Labour's 'Shocking' Decision To Move Asylum Seekers Into Military Barracks Is Already Causing Trouble

An inflatable dinghy carrying around 65 migrants crosses the English Channel on March 06, 2024 in the English Channel. The government tried to execute a hat trick earlier this week.Monday began on a particularly sticky note, as a cross-bench of MPs unveiled a brutal report into the Home Office’s management of the asylum system.The Home Affairs Committee accused the department of squandering billions of taxpayers’ pounds on mismanagement of asylum accommodation, and claimed flawed contracts and incompetent delivery were to blame for the chaotic system the UK is now faced with.The MPs said they expected accommodation costs had tripled to more than £15 billion since hotels were first used to house asylum seekers.Prime minister Keir Starmer quickly said he was “frustrated and angry” by the “mess” left by the Tory government (even though his government were, of course, elected 16 months ago). The government knows full well that this is an unsafe and inappropriate form of accommodation The following day, he announced they were moving 900 asylum seekers from hotels into disused military barracks as part of Labour’s drive to stop using asylum hotels altogether by 2029.Even though this was a U-turn on Labour’s previous promises to focus on “smaller sites” and the private rental market, it was at least a response to their critics like Reform UK and the Conservatives who have long called for a stronger migrant crackdown.With immigration and asylum now a prominent concern for Brits according to polls, it’s not too surprising Labour wanted to send out a sharp response.Starmer told the BBC he was “really pleased” more asylum seekers would be housed on military bases “by the end of this year” after he told officials to “go faster, go further” to locate appropriate sites.Defence minister Luke Pollard told the same broadcaster these barracks were not “luxury accommodation by any means” but “adequate for what is required.”Indeed, much of this push to move asylum seekers out of hotels is driven by cost – even though the National Audit Office concluded in March 2024 that large military sites would only cost more than hotels to accommodate.But human rights organisations have long warned against the use of such sites as an alternative – Freedom from Torture’s Natasha Tsangarides told HuffPost UK about the consequences.“Every day, we see the impact that inappropriate and unsafe accommodation has on torture survivors,” she said.With one in three asylum seekers believed to be survivors of torture, she said it was important they are housed in the community to help them recover.Protesters hold placards during a demonstration in Orpington near London, Friday, Aug. 22, 2025 The continued reliance on “unsafe and inappropriate accommodation” makes it clear the government is not listening to warnings from organisations like hers, Tsangarides said – noting the government have still not addressed the underlying problems of poor quality decision making.Tsangarides, the associate director of advocacy for Freedom from Torture, said: “It’s frankly shocking because the government knows full well that this is an unsafe and inappropriate form of accommodation.“There is a wealth of evidence in the public domain that points to why that is the case.“For people who have fled torture, poor housing can be really re-traumatising.”She warned that putting people in accommodation which could be “quite reminiscent of places where people themselves have been tortured” can trigger serious mental health difficulties, like flashbacks, anxiety, depression and suicidal ideation”.“The government needs to be more responsible with this vulnerable population, and think of solution that really centre the safety and dignity of these people,” she added. Asked if it was a case of choosing between hotels and military barracks, the expert said Freedom from Torture would call for the closure of both of them because they are “wholly inappropriate sites”. Another short-term measure from a system that urgently needs long-term humane reform Sile Reynolds, head of asylum advocacy at Freedom from Torture said: “Every day in our therapy rooms, we see first-hand the devastating impact unsafe and unsuitable asylum housing has on survivors of torture. These are men, women and children who are trying to recover after unimaginable cruelty.“They need stability, privacy and safety – not another source of fear. Better quality and faster asylum decisions would allow the government to empty the hotels, while locally-tailored and resourced housing models would mean that refugees could rebuild their lives in thriving communities.”The charity also pointed to fears the government could breach the UN Convention Against Torture unless it looks after its asylum seekers.It warned survivors have “an internationally recognised right to rehabilitation, which aims to restore their physical, mental, social, and vocational abilitiesfor their full inclusion and participation in society”“As a signatory to the Convention, the government must provide the means for as full rehabilitation as possible,” the charity warned in a report on housing asylum seekers this week.Around 200 migrants are already suing the government over alleged inhumane treatment at another former military base at the Manston asylum processing centre under the European Convention on Human Rights.Freedom from Torture recommended closing large sites and phasing out the use of hotels, and housing asylum seekers in communities across the UK instead.The Scottish Refugee Council also slammed the news, calling it “another short-term measure from a system that urgently needs long-term humane reform”. The government is undoubtedly under growing political pressure, especially amid the rise of anti-migrant Reform UK.The MP for Inverness, Skye and Wester Ross Angus MacDonald also hit out at the decision to house asylum seekers at a Barracks in his constituency.The Liberal Democrat told Times Radio this week: “I can think of no reason why they would want to put people there. It’s bad for the area. It’s bad for the migrants. It’s a no win situation.”He added: “I’m sure it won’t be welcomed. What is the difference between a town centre migrant hotel and a town centre migrant barracks? It is a 10 minute walk to the high street.”And Scottish first Minister John Swinney accused the UK government of a “poor approach” too, and warned there had not been enough engagement.As immigration expert Zoe Gardner wrote in the Metro: “This is cruelty for cruelty’s sake – a desperate bid to signal hostility, not a real attempt to fix the system or deliver value for money or results.”The Home Office has been approached for comment.Related...'Disgusting': Kemi Badenoch Savaged Over Plans For Trump-Style Immigration RaidsLabour's New Plan For Asylum Accommodation Is Exactly Like The One They Spurned Just Months AgoKeir Starmer's Asylum Seeker Woes Just Keep Getting Worse

