HS2: a complete failure by the British state and its politicians

There have been many chances to avert this ‘appalling mess’, but, fuelled by political puff and short-termism, the project has become a farceWhen was it obvious that HS2 was an economic turkey at risk of becoming “an appalling mess”, as transport secretary Heidi Alexander described today’s position?A fair case can be made for 2013, a year of two neon-lit warnings of trouble ahead. One was a scathing report on HS2 from the National Audit Office (NAO), the first of many, when the project was still at the planning stage. The NAO concluded it was impossible to say whether the programme was likely to deliver value for money; the cost and benefit estimates were “uncertain”; there had been “past errors in the underlying model”; the Department for Transport had “poorly articulated” the strategic need for a transformation in rail capacity and how HS2 was supposed to rebalance economic growth. In short, there was “a weak foundation for securing and demonstrating success in the future”. Continue reading...

Comments

Business News

Express

Comments

Similar News

HS2 delayed beyond 2033 as minister attacks ‘appalling mess’

Minister says she will ‘sort out’ HS2 and confirms opening will be delayed

Minister says she will ‘sort out’ HS2 and confirms opening will be delayed

HS2: 16 years of high hopes, bruising reality and burgeoning costs

Minister says she will ‘sort out’ HS2 and confirms opening will be delayed

Minister says she will ‘sort out’ HS2 and confirms opening will be delayed

HS2 opening to be delayed beyond 2033

HS2 opening to be delayed beyond 2033

Another delay to HS2 to be announced

Opening of HS2 line set to be delayed beyond 2033

Reviews show Tories wasted billions of pounds on HS2, transport secretary to say

HS2 reports subcontractor over alleged fraud

Labour had the chance to finally kill off HS2. Instead, it’s throwing more money into the pit | Simon Jenkins

HS2: Investigation launched into two firms supplying workers

HS2 investigates claims company overcharged for supplying workers

HS2 investigating two firms supplying construction staff

Business News

American Express makes major British Airways points change after customers' fury

Microsoft planning to ax thousands of sales jobs as focus shifts to AI: report

How EchoStar boss managed to get key sit-down with Trump – and stave off likely demise

Jennifer Garner’s baby food company Once Upon a Farm files for IPO: report

What are the stakes in Strait of Hormuz if Iran-Israel conflict worsens?

Wine shortage warning as workers at UK bottling factory planning summer strike

The Silicon Valley leaders who have experimented with psychedelics

The new American dream? Buying and renting out vacation homes in Italy.

Everything Dakota Johnson has worn this year, ranked from least to most daring

Zelenskyy opens up about his White House clash with Trump in exclusive interview

I tried 32 of Trader Joe's seasonal summer products, and there are only a few I wouldn't buy again

CEOs haven't felt this gloomy about the economy since the pandemic

Iran's F-14 Tomcats are the last of their kind. Israel's been blowing some of them up.

As an AI entrepreneur, will.i.am says data privacy and training the next generation should be prioritized

The US Navy's most advanced aircraft carrier is readying to deploy to Europe again

A woman who retired early at 58 thought she was ready with over $500,000 in savings. A few years later, it was gone.

Meta's Scale AI deal has clients like Google halting projects, contractors scrambling, and one investor bailing out

Lyft CMO Brian Irving talks 'customer-obsessed' marketing and product development

Pro-Trump media figures split over the U.S. role in the Israel-Iran conflict

Key takeaways from today’s Fed meeting and Powell’s news conference

New Owner for High Times Magazine Bets on a Counterculture Comeback

Deontay Wilder Ahead Of Comeback Fight: I Never Thought About Quitting

Trump Administration Closes LGBTQ+ Suicide Prevention Support

2025 Ohio Derby Odds And Picks: Can Clever Again Get Back On Track?

Heed General Mattis’ Warning, D.C.: Less Diplomacy Means ‘More Ammunition’

The Fed Opts Not To Cut Interest Rates Again—Even As Trump Ups Attacks On Fed Boss Powell

Supreme Court Wades Into Louisiana’s Coastal Erosion Lawsuit Issue

Social Security, Medicare insolvency dates move up to 2033

Federal judge to deny Trump administration's motion to dismiss lawsuit over block on wind projects

Martin Lewis's MSE shares update on £70 payout from Mastercard

Will employers be targeted for hiring undocumented workers?

Switching off RTS energy meter system to be delayed, says Government

Texas Instruments to spend $60B to boost US chip manufacturing under Trump push

Nike delays launch for new brand with Kim Kardashian’s Skims over production delays

Pope Leo says AI threatens humanity and ‘poses challenges to human dignity, justice and labor’

Federal Reserve keeps interest rates unchanged — says uncertainty over tariffs has ‘diminished’

Amazon's cooling blanket is the 'best thing ever' for night sweats and it's now almost 20% off

Switching off RTS energy meter system to be delayed, says Government

Chobani's founder says the Make America Healthy Again movement's ingredient crackdown poses a big risk for food makers

I tried chicken tenders from 13 fast-food chains and ranked them from worst to best

The Fed holds interest rates steady again as trade tensions heat up

AI runs on dirty power &mdash; and the public pays the price

Old meter switch-off is pushed back

Fed holds interest rates for fourth time despite tariff turmoil

Regulators Approve Lenacapavir for H.I.V. Prevention

Dan Storper, Founder of Putumayo World Music Label, Dies at 74

Draft These 3 Defenses in 2025 Fantasy Football

These Trump Loyalists Are Pleading Against Iran Strike—As Trump Dismisses GOP Divisions

Netflix Doc Series On Dallas Cowboys Cheerleaders Gets Even Better In Season 2

Jenna Ortega’s ‘Death Of A Unicorn’ Gets Max Streaming Date

Tampa Bay Rays In Exclusive Talks To Sell Club To Group Led By Florida Home Builder

Books: Phil Gramm And Don Boudreaux Address Seven Major Economic Myths

Ex-Phillies GM Ruben Amaro: Nick Castellanos Disrespected Rob Thomson ‘A Whole Lot’

Trump slams Jerome Powell as a 'stupid person' ahead of Fed decision on interest rates

Los Angeles mayor lifts downtown curfew she imposed during protests against immigration raids

More employers are sending workers shopping for their own health coverage

The average rate on a 30-year mortgage eased to 6.81% this week, Freddie Mac says, its third straight decline

Average long-term US mortgage rate eases to 6.81%, third consecutive weekly decline

Mastercard issues compensation update and millions of customers will be fuming

New state pensioners earning £23,027 and 1p set to lose winter fuel payment

AI runs on dirty power — and the public pays the price