I was a middle manager for 30 years, and I still think companies are right to eliminate those roles. Here's why.

Munevar Jr. occasionally questioned the value he brought as a middle manager.Jeannine LaneAlvaro Munevar Jr. leveraged middle management jobs to help him retire early from his tech career.Now, Big Tech companies are culling middle managers, a reduction that Munevar Jr. said makes sense.He said he witnessed how middle managers allowed fiefdoms to thrive and slowed down productivity.I spent nearly all of my 30-year tech career in middle management. I managed teams that built and delivered web and mobile business applications.I intentionally stayed in the middle management bracket, where I was paid well and typically worked 40 to 45 hours most weeks. This meant I had enough time to build a real-estate side business. Doing that helped me achieve my goal of early retirement. In 2024, I left my corporate job and live off my real-estate passive income.My retirement at 59 came as the wider tech industry began eliminating many middle management positions.Big Tech companies like Microsoft, Amazon, Meta, and Google have been trying to flatten their company structure by removing managers. Google's CEO, Sundar Pichai, has said this is to increase efficiency, while Amazon's Andy Jassy, who has said he wants the company to run like the "world's largest startup," has suggested that removing management layers can cut bureaucracy.Although I really enjoyed working and learning as a middle manager, I did occasionally question the value I was bringing at that level.I worked in startups and bigger companies alikeBeginning in the late 1990s, I worked in both engineering and middle management roles for a few small startup companies.These startups maintained a flat management structure where the CEO worked directly with individual contributors to quickly make key decisions and deliver software products. There were few middle managers, and little bureaucracy. This leaner model meant we had fewer scheduled meetings and fewer roadblocks to building out products.In the startups I worked for, everyone was focused on rapidly solving problems to reach the objective. Your job and future stock awards were based on the team's ability to focus and deliver quickly. Teams could make and execute plans more rapidly without the bureaucracy of a middle management layer — the reviews and approvals that middle managers tend to oversee in larger companies often only slow things down.When I worked in tech roles at larger companies, my role often involved monitoring progress and confirming that software development teams were meeting the project timelines. I was responsible for explaining the delays to senior management and recommending improvements to avoid future hold-ups.I spent significant time relaying status updates to the leaders above me and directives to the individual contributors below me. From working at startups, I knew that this back and forth could be reduced in a leaner management environment.While working at larger companies, I also noticed that fiefdoms began to thrive due to the large number of middle managers.Fiefdoms, a well-known phenomenon in tech, are essentially siloed groups of workers who are closely controlled by middle managers. These managers oversee what information about the group they share with the rest of the company.I noticed that fiefdoms often benefited managers. By overseeing a larger head count, they had a greater perceived value. However, it unfortunately ended up isolating teams and departments from one another, leading to duplicated efforts across the company due to limited communication between groups.On several occasions, my team and I would spend months building out a new software solution only to learn upon presenting our work that another manager's silo of engineers had already built out a similar one. This is a management fiefdom scenario at its worst, and it negatively impacted morale. My team members were furious that their efforts had been wasted because of the lack of communication.I'm not sad to see middle managers goI built my tech career in middle management, so it may seem odd that I recommend removing the very role I once performed.But after working in tech for over 30 years, I've witnessed significant wasted effort, duplicated results, and territorial management practices in the traditional, heavier middle management model.There may be disruption and some confusion until the new model has fully worked itself out, but I expect that flattening companies will ultimately create leaner, better working environments.Do you have a story to share about middle management in tech? Contact the editor, Charissa Cheong, at [email protected] the original article on Business Insider

Comments

Business News

Major pensions update as millions set for 'retirement savings boost'

Express

Comments

Business News

Major pensions update as millions set for 'retirement savings boost'

Top interim support companies can count on from Hutcheon Mearns

Is Scottish care sector at risk from immigration shake-up?

Wise latest to unveil plans to switch main listing from London to New York

New car market returns to growth

Exact code to spot when £100 Nationwide payment lands in millions of accounts within weeks – will you be better off?