Comments

Breaking news

Court backlog scandal: ‘I waited six years to see my violent ex sent down’

Metro

Comments

Similar News

Man Released Under Labour's Jail-Emptying Programme Charged With London Murder

It's the Rachel Reeves and Angela Rayner show! AI-generated video to the beat of Blurred Lines pokes fun at scandal-hit Labour ministers

Labour-run Birmingham council was probably never bankrupt, expert says

Greens Overtake Labour For The First Time In Opinion Poll Amid New Surge Of Support

Starmer Raises Eyebrows By Promoting Labour's Work On 'Renters' Rights' Amid Reeves' Rental Row

Stunning poll shows Labour and Tories behind the GREENS for the first time as Reform UK smashes traditional political allegiances

Ministers accused of abandoning hope of tackling spiralling benefits bill after Labour revolt: White paper 'is scrapped' and disability review 'won't focus on savings'

Labour struggles to contain fresh NHS strike threats as unions dismiss 2.5% pay rise... despite ministers warning taxpayers can't afford more

Labour minister recalls odd Prince Andrew request - 'he didn't deserve titles'

Labour slammed for hiring butlers for VIP guests during cost of living crisis

Just 2% of councils think Labour funding plan for struggling households is enough

Six Labour MPs suspended over two-child benefit limit demand 'cruel policy scrapped in full'

Leftist Labour Party Falls to Record Low Support, as Farage's Reform and Greens Surge

Gazan students allowed to bring their families to Britain as Labour reverses ban

Rachel Reeves has proven me right about Labour – yet again

Labour gives latest update on PIP disability benefit review after U-turn

Panicking Reeves 'could cripple economy with 2p income tax hike' - the first for 50 YEARS - as she bows to Labour MPs by kicking welfare reforms into long grass

Labour frees 38,000 criminals early under controversial soft justice scheme

Schoolgirl, 16, whose body was found in river weeks after reporting labourer for rape helped convict him from beyond the grave - as he faces jail

Is sorry really enough? Fury as Starmer snubs sleaze probe into Reeves for unlawfully renting out London home without a licence - despite others being taken to court and Labour vowing crackdown

Breaking news

Court backlog scandal: ‘I waited six years to see my violent ex sent down’

His Brother Admitted To A Murder. He Is Set To Be Executed For It.

New Pentagon policy undercuts trans troops' ability to ask to stay in the military, AP learns

Pet monkey in diaper sparks chaos in Texas Halloween shop

Trump efforts to help US coal undercut by export drop during trade war

FDA restricts use of kids' fluoride supplements citing emerging health risks

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs transferred to new prison to serve four-year sentence

Police investigating break-in at home reported to belong to NBA star Shai Gilgeous-Alexander

Pfizer sues to stop rival bid for drugmaker Metsera by Denmark's Novo Nordisk

Stephen Miller holds secret calls with diplomats every day to push Trump’s immigration agenda across the globe: report

Remains of three unidentified people handed over to Israel, Red Cross says

Republican Rep. Nancy Mace accused of directing expletive-ridden rant at ‘incompetent’ airport cops: police report

Glasgow firework control zones in force for first time after Bonfire Night carnage

Email exchange between Andrew and Epstein released in court papers - after King strips him of titles

