Keir Starmer Rejects Enoch Powell Comparisons And Stands By 'Island Of Strangers' Claim

Keir Starmer unveils the government’s immigration plans at a Downing Street press conference.Keir Starmer stands by his controversial claim that high levels of immigration risk making Britain “an island of strangers”.The prime minister’s official spokesman also rejected claims that his comments made him sound like right-wing former Tory minister Enoch Powell.Starmer sparked fury with his remarks, which were contained in a speech unveiling Labour’s plans to slash the number of migrants coming to the UK.He said: “In a diverse nation like ours, and I celebrate that, these rules become even more important.“Without them, we risk becoming an island of strangers, not a nation that walks forward together.”Critics pointed out that his words were uncannily similar to those used by Powell in his infamous “rivers of blood” speech in 1968.Powell said: “While, to the immigrant, entry to this country was admission to privileges and opportunities, the impact upon the existing population was very different. For they found themselves made strangers in their own country.”Among those who condemned the PM was Labour MP Nadia Whittome, who said: “The step-up in anti-migrant rhetoric from the government is shameful and dangerous. Migrants are our neighbours, friends and family.“To suggest that Britain risks becoming ‘an island of strangers’ because of immigration mimics the scaremongering of the far-right.”But asked today if Starmer stood by his comments, his spokesman said: “Yes.”On claims that the PM’s remarks echoed Enoch Powell’s, he said: “I reject that comparison. The prime minister has made the argument that migrants make a massive contribution to the UK and have done for generations, not least those who came after the war.“But it is also reasonable to recognise that uncontrolled migration of recent years has put pressure on public services.”The spokesman added: “The prime minister was using his own words to recognise the contribution immigrants have made, but also that uncontrolled migration has been too high. This government is not going to shy away from this issue.”The spokesman also said Starmer “rejects previous speeches” made by Powell.Related...Yvette Cooper Refuses To Repeat Keir Starmer's 'Island Of Strangers' ClaimWhy Starmer's Claim That Britain Risks Becoming An 'Island Of Strangers' Has Caused OutrageAnalysis: Keir Starmer's Credibility Problem On Immigration Means He Can't Out-Farage Farage

Comments

Breaking news

Police probe after boy, 3, injured in attack by 'bull breed' dog

The Herald

Comments

Similar News

Reform holds on to five-point poll lead as dust settles after local elections - despite Keir Starmer's desperate attempt to woo back voters

Chilling video shows car engulfed in flames outside Keir Starmer’s house

Chilling video shows blaze outside Keir Starmer's home as man, 21, arrested

Keir Starmer doubles down on 'island of strangers' remark after Enoch Powell comparison

Revealed: Keir Starmer's sister-in-law was staying at 'firebombed' £2m house - as it emerges he sold 'torched' SUV to neighbour last year

Keir doubles down on migration pledge as new raft of small boats arrive hours after ‘take back borders’ promise

Nigel Farage's Reform UK reached a crucial 'tipping point' - and it's worrying news for Keir Starmer

'Britain is already an island of strangers': Tory Robert Jenrick echoes Keir Starmer's hardline migrant speech - and says PM didn't go far enough

Moment flames engulf car outside Keir Starmer’s home as man arrested over ‘arson’ attack on TWO properties linked to PM

What we know about arson attacks at Keir Starmer’s home as terror police investigate

First pictures of car exploding near Keir Starmer’s house in ‘arson attack’

Former Scottish Labour MP accuses party of 'losing its soul' after Keir Starmer pledges immigration crack down

Moment car explodes on road where Keir Starmer's £2m home was 'targeted in arson attack' - as counter-terror cops quiz suspect, 21, over fires

Oldest surviving victim of the Post Office scandal savages Keir Starmer for 'continuing this little game' as she reveals she STILL hasn't been compensated

Tory MP Robert Jenrick backs Keir Starmer in ‘island of strangers’ row

Yvette Cooper Refuses To Repeat Keir Starmer's 'Island Of Strangers' Claim

Man arrested over arson attacks after fire at Keir Starmer's house

Keir Starmer home fire: Man arrested over alleged arson attack

Keir Starmer arson attacks arrest: Man, 21, arrested by counter terror cops on suspicion of arson with intent to endanger life after three fires

Man arrested after fires at homes linked to PM Keir Starmer

Breaking news

Police probe after boy, 3, injured in attack by 'bull breed' dog

Clarkston laundrette gutted by flames after blaze breaks out

What does ‘to have the whip suspended’ mean in Politics?

