Should We Stop Calling Kids 'Naughty'? I Asked A Psychologist

There’s been chatter of late about the word “naughty” and whether parents (and grandparents, childcare workers, etc) should be using it to describe children. It all began when former newsreader and child counsellor Kate Silverton told the Netmums podcast about the “naughty” label and how kids can “internalise” the message. This can lead them to believe it’s who they are, which can lead to more tricky behaviour. Silverton, who has written a parenting book called There’s No Such Thing As Naughty, said: “Every day they’re taking in messages from us, from their friends, from their teachers. And words carry such weight of meaning. ‘Stop being silly’, ‘You are so naughty’, He’s the naughty one’.“And we all fall into that trap. But our children are paying very close attention to how we think of them. They are internalising, because, they don’t have that fully formed, rational brain.”She continued: “It’s just a fallacy to call children naughty. They’re not making conscious choices for the majority of the time. They are driven by a very, very immature brain ... And I’d really like to change that language.”Her comments have inspired a wave of opinions, including from Supernanny star Jo Frost, who said on social media the word naughty “isn’t inherently harmful” but added “it must be used with intention, clarity, and care”.She gave the example of saying “that was naughty” to a child only works if followed by context, such as: “That was naughty behaviour because you hit your sister. In this family we value kindness not hurting.”She continued: “You’re not labelling the child. You’re guiding the behaviour – and that distinction is vital.”Her argument is that the word itself isn’t the problem, but rather when people use it “without explanation”. She added: “When we remove language instead of teaching how to use it responsibly, we leave parents confused and children unclear.”What does a psychologist think?Dr Patapia Tzotzoli, clinical psychologist and founder of My Triage Network, told HuffPost UK: “The language we use with children matters – but context and tone are just as important.”She explained there’s a big difference between a parent snapping ‘naughty’ in frustration after a child throws food in anger, and playfully using the word in a light, joking tone whilst smiling.“That said, there’s truth in the concern that repeated use of the word ‘naughty’ can shape a child’s self-concept, especially if used harshly or frequently,” she said.She added (similarly to Jo Frost) that this can be avoided when parents focus on the behaviour, rather than the child’s character.Dr Tzotzoli said parents could instead say “that’s wasn’t helpful” or “this wasn’t a good choice” rather than the blanket – and pretty vague – statement of “you’re naughty”.“This not only avoids shame but also preserves connection, fosters emotional safety, and promotes reflection,” she explained.“In short, it supports a secure parent-child bond, which is essential for effective, long-term emotional regulation and cooperation.”Well, now you know!Related...Psychologist Shares 1 Mistake Parents Make After Tantrums And Squabbles6 Habits That Make Your Kids Well, Not Just Happy — According to PsychologistsI'm A Parenting Coach – If Kids Are Rude, Try This 2-Word Response

Comments

Breaking news

New 'stylish' Italian café opens at Scottish airport

The Herald

Tyson Fury admits it's 'inevitable' his children will get into boxing and shares why they 'MUST' follow in his footsteps as he reveals the one thing that will tempt him out of retirement

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

World's funniest countries, revealed: Czech Republic tops the global league table...while Britain and the US trail behind

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Orcas are spotted SNOGGING in the wild for the first time - and they even use tongues

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Katy Perry is facing more than just heartbreak following her split from Orlando Bloom as she faces major High Court showdown in a matter of months

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Motorists slapped with nearly 40,000 private parking charges a day as DVLA sold record 14.4m driver details last year

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

The world's most glamorous cricket commentator stuns on her luxurious Italian holiday

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Maya Jama denies accusations that Love Island producers are heavily involved in steering Islanders' actions in the villa as she insists 'it has to be real because it's reality'

about 2 hours ago

Dailymail

Ex-wife loses Supreme Court fight against retired banker over the £80m he gave her in a bid to avoid tax - before she divorced him and kept the money

about 2 hours ago

Comments

Breaking news

New 'stylish' Italian café opens at Scottish airport

Yellow warning for thunderstorms issued for parts of Scotland

Uber Eats reveals nominees from Scotland for Restaurant of the Year Awards

'Life-changing' work at university selected for prestigious science showcase

'Historic convergence' of crypto and golf at Trump International in Aberdeen

86-year-old woman robbed in Glasgow attack as man arrested and charged

UK and US publishers back move to block AI scrapers by default

Almost 20,000 asylum seekers in 6 months proves a crucial point

Migrants being ‘whipped’ onto dinghies amid record 20,000 Channel crossings

Does Brown Period Blood Signal Hormonal Issues? I Asked A GP

Banker wins top court battle in landmark £80m inheritance tax divorce row

Couples warned to ‘keep clear records on source of wealth’ following landmark divorce ruling

