My Mum Dropped A Shocking Family Secret In My Lap. I Never Looked At My Father The Same Way Again.

“There’s something I have to tell you,” my mother said in a tone that suggested a life-changing reveal was coming my way at Applebee’s. “I’m adopted?” I asked. At 22, I knew my dark colouring had long been a point of discomfort for my parents, both blonde with light eyes. “Who does she look like...?” people would ask, fishing for a story.“Joy looks like Joy,” my mother used to say.“You’re not adopted,” she said now. “Daddy’s not my real father?” I guessed. It had never occurred to me before that only one of them wasn’t my biological parent, but the look on my mother’s face told me the answer was yes before she said the word. I always knew my parents tried to have a baby for five years, and that my mother’s beloved gynaecologist helped her conceive me, their only child. What I only learned that night was how her doctor helped — by inseminating my mother with donated sperm. “The doctor told me to lie on my back for 10 minutes after — I insisted on lying there for an hour, just to be sure,” my mother said proudly. "This picture was taken at the Wayside Inn in Sudbury, Massachusetts, when I was two years old in 1976," the author writes. "My dad preferred to be behind the lens so most photos in our collection are of my mother and me, but for this one, he must have handed her the camera."All she knew about the donor’s identity was that he was a medical student. Doctor’s office fertilisations like this were done for heterosexual married couples only in the 1970s, with the clear understanding that no one — including their child ― would ever have to know. My father had gone along with this grudgingly. “He did it for me,” my mother said, reaching for my hand across the table at the restaurant. “So I could have you.”She explained that my father would have been fine letting nature take its course — or not. But my mother was desperate for a baby. This was why she was telling me now, with my dad’s approval. He and I weren’t getting along, and she wanted me to see the sacrifice he had made for her — for us. Suddenly the emotional distance I had often felt with my dad made sense. I remembered going out with him alone only a few times when I was a little kid. He let me sit in the front seat of the car and drink orange soda from a can — things my mother never allowed. But our times together felt out of sync. I was once so excited to paint my bedroom dresser with my father in the basement, only to find that he had finished by the time I found the perfect outfit for the project. I was jealous of the way my little cousins raced into their dad’s arms when he came home. My dad and I were like coworkers who both reported to my mom — cordial, but in quiet competition to be her favourite. The author and her father, Stuart, circa 1980.“Where is he when I need him?” my mother used to yell when something went wrong and my father was out, as he often was. But I liked it better when he wasn’t around. His arrival home brought his unhappiness into the house, which I didn’t know how to manage.With my mother, whose moods could also be unpredictable, I knew exactly how to jolly her up: by doing humorous impressions of people we both knew, or playing with her hair, or showing her some of my art. I didn’t really know how to make my dad happy, and not being able to figure it out made me feel like a failure. I wondered now if this lack of biological connection was why he didn’t look at me the way a father looked at a beloved daughter ― because he didn’t see himself reflected back? I could never bring myself to ask. My dad and I talked about the details of my conception only twice, once right after my mother’s big reveal, when I wanted to know if this was something he thought about often (it was), and if it caused him pain (it did). The second time was 20 years later, when I told him about finding my donor siblings. "My dad and I usually side-hugged, but I've always liked this shot of us in a close embrace taken around the time of my college graduation in 1996," the author writes.In the early 2000s, I had heard about the Donor Sibling Registry, started by a mother and the son she had conceived using a sperm donor. I joined because I’d recently been on the subway sitting across from someone I thought looked so much like me that I almost introduced myself. Could she have been a half-sibling? Then at the dentist’s office, a hygienist said there was another patient who resembled me so closely — even our dental X-rays looked alike — that she just assumed this person was my sister. “Oh no,” I had told her. “I’m an only child.” But was I? Nothing came of my profile on the Donor Sibling Registry until 10 years later, when I received a Facebook message from a man who thought he might be my half-brother. By that time, genetic testing kits were readily available. I ordered one. The results revealed this man was not my half-sibling, but two other people were. My half-brother, half-sister and I met, and the connection I felt sent me on a high. I decided to tell my parents. They did not share my enthusiasm.My father made it clear he didn’t want me to have a public relationship with these new family members. He swore it wasn’t because revealing this to our relatives and friends would make the truth about my conception clear to everyone, but of course that was the reason. He yelled. I held my ground. The author with her dad at her college graduation in 1996. "My father didn’t have the opportunity to go to the college of his choice; he worked