The Guardian view on Labour’s fiscal stance: it’s time to lay new foundations | Editorial

No chancellor has raised income tax since 1975, but voters may accept it if everyone contributes, the richest most of all, and the money pays for fairer, better servicesDenis Healey, a Labour chancellor, advised that when in a hole, one should stop digging. The failure to observe this iron law of politics is behind the sense of constant crisis engulfing Rachel Reeves. The current chancellor’s problem is one of her own making. She designed her fiscal rules with so little wriggle room that even small changes in economic forecasts – such as revisions to GDP – mean that her numbers stop adding up. That, in turn, starts chatter about budgetary “holes” and the need for tax rises and spending cuts – despite no change in the economy.In politics, as in digging, it helps to know when to put down the spade. Ms Reeves could end this drama by relaxing her fiscal rules. Or better still, replacing them, as the economist Tim Leunig suggested, with a 250-word summary of Britain’s economic position at the budget, and the effect of the government’s proposals. Instead, she has framed her decision to break an election promise not to raise income tax as unavoidable. She told BBC radio: “It would, of course, be possible to stick with the manifesto commitments, but that would require things like deep cuts in capital spending.” But this is not true. She’s blaming her rules for cuts they don’t require.Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here. Continue reading...

Comments

Business News

Wines From Five French Regions To Pair With Fall Foods

Forbes

My twins have done everything together since birth. Now that they're older, I'm helping them recognize their individuality.

1 day ago

Creedence Clearwater Revival’s Chart Comeback Takes Off Thanks To Halloween

Forbes

David Harbour is in a PR pickle ahead of 'Stranger Things.' Here's how 2 experts say they'd make the public forget about it.

1 day ago

I tried ChatGPT-5.1's personality presets. Cynical and Quirky are my favorites.

insider

Read the 8-page pitch deck a founder backed by Slow Ventures is using to try to solve retail's $25 billion a year return problem

1 day ago

M&S shopper flaunts contents of £10 surprise food bag and everyone has same comment

Mirror

Comments

Business News

Wines From Five French Regions To Pair With Fall Foods

Best Italian Panettone For Getting And Gifting 2025

Why Every Fed Official Should Eat At Akron, OH’s Diamond Grille

Rebuilding After War And Why Iraq Can’t Keep The Lights On

Natural item will remove stubborn toilet stains in minutes — no scrubbing

'Biggest ever' Black Friday holiday sale with money off trips to Morocco, Budapest and France

TSB Bank issues £452 alert to all customers as money taken from accounts

DWP cash boost worth £4,300 every year but 910,000 families are missing out

Can a car be a safe haven for your cash? The most collectable modern classics under £25,000

10 of the best and 10 of the worst Netflix shows that came out this year, so far

Photos show how Camp David, the president's private escape, has changed through the years

My mom didn't like that I'm homeschooling my daughter. Now that she has seen the benefits, she's helping me teach.

My twins have done everything together since birth. Now that they're older, I'm helping them recognize their individuality.

Creedence Clearwater Revival’s Chart Comeback Takes Off Thanks To Halloween

Taylor Swift’s Current Smash Beats Two Of Her Most Famous No. 1 Smashes

Glen Powell Finally Hosts ‘SNL’ With Olivia Dean And Will Forte

From Romania To California, College Gymnastics Recruiting Goes Global

How Early Detection Helped Maria Menounos Against Pancreatic Cancer

DWP paying £1,085 to thousands in UK before Christmas - see if you're eligible

In this Brazilian state, a new push to track cattle is key to slowing deforestation

Robin Williams' 10 best and 10 worst movies, according to critics

7 of the best and 6 of the worst looks ever worn at the CMA Awards

David Harbour is in a PR pickle ahead of 'Stranger Things.' Here's how 2 experts say they'd make the public forget about it.

I tried ChatGPT-5.1's personality presets. Cynical and Quirky are my favorites.

Gen Z is bringing back one of the most divisive dining trends of the 2010s

Nature is not a blocker to housing growth, MPs find

China’s Carbon Plateau: A Turning Point Or A Temporary Pause?

Lesser Known Wine Styles To Love From Six Countries

The ‘Rolls-Royce Of Turkey’ Is Coming To America

Interpath-owner to kick off &#163;900m sale of Claire's administrator

Fitness fans can cut the price of Fitbit as Amazon takes 30% off two popular watches

How to put your own Big Short on tech stocks - and profit if there's a market meltdown

Hundreds of thousands rally in Manila against flood-control corruption scandal

McDonald's is losing its low-income customers. Economists call it a symptom of the stark wealth divide

I live in a pool house in a stranger's backyard. The tiny house is perfect for me.

I'm a CEO and mom in NYC. Ping pong, piano, and 4:45 am wake-ups are how I stay healthy and focused.

Life360 CEO says company will remain 'remote-first' &mdash; and reallocated its office budget to company meet-ups

I took over my second grader's class project, and I regret it. My good intentions didn't teach her anything.

From screenwriting to stand-up: How 6 Goldman Sachs managing directors turned unlikely experiences into career success

Beyond Sonder and Marriott's messy breakup, employees and customers are paying the price

The married cofounders of Mejuri use Jeff Bezos' famous management principle to handle disagreements

Glen Powell invited a special guest to his 'SNL' hosting debut: his UPS driver

Read the 8-page pitch deck a founder backed by Slow Ventures is using to try to solve retail's $25 billion a year return problem

M&S shopper flaunts contents of £10 surprise food bag and everyone has same comment

‘I found the perfect stocking filler gift for beauty lovers – and Molly-Mae is a fan’

Shoppers urge 'switch from expensive straighteners' after trying 58% off Remington pair

19 best beauty Christmas gifts according to our beauty editor – starting from £10

DWP issues Winter Fuel Payment warning and says 'you do not need to'

Pensioners and people with ISAs told 'act now' to avoid November Budget losses

Managers managing managers is out. Managers managing AI agents is in.

6-figure eBay veterans who have been on the platform for 20 years explain how to make money reselling items

Pro-union flyers appear in Starbucks headquarters as some corporate staff quietly support barista strikes

How laid-off Amazon workers are coping with the shock and planning their next career moves

Mamdani is promising free childcare in NYC. Here's how New Mexico did it &mdash; and gave caregivers a raise in the process.

I went to Toys R Us. It was strange &mdash; and shows what can happen to 'zombie' retail brands after bankruptcy.

She was 35 with a new baby when cancer hit. Her family is still paying the price.

Americans really want their cheap stuff back

2025 College Football Bowl Eligibility Tracker: Week 13

UFC 322 Results, Bonuses, Highlights And Reactions

'I made £2million in 14 hours thanks to TikTok - here's how I pulled it off'

Interpath-owner to kick off £900m sale of Claire's administrator

Life360 CEO says company will remain 'remote-first' — and reallocated its office budget to company meet-ups

Mamdani is promising free childcare in NYC. Here's how New Mexico did it — and gave caregivers a raise in the process.

I went to Toys R Us. It was strange — and shows what can happen to 'zombie' retail brands after bankruptcy.