—the Dark Money Billionaires Funding the Left’s ‘Day of Defiance’

Exclusive — Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent: Breitbart News ‘My Number One Source Every Morning’

Exclusive: Barry Sanders Reveals New Details on His Heart Attack

The most exclusive WhatsApp group in the world: How the future queens of Europe have become 'royal besties' by bonding over privacy, social media and how to tell who their real friends are

Exclusive: Country Legend Lee Greenwood Talks the Honor of Joining Trump for Saturday's U.S. Army 250th Anniversary

Exclusive: Freedom Caucus Members Champion Rescissions Package as First Step to Fiscal Responsibility

Exclusive -- U.S. Chief of Protocol Monica Crowley on Army Parade: ‘A Call to Inspire the Next Generation of Service-Minded Americans’

Exclusive: Treasury Secretary Bessent Is Not Looking To Succeed Fed’s Powell

Exclusive — Sen. Joni Ernst Aims to Stop Fraudulent Payments as Pay-For in Big Beautiful Bill

Exclusive – Tom Emmer Unloads on 'Absolute Failure' Tim Walz: 'He Represents Illegal Aliens, Criminals,' Not Minnesotans

Exclusive: Rep. Tony Wied Proposes Bill That Bars Federal Funding to 'Anarchist Jurisdictions'

Exclusive—Sen. Markwayne Mullin: Gavin Newsom Is the Only Democrat Who 'Could Possibly Make Biden Look Good as President’

Exclusive — Sen. Cotton Shoots Back at Gov. Newsom: 'California Deserves Better'

Exclusive -- U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli: Gavin Newsom Needs to 'Turn on the TV'

EXCLUSIVE CLIP: The Amateur Gets New Digital Release Date – How To Watch

Breaking news

'Flourish on our own two feet:' Swinney ramps up independence push amid SNP unrest

‘Teen boy shoots dead three at carnival including an infant and injures two others’

When is traffic banned on London’s Oxford Street?

How unpopular is Trump? Even some people who attended his military parade don’t like him

Businesses plan further job cuts after national insurance hikes

Rail deal worth £500m will help save Scunthorpe steelworks, says minister

Tinder launches ‘double date’ feature as Gen Z seek low-pressure dating

Cars to be banned from Oxford Street ‘as quickly as possible’

NHS staff slam trend of patients filming their procedures for TikTok

Fast-moving brush fire on Hawaii's Maui island evacuates about 50 people. No structures have burned

Purdue Pharma to pay $7.4 billion in opioid lawsuit settlement

Trump’s military parade will take ‘many days’ to clean up, says D.C. mayor

Trump says US-UK deal ‘done’ as steel tariffs still up in air

After a calm night, LA mayor shortens downtown curfew hours imposed after violent protests

How deleting your old emails could help England avoid major water shortages

Former Coast Guard officer and sharpshooter accused of threatening to assassinate Trump

Trump departs G7 early after warning ‘everyone should immediately evacuate Tehran’

Covid-19 and RSV head data scientist dramatically quits saying she doesn’t trust RFK Jr department to use it ‘objectively’

MAGA’s ‘no more wars’ wing is at war ... with Donald Trump

Doctor to plead guilty to giving Matthew Perry ketamine before fatal overdose

Thousands of British Steel jobs secured thanks to £500m Network Rail deal

Donald Trump calls for immediate evacuation of Iran's capital amid conflict

Donald Trump leaves G7 summit early - hours before Volodymyr Zelensky due to arrive

Real Housewives star's care home gets damning Ofsted report and and is forced to close

Two more countries added to list Brits shouldn't travel to in new warnings

Conspiracy of silence over grooming gangs' race doomed thousands of girls to abuse: Sickening evidence covered up 'for fear of appearing racist', damning report finds

More than 1million UK workers likely to resign in the next year due to illness or poor mental health

EPHRAIM HARDCASTLE: King Charles has suspended his bid to remove Prince Andrew from Royal Lodge - but is the Crown losing patience with the disgraced duke?

Isla Fisher shares touching Father's Day tribute to ex-husband Sacha Baron Cohen - just days after finalising their divorce

The 'abandoned' Brits trapped in Israel: Pressure on Foreign Office to evacuate UK nationals who say they are stranded in Middle East war zone while other countries rush to bring citizens home

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews last night's TV: You have to admire the understaffed police solving this brutal gang killing

Revealed: The eight perverted grooming gangs convicted of preying on girls - in Rochdale alone

Lilo and Stitch actor David Hekili Kenui Bell dies as family pays heartbreaking tribute

'Grovelling' Starmer was 'like a dog wagging its tail' after spawling at Trump's feet in trade deal press conference, body language expert claims

Brad Pitt's girlfriend Ines de Ramon dons risque bridal-inspired ensemble at glitzy F1 premiere

Patients angering NHS staff by secretly filming consultations for TikTok and Instagram

MAGA turns on Trump-appointed justice Amy Coney Barrett as she threatens to upend SCOTUS

'Betrayed by the state' and 'Israel claims control'

What the capsizing and relaunching of a warship tells us about North Korea's regime

Banned From YouTube, Sneako Is Welcomed by Eric Adams

Trump and Starmer Finalize Trade Deal Lowering Tariffs on U.K. Cars, Steel and More

Minnesota Suspect Traveled to 4 Lawmakers’ Homes on Night of Attacks

Iran’s Best-Protected Nuclear Site Is Deep Underground

Trump’s Choice on Israel-Iran: Help Destroy Nuclear Facility or Continue to Negotiate

Supermarket catches cat thief who wouldn’t stop nicking expensive food

Starmer stoops to pick up UK-US trade agreement papers dropped by Trump

Woman charged nearly £4,600 for two hour car park stay

Radio pulses are coming from below Antarctica – scientists can’t explain why

Man formerly on death row can't serve 2 life terms at the same time, Tennessee Supreme Court rules

Doctor charged with supplying Matthew Perry ketamine will plead guilty to distributing the drug

US sends aircraft carrier from South China Sea to Middle East as conflict between Israel and Iran grows

Georgia man charged with leaving threatening messages for 2 Republican senators

Trump fires back at Tucker Carlson after he accuses US president of being ‘complicit’ in Israel-Iran attacks

Fake fundraising pages sprout after floods ravage West Virginia, leaving at least six dead, including a 3-year-old

US and UK announce a trade deal, but steel imports are still being negotiated

Supreme Court to hear appeal from Chevron in landmark Louisiana coastal damage lawsuits

Skip the cream and sugar on your next coffee run! Researchers say you’ll live longer