Here's how we all ended up paying Big Tech's power bill

Public utilities are on track to build $1.1 trillion in new infrastructure by 2029, largely to keep up with the pace of AI data center demand.ZisserAI is driving up the cost of electricity.Utilities in Indiana and Ohio are requiring data centers to pay more for power.Big Tech is fighting back as other states grapple with how to charge data center customers.In several states, public utilities are asking power-hungry data centers to cover more of their mounting electricity costs.Utilities have long enforced special terms and conditions, called tariffs, on their largest customers, to ensure they are paying their fair share.Facing a historic surge in electricity demand amid Big Tech's AI race, utilities in states like Indiana and Ohio are now turning to tariffs to protect residents and small businesses from higher power bills as more data centers come online.Data centers consumed about 4.4% of all electricity in the US in 2023, according to research from the US Department of Energy. That amount could triple by 2028.That level of demand growth hasn't been seen since the 1960s, when gains in efficiency tempered the power industry's costs of growth, protecting consumers from hefty rate hikes.Now, power plants are more expensive to build, especially the natural gas plants that some utilities are proposing to serve new data centers.Ratepayer advocates and regulatory experts say that using tariffs for data centers is a good start, but they may not be enough to prevent the full costs of the AI boom from hitting consumer wallets.The demand surge coming from a handful of very large customers, combined with the rising costs of building new infrastructure, could mean the old rules of utility pricing don't apply in the age of AI."Data center growth is overwhelming long-standing approaches to approving utility rates," researchers at Harvard Law School's Electricity Law Initiative wrote in a paper earlier this year, "causing the public to subsidize Big Tech's power bills."Earlier this month, Ohio regulators approved American Electric Power's plan to create a tariff specifically for its data center customers. In February, regulators in Indiana approved changes to Indiana Michigan Power's large customer tariffs, aimed at shielding the utility's individual and small business customers from higher costs associated with data centers.Several other states, including Virginia, Texas, Kansas, and California, are considering or have proposed implementing special tariffs for data centers.The tariffs are a response to the unprecedented demand for electricity coming from Big Tech's AI data centers.Investor-owned utilities in the US are on track to build $1.1 trillion in new infrastructure over the next five years, largely to keep pace with that demand, according to industry group Edison Electric Institute. About 72% of electricity customers in the US are served by investor-owned utilities, which profit by building new infrastructure.This business model was born when population growth and economic development drove electricity demand, and everyone was thought to benefit from system-wide upgrades.With Big Tech companies driving most of today's electricity demand, some are questioning which customers exactly should pay for upgrades."We really need to think about who should pay for this stuff," Ari Peskoe, Director of Harvard Law School's Electricity Law Initiative, told Business Insider."I don't think it's fair to just have these very wealthy corporations come in and force utilities to build more infrastructure and then just socialize the costs the way we normally do."Why am I subsidizing Big Tech's power bill?Historically, state regulators have allowed public utilities to recover the cost of investment, plus a rate of return, of new transmission lines and power plants by raising rates for all customers.The utility business model was based on the assumption that society benefited from the grid's expansion; therefore, "we should all pay for the infrastructure needed to allow for its growth," said Peskoe.Staggering data center power demand has flipped this assumption on its head. At a time when residential electricity use is going down, Big Tech companies stand to gain the most from major utility expansion. Under the old rules of cost allocation, everyone else might have to pay for it.In Louisiana, customers of the state's major public utility could be responsible for $5 billion in costs associated with new natural gas plants and transmission lines needed to serve a Meta data center.Wisconsin ratepayers could pay for a $2 million transmission project for Microsoft's data center campus outside Milwaukee. In Colorado, Xcel Energy customers could end up paying $1.7 billion for new transmission lines to serve the state's growing data center load.What are states doing about it?In February, Indiana regulators approved changes to Indiana Michigan Power Company's tariff for large industrial customers, setting the terms for connecting data center customers to the grid.The changes were part of a settlement agreement between I&M, its three largest data center customers — Amazon, Microsoft, and Google — consumer advocacy groups, and the Data Center Coalition.The revised tariff requires "large load" customers that use a lot of electricity to make "long-term financial commitments proportional to their size," I&M said in a press release.Data centers are driving record load growth in the utility's Indiana service territory. Peak load — the highest amount of electricity used by customers at a time — is on track to more than double by 2030.Ben Inskeep, program director at Citizens Action Coalition Indiana, a participant in the IMP settlement, said the revised tariff will help protect ratepayers from the cost of "stranded assets" — infrastructure that gets built, but ultimately doesn't get used. But it doesn't address several other aspects of data center growth that could show up in consumer electricity bills, he said.Many factors account for the final number that customers see on a monthly electric bill, and the cost of new infrastructure is just one of them."We're seeing really high load growth from data centers driving the cost of capacity super high and driving the cost of building new resources super high, and those costs could still end up in consumer bills," said Inskeep.For its part, Big Tech is fighting to keep its own electric bills from rising.In Ohio, a lawyer for Amazon told regulators that AEP had "singled out" data centers for a "discriminatory tariff." A lawyer for Google called the tariff a "departure from the fundamental rules" of utility regulation.That's exactly the point, said Peskoe."What we really need is a new approach to allocating the utilities' costs," said Peskoe. "That's what a lot of this comes down to — making sure that the data centers are paying for infrastructure that's serving them, that's being built for them."Read the original article on Business Insider

Comments

Business News

Big Box Store Sam’s Club Joins IndyCar’s Andretti Global Racing

Forbes

American Eagle responds to the controversy around its ad campaign with Sydney Sweeney: 'Great jeans look good on everyone'

about 3 hours ago

The economist who coined the acronym BRICS talks about how his original vision evolved

NPR

Headgum Founders Jake Hurwitz & Amir Blumenfeld Celebrate 10 Years Of Running A Podcast Network: ‘We’re Trying To Hold On To The Last Few Indie Comedy Vibes That Are Left In Podcasting’

about 5 hours ago

Can Cleveland Golf’s Triangular-Shaped HiBore XL Start A Trend?

