I work in HR and am a fan of AI. After interviewing with an AI bot, I think it should stay out of job interviews.

Part of Fenech's job is trying out AI tools and staying on top of how the technology is being leveraged.Emily FenechEmily Fenech works in HR and believes strongly in using AI to automate workflows.She did a mock AI interview and said the bot was robotic and lacked emotional intelligence.Fenech warned against AI in emotionally nuanced tasks in the recruitment process.This as-told-to essay is based on a conversation with Emily Fenech, a 41-year-old marketing VP based in Nashville. Her identity and employment have been verified by Business Insider. This story has been edited for length and clarity.I'm a big fan of AI.I work at AllVoices, a company in the HR space that uses AI to help with some of the manual and employee-relations tasks that HR folks deal with.Part of my role is checking out AI applications and staying on top of how it's being leveraged in different use cases. I write about it. I make resources about it. I'm always looking to see what's out there.I recently made a LinkedIn post that went viral, which was about the 10 coolest AI applications for HR, like instant guides or reading notes.A lot of people commented on the post, suggesting different tools, and an AI interview tool kept coming up in the comments. So I decided to run a mock interview with the tool.That's when I had a pretty negative experience.It was robotic and lacked emotional intelligenceWhen I joined, the voice was robotic. I was looking at a logo, not even an avatar, which I think can also be creepy. But I was just staring into this blankness with a robotic voice asking me high-stakes questions, with my future livelihood on the line.At first, I thought it could be good as a screener. It created a hypothetical situation of interviewing for an office manager role and asked me to describe my experience in office management.I told it I had 25 years as an office manager, and it responded with an exaggerated reply that made me feel gaslit. It said something along the lines of, "Wow, that's so impressive. 25 years of experience." It then asked me for more details on my responsibilities, and that's where it kind of fell apart.I'm not an office manager. I'm a marketer. So I said, "I plan birthday parties and order toilet paper," as a joke. It responded with something like, "Wow, your ability to plan parties is an impressive quality."Even though I was using sarcasm and making jokes because I was not qualified for the role, this robot kept telling me how impressive I was. It felt like it would have found something positive to say about anything.I assumed that this technology was early and no one was actually using it yet, but I was surprised to see comments from people on LinkedIn who said they experienced this or that their company uses the tool.I think what's unfair about it is it's giving you robotic energy. Humans match the energy that they get in a conversation. When that energy was robotic, I felt myself using short sentences and feeling like I didn't want to talk to it because it wasn't a person.AI should stay out of the interview processI work in the employee-relations space and we use AI for all sorts of things in HR.For example, I think transcribing conversations is one of the best use cases. I also know a company that uses AI for performance management to keep track of goals by taking inputs from emails and one-on-one meetings with employees. Some employee support AI tools can help employees find their PTO policy or W2 form without needing HR employees to serve as the middleman.AI is really good for structuring unstructured data, remembering things, and taking notes. But any conversation that requires emotional intelligence, please don't use AI. It doesn't get sarcasm and there's no human cues. It just can't read the room.If it can answer a question correctly or give you a suggestion without making a decision, I don't see the harm.When it's deciding from a pool of candidates who proceeds and who doesn't, it's obvious to see the potential for harm.Read the original article on Business Insider

Comments

Business News

Thames Water still in ‘crisis mode’ as turnaround set to take a decade

Evening Standard

Russia's population crisis is so dire, it's staring down a labor shortage of 11 million people by 2030, a minister told Putin

about 10 hours ago

Here's How To Watch Golf’s 2025 Open Championship

Forbes

Comments

Business News

Thames Water still in ‘crisis mode’ as turnaround set to take a decade

OBR boss denies forecast drove welfare cut proposals

No extra money to cover resident doctor strikes, NHS trust leaders warn

US tariff of 30% on EU could ‘stop trade as we know it’ – Irish foreign minister

No extra money to cover resident doctor strikes, NHS trust leaders warn

Thames Water still in ‘crisis mode’ as turnaround set to take a decade

US tariff of 30% on EU could ‘stop trade as we know it’ – Irish foreign minister

JP Morgan posts strong 2nd quarter numbers; Dimon warns of tariff, geopolitical risk

