'My Mother-In-Law Huffed At Me For Breastfeeding. Was My Reaction Unfair?'

You’re reading Between Us, a place for parents to offload and share their tricky parenting dilemmas. Share your parenting dilemma here and we’ll seek advice from experts.It’s all too easy to say that grandparents shouldn’t speak much about how their children raise their own kids.But when we consider that 57% of UK parents rely on those same people for childcare, the picture gets fuzzier. Redditor u/Lll-Hall-2953 took to the internet this week to say her mother-in-law doesn’t like her breastfeeding in her presence – and she’s extremely vocal about it.So, we spoke to Jo Hayes, founder of Etiquette Expert, and Dorcy Porter, founder of the Conscious Co-Parenting Institute, about how to handle grandparents who take their parenting “rules” too far.The original poster (OP) was tired of her mother-in-law’s commentsPosting to r/AITAH (Am I The Asshole Here), the mother shared that she’s just had a baby and is breastfeeding.Recently, her mother-in-law visited on short notice while she was doing chores around the house.She pottered around the garden, chatted with OP’s husband for a bit, and watched the news. The poster was sitting watching the news with her when her baby started to get fussy, so she decided to feed them. “My MIL swung her head to me and gave me a look. She huffed and said ‘Really? Around me? I’ll just get naked too and have it all hanging out huh’ and rolled her eyes at me,” the poster claimed.She said this isn’t the first time her husband’s mother had made similar comments about breastfeeding, either. So, because she was tired and frustrated, the poster said: “I just pulled off my top and stood up right in front of her and told her, ‘I’ll feed my baby when I want in my house.’“She just stared at me and I added ‘If you don’t like it you can leave.’ I sat back down and she said ‘I can’t believe this girl,’ and got up and left.” Her husband thought the response was a bit extreme, and her mother-in-law is apparently furious. Both experts think the criticism was unfair“What on Earth is distasteful about breastfeeding in the home?” etiquette expert Hayes asked. “If it’s distasteful there, where could it possibly be considered ‘tasteful’? It’s unhelpful and uncharitable to make them feel bad for parenting in a way that you don’t necessarily approve of.” Porter added: “When a grandparent criticises your parenting, it’s rarely about the thing they’re pointing at.“It’s about their unmet needs, unhealed wounds, or fear of losing relevance.”When a grandparent oversteps their boundaries, Hayes advises parents to “kindly, calmly but clearly communicate this to your parents or in-laws”.Reaffirm that “the parent of the child is the one who gets to make parenting decisions ― not the grandparents”.“You don’t owe anyone a parenting debate,” Porter said.“A calm, clear ‘This is what works for us’ is more powerful than over-explaining or defending your choices.” She concluded: “You’re allowed to break patterns that your parents never had the tools to heal. That’s not betrayal. That’s leadership.”Related...We're Therapists – These Are The Most Common Ways Grandparents Overstep'Motherhood Does Not Erase Your Sexuality' – 3 Mums On Sex During And After PregnancyYou Ask, Experts Answer: 'My Husband Lent £7,500 To His Mother Without Telling Me'After I Cut Off Contact From My Mother, I Was Shocked By The Brutal Move My Sisters Made

Comments

Breaking news

Jerusalem wildfires latest: Israel declares national emergency and appeals for international aid over ‘largest ever’ blaze

about 1 hour ago

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Kyiv and US sign vital minerals deal after Trump softens demands

Secrets of Olly Murs' jaw-dropping body transformation: Personal trainer reveals exact routine singer followed to get in the best shape of his life at 40 - even if it has divided fans!

about 4 hours ago

Don't forget the sun cream... for your CAT: Vet urges pet owners to take care of their felines as temperatures rise

about 4 hours ago

Scientists are using living human brain tissue to study Alzheimer's on their hunt for a cure - and experts are expecting a breakthrough

about 4 hours ago

The vintage Ikea pieces that are now worth thousands, as new London mega-store opens - so, do YOU have one in your home?

about 4 hours ago

Girlfriends behind rap group Kneecap revealed as one of Ireland's 'most sought-after singers' and a drama school director - amid calls for band to be axed from Glastonbury over pro-Hamas and 'kill your local MP' chants

about 4 hours ago

Inside dystopian megacity that makes half the world's laptops: Chinese metropolis of 30million where workers 'don't see the sunlight' and big brother is always watching... but which you've probably never heard of

about 4 hours ago

China and Philippines' war on the high seas: How two countries have rammed each others' ships and blockaded tiny South China Sea islands in territorial battle that threatens to spiral into WW3

about 4 hours ago

British expat in Spain shares 'mistake' everyone makes before they move

about 4 hours ago

When TINA NASH'S boyfriend gouged out her eyes the case horrified the nation. Now he's about to be let out she tells how she knows he's a psychopath... and fears he'll strike again

about 4 hours ago

David Beckham's most popular haircut is revealed - ahead of his milestone 50th birthday

Drax takes ancient trees from near my Carolina home and burns them 4,000 miles away. This greenwashing scandal utterly shames Britain

about 4 hours ago

Could a gorilla beat 100 men in a fight? This question's electrifying the world - now a top expert gives fascinating definitive answer... and it's not what you expect

about 4 hours ago

Amanda Owen's dream life on the farm derailed: How it's gone wrong for Yorkshire Shepherdess once branded UK's most 'authentic' star

about 4 hours ago

Could AI boyfriends solve modern dating woes? Widow reveals how she found comfort in virtual companions

about 4 hours ago

Comments

Breaking news

Jerusalem wildfires latest: Israel declares national emergency and appeals for international aid over ‘largest ever’ blaze

