I shopped at Costco in the Midwest and New York City. Here are the most surprising differences I noticed.

The author at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderI visited two Costco stores, one in the Midwest and one in New York City.New York City's Costco store was smaller, which made it feel more crowded.The prices and offerings were mostly identical, though the food courts featured different sodas.As someone who grew up in Wisconsin and moved to New York City a decade ago, I enjoy analyzing the similarities and differences between the two regions I call home.As part of a series comparing nationwide chains like Target and Trader Joe's in the Midwest and New York City, I visited Costco locations in Wisconsin and Manhattan in 2023. My Gold Star membership, which costs $60 per year, grants me entry to all Costco stores.Costco remains a popular brand across the US and the world, offering bulk items at lower prices than many retailers. Its net sales added up to $249.6 billion in the 2024 fiscal year, a 5% increase from 2023.While its stores are pretty standardized, which I found when I visited a Costco in Iceland, I was still interested to see if there were any regional variations in their prices, items, and shopping experiences.Here are the most surprising differences I noticed.During a trip home to Wisconsin in November 2023, I visited a Costco store in Grafton, Wisconsin, measuring 151,000 square feet.Costco in Wisconsin, where it's pronounced "Cah-stco."Talia Lakritz/BIA large technology section was set up at the entrance.Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThere were also tables full of winter coats, sweaters, and other apparel.Clothes at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThe store wasn't too crowded on the Thursday afternoon I visited, with plenty of room to move in the aisles.Shoppers at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThe Kirkland bakery sold cookies, pastries, and birthday cakes.The Kirkland bakery at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThe produce was located in a walk-in refrigerated section.The fresh produce fridge at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThe samples were plentiful, with Costco employees handing out veggie crisps, granola-bar pieces, and cups of sparkling water.A sample at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderI spotted a few local products like cheddar cheese curds produced in Ellsworth, Wisconsin.Cheese curds at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThis Costco also stocked coffee beans roasted in Door County, Wisconsin.Coffee from Door County, Wisconsin, at Costco.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThe lines for both self checkout and cashiers were only a few carts deep and moved quickly.Self check-out at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThe food court was located beyond the checkout counters and sold pizza, chicken bakes, sandwiches, hot dogs, and desserts like churros and ice-cream sundaes.The food court at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderA sign on the window notified customers about potential allergy issues.Food for sale at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThe soda fountain included Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Tropicana lemonade, and Starry lemon-lime soda.Soda at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderNext to the food court, there were plenty of tables where customers could sit and eat before heading to their next destination.Seating at Costco in Wisconsin.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderWhen I returned to New York City, I visited Manhattan's sole Costco location in East Harlem.Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThe Costco store is part of East River Plaza, a shopping complex that also includes stores like Aldi, Marshalls, and Ashley Homestore.East River Plaza in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderUnlike in the Midwest, where free parking lots are the norm at most stores, parking in the East River Plaza's garage costs $6 for up to two hours.Paid parking at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderPeople were already lined up and waiting to get in when I arrived a few minutes before the store opened at 10 a.m. on a Friday in January.A line outside Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderAt 110,000 square feet, New York City's Costco store was noticeably smaller than the one I visited in the Midwest.The entrance to Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderAt times, I found it difficult to navigate my cart through the crowds and smaller aisles.Aisles at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderNew York's Costco store had many of the same warm clothing items on display.Clothes for sale at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThere was a large selection of cheeses, but no Wisconsin cheese curds.Cheese at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderSome signs varied slightly between stores — for example, a sign at the Midwest Costco indicated "fresh produce," while the New York Costco just said "produce."The produce fridge at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderThe New York City Costco also had a kosher bakery section where cakes and pastries were prepared in accordance with Jewish dietary laws.The bakery at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderCostco's famous $4.99 rotisserie chickens cost the same at both stores, though they flew off the shelves in New York as shoppers waited for each fresh batch.Rotisserie chickens at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderI was surprised there weren't any samples available to try, but a Costco employee later told me that the stations hadn't been set up yet so soon after opening.Eggs at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderBoth the cashier and self-checkout lines stretched out into the aisles with large numbers of people jostling for spots.Checkout lines at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderAbove the checkout lines, signs advertised the food court's offerings, which were identical to the Wisconsin Costco's menu and prices.Items for sale at the food court at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderOne difference I noticed in the food court was that unlike in the Midwest, no allergy information was posted on the display case.Food for sale at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderAdditionally, the soda fountain in Manhattan offered Brisk iced tea instead of Starry.The soda fountain in the food court at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderCompared to the Midwest, New York City's Costco felt like a more cramped, hectic shopping experience to me, but the low prices and huge selection make it worth the trip in any region.The author at Costco in New York City.Talia Lakritz/Business InsiderRead the original article on Business Insider

Comments

Business News

Amazon launches its first internet satellites to compete against SpaceX's Starlinks