US inflation heats up to 2.7% — a possible sign that Trump tariffs have begun to sting

Port of Los Angeles sees record container traffic as importers sprint to beat Trump tariff deadlines

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang can resume AI chip sales to China after meeting with Trump: ‘Monster win’

Are you an overspender or excessive saver? You might have ‘money dysmorphia’

Biggest financial reforms ‘in a decade’ to bring risk-taking back into City

Biggest financial reforms ‘in a decade’ to bring risk-taking back into City

Reeves sets out sweeping reforms to financial sector in search for growth

US tariff of 30% on EU could ‘stop trade as we know it’ – Irish foreign minister

US tariff of 30% on EU could ‘stop trade as we know it’ – Irish foreign minister

From an L.A. parking lot to a $1 billion deal — the red-hot success story of Dave's Hot Chicken

JPMorgan’s Jamie Dimon warns of ‘significant risks’ to US economy over Trump trade policies

Biggest financial reforms ‘in a decade’ to bring risk-taking back into City

Reeves sets out sweeping reforms to financial sector in search for growth

FTSE 100 touches above 9,000 for the first time

Want to grow faster? It might be time to replace yourself

Robert Walters cuts headcount further amid increased uncertainty

Rachel Reeves hails ‘instant impact’ of new mortgage reforms for first-time buyers

Robert Walters cuts headcount further amid increased uncertainty

FTSE 100 touches above 9,000 for the first time

Reeves sets out sweeping reforms to financial sector in search for growth

Reeves hails ‘instant impact’ for aspiring homeowners as red tape is cut

Thames Water boss receives £1m despite doubling in "serious" pollution

Thames Water sinks to £1.6bn loss as debt mountain balloons

Bank of England to ease rules for smaller and mid-sized banks

Thames Water sinks to £1.6bn loss as debt mountain balloons

Bank of England to ease rules for smaller and mid-sized banks

Nissan to close its Oppama plant in Japan to cut costs

Asian shares mostly finish higher although worries continue over Trump's tariffs

U.S. inflation may have worsened last month as Trump's tariffs start to bite

Thames Water turnaround will take 'at least a decade', boss warns

‘This £8.99 deal saved me £80 on all my handbag beauty essentials including luxe perfume’

Trading 212 review: How does it compare to rivals?

Thames Water losses hit £1.7bn as debt pile grows and utility's future remains at risk

Mansion House glitz cannot hide the stark realities for the UK economy

FTSE 100 Live 15 July: Index set to break 9000, Barratt Redrow posts update

Thames Water sinks to £1.6bn loss as debt mountain balloons

August 2025 benefits and pension payments dates plus cost of living support

Business news live: Rachel Reeves to address taxes and pensions in Mansion House speech

Grants of up to &#163;3,750 for (some) new electric cars

Benefit claimants could have payments stopped in hospital

DWP outlines major £725 Universal Credit changes that would start next year

Gtech's 'flawless' cordless vacuum bundle is £200 off and makes cleaning 'so much easier'

How we test and review investment platforms

Meet the BlackRock Frontiers fund managers who go where most investors fear to tread

Are LVMH shares cheap? Analysts eye rebound after Louis Vuitton owner's recent price slump

Elon Musk said a year ago that AI has no use at SpaceX. Now he's willing to pay $170k a head for AI engineers.

Jensen Huang says the US needs to win a key people battle with China

Russia's population crisis is so dire, it's staring down a labor shortage of 11 million people by 2030, a minister told Putin

Here's How To Watch Golf’s 2025 Open Championship

Rural Health Resilience: A Four-Part Series On Healing The Other America

Heavy Rains Trigger Flash Flooding And Disrupt Transport Services In New York And New Jersey

India Box Office: ‘Maalik’ Outperforms ‘Aankhon Ki Gustaakhiyan’

Grants of up to £3,750 for (some) new electric cars