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Kyiv and US sign vital minerals deal after Trump softens demands

Sir Rod Stewart steps in to help autistic Scots boy caught in 'blackhole' waiting for diagnosis

New Motability Scheme update for people on PIP, ADP and other disability benefits

Dear Coleen: I'm in a relationship but think I've fallen for female friend

Sir Rod Stewart help offer is great but waiting lists are far too long for young Scots

Irn-Bru proposes Kelpies makeover for World Unicorn Day alongside new flavours

Victim of vicious racist attack left lifeless in street after cops sent to wrong town

'The untouchables' Directors behind £6m NHS corruption scandal 'thought they would walk free'

Sextortion gangs using AI porn fakes to target rising number of Scots victims

SNP by-election candidate spotted with activist who called King Charles 'inbred'

MSP demands crackdown on youth violence after brutal attacks on girls filmed for Snapchat

SFA linesman who missed 'ghost goal' in viral blunder selected as Scottish Labour candidate

Russell Grant's horoscopes as Aquarius explores exciting new paths

Tesla's board looking for Elon Musk's successor as CEO - reports

5 new books you need to read in May 2025 - including Love Island thriller and ‘incredible’ romantasy

Dad killed in Leeds hit and run 'lived and breathed his IVF miracle son'

Belfast public needle bin 'not a silver bullet'

North Korea: First road bridge to Russia 'significant' development

Armagh healthy ready meal firm enters liquidation

Mosquitoes in Scotland as far north as Shetland

What we know about US-Ukraine minerals deal

US releases Mohsen Mahdawi, detained Columbia student activist

Mushroom trial: Rare for alleged killer to host lunch, ex-husband says

Trump tells business chiefs he needs 'little bit of time' as US economy shrinks

Trump’s Tariffs Lead Japan to Slash Its Economic Growth Forecast

Trump suddenly slow-walks tariff deals at town hall: ‘I’m in less of a hurry than you’

Trump says he would ‘love’ to see ESPN pundit Stephen A. Smith run for president

The top photos of the day by AP's photojournalists

The trade clause that's rarely examined &#8211; but already costing online shoppers more

Augmented reality brings to life the stories of VE Day

Victims of second Post Office scandal to receive 'recognition' payments before compensation

Seriously ill children from Gaza war zone allowed into the UK for treatment for the first time

Mystery as popular parachutist dies during skydive in 'deeply upsetting' tragedy

Horrifying moment fan falls from 21-foot wall at Major League Baseball game as players pray and hold crosses

US judge refers Apple for possible criminal contempt

US and Ukraine sign long-awaited natural resources deal

Investigating Shrimp Fraud Is an Urgent Matter on the Gulf Coast

PHOTO COLLECTION: Spring Weather

In this Indian city, smartwatches are part of the solution to dealing with searing heat

Port Arthur LNG scaffolding collapse: Three construction workers dead in horror industrial accident

China claims US could be true origin of Covid in astonishing new report

Beloved restaurant chain Steak of the Art collapses into administration

Major UK brewery closes after 40 years as Covid and tax hikes take their toll

Secrets of Olly Murs' jaw-dropping body transformation: Personal trainer reveals exact routine singer followed to get in the best shape of his life at 40 - even if it has divided fans!

Don't forget the sun cream... for your CAT: Vet urges pet owners to take care of their felines as temperatures rise

Scientists are using living human brain tissue to study Alzheimer's on their hunt for a cure - and experts are expecting a breakthrough

The vintage Ikea pieces that are now worth thousands, as new London mega-store opens - so, do YOU have one in your home?

Girlfriends behind rap group Kneecap revealed as one of Ireland's 'most sought-after singers' and a drama school director - amid calls for band to be axed from Glastonbury over pro-Hamas and 'kill your local MP' chants

Inside dystopian megacity that makes half the world's laptops: Chinese metropolis of 30million where workers 'don't see the sunlight' and big brother is always watching... but which you've probably never heard of

China and Philippines' war on the high seas: How two countries have rammed each others' ships and blockaded tiny South China Sea islands in territorial battle that threatens to spiral into WW3

British expat in Spain shares 'mistake' everyone makes before they move

When TINA NASH'S boyfriend gouged out her eyes the case horrified the nation. Now he's about to be let out she tells how she knows he's a psychopath... and fears he'll strike again

David Beckham's most popular haircut is revealed - ahead of his milestone 50th birthday

Why weight-loss jabs are making you feel worse. Expert reveals the shocking Ozempic side-effect doctors won't talk about

How to get Kate's summer hair and the secret anti-aging technique to ask for, revealed by her top hairstylist

Drax takes ancient trees from near my Carolina home and burns them 4,000 miles away. This greenwashing scandal utterly shames Britain

Could a gorilla beat 100 men in a fight? This question's electrifying the world - now a top expert gives fascinating definitive answer... and it's not what you expect

Amanda Owen's dream life on the farm derailed: How it's gone wrong for Yorkshire Shepherdess once branded UK's most 'authentic' star

Could AI boyfriends solve modern dating woes? Widow reveals how she found comfort in virtual companions

The trade clause that's rarely examined – but already costing online shoppers more