Israeli Spokesperson Accuses BBC's Nick Robinson Of Lying About Gaza In Furious Row Live On Air

Israel's spokesperson David Mencer and BBC Radio 4's Nick RobinsonAn Israeli government spokesperson furiously accused top BBC presenter Nick Robinson of lying about aid getting into Gaza live on air.David Mencer was speaking to Radio 4′s Today programme as concerns over the humanitarian crisis grow in the Palestinian territory.Israel closed all crossings into Gaza on March 2, meaning no fresh supplies have been allowed to enter since – plunging much of the 2.1 million population into starvation.Israel has also dismantled the long-standing system for getting food into Gaza and set up its own controversial Gaza Humanitarian Foundation.The UN has reported Palestinians being killed while seeking food, on aid routes and at distribution points, while Save the Children warned that massacres are occurring at food distribution sites every day.Even so, Israel insists it is not responsible for the soaring rates of malnutrition.Tensions began to rise during this morning’s interview when Robinson asked the Israeli spokesperson if his country’s food distribution system for Gaza was failing.Mencer denied such a claim, saying their aid efforts were key for cutting Hamas out of the picture.He added: “It is working simply on the facts that 90 million meals have gone in with the new system, but Hamas – you know what they’re doing?”The presenter replied: “That doesn’t prove they’re working, you’ve just acknowledged at the beginning of this conversation there is malnutrition, it’s getting worse and there’s starvation.“So just putting a large number on the amount of food distributed doesn’t prove the system is working, the evidence is whether people are getting fed or not. Some are, some are not.”Mencer said there are two parts of the process – the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation where millions of meals are given “directly to civilians”, as well as UN coordinated shipments of medicine and raw materials.“But you restrict access to the UN shipments, don’t you?” Robinson asked.Mencer furiously hit back: “That’s not true! That is false Nick, you must not say lies! You must not say falsehoods.”Robinson replied: “Don’t accuse me of lying, Mr Mencer, it’s cheap and it’s unhelpful. I’ll put some facts to you, if you think they’re only a partial version, I’ll give you time and chance to answer them.“But at the time when people are dying of malnutrition, the hostages are languishing in tunnels, it really does not help for you to shout abuse over a line. I am not lying, I am putting a question to you.”“Nick you are lying! You are lying!” Mencer said.“Listen to the question and then you can answer it,” the presenter said.“Do you accept there is malnutrition in Gaza, it’s getting worse and some people are starving?”@bbcnickrobinson questions Israeli Government spokesman David Mencer.#R4Todaypic.twitter.com/Llq4QHD7yB— BBC Radio 4 Today (@BBCr4today) July 25, 2025Mencer hit back: “I will answer the question now Nick, you’ve had your chance. You invited me on, indeed, your producers begged me to come on and I will now give you the facts.“That is my job as the spokesperson for the office of the prime minister [Netanyahu] to give you the facts.”He said there are 1,000 trucks of aid waiting on the Gaza side.He then claimed the UN is working with Hamas to restrict the amount of aid to their own people – and alleged that the BBC does not report that.Robinson pointed out that the UN argues they are limited in their ability to deliver food by what the UN describes as “tremendous bureaucratic impediments, tremendous security impediments” – so trucks cannot get to civilians.The UN pointed out that on Thursday, out of 16 attempts to coordinate humanitarian movements, only eight were facilitated by the Israeli authorities.“If you would stop interrupting me, we could get something from this interview,” Mencer replied. “You do not perceive Hamas to be a terrorist organisation –”“You’ve no idea what I perceive. You’ve no idea, Mr Mencer,” the journalist said.“Tell us all then, do you believe Hamas to be a terrorist organisation?” Mencer insisted.“No, you’re not interviewing me. I am interviewing you,” Robinson said.Mencer replied: “Take yourself off from those ideas that those executives upstairs tell you to say, and tell me right now you believe Hamas to be a terrorist organisation.”Sounding rather frustrated, Robinson said: “Mr Mencer, every interview you do this, it’s very tedious for listeners, it’s very tedious for me.”After more back and forth, Robinson eventually wrapped up the extraordinary interview by saying: “If you’d like to apply for that job at the BBC, do give it a try, but for the moment, thank you for joining us to tell us what the Israeli government is thinking.”Related...Germany's Broadcaster Responds To Reports They'll Leave Eurovision If Israel Is BannedIsrael Is Using Starvation To Commit Genocide In Gaza, New Amnesty Report SaysHundreds Of Palestinian Health Workers Remain Unlawfully Detained By Israel: NGOs