two jobs to put me through Vassar, and in doing so, he changed my life," she writes.I felt like I had lived my life playing peacemaker and good girl — the roles in our family that my parents demanded of me — and now here was a kin relationship that could be all mine. Later that day, my dad called back to say he was sorry. It is the only time I remember ever receiving an apology from him. He admitted what was happening was difficult, but he said he was happy for me. I told my father I didn’t have any interest in finding the identity of my sperm donor, and that was true. My half-brother felt differently, though, and searching through the web of connections our genetic testing revealed, he found the name of our biological father, who turned out to be a retired doctor. I saw a few Facebook photos of him, and he appeared to me to be someone who liked to hike and fish. I was indoorsy — like the dad who raised me ― so I didn’t inherit that. Instead, I got the retired doctor’s angular jaw and a smile that tilted slightly higher on one side, suggesting we were up to something. The author and her dad circa 2000. "My dad wasn’t a baseball fan, but I took him to a Red Sox game because I thought that was a father-daughter thing to do," she writes.My half-brother reached out to see if our donor would like to meet, but he declined. I understood. Our half-sibling group has since grown from three to 10, and there are probably more of us out there. By that point, our biological father was in his 80s, with children and likely grandchildren. I didn’t imagine he wanted the risk of getting to know who-knows-how-many additional progeny. What if we wanted support — emotional or financial? I didn’t want anything from him other than an answer to one question: Why did you do it? I wondered if it was it to help couples have children, to feel virile, to make some extra money — I believe sperm donors were paid for their contributions ― or something else.But I could live with not knowing the answer because it was only thanks to my donor that I was living at all. One man was responsible for the beginning of my life, and another for everything that came after. As I got older, I came to see that my father didn’t really look to me to make him happy, the way my mother did. He wanted to take care of me, not the other way around. This was why we were sometimes at odds — we both felt more comfortable giving support than receiving it. My mom and I used to joke about “The Father Book of Knowledge,” since he seemed to know everything about anything. But I truly trusted his advice over any doctor or expert. When I went into labor with my son and was terrified, my father drove four hours nonstop to hold my hand. In his hands, I felt safe. My mother was there for chats about family and friends and the day-to-day stuff of life, but my dad was always the first person I called whenever something went really right — or really wrong.Where was he when I needed him? Always a phone call away. "This photo was taken at my cousin's son's Bar Mitzvah in 2010," the author writes "I love the tender way my dad is holding Nathaniel's hand."I spent much of my youth concentrating on the distance between my father and me. As I got older, I tried to focus on what brought us together. I’d never been a daddy’s girl, but I had grown into a woman who loved her dad. Six years ago, my son and I came upon a newborn bunny under a bush that seemed to have been abandoned. We picked it up and took it home. “You did what?” my father said, when I called to ask for his advice. “It would have been better off if you left it there.” I hoped he was wrong, but he was rarely wrong. I put the tiny rabbit on a heating pad like he said to do, but it didn’t live for longer than an hour. “Was it our fault?” my son asked. “No, baby,” I said, even though I wasn’t sure. “And this way he died with us, in a warm place. And not alone. He didn’t suffer.”My dad didn’t suffer either, when he died one week later without any warning. At least I hope he didn’t. The heart attack was very fast. At least I hope it was.The author's father with her son, Nathaniel, in 2010. "It wasn’t until my son was born that I found out my dad was really good with infants," she writes.I only just now played the last voicemail message he ever left me.“This is the Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Rabbits,” he said in his joking voice. “We hear there is a report of bunny abuse... I’m just kidding, Joy Anne. You did the best you could.” I tried. So did he. My mother told me the truth about my conception to help me appreciate my dad more, and it did. My real father didn’t love me because I was his biological child. He loved me in spite of the fact that I wasn’t. Joy Peskin is a writer with work published in Salon, Glamour, Parents Magazine, Publishers Weekly and Lilith. Her essay “My Mother, the Imposter” received first place in the Simon Rockower Awards for Excellence in Jewish Journalism in the “Writing about Seniors” category. Joy is senior executive editor at a major publishing house and a CASA (court-appointed special advocate) for a teen in foster care. For more info, visit joypeskin.com.Do you have a compelling personal story you’d like to see published on HuffPost? Find out what we’re looking for here and send us a pitch at [email protected] 94-Year-Old Father Dropped A Bomb During A Zoom Call – The Explosion Changed Everything'I Stopped Splitting Rent With My Husband After 1 Sentence From My Mother-In-Law. Did I Overreact?I Was Adopted At Age 25. Here’s How It Changed My Life.

