The Big Stay is finally paying off: Quitting to job-switch is worse for wage growth than sticking it out

Recently, typical wage growth for job stayers has surpassed those quitting and switching jobs.Getty ImagesMany workers are resisting the quitting urge: Welcome to the Big Stay.In a rare turn of events, wage growth for job stayers is better than gains for job switchers.White-collar sectors have seen robust wage growth, though it's hard to land a new job.It's time to let go of Great Resignation FOMO.Typical year-over-year wage growth for job stayers has surpassed that for those quitting and switching roles. While it's a small gain at this point, you can see in the chart below that it's an extremely rare event and hasn't happened for a sustained period since 2009. Plus, it's a big turnaround from July 2022, when the gap was 8.5% vs. 5.9% in favor of job switchers.It speaks to how hesitant companies have become to hire; when they do decide to bring someone on board, they don't need to shell out a big raise to seal the deal.As a result, the white-collar workers who held tight to their jobs have become the sector's upper class: They're benefiting from low layoffs and robust wage growth. For those who both switched during the Great Resignation and have hung on to their new role ever since, that might be an economic double whammy — they cashed in at that higher salary and have been sitting pretty since.On the other end of the spectrum are white-collar workers who are out of work and looking, at a time when US businesses are hiring at nearly the lowest rate since 2014, excluding an early pandemic plunge.So you may be wondering: Is it a good time to switch jobs or not?Cory Stahle, an economist at the Indeed Hiring Lab, sums it up. "If the right job comes up, one that moves you forward in your career and gives you a healthy raise, certainly consider taking it," he said. "If not, there is at least some assurance that staying put still provides decent pay increases right now." Have a story to share about your job or job search? Reach out to these reporters at [email protected] and [email protected]. Job stayers are the new white-collar upper classIn contrast to the years of the Great Resignation, when job stayers were leaving money on the table by not hopping to a new company, the Big Stay has finally started paying off for those who are staying put.In May, white-collar-dominated industries had robust wage growth over the year. Average hourly earnings increased 6% from a year ago in the information sector, which includes broadcasting, telecommunications, and data processing. Professional and business services, such as the management of companies and enterprises, legal services, and computer system design services, had wage growth of about 5%.According to an analysis from the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, median wage growth for job stayers across all industries has outpaced growth for job switchers since February.The Big Stay seems here to stay for the time being — white-collar folks aren't leaving their jobs. Even if they're no longer enjoying their work, some see it as better than facing a long stretch of unemployment or an uncertain job market. And, financially, it's paying off."There's fewer people coming in, fewer people heading out," Guy Berger, the director of economic research at the Burning Glass Institute, said. "That mix tends to favor established workers who tend to be older and tends to hurt younger people trying to get their foot in the door."Job seekers are trading down in title and payOn the other side are the white-collar job seekers. The things that make the market relatively pleasant for job stayers are working against the job seekers: Employers are running leaner in the face of economic uncertainty and would rather rely on the talent they have. Job stayers may be worried about their chances of getting a different job and aren't vacating roles."As white-collar industries reverse some of that pandemic hiring and also pull back on hiring amid economic uncertainty, it's getting tougher to find a job," Daniel Zhao, lead economist at Glassdoor, told Business Insider. Glassdoor data last year showed that a growing percentage of workers switching employers were accepting lower-paid roles, especially in tech.Zhao said that's because, "Many job switchers today were involuntarily laid off, resulting in more workers having to settle for a lower-paying or lower seniority job."Berger said that in addition to weak hiring leading to fewer opportunities, there are also more people with a college education, which means more competition for jobs."It's also possible that in some segments AI is slowing demand for white-collar workers, though I doubt this is as big as some people think," Berger said.There's some good news in professional and business services, where the hiring rate continues to be strong and has been trending upward, although it's still below its late 2021 high, and the sector has had several monthly net employment losses over the past year. The information sector's hires rate is still low compared to the overall hires rate, but has climbed somewhat. Hiring in financial activities is lower than in the other two traditionally white-collar fields.Job seekers are already lowering their expectations: The average lowest wage all workers would accept for a new job plummeted from $82,000 in November 2024 to $74,000 in March 2025. Among those with college degrees, it fell from $102,000 to $95,000 in the same period.And the share of graduates in jobs that don't require a degree ticked up for recent graduates in the first quarter of 2025, indicating that degree holders are overqualified for more roles."White-collar industries like finance, tech, and consulting are still appealing, especially for new grads, because of their promise of rapid career growth and high pay," Zhao said. "But that promise of career growth and high pay is becoming less attainable and more exclusive due to the soft hiring environment."Read the original article on Business Insider

Comments

Business News

washington times

Bonnaroo music fest stops short due to thunderstorm

44 minutes ago

Newyork Post

The Israel-Iran conflict is shaking the markets — but nervous investors aren’t panicking

about 1 hour ago

insider

My sister and I are identical twins. We did everything together until college, when we set out to find our own identities.

about 1 hour ago

I had my baby at 48 through IVF. Being an older mom has so many benefits.

insider

My 7-year-old interviewed the author of his favorite book. He asked big and small questions with more confidence than I have.

about 7 hours ago

Rising Lion: Iran Endangers US Allies And Global Energy Security

Forbes

Comments

Business News

Bonnaroo music fest stops short due to thunderstorm

The Israel-Iran conflict is shaking the markets — but nervous investors aren’t panicking

My sister and I are identical twins. We did everything together until college, when we set out to find our own identities.