Forbes

Comments

Business News

Big Box Store Sam’s Club Joins IndyCar’s Andretti Global Racing

July Jobs Report Casts New Warning On Immigration And Worker Declines

Interview: Superman Wētā VFX Supervisor Guy Williams On DC Worldbuilding

When Is ‘The Bad Guys 2’ Coming To Streaming?

Lyme Disease Nearly Ended Justin Timberlake’s Tour: What You Need To Know

Lina Kahn is taking a victory lap over the Figma IPO

Trump's tariffs are (still) coming

Saskatoon company launches Saskatchewan’s 1st corporate child care program

Canada should ‘stand up’ to U.S. after Trump tariff hike, B.C. forestry exec says

A raging Trump digs in on his trade war after brutal jobs report

Zillow hit with federal copyright lawsuit over 47K allegedly stolen property photos

Meta dishes out $250M to lure 24-year-old AI whiz kid: ‘We have reached the climax of ‘Revenge of the Nerds’

Engineering students build innovative 3D-printed drone that can switch between water and air

UFC Vegas 108 Fight Card: Odds, Predictions, Prop Bets And Picks

6 Exciting New Netflix Movies In August 2025

‘The Naked Gun’: What Happens In End-Credits And Post-Credits Scenes?

New Album ‘Strange Hours’ Brings Eli Young Band Full-Circle

James Gunn’s ‘Superman’ Cracks $300 Million At Domestic Box Office

Trump Fires Senior Labor Official Over Jobs Numbers

Inside The Troubled Road To Micah Parson’s Trade Request

Investment trusts rise up from the ashes

Watch shares plummet as tariffs hurt Switzerland

Donald Trump hits out at Federal Reserve as US jobs fall

Euronext eyes Stock Exchange bid amid deals frenzy

ALEX BRUMMER: Donald Trump's deals are a global blow

RAY MASSEY: Genesis G80 is a swish, smooth sensation

A Federal Reserve governor just said she's resigning early, giving Trump a chance to put even more pressure on Powell

Your chats with Meta's AI might end up on Google &mdash; just like ChatGPT until it turned them off

I'm a New Yorker who went to Montreal for the first time, and 5 things surprised me

American Eagle responds to the controversy around its ad campaign with Sydney Sweeney: 'Great jeans look good on everyone'

The economist who coined the acronym BRICS talks about how his original vision evolved

Could higher tariffs mean more layoffs in Canada? What industry experts say

Calgary home sales fall 12 per cent in July as inventory reaches pre-pandemic highs

Trump says he will fire lead official on economic data as stocks shudder

Car finance payouts have been limited, but lenders aren't off the hook

Ahead of Trump’s Trade Deadline, Firms Rushed Goods Out of Duty-Free Warehouses

Michael Cardozo, 84, New York City’s Longest-Serving Chief Lawyer, Dies

Fed Governor Resigns, Giving Trump Opportunity to Shape Central Bank

Trump, Claiming Weak Jobs Numbers Were ‘Rigged,’ Moves to Fire Labor Official

Lenders do not owe millions compensation over car finance, Supreme Court rules

Jury orders Tesla to pay more than $200 million in Autopilot crash case

Switzerland, the land of luxury brands, could see prices skyrocket from Trump's 39% tariffs

Trump calls for firings after soft jobs report

Delta Air Lines tries to calm fury over ticket prices, telling lawmakers it won’t use AI

Ford recalls 312K vehicles over loss of brake power that can increase crash risk

Fed governor Adriana Kugler resigning, opening up spot for Trump to fill

Elon Musk’s Tesla ordered to pay $329M in deadly Autopilot crash case: ‘This will open the floodgates’

Lenders do not owe millions compensation over car finance, Supreme Court rules

Headgum Founders Jake Hurwitz & Amir Blumenfeld Celebrate 10 Years Of Running A Podcast Network: ‘We’re Trying To Hold On To The Last Few Indie Comedy Vibes That Are Left In Podcasting’

Can Cleveland Golf’s Triangular-Shaped HiBore XL Start A Trend?

What McLaren CEO Zak Brown Thinks Of FOX Acquiring A Third Of IndyCar

Trump Orders Nuclear Submarines Moved In Response To Threats From Former Russian President

For Phillies Prospect Justin Crawford, The Time Is Now

What car finance ruling means for you as drivers could still get compensation

The 37 taxes you pay and why it now takes £3.1m to feel 'wealthy' - This is Money podcast

India grows 80% of the world's turmeric. So why are farmers struggling?

Trump says he gave new orders to US nuclear submarines in response to an ex-Russian president's 'foolish' talk

Tesla must pay over $242M in damages after being found partly at fault for deadly Autopilot crash

'Let's step outside': Sharon Stone on her explosive first encounter with Michael Douglas before 'Basic Instinct'

Trump said he plans to fire Bureau of Labor Statistics commissioner hours after disappointing July jobs report

Your chats with Meta's AI might end up on Google — just like ChatGPT until it turned them off