This 1 Subtle Bias Against Girls Is Everywhere On Kids TV Shows – And It's Harmful

Even modern children TV shows in the study communicated subtle but harmful gender biases about how boys and girls should act and lead. What your kids see on popular children’s TV shows could teach them lasting lessons about what kind of leaders girls and boys can grow up to be. According to a new study in Psychological Science, harmful gender biases continue to persist in TV programming for kids. Researchers analysed scripts from 98 children’s television programs in the U.S. from 1960 to 2018, including classics like Scooby-Doo, Where Are You! (1970) and modern shows like SpongeBob SquarePants (2002), Dora the Explorer (2012) and The Powerpuff Girls (2016). What they found was that gender stereotypes are at the core of children’s TV content. Troublingly, this pattern has not improved and has, in fact, remained consistent over 60 years. “Gendered patterns in language are a much subtler form of bias – the part of the iceberg that’s hidden underwater – one likely to go unnoticed by audiences and creators alike,” the study’s lead author, Andrea Vial, told HuffPost.The number of female characters in TV shows and movies has increased considerably, Vial noted, but what female characters on children’s TV shows get to do and say is still sending gendered messages to kids.Even creators with good intentions can perpetuate limiting beliefs about girls’ agency. “These linguistic biases may seem too subtle to matter. But they do matter, because they quietly shape children’s beliefs about the way the world works,” Vial said. Here’s how. Female characters get relegated to passive “done-to” rolesResearchers looked at over 2.7 million sentences in over 6,000 scripted episodes of TV. What they found was that when pronouns like “he” and words like “boy” would appear, they would often be in sentences where boys were agents or “doers”.In scripts, “male” words were associated with actions of achievement, money, power and reward.For example, the sentence “Never send a boy to do a man’s job” showed up in a 1964 episode of Bewitched and was coded by researchers to have the agentic category of “job” co-occurring with male words “boy” and “man”.But when pronouns like “she” and words like “girl” appeared, they would be in sentences where female characters were in a passive position.Even shows from the 2000s had notable differences in boys being the “doers” rather than the “done-tos”, with shows like Curious George, Boy Meets World, Drake and Josh, Danny Phantom, and Phineas and Ferb being standout examples. “For these shows, the syntactic male advantage was particularly stark,” Vial said. She noted that when boys are more likely to get seen as “doers”, this “sends kids the message that agency belongs more naturally to boys than to girls, even if no one explicitly intends to send that message.”Gender equity researcher Amy Diehl also said this can teach children to assume harmful stereotypes about girls and boys. “From a young age, children learn by categorising. This is normal. When they watch television that shows boys generally ‘doing’ and girls generally being ‘done to,’ they unconsciously register the pattern,” Diehl said. “In this case, the pattern is a harmful stereotype, which may lead them to assume that girls are passive and boys are active.”Why has there been so little progress with gender stereotypes in children’s TV?Diehl said that one reason why there has not been more progress might be due to the writers in the room creating these storylines. The study looked at TV shows written between 1960 and 2018, and in 2019, a separate Rutgers University study found that the people responsible for U.S. and Canadian children’s television content are predominantly men.In the U.S., men are 80% of directors, 71% of show creators, and more than half of writers. Only 18% of episodes were written only by women and only 25% were mixed-gender writing teams. “‘Mixed-gender’ writing rooms are often dominated by white men with women being numerical tokens, meaning that women can have trouble getting their perspectives heard,” Diehl said. “Although women’s place in society has changed a lot ... since the 1960s, it’s not surprising that these changes are minimally reflected in the language of children’s media,” Vial said. “It would take a concerted effort by writers and producers, and attention to subtle linguistic biases like the ones we uncovered, to make meaningful change.”Until this change takes place on screens, parents should be vigilant about monitoring what their children hear from TV. In the study, researchers also found that words related to “home” and “family” were more often associated with “female” words.For example, “She needs to stay in bed for a few days,” from a 2012 episode of “My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic,” was coded as containing a “home” category co-occurring with a female word (“she”).“This is another harmful stereotype that can lead children to assume that men belong in the workplace and women at home,” Diehl said. “Parents can interrupt these stereotypes by pointing them out and by seeking out shows that have more diversity in character roles.”Families can also take these lessons offline and teach children to engage with people in non-stereotypical roles, such as by reading books about women in STEM or playing with toys traditionally associated with the opposite gender, Diehl suggested. What this study underscores is that even the simple way we structure our sentences when speaking to children can teach limiting ideas about the roles girls and boys should have.Vial said parents who try hard to teach their children a gender-inclusive outlook are often surprised to find that their kids “somehow still come to endorse gender-biased views and stereotypes. ‘Where did that come from?’” she said.“As our study demonstrates, they may be picking it up from a seemingly innocent source: age-appropriate television content that, at first blush, may not even seem biased.”Related...Women Share The Absurd Stereotypes They Face For Not Wearing A BraStop Judging Teen Mums, I Graduated Top Of My ClassThe Gender Stereotypes In This Dating Ad Are So Bad, It Got Banned

Comments

Breaking news

Red Arrows fly past: Where and when to see this weekend’s displays

Metro

Comments

Breaking news

Red Arrows fly past: Where and when to see this weekend’s displays

UK’s biggest ever EuroMillions jackpot of £210,000,000 up for grabs after another rollover

Margaret Qualley Once Tried To Set Up Her Mum Andie MacDowell With This Former Co-Star

Wednesday Season 2: 11 Behind-The-Scenes Secrets About How The Show Was Made

These 6 Tiny Body Language Clues Could Indicate Your Partner’s Not That Into You

Trump-Putin summit live: US president hails ‘successful’ meeting despite no deal as Zelensky heads to Washington

How ‘Devil in Ozarks’ escaped prison: Elaborate six-month plan revealed

A charred Grand Canyon mascot is recovered from the rubble. Can Brighty the Burro be saved?

