The US Navy's overreliance on top missile interceptors is 'unsustainable' in more intense fights, top admiral warns

The Standard Missile-3, or SM-3, is one of the US Navy's top interceptors.US Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Jonathan NyeThe US Navy has expended a lot of high-end ballistic missile interceptors in recent air defense operations.A top admiral told BI that this practice is "unsustainable" in high-tempo combat operations.Adm. James Kilby said cheaper alternatives are needed to preserve critical munitions stockpiles.US warships fighting around the Middle East have been leaning hard on top ballistic missile interceptors. That won't be sustainable in high-tempo combat operations that can fast consume key munitions, a top Navy admiral cautioned.Adm. James Kilby, the acting chief of naval operations, told Business Insider that cheaper alternatives for air defense are needed to preserve critical munitions stockpiles.The Navy has regularly found itself in air defense engagements around the Middle East since a fresh wave of violence swept across the region in October 2023. In the Red Sea and the Gulf of Aden, American warships have shot down hundreds of missiles and drones that the Tehran-backed Houthi rebels in Yemen have launched at merchant shipping lanes.And in the Eastern Mediterranean, US warships have intercepted massive Iranian ballistic missile salvos targeting Israel over three separate exchanges of fire.Kilby said the Navy has fired "significant numbers of advanced munitions" in support of these operations. However, "while the Navy remains fully capable and ready to respond to any contingency today, the pace and volume of these high-end weapon expenditures were neither anticipated by the Navy nor the defense industrial base.""As a result, our inventory of the most capable interceptors is reduced and requires an increased munitions delivery rate," he said.Navy warships around the Middle East, including in the Red Sea, have faced intense air defense battles over the past two years.US Navy photoKilby said the Navy is working with the US Missile Defense Agency, the Maritime Industrial Base Program Office, and its industry partners to expand interceptor production capacity. The efforts, he stressed, will help rebuild and sustain munitions stockpiles.Officials and analysts have said the Navy needs more of its best interceptors for higher-level threats in the Pacific, like China and its expanding ballistic missile arsenal. Some observers have raised concerns that US warships are rapidly expending essential munitions without adequate plans to replace them.A specific concern is the Standard Missile-3, or SM-3, interceptor inventory. These weapons can take out short- to intermediate-range missiles during the midcourse phase of flight. Unlike other ship-launched munitions, the SM-3 can engage threats in space.US warships in the Eastern Mediterranean have used the powerful SM-3s to defend Israel from Iranian missile attacks. These interceptors, produced by Raytheon, Aerojet, and, for newer types, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, are exceptionally effective weapons, but they come at a high price tag, between $10 million and $30 million, depending on the variant.Another Navy ballistic missile interceptor is the roughly $4 million SM-6, suited for defense against aircraft and cruise missiles, as well as terminal defense against ballistic missile threats."The Navy's current reliance on high-cost interceptors, such as SM-6 and SM-3, is unsustainable in high-tempo operations," Kilby warned. He added that the military "must shift to use lower-cost alternatives while preserving expensive defenses for strategic weapons — or risk running short when it matters most."Navy leadership has pointed to the Red Sea conflict as a clear example of the problem, as US warships have been forced to expend multimillion-dollar missiles to destroy cheap Houthi drones that can cost just thousands of dollars.Navy warships have used the SM-3 to defend Israel from Iranian missile attacks.U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Jonathan NyeAlternative options are limited for ballistic missile threats, but there are some better choices for drones that are being used to reduce pressure on interceptor arsenals.As the Red Sea conflict dragged on, US forces increasingly found themselves relying on lower-cost alternatives to preserve the expensive missiles. During the weekslong Operation Rough Rider targeting the Houthis earlier this year, for instance, American fighter jets used cheap laser-guided rockets for around half of all Houthi drone kills.The $25,000 AGR-20 Advanced Precision Kill Weapon System rocket is significantly cheaper than a $500,000 air-to-air missile. And these rockets are substantially cheaper than ship-launched SM-2 interceptors — weapons on the lower end of the Navy's missile defense capabilities that cost more than $2 million.The Navy has made it a priority in its current and future operations to bring the cost difference between air defense weapons and the threats they engage much closer to parity, especially as drones become increasingly relevant in naval warfare.Kilby said the Navy is also consistently evaluating and updating its tactics, techniques, and procedures to prepare for future operations. This includes finding ways to speed up the learning process, leading to more efficiency on the water.For instance, Kilby said data from the Navy's advanced Aegis Weapons System — which is equipped on Arleigh Burke-class destroyers and Ticonderoga-class cruisers — previously took weeks to process after an air defense engagement. But thanks to collaboration between the sea service, industry, and tech community, that timeline has decreased to just 24 hours."The 24-hour assessment timeline allows our ships and weapons systems operators to improve tactical proficiency and effectiveness while remaining in combat," Kilby said.Read the original article on Business Insider