PHOTO ESSAY: Tohono O'odham families carry on sacred saguaro fruit harvest in Arizona borderlands

One of America’s biggest household brands files for bankruptcy

Watch: Rachel Reeves appears to cry at PMQs after Starmer refuses to guarantee she will stay on

Thousands of city workers are on strike in Philadelphia but judge orders some back to work

Tesla sales fell 13% in the last three months as anti-Musk sentiment still has an effect

Aviva hands out £500 of free shares to staff after Direct Line takeover

Disney Dream cruise passengers reveal horrifying moment mom realised her daughter fell overboard

Four dead after record-breaking heatwave sweeps Europe

Politics latest: Rachel Reeves has Starmer’s full backing, No 10 says after chancellor cries in PMQs

Business news live: Gilt yields spike on Reeves exit speculation and CEO of AstraZeneca discusses leaving London

Kate Middleton reveals ‘life-changing’ cancer journey is a ‘rollercoaster’

Scots shopping Amazon Prime Day warned of fraudsters using AI scams

Knife thugs jailed after stabbing man in stomach in street murder bid

Perfect weather as golfers enjoy annual women's open at resplendent Wishaw course

Your morning coffee 'flips an ancient switch' to help you live longer

Scots drug smugglers arrested in £26m cocaine bust after high-speed Navy chase off Irish coast

Second arrest over Glasgow murder bid after man struck by car

Colvend Primary School delighted with eighth Green Flag Award

Teacher 'swigged alcohol during rave-like lesson and called pupils little sh**s'

Paramount settles Trump lawsuit with $16m payout

Dalai Lama says he plans to reincarnate - but how is a successor chosen and why is it controversial?

AstraZeneca's exit is a frightening prospect for the City and the government

Emotional Reeves a painful watch - and a reminder of tough decisions ahead

Samsung and Google smartphone deals include free earbuds and smartwatches

Wife sent intimate snaps to Nigerian love scammer who threatened to reveal 'affair' - then tragedy struck

Gen Z never leave the house without this accessory - and it's not what you expect

Stacey Solomon launches new 'spa day' bodycare range and it's currently 20% off

Europe 'doomed to war with Russia,' as Putin puppet demands strikes against continent

Kate Middleton's candid admission on cancer treatment as it's 'difficult to function'

Horror as 400 human corpses found inside house of horrors on US-Mexico border

Rachel Reeves had 'altercation with Commons Speaker' before crying at PMQs

Simple lawnmower check before you cut grass stops it turning brown and patchy

British base jumper who worked on Mission Impossible died as wingsuit failed in Alps tragedy

Huge explosion rocks airport as helicopter crashes into ball of flames

Tesco's £19 black dress offers 'Nobody's Child luxury' but for less

Gangland mourners threatened over attending funerals of Eddie Lyons and Ross Monaghan

Toddler dies after being left in back of scorching hot car in middle of heatwave

Kate Middleton admits 'everyone expects you to be better' in brave cancer admission

On-trend Habitat homeware picks that look much more expensive than they are - but prices start at just £8

Scientist warns shortest day in history is coming in WEEKS as Earth's rotation unexpectedly speeds up

Tyson Fury admits it's 'inevitable' his children will get into boxing and shares why they 'MUST' follow in his footsteps as he reveals the one thing that will tempt him out of retirement

World's funniest countries, revealed: Czech Republic tops the global league table...while Britain and the US trail behind

Orcas are spotted SNOGGING in the wild for the first time - and they even use tongues

Katy Perry is facing more than just heartbreak following her split from Orlando Bloom as she faces major High Court showdown in a matter of months

Motorists slapped with nearly 40,000 private parking charges a day as DVLA sold record 14.4m driver details last year

The world's most glamorous cricket commentator stuns on her luxurious Italian holiday

Maya Jama denies accusations that Love Island producers are heavily involved in steering Islanders' actions in the villa as she insists 'it has to be real because it's reality'

Ex-wife loses Supreme Court fight against retired banker over the £80m he gave her in a bid to avoid tax - before she divorced him and kept the money