Comments

Breaking news

Collapse at Chile's major copper mine kills 1 worker and leaves 5 missing

Independent

New Cat Deeley fear that's left shattered Patrick Kielty in 'very dark place': Insiders tell GRANT TUCKER shock rumour that's exploding in TV world after incident 3 months ago that was talk of his Irish village

about 3 hours ago

Dailymail

Astonishing whispers about Katy Perry and Justin Trudeau's date: Why he feels 'ambushed' and insiders now say he's the victim of a fading pop star: TOM LEONARD

about 3 hours ago

Mother of Baby P would pose a 'high risk' if she was ever around children once freed, parole board warns

Dailymail

Dailymail

My haunted Cotswolds house that proves hauntings are real. NADINE DORRIES thought she'd found her forever home. Then after family deaths and sinister encounters that terrified her children, she called a priest...

about 3 hours ago

Twelve years house arrest for Colombian ex-leader Álvaro Uribe

BBC News

Was a hitman hired to kill Dordogne expat? Days before Karen Carter's brutal stabbing a mysterious man was seen outside her house. Now locals believe her murder could be the work of an assassin

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

France to PAUSE all evacuations of Palestinian asylum seekers from Gaza pending outcome of anti-semitism investigation

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

How an ex-ballerina finally tamed rock's wildest philanderer... At 82, Mick Jagger has never been happier with girlfriend Mel, 38, and are even talking of having another baby 'if fate allows'

about 4 hours ago

Comments

Breaking news

Collapse at Chile's major copper mine kills 1 worker and leaves 5 missing

‘Fire clouds’ springing up around the Grand Canyon

‘Revolving door’ between ICE and private prison companies is boosting Trump’s deportation plans

'Russia stunned into silence' by Donald Trump's nuclear subs move

Why the Oasis reunion tour is 'catastrophic' for Edinburgh Fringe performers

Russian tourists are holidaying at a new North Korean seaside resort - but what's it really like?

You'll need sharpest mind to spot 2 beach essentials in just 10 seconds

Urgent manhunt after murders of four family members and baby found in abandoned car

Jeannie Seely dead: Country music legend who sang Don’t Touch Me passes away at 85

Driving too slowly could cause fatal 'Black Death' for your car, expert warns

Trump demands UK pharmaceutical giants to lower drug costs sparking fears NHS could pay the price if they refuse

New Cat Deeley fear that's left shattered Patrick Kielty in 'very dark place': Insiders tell GRANT TUCKER shock rumour that's exploding in TV world after incident 3 months ago that was talk of his Irish village

Astonishing whispers about Katy Perry and Justin Trudeau's date: Why he feels 'ambushed' and insiders now say he's the victim of a fading pop star: TOM LEONARD

Mother of Baby P would pose a 'high risk' if she was ever around children once freed, parole board warns

Hulk Hogan's official death certificate revealed including details of what will happen to his remains

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: How drink doomed Princess's love affair with Richard Burton

Supermarket begins selling Christmas themed treats in JULY as Brits jet off on their summer holidays

DAILY MAIL COMMENT: Keir Starmer must fight for UK drug firms

Brits shouldn't be signed off work for anxiety and depression, says former Health Secretary Jeremy Hunt

Heston Blumenthal reveals he's taking weight-loss drug Wegovy and shares fears that slimming jabs could pose a threat to the food industry