Man arrested after woman ‘body slammed’ in worrying trend spreading across London

Amazon shopper says you 'can't go wrong' with 'comfy' £30 open-ear headphones

Law student caught smuggling £150k of drugs through Edinburgh Airport

Husband and wife to walk Kirkcudbright Half Marathon for cause close to their hearts

Former Dumfries and Galloway MP formerly introduced to House of Lords

Falkirk schools' have highest number of leavers going to 'positive destination'

Scots nurse suspended over row with trans doctor welcomes Supreme Court ruling on definition of woman

Shoppers rave over Next's 'showstopper' vase that enhances any hallway or windowsill

Toddler bitten by bull-type dog outside shop as police probe attack

Leading lawyer who had kidney transplant now facing second one

Woman charged after little boy with Down's Syndrome "smacked" at school as dad hits out

Disturbing doorbell camera footage captures last sighting of 'spooked' missing teen

Tory MP charged with two counts of sexual assault following alleged incidents at exclusive club

British tourist fighting for life in Crete after collapsing in hotel pool

Teenage girl raped in Bellshill park as police hunt two men

UK's biggest water company apologises to customers but defends bonuses

Three Belgian soldiers injured in 'shooting incident' during training exercise in Scotland

'Self-obsessed' woman jailed after buying holidays and luxury gifts on company credit card

FBI-trained expert explains which body part is the 'most honest' when it comes to lying

Train passenger knocked unconscious when Motherwell thug stamped on his head

Kim Kardashian feared she was going to die during Paris heist - and tells robber she forgives him

Jaguar Land Rover ‘cannot discount’ building cars in US amid tariffs

Kim Kardashian forgives Paris robber in emotional testimony for $10m heist trial: Live updates

San Jose’s Democratic mayor defends plan to arrest homeless people who refuse shelter

Kate hailed a ‘fashion icon’ as she presents award in Victoria Beckham suit

How Russia is pushing to take control of Africa’s nuclear future

Government bans early work of Botticelli from being exported out of UK

European economist says Russia's economy is strained due to the Ukraine war and sanctions

Stanley Tucci returns to Italy with National Geographic series and vows to 'go more in depth'

Trump’s ‘big beautiful bill’ proposes a MAGA bank account for kids. What does it mean?

How Trump’s aid cuts are inflicting double the pain on LGBT+ people

Olympic gold medalist who served on Trump’s council for fitness arrested in prostitution sting

‘That’s not America first’: MAGA turns on Trump over gift $400m jet from Qatar

College student dies after falling from hotel balcony on trip to Bahamas: ‘An enormous tragedy’

Deported inmates taunt and mock Matt Gaetz and GOP delegation visiting El Salvador mega prison for OAN show

Funerals held in Myanmar for pupils and teachers killed in airstrike on school

Harvard loses another $450 million in grants in escalating battle with Trump administration

Menendez brothers resentencing hearing set to get underway after months of delays: Live

A closer look at the jurors in the Sean 'Diddy' Combs trial

Bill to make pornography a federal crime introduced by GOP senator

Washington Post CEO in a ‘state of hiding’ as staffers joke about his rumored drinking amid low morale

Teen girl raped in park as police probe underway

Police probe Ayr vs Partick fan disorder that left officer injured

Trans tribunal nurse welcomes Supreme Court judgment on biological sex

Tory MP charged with two sexual assaults at London’s Groucho Club

Water could be restricted for 16,000,000 people in UK ahead of potential drought

Major UK Pride parades ban political parties from marching

Top UN general warns ‘hunger used as weapon of war’ to starve Palestinians

'Look rich, chic and classy' with Primark's new summer collection from £5

Sky's Ultimate TV and broadband deal for only £39 ends tomorrow

Peter Sullivan has murder conviction quashed in UK's longest miscarriage of justice

Breathing Space bench to be unveiled at Uddingston station

Exact times ScotRail passengers can drink booze on trains from next month as ban axed

Lanarkshire cops hunt two men after 'serious' sex attack on girl, 17