Comments

Breaking news

Dr. Phil’s anti-woke TV network files for bankruptcy, accuses Christian broadcasting partner of ‘sabotage’

Independent

25% of young children and pregnant women malnourished in Gaza, charity says, as PM vows to fly critical medical cases to UK

about 2 hours ago

Plane plunges 300ft in 36 seconds to avoid other aircraft

Skynews

Taylor Swift hits back at ex Matty Healy's 'obnoxious' mother Denise Welch for her interview 'attack'... and issues firm warning

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

Experts recommend a 'micro' exercise to lose weight... and it only takes 30 seconds

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

Johnny Depp makes surprise appearance at Alice Cooper's London gig as they perform Black Sabbath's Paranoid dedicated to Ozzy Osbourne

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

Ghislaine Maxwell granted limited immunity during NINE HOUR grilling by deputy attorney general

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

Slain grandparents' selfless final act to save their two-year-old grandson

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

How much Son Heung-min's 'K Factor' is really worth to Tottenham: The enormous value of South Korean fandom, what Spurs lose if he completes Los Angeles switch - and the US jackpot they can finally seize

about 4 hours ago

Starmer risks cabinet revolt by rejecting MPs' demands to acknowledge a Palestinian state

Dailymail

Comments

Similar News

Europe's Spate of Hostilities Toward Jews and Israelis Prompts Antisemitism Calls

Iran Says 27 Inmates from Infamous Evin Prison Still at Large After Israeli Airstrike

As Starvation Rises, Israeli Minister Says Israel Is ‘Driving Out’ Gazans

Gaza ceasefire talks: What we know as US envoy meets Israeli and Qatari officials

Video: Gaza protesters block Israeli tourists from entering Greek island

The Latest: Israeli official says a Hamas ceasefire proposal is 'workable'

Pro-Palestine protesters block Israeli cruise ship from docking on Greek island

70-year-old Israeli woman is arrested over plot to blow up Netanyahu with an RPG

More than 100 aid groups warn of starvation in Gaza as Israeli strikes kill 21 overnight

Israeli strikes kill 21 people in overnight strikes as fears of famine sweep war zone

Sadiq Khan heaps pressure on Keir Starmer to recognise Palestinian state ahead of Trump visits amid global condemnation of Israeli violence in Gaza

The Latest: Israeli strikes in Gaza kill at least 21 people, health authorities say

Iran's detainees in 'unbearable' conditions after Israeli strikes on prison

Israeli strikes kill at least 20 in Gaza, health officials say

Photos show Palestinian suffering as Israeli troops push deeper into central Gaza

Shot in the head or pounded by Israeli bombs: How a week of bloodshed shattered Syria’s fragile peace

WHO says Israeli forces attacked its Gaza facilities and detained staff

WHO condemns Israeli raid on central Gaza residence and warehouse attack

Gazan doctor held in 'inhumane' conditions in Israeli jail, says lawyer

Iran’s Leaders Turn to a New Brand of Nationalism After Israeli and U.S. Attacks

Breaking news

Dr. Phil’s anti-woke TV network files for bankruptcy, accuses Christian broadcasting partner of ‘sabotage’

As the ADA turns 35, groups fighting for disability rights could see their federal dollars slashed

Trump’s Secret Service detail to pay $600K for golf carts and port-a-potties to use at his New Jersey club

Lori Vallow Daybell stoked tensions with judge in her Arizona murder conspiracy trials

Parts of the Appalachian Trail are still damaged after Helene. Volunteers are fixing it by hand

Alec Baldwin talks his love for 'Peanuts' and the 'immeasurable' effects of his trial