'Pull new Masterchef series to stop Gregg Wallace accusers being triggered', Broadcast union urges BBC

Helen Flanagan admits she 'wants to stay single' as she candidly discusses feeling 'quite sensitive' dating after split from Robbie Talbot

Stevie Nicks, 77, sparks health concerns as she pulls out of tour dates due to injury

British families of Hamas hostages blast Keir Starmer's plan to recognise Palestinian state that they claim will leave loved ones 'rotting in dungeons'

Teenage boy who was maimed in Gaza becomes the first to be treated for war injuries in the UK

$500m heist of the century: How a twinkly-eyed Italian outsmarted the 'Fort Knox' of Antwerp's diamond district in an audacious robbery worthy of an Ocean's Eleven plot... only to be foiled by a half-eaten salami sandwich

AMANDA PLATELL: My sneaking suspicion that there IS another 'party' in the end of Cat Deeley and Patrick Kielty's marriage

ANDREW NEIL: The Industrial Revolution hit working class jobs but the rise of AI will decimate middle-class employment

As the true scale of the involvement of South Yorkshire Police officers in the Rotherham grooming gangs scandal is revealed, one victim - just 14 at the time - tells her horrific story

My haunted Cotswolds house that proves hauntings are real. NADINE DORRIES thought she'd found her forever home. Then after family deaths and sinister encounters that terrified her children, she called a priest...

Twelve years house arrest for Colombian ex-leader Álvaro Uribe

Jeremy Bowen: 'Thank you, but it's too late': Why some Palestinians aren't convinced by Starmer's promise

They escaped Ukraine's frontlines. The sound of drones followed them

Tesla found partly to blame for fatal Autopilot crash

North Korea sent me abroad to be a secret IT worker. My wages funded the regime

Michael Cardozo, 84, New York City’s Longest-Serving Chief Lawyer, Dies

Trump Fires BLS Commissioner, Claiming Weak Jobs Numbers Were ‘Rigged’

After D.C. Plane Crash, Air Traffic Controllers Were Not Tested for Alcohol

I’m a Therapist. ChatGPT Is Eerily Effective.

Army Pilots Might Have Struggled to See Passenger Jet Before D.C. Crash

The disability employment gap affects 16 million people in the UK – but can the goverment fix it?

Trump moves nuclear submarines and threatens Russia over ‘foolish’ statements

Jeannie Seely, soulful country singer behind hits like 'Don't Touch Me,' dies at 85

Tennessee death row inmate with pacemaker can be executed despite likelihood heart device will prolong suffering: court

Tesla must pay $329 million for a deadly crash involving Autopilot, jury says

Murdered ‘American Idol’ executive met with the police one day prior as new details emerge on deadly break-in

Woman faces more than $20,000 in medical bills after wild bat flies into her mouth

‘First Amendment has limits’: Tom Homan insists that Mahmoud Khalil will be deported

Judge allows the National Science Foundation to withhold hundreds of millions of research dollars

Democrats want to move on. Joe Biden and Kamala Harris won’t let them

Man's body chopped into pieces by his mum and girlfriend who then put remains in bin

Schoolboy, 13, dies after getting trapped in drain during horror Baltimore storm

UK weather: Heatwave returns as new weather maps show four-day 35C scorcher

CHRIS HUGHES: ‘Israeli top negotiator convinced me peace in Middle East is still possible’

M60 traffic LIVE: Motorway closed in both directions after horror crash involving biker

Rapist got unconscious woman pregnant and left her 'so alone and trapped'

Man brutally killed woman on first date and left her body parts around town

Was a hitman hired to kill Dordogne expat? Days before Karen Carter's brutal stabbing a mysterious man was seen outside her house. Now locals believe her murder could be the work of an assassin

France to PAUSE all evacuations of Palestinian asylum seekers from Gaza pending outcome of anti-semitism investigation

How an ex-ballerina finally tamed rock's wildest philanderer... At 82, Mick Jagger has never been happier with girlfriend Mel, 38, and are even talking of having another baby 'if fate allows'

Jeremy Bowen: 'Thank you, but it's too late': Why some Palestinians aren't convinced by Starmer's promise