I've spent hundreds of hours on Amtrak trains. I always prepare for these 5 mishaps that can make journeys more difficult.

about 5 hours ago

3 days in the office is the sweet spot — any more and staff start disengaging from work, PwC HR boss says

Comments

Business News

Amazon launches its first internet satellites to compete against SpaceX's Starlinks

DWP clarifies Universal Credit rules for holidays – payments could stop unless you do this

The Crusader: PCN error based on faulty camera drives husband to despair

French train lovers targeted in new 'first-of-its-kind' VisitScotland campaign

Appeal bid for ‘coffee stops’ on Scotland-England border rejected

Boutique hotel and restaurant in historic Scottish location goes on market

White House blasts Amazon over tariff surcharge label: ‘This is a hostile and political act’

Trump to ease blow from auto tariffs by giving car makers exemptions on steel, aluminum: report

UK’s oldest Indian restaurant with Michelin star at threat of closure pleas with King Charles to keep it open

Have you been underpaid the state pension? Use simple tool to find out as DWP pays back £800million

Huge rule change for banks after over 400,000 had accounts closed last year after Farage scandal

Is Declan Rice The Best Midfielder In The World Right Now?

A New Study Shows How Gen AI May Transform Access To Mental Health Services

Climate Change Serendipity: A Bordeaux Grand Cru Winery Makes Authentic Japanese Soy Sauce

Maury Povich Has Some Thoughts About The Media Business Today

Calling AI To The Grocery Aisle

Russia’s New Jet-Engine Drone Aims To Break Through Ukrainian Defenses

Donna Summer Debuts A Decades-Old Album On Several Charts

Led Zeppelin’s Biggest Hit On The Charts Was Never Actually A Single

Bob Marley’s Bestseller Bounces Back To The Charts In A Big Way

Kentucky Derby 2025: Journalism, Sovereignty, And Rodriguez In Works

Three Different Beatles Albums Chart This Week — And Two Of Them Return

Birmingham lorry drivers’ pay cuts ‘an escalation’ of bin strike, union says

Richard Caring's Ivy Collection of restaurants serves up record sales and profits

'My wife lost her job and we're buying a house - do we need to tell our mortgage provider?'

The councils dishing out most (and least) fines to parents over holidays

'So sad' say shoppers as major toy retailer set to close store this weekend

'I love the original Wonderskin lip stain so much I bought the new shade to see if it's as good'

M&S stores left with empty food shelves as it continues to battle cyber attack

Top Tech: Giffgaff is dishing out £100 to try its new broadband to rival Sky and Virgin

Where Arsenal vs PSG is on TV for free as Champions League game not on TNT Sports

Garnier hyaluronic acid-infused SPF50 gets a 'better than £10 Tuesday' saving in Amazon deal

M&S cyber attack that crippled stores is 'linked to gang of teenage hackers'

Tesco shoppers told to act before May 31 as supermarket issues alert

'Fantastic' kids mini trampoline is reduced to £68 from £200 in time for the heatwave week

‘Next has a £24 fragrance that smells just as good as my favourite Chanel perfume’

THG sales hurt by beauty weakness but nutrition shows recovery

New electric car MOT tests could be introduced in Britain - here's why

Trainer prices will rise due to tariffs, says Adidas

I've spent hundreds of hours on Amtrak trains. I always prepare for these 5 mishaps that can make journeys more difficult.

3 days in the office is the sweet spot &mdash; any more and staff start disengaging from work, PwC HR boss says

Inside the first week back at JPMorgan's largest US office, from the memos to the jockeying for desks

Ray Dalio warns that the international world order is on the brink of breaking down

’Nowhere to turn’: Small businesses dependent on imports from China are feeling more desperate

Tens of thousands of Los Angeles County workers begin 2-day strike

Landlocked Sahel states back Morocco's sea access initiative

Coca-Cola reports better-than-expected quarterly profit, says it can manage through tariffs

Top five easy access Cash ISAs paying up to 5.71% interest

Two DWP changes to the state pension from next year that mean payments will drop

DWP and HMRC payment date changes to be aware of

Angela Rayner’s workers overhaul could cost jobs, claim store bosses

Hiltzik: Inside the GOP's secret plan to destroy Medicaid

Tony Lam was an original influencer in Little Saigon — and he's still got it

Edison told the government that Calderon was an 'executive.' Now it claims she wasn't.

Adidas cautions over higher prices and halts outlook upgrade due to tariff woes

Oil refining comes to an end in Scotland as Grangemouth halts processing work

Ladbrokes owner appoints interim chief Stella David as permanent boss

Around 150 jobs at risk as ABF warns bioethanol plant could close

Sky internet went down leaving hundreds of customers with broadband issues – how to check your area

Thousands of Tesco Clubcard holders need to act now to avoid losing vouchers

3 days in the office is the sweet spot — any more and staff start disengaging from work, PwC HR boss says