Full list of 80 Asda stores selling Nintendo Switch 2 TODAY after pre-order chaos saw games flogged on eBay for £1000

Flying Tiger is selling ‘genius’ 2-in-1 picnic and camping essential – it’s only £20 & perfect for a family

Major fashion retailer with 180 UK stores confirms it will shut ‘favourite’ shop in just DAYS

Tesco slashes the price of summer garden essential from £80 to £24 – it’s the cheapest on the market

Morrisons shoppers fury over ‘frustrating’ More card offer after item SELLS OUT

Wetherspoons fans devastated as ‘favourite’ dip axed from menu

Top chef reveals the cheap place he loves - and the overrated chain he would avoid

Asian shares trade mixed after Wall Street’s rally stalls on U.S. economic data

Suspect in UnitedHealthcare CEO killing said he 'had it coming,' prosecutors say

Rachel Reeves's outrageous plot to grab winter fuel cash from families of dead pensioners

Wizz Air profit slumps after grounding planes over engine issues

ONS admits April inflation figure was too high after vehicle tax data error

Dr Martens sees profits slide but on track for return to growth

Car insurance code that could be the key to finding cheaper insurance when you buy a new motor

Car finance compensation update as millions could be due back cash

I lost £120k life savings and ended up in hospital after falling through faulty flooring installed by cowboy builder

Energy costs 'an anchor on our ambition', CBI chief warns government

Owners turn to 'game-changing' 89p-a-day pet food deliveries to improve dog health

Isle of Paradise’s ‘easy to use’ fake tan drops are less than £10 in flash beauty deal

Two more major retailers hit by cyber attacks with customer information stolen

Will you pay less for car hire this summer? How much a rental costs in 12 popular holiday hotspots in 2025

Can you boost your chance of winning the £208M Euromillions? From rare numbers to lucky places to buy

Britain's biggest Italian restaurant will be one of four huge new dining venues at Olympia

FTSE 100 Live 05 June: Wise plans US switch, Dr Martens unveils new strategy

The new 'one-room schoolhouse': Millions of kids are joining America's microschool movement

In their investment era: Swifties celebrate helping their idol reclaim her music

Labour four-word WASPI reply after being accused of 'undermining' Ombudsman's ruling

'I'm saving 10 years on my mortgage thanks to shopping app I use at Tesco, Morrisons, M&S'

Martin Lewis says make these 4 checks now which could save thousands on council tax

Reeves' new pension rules 'omission' as key issue on 'back burner'

HMRC urgently sending letters to 100,000 people after 'breach'

Department for Transport 'funding' update on free bus passes for over 60s in England

Scotland Office and Scottish Chambers of Commerce in ‘Brand Scotland’ mission deal

Golf survey reveals mixed bag for Scotland's courses

Family sells landmark hotel dating from 17th century in popular Scottish town

In 12 charts: The Herald Scottish Golf Survey

Owner of famous Islay distillery scraps target amid tariff uncertainty

Hard facts from the fairways tee up latest edition

Renowned Scottish chef unveils new restaurant in historic Scottish town

Lidl is selling a £4 pool must-have for your summer holiday & it’s £8 cheaper than a John Lewis version

Tesco is selling £12 cabin case that’s £287 cheaper than Samsonite version – and it’s great for EasyJet and RyanAir

Using one simple phrase on Vinted can make items sell faster

Victorian chapel home in Hampshire could be yours for £1.4m

Does someone else have a mortgage on my new home? CRANE ON THE CASE

Why did NS&I name the precise town where the most recent £1m Premium Bonds jackpot winner came from?

Can you expect to pay less for car hire this summer? Here's how much a rental costs in 12 popular hotspots in 2025

Are we allowed an 8ft fence for privacy? Our neighbour says we've broken planning rules

Sundar Pichai is vibe coding. 'It feels so delightful to be a coder.'

Harvard Calls Out ‘Illegal Retaliatory Step’ As Trump Bars Entry Of Its International Students

UFC 316: 10 Things You Need To Know About Saturday’s PPV

Aaron Donald On The Los Angeles Rams Entering 2025 Season: ‘The Sky’s The Limit’

Huge update for homebuyers with Halifax and Santander

Nintendo Switch 2 stock live: Where to buy, including Amazon, GAME, Argos and EE

Meta's tech chief says it's time for Silicon Valley to embrace the military again