Fossils of ancient shark species discovered in Kentucky cave

Manhunt for inmate ‘mistakenly’ released from New Orleans jail where 10 previously escaped

California doctor sued for ‘wrongful death’ after shipping abortion drugs interstate in legal first

Oasis superfan gets Murrayfield ticket tattoo ahead of Edinburgh dates

Police Scotland pay out £3m to stop staff taking them to employment tribunals

Time to park our fears over Trump and use trip to smooth relations with UK

Roofer broke 94-year-old woman's neck after ploughing Transit van into her car

Probe launched after woman filmed dragging dogs by necks in shocking clip

25% of young children and pregnant women malnourished in Gaza, charity says, as PM vows to fly critical medical cases to UK

Plane plunges 300ft in 36 seconds to avoid other aircraft

UKHSA issues vaccine alert over illness that can turn serious

Teenagers say they prefer getting health advice from TikTok than doctors

Met Office reveals exact dates when 'very hot' weather could return

Terrifying mystery illness leaves patients 'like statues' - with brains still working

Today's horoscope for July 26 as Gemini embarks on new beginnings

Drivers can make their car use 'zero fuel' - without switching to an EV

'I swapped energy drinks for new wellness trend and festivals won't be the same again'

Royal Caribbean crew member 'stabs colleague then jumps overboard to his death'

UK condemns Hong Kong cash offer for help in arresting activists

Horror master Kiyoshi Kurosawa to bring eerie storytelling to his first samurai film

Disney brings the Grid, and the light bikes, with 'Tron: Ares' footage at Comic-Con

The reverse migration: African Americans relocating to Kenya cite heritage and restoration

A grenade is missing from the scene of an explosion that killed 3 LA deputies

Unassuming 1937 book worth £24k - and other books that could land you a cash windfall

Three British men accused of gang rape at Croatian beach resort hotel

Only 1 in 3 can work out which hat contains the cat in baffling brainteaser

Man dies after drowning off the coast of Lanzarote during peak holiday season

AOC hit with $3K bill for splashy 'Tax the Rich' dress at 2021 Met Gala appearance

Parasitic sea vampire bites RFK Jr in health chief's bizarre new stunt

JD Vance breaks ranks with Trump and admits he has 'no idea' if president's letter to Epstein is real

Taylor Swift hits back at ex Matty Healy's 'obnoxious' mother Denise Welch for her interview 'attack'... and issues firm warning

Experts recommend a 'micro' exercise to lose weight... and it only takes 30 seconds

Johnny Depp makes surprise appearance at Alice Cooper's London gig as they perform Black Sabbath's Paranoid dedicated to Ozzy Osbourne

Ghislaine Maxwell granted limited immunity during NINE HOUR grilling by deputy attorney general

Slain grandparents' selfless final act to save their two-year-old grandson

How much Son Heung-min's 'K Factor' is really worth to Tottenham: The enormous value of South Korean fandom, what Spurs lose if he completes Los Angeles switch - and the US jackpot they can finally seize

Starmer risks cabinet revolt by rejecting MPs' demands to acknowledge a Palestinian state

Children drawing on walls and dropping toys in the loo costs parents millions

Watch moment 'air scooter' fails Channel crossing attempt

School-leavers losing their lives for Russia in Putin's war with Ukraine

Salon owner 'ready' for key L'Oréal dispute hearing

Insect boom for UK after warmest, sunniest spring on record

Starmer suggests UK will play role in new Gaza aid air drops

Married couple whose home was bursting with truckloads of illegal sex pills sentenced

With Columbia as a model, White House seeks fines in potential deals with Harvard and others

Ghislaine Maxwell given ‘limited immunity’ in meetings with deputy attorney general: reports

'Immigration is killing Europe': Trump issues warning to leaders as he arrives in Scotland

Botox-like injections spark outbreak of rare disease many doctors have never treated

Hackers prove age verification systems on pornography sites can be bypassed in seconds

Rising costs and tight budgets mean school trips are under threat - even though some kids have never seen the sea

Life was hell after I stabbed my dad Fred West with a screwdriver - but it was mum I was scared of