Prosecutors get new information about murder of Meredith Kercher

Marine 'tried to kidnap and sexually assault schoolgirl, 12, he met at park'

Boy, 10, came home from school with stomach bug symptoms - then he suddenly died

King Charles 'wrestles Prince Andrew's future from his grasp' with brutal statement

Lionesses legend Mary Earps makes explosive claims about Hannah Hampton's 'bad behaviour' and Sarina Wiegman's preferential treatment for rival goalkeeper as she lifts lid on her dramatic exit before the Euros

Sudanese warlord dubbed 'Butcher of the Century' arrested for his atrocities after posting TikToks of him committing brutal executions and boasting of killing more than 2,000 civilians

Heartless fraudster who posed as a police officer to steal £27,000 of cash and jewellery from pensioner's home in affluent Cheshire village

Paul Scholes issues emotional 'thank you' to fans after opening up on caring for his non-verbal autistic son, 20

'It was like a punch to the stomach': Grieving mother's anguish after teens jailed for killing her son, 16, with zombie knife at house party have convictions quashed

The man Trump calls a '100 per cent communist lunatic'... Zohran Mamdani has described capitalism as 'theft' and the police as 'evil' - and now he's set to be mayor of New York: TOM LEONARD

Lindsay Lohan posts rare photo of son, 2, as she gets into the Halloween spirit with matching Batman costumes

Traitors stars Paloma Faith and Alan Carr finally put their feud to bed as singer reposts a Halloween throwback of their celebrations together

Tchéky Karyo dies aged 72: French actor who starred in BBC hit drama The Missing and James Bond's GoldenEye passes away after cancer battle

Andrew's 'hermit life' in Sandringham: Disgraced royal will keep 'lowest possible profile' in Norfolk as locals warn 'horrible man' is not welcome after his Royal Lodge eviction

Terrifying moment high-speed train carrying 400 passengers ploughs into fruit lorry at level crossing

Frightening scenes from Oasis concert in Melbourne leaves brothers Noel and Liam Gallagher in shock as FLARES launch into sold-out crowd

Alan Carr's legion of fans think he's now a shoo-in to host Strictly... as the comedian and presenter becomes unlikely favourite to win Celebrity Traitors: KATIE HIND

The Kenyan corner shop owner tricked into fighting for Putin - who escaped the meatgrinder by hiding under a corpse... DAVID PATRIKARAKOS investigates the impoverished Africans being lured to Russia as cannon fodder

Big Brother's Farida and Zelah are evicted from the house in brutal DOUBLE eviction

'The Tripod has collapsed': That's how Sarah, Beatrice and Eugenie described their bond. But now insiders say the princesses are more disappointed in their mother than their father, writes REBECCA ENGLISH

'Downfall of a prince' and 'something completely Python'

The U.S. Was Ordered to Pay Food Stamp Benefits

NASA Gets Moon Lander Plan B’s From SpaceX and Blue Origin

SNAP Map: Here’s Who Will Be Affected by Disruptions to Food Aid

What Tuesday’s Elections Might Tell Us About Trump

Teenager plays ‘game of chicken’ with train going at 100mph

Urgent recall for popular chocolate bar after allergen label mistake

Cockroaches, blood in the sinks and nowhere to bathe: Immigrants sue over ‘horrific’ conditions inside Chicago ICE facility

More than half of Americans underestimate the link between how much they drink and cancer

Ohio man forgot his winning $50 lotto ticket at home when he went to cash it. So he bought another and hit the jackpot

Judge orders arrest of ex-Green Beret tied to failed Venezuela raid after court no-show

30 staff sacked at Grand Theft Auto developer in alleged ‘union-busting’ move

Virginia Roberts Giuffre family celebrates her ‘extraordinary courage’ as Andrew is stripped of title

Federal judge blocks Trump’s citizenship requirement on federal voting form

“Where would America be without us?” A community of refugees is stunned by White House limits

Explosion at New Mexico oil refinery sends thick smoke across Artesia

17-year-old accused of beating his grandmother, 73, to death inside the Mississippi church they attended

Protesters call for governor’s resignation after Rio’s deadliest police raid

Camilla was ‘concerned’ Andrew row would impact her work with abuse survivors

Sean 'Diddy' Combs transferred to New Jersey prison to serve 4-year prostitution-related sentence

13-year-old boy wanted for grandmother’s killing, fatally killed by police

NY judge dismisses legal challenge from Texas in early test of abortion shield law

Daylight saving time ends this weekend. Here’s a simple way to reset your body clock faster