Comments

Business News

Watchdogs insist reducing regulation will not increase risk of financial crisis

Evening Standard

Comments

Business News

Watchdogs insist reducing regulation will not increase risk of financial crisis

Brand Wimbledon serves a masterclass in building long-term global identity

Housebuilders’ £100m offer after probe ‘definitely looks dodgy’, Parliament told

Meta shareholders look to haul CEO Mark Zuckerberg, Sheryl Sandberg to court over 2012 scandal

Google to invest $25B in AI data centers across largest US electric grid over next 2 years

Elon Musk’s Tesla loses top North American sales executive in latest senior departure: report

Apple inks $500M deal with US-based rare-earth mine operator MP Materials

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott won’t release ‘intimate’ and ‘embarrassing’ emails with Elon Musk

Nearly 1,000 users report apparent X outage

Watchdogs insist reducing regulation will not increase risk of financial crisis

FTSE 100 falls back after passing 9,000 milestone

FTSE 100 falls back after passing 9,000 milestone

No extra money to cover resident doctor strikes, NHS trust leaders warn

Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent says ‘formal process’ to find Jerome Powell’s successor has started

Most believe AI helps small businesses compete with larger firms

Savers to be offered deals that could see them more than quadruple their wealth

Offshore wind farms to be allowed to apply for contracts before planning consent

Offshore wind farms to be allowed to apply for contracts before planning consent

Mark Cuban rips Zohran Mamdani’s pledges to freeze rent, make groceries cheap: ‘None of that s–t has a chance’

What would a wealth tax mean for Britain? Ask Chris Blackhurst anything

Key points from Rachel Reeves’s Leeds reforms

Vote in our Independent Money poll: How confident are you in investing?

Thames Water still in ‘crisis mode’ as turnaround set to take a decade

OBR boss denies forecast drove welfare cut proposals

No extra money to cover resident doctor strikes, NHS trust leaders warn

US tariff of 30% on EU could ‘stop trade as we know it’ – Irish foreign minister

No extra money to cover resident doctor strikes, NHS trust leaders warn

Thames Water still in ‘crisis mode’ as turnaround set to take a decade

US tariff of 30% on EU could ‘stop trade as we know it’ – Irish foreign minister

JP Morgan posts strong 2nd quarter numbers; Dimon warns of tariff, geopolitical risk

US inflation heats up to 2.7% — a possible sign that Trump tariffs have begun to sting

Port of Los Angeles sees record container traffic as importers sprint to beat Trump tariff deadlines

Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang can resume AI chip sales to China after meeting with Trump: ‘Monster win’

Are you an overspender or excessive saver? You might have ‘money dysmorphia’

Biggest financial reforms ‘in a decade’ to bring risk-taking back into City

Biggest financial reforms ‘in a decade’ to bring risk-taking back into City

Reeves sets out sweeping reforms to financial sector in search for growth

US tariff of 30% on EU could ‘stop trade as we know it’ – Irish foreign minister

US tariff of 30% on EU could ‘stop trade as we know it’ – Irish foreign minister

From an L.A. parking lot to a $1 billion deal — the red-hot success story of Dave's Hot Chicken

JPMorgan’s Jamie Dimon warns of ‘significant risks’ to US economy over Trump trade policies

Biggest financial reforms ‘in a decade’ to bring risk-taking back into City

Reeves sets out sweeping reforms to financial sector in search for growth

FTSE 100 touches above 9,000 for the first time

Want to grow faster? It might be time to replace yourself

Robert Walters cuts headcount further amid increased uncertainty

Rachel Reeves hails ‘instant impact’ of new mortgage reforms for first-time buyers

Robert Walters cuts headcount further amid increased uncertainty

FTSE 100 touches above 9,000 for the first time

Reeves sets out sweeping reforms to financial sector in search for growth

Reeves hails ‘instant impact’ for aspiring homeowners as red tape is cut

Thames Water boss receives £1m despite doubling in "serious" pollution

Thames Water sinks to £1.6bn loss as debt mountain balloons

Bank of England to ease rules for smaller and mid-sized banks

Thames Water sinks to £1.6bn loss as debt mountain balloons

Bank of England to ease rules for smaller and mid-sized banks

Nissan to close its Oppama plant in Japan to cut costs

Asian shares mostly finish higher although worries continue over Trump's tariffs

U.S. inflation may have worsened last month as Trump's tariffs start to bite

Thames Water turnaround will take 'at least a decade', boss warns