Bid to track tourists amid fears hundreds could have been exposed to rabies at bat-infested cabins

What we have learnt from 100 days of Pope Leo XIV

One dead and 20 injured as train collides with vehicle in Denmark

Erin becomes a Category 3 hurricane in the Caribbean and is expected to strengthen further

‘I paid £500 after finding my dream dog for sale online. There was one problem – it didn’t exist’

Fury over 'overgrown' Glasgow cemetery where woman's loved ones are buried

Schoolgirl found dead as teen boy arrested on suspicion of rape and murder

Scots primary kids 'told to send explicit photos' after being targeted in WhatsApp group

‘I lost 20 stone after doctors said my weight would kill me in weeks’

Weatherpoons manager sacked for giving half-price food to worker wins employment tribunal

Hand pats, manspreading and discontent: The body language giveaways from the Trump-Putin Alaska summit

Putin has wriggled off the hook yet again, Trump is the clear loser, and Ukrainians are furious

Trump-Putin talks: Odd things you may have missed - red carpets to chicken Kyiv

Seven-month-old boy 'kidnapped' as mum attacked outside California store

Primary school teacher had sick videos of kids and searched 'Japanese schoolgirls'

People mock Donald Trump after 'delusional' reaction to Vladimir Putin's Moscow invite

MIKEY SMITH: 11 unhinged Donald Trump moments as he gets absolutely played by Putin at Ukraine summit

Evil mum 'stole' son's blood and left starving kids naked outside in house of horrors

Princess Andre says she's 'in love' with £16 shimmer body oil that leaves a radiant glow

Zelensky to meet with Donald Trump at White House after Putin summit

Vital 'five-second rule' every dog owner needs to know in a heatwave

Molly-Mae raves about her current go-to Adidas trainers that are ‘so comfy’

Air Canada strikes: Tourists stranded as 10,000 flight attendants walk out

NHS warns 'call 999' for this chest symptom in the hot weather

Storage hunter stunned over rare find after opening up £1,500 newly-bought unit

Donald Trump channels inner Meghan Markle with subtle 'power pat' at Putin talks

'I was stolen from my mum as a baby, she left the hospital room and I vanished'

Late Queen’s brutal assessment of key royal laid bare after tense first meeting

Tudor England's unluckiest deaths revealed... including priest who 'tumbled off a toilet seat' and the butcher who walked home in slippers

I was tricked into licking a woman's drug-laced BREASTS in 'Good night, Cinderella' scam… when I woke up she had taken valuables worth thousands

Peter Andre shares sweet family snap as he enjoys holiday with wife Emily and their three children after ex Katie Price hit back at his bombshell statement

Zelensky to meet Trump after Putin peace talks end with no deal: Ukraine president will fly to Washington to discuss next steps to end Russia's invasion

Selina Scott says she blames Sadiq Khan for her terrifying mugging, declaring 'he's got security - so why doesn't the public?'

Judges who bring their personal politics to court should be removed, insists shadow justice secretary Robert Jenrick

Moment Putin's legs 'twitch suspiciously' in Trump farewell as Russian dictator dons platforms to overcome 'Napoleon complex' - amid rumours he wore EXOSKELETON

Billie Shepherd reveals devastating Lyme disease diagnosis that left her bed bound as she becomes latest celeb to open up about battle with the condition

I discovered a hotel breakfast hack that allows you to eat at five-star hotels for just £4 - and you don't even have to stay

Brooklyn Beckham 'heartbroken' wife Nicola Peltz is being 'painted as a viper' in feud - after pair 'snubbed' his family from vow renewal

People who woke up from a coma reveal exactly what they experienced while unconscious: 'I was trying to scream... but I couldn't make a sound'

Scientists pinpoint the personality type which is most likely to have mental health problems

'She was so f***ed up': Carolyn Bessette's friends tell MAUREEN CALLAHAN of her secret Daddy issue, JFK Jr's murder brag that drove her mad... and why everything we know about her is a lie

Find out your 'C-day': Enter your birthday to find out when you were likely conceived... and what was top of the charts back then!

I was a nurse at Broadmoor Hospital... Ronnie Kray and the Yorkshire ripper were NOT my scariest patients - here's who still gives me nightmares

Samsung Z Flip 7 review: I was too young for the original flip-phone era - but I'm totally converted with this retro revival

Warning over Paris restaurant 'scam' as travellers shame 'tourist trap' near the Eiffel Tower

Chilling sight of Putin shaking his head and shouting over journalists as they demanded to know when he would 'stop killing civilians' in Ukraine

Double hit-and-run suspect is missing: International arrest warrant issued for British man arrested after allegedly mowing down two holidaymakers in Magaluf

The battle for West Bewley Road: Villagers fight plans for 190 new homes saying they will destroy the environment and their livelihoods

Moment US B2 stealth bomber thunders over Putin as he arrives at Alaska summit - but Russian president shrugs it off

Celebrities you had no idea auditioned for The X Factor: From reality TV icons to popstars - and even an Olympian - these stars were determined to make it no matter what!

Hundreds of flights grounded as Air Canada staff strike

The Red Rose who could have been a Black Fern - Feaunati's World Cup call