I had my baby at 48 through IVF. Being an older mom has so many benefits.

Trump’s Military Parade Is Designed for TV, but It Won’t Be on Every Channel

Minnesota ‘Politically Motivated Assassination’: Manhunt Underway For Alleged Killer (Live Updates)

FOX Believes IndyCar Is Ready For Prime Time At Gateway Sunday Night

Easy Does It On National Rose Day

NYT ‘Connections’ Hints And Answers For Sunday, June 15th

Today’s NYT Mini Crossword Clues And Answers For Sunday, June 15th

Rescuers still pulling bodies out of the water as death toll in South Africa floods reaches 86

First direct flight from US to Greenland since 2008 lands on Trump's birthday

Trump curbs immigration enforcement at farms, meatpacking plants, hotels and restaurants

TONY HETHERINGTON: When is a bank not a bank?

That's Nice! Informa chiefs swan off on Riviera junket

JEFF PRESTRIDGE: I love looking fund managers in the eye - and so should you

Last post for the letter as Royal Mail falls into foreign hands?

Should I fight the sexist boys' club at work? NICOLA HORLICK replies

HAMISH MCRAE: Do markets accept ongoing conflict now as a fact of life?

Luxury property prices slump as non-doms flee London

UK's borrowing costs under Labour are the worst in the developed world

ABRDN EQUITY INCOME TRUST: UK has never looked so good

Network Rail under fire as it snubs British steelmakers in contract

Tech mogul's spat with ex-husband spills into courtroom

Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky says his company is a 'convenient scapegoat' as European cities protest overtourism

Scale AI founder Alexandr Wang says he's waiting for Elon Musk's Neuralink before he has kids

‘Jaws’ Turns 50: How To Watch Steven Spielberg’s Classic On Streaming

Hollywood Drops The Hammer On AI, Midjourney And Stable Diffusion

After PWHL Expansion Draft, Original Teams Start Their Roster Rebuilds

Iran’s Nuclear Sites Will Be Hard To Dismantle, but Israel’s Missile Advantage Grows

Rachel Reeves could do 1 thing to launch stealth tax raid on pensions

Iran’s Vital Oil Industry Is Vulnerable in an Escalating Conflict

Why Hiccup And Astrid In ‘How To Train Your Dragon’ Look So Familiar

Richardson Hitchins Vs. George Kambosos Jr: When Does It Start?

‘No Kings’ Protests Draw Millions To Demonstrations Around The U.S. (Live Photo Updates)

Minnesota ‘Politically Motivated Assassination’: What We Know About The Suspect (Live Updates)

Jeff Gordon On Hendrick Motorsports’ Success This Season And New Partnership With Phorm Energy

Taylor Swift’s ‘Reputation’ Finally Reaches The Top 10

As Trump goes to G7 summit, other world leaders aim to show they're not intimidated

Rescuers still pulling bodies out of the water as death toll in South Africa floods reaches 86

WMATA train operators arrested, accused of healthcare fraud scheme

Satellite images show extensive damage that Israeli fighter jets inflicted on one of Iran's top nuclear facilities

‘How To Train Your Dragon’ Review: A Spectacular Adaptation That Leaves Disney’s Live-Action Remakes In The Dust

Metallica’s Hit Single Reaches A New All-Time Peak, Decades After Its Release

I've saved hundreds of dollars by scoring second-hand items. The trick is hunting in the right neighborhoods.

My 7-year-old interviewed the author of his favorite book. He asked big and small questions with more confidence than I have.

Rising Lion: Iran Endangers US Allies And Global Energy Security

Ringo Starr Rocks N.Y.C.’s Radio City With A Little Help From His Friends

South Africa End Decades Of Heartbreak In Tonic For Test Cricket

Minn. State Rep. Killed, Senator Shot In ‘Politically Motivated Assassination’ Attempt

Sydney Sweeney's 'gripping' new thriller from Alien director now streaming free

Dua Lipa was just spotted wearing this 'sexy' Boux Avenue bra and right now it's half-price

Vintage photos show how fatherhood has evolved in the US

There’s A New ‘Ginny And Georgia’ Season 4 Release Date Update

Inside Jean Jacques Boissy’s Path Back To The BAL Final

Marvel’s Spider-Man: Beyond Amazing — The Exhibition Amazes In Chicago

Nation Braces For Trump’s Military Parade—And Nationwide ‘No Kings’ Protests (Live Updates)

Jeff Bezos and Lauren Sanchez to spotlight Venice's artisanal heritage during upcoming nuptials

DWP confirms people born before exact date will receive 2025 Winter Fuel Payments

Twin federal proposals threaten provider taxes, key source of Medicaid funding for states