Trump voters with student loans are having 'buyer's remorse' over his latest debt collection moves

President Donald Trump restarted collections on defaulted student loans.Elsa/Getty ImagesStudent-loan borrowers who voted for Trump said they're frustrated with the collections restart.They still support Trump's stance on collecting student loans, but think default punishments are happening too fast.While negative credit reporting resumed, Trump paused Social Security garnishment.Tracy Davis, 42, still thinks that voting for President Donald Trump was a good choice.But she wishes the president would think more carefully about how his actions are affecting student-loan borrowers like herself."I did vote for Trump," Davis told Business Insider. "This was a very big surprise for me. I mean, I was thinking he was going to fix some things, and it didn't go the way I was seeing it going with student loans."Davis is referring to the Trump administration's move to restart collections on defaulted student loans in early May after a five-year pause. Negative credit reporting for defaulted student loans resumed in October 2024, and Trump's Education Department announced that collections would resume in an effort to restore accountability to the student-loan system."Borrowing money and failing to pay it back isn't a victimless offense," Linda McMahon, Trump's education secretary, wrote in an opinion piece. "Debt doesn't go away; it gets transferred to others. If borrowers don't pay their debts to the government, taxpayers do."Prior to the pandemic pause, Davis said she was able to make her $150 student-loan payments. However, once the pause lifted, she was billed nearly $400, which she said she could not afford. It caused her to fall behind on payments, and her credit score took a hit after negative credit reporting resumed."I think they pulled the trigger a little too fast, especially with hitting the credit report, because we're not all in the same situation," Davis said. "I just wish there was more thought put into it."Business Insider has heard from dozens of student-loan borrowers who are delinquent or in default on their debt, including some who voted for Trump. Borrowers tend to go into default after 270 days of missed payments.While many borrowers expressed frustration with the abrupt collections restart and the consequences for defaulting, like negative credit reporting and wage garnishment, some said they recognize the importance of restarting the system and ensuring borrowers pay back their loans.Ellen Keast, a spokesperson for the Department of Education, previously confirmed to BI that Social Security garnishment for defaulted borrowers is paused: "The Trump Administration is committed to protecting social security recipients who oftentimes rely on a fixed income."However, the department still plans to garnish wages for defaulted borrowers later this summer. Davis is concerned that she might be on the receiving end of that policy."If you were way behind and you had no intention of paying them back, yes, go after them, garnish wages," Davis said. "But when you're trying to make it and you're trying to honestly make an effort to pay them off, I don't think that's right that we're getting wages garnished or credit hits."'Buyer's remorse'Miranda Metheny, 37, is in default on her student loans — and she's rethinking the vote she cast for Trump."I'm having a bit of buyer's remorse," Metheny said. "Now, seeing what all is taking place, I'm like, maybe I just shouldn't have voted."Metheny is unable to work due to a disability, and she can't afford to dig into the $600 monthly disability insurance to pay off her student loans while also helping support her two children."We already don't make enough to really even survive at this point," Metheny said. "We're all robbing Peter to pay Paul, and now you're going to cut into that? I worry about people that are already hurting."The Department of Education estimated that 5 million borrowers are currently in default. Recent data from the New York Federal Reserve showed that millions more could enter default this summer; since negative credit reporting resumed in the fall, 8.04% of balances moved into serious delinquency in the first quarter of 2025.While some higher education analysts previously told BI that the surge in delinquency was expected, many borrowers are at risk of defaulting because they might not be aware of their payment status and are unprepared to afford an extra monthly bill.Some student-loan borrowers at risk of default said they still support Trump's move to collect on defaulted student loans. Cheri, 67, said that she voted for Trump and supports his stance that loans should be paid back. She hasn't made any payments on her loans since the pandemic pause, though, and she said she's not financially prepared to shoulder another monthly bill."I'm not going to bash the Trump administration. But that being said, I think that turning people over to collections is a very drastic move after what we just went through over the past four years," Cheri said. "I'm opposed to that."Aside from collections on defaulted student loans, the Trump administration is urging Congress to pass the president's big spending bill. The version of the bill that passed the House would condense existing income-driven repayment plans into two plans that have longer repayment periods. McMahon wrote in a June 11 post on X that the bill "will prevent future Democrat administrations from illegally transferring student loan debt to American taxpayers."Former President Joe Biden's SAVE plan — an income-driven repayment plan that would have allowed for cheaper monthly payments — is also blocked in court, leaving borrowers with fewer repayment options.As far as default consequences go, Sen. Elizabeth Warren said that McMahon confirmed in a private meeting on June 10 that Social Security garnishments will remain paused."The Education Secretary has assured me that the pause that is currently in place will stay in place and if there is to be any change in that, she would get in touch with me directly before we go there," Warren said.Metheny said she hopes that the administration will consider more relief for borrowers."We're not all billionaires," she said. "We can't just come up with that amount of money that quickly."Are you in default, or concerned about defaulting, on your student loans? Share your story with this reporter at [email protected] the original article on Business Insider

Comments

Business News

Is Father's Day getting more respect? Depends on who you ask

ABC News

My father and I work at AT&T together. On our hourlong commutes, he teaches me valuable lessons about life and my career.

about 5 hours ago

21 times real-life fathers and sons played family on-screen

insider

I pay $2,800 every month toward my student loans. Although I only have $200 left each week to spend, I'll be debt-free this year.

about 7 hours ago

Reeves vows to shield UK from Israel-Iran price shock

BBC News

I tipped this British stock when its shares cost 19p. Today they're worth £1.44... and here are four more UK stocks that deliver through thick and thin: MIDAS SHARE TIPS

about 8 hours ago

Comments

Similar News

‘No way to invest in a career here’: US academics flee overseas to avoid Trump crackdown

‘Stay below the radar’: corporate America goes quiet after Trump’s return

Trump's Harvard battle is making some students consider European universities instead

How a Tiny Community Got Caught Up in Trump’s Attacks on Canada

First direct flight from U.S. to Greenland since 2008 lands on Trump's birthday

Trump curbs immigration enforcement at farms, meatpacking plants, hotels and restaurants

Photos show the US Army's 250th anniversary parade held on Trump's birthday

Two Nations: Trump’s Military Parade Rolls On Amid Nationwide ‘No Kings’ Protests

Trump’s Military Parade Begins—Amid Nationwide ‘No Kings’ Protests

Trump’s Military Parade Is Designed for TV, but It Won’t Be on Every Channel

First direct flight from US to Greenland since 2008 lands on Trump's birthday

Trump curbs immigration enforcement at farms, meatpacking plants, hotels and restaurants

Leaders at G7 summit need to challenge Trump without ganging up on him

As Trump goes to G7 summit, other world leaders aim to show they're not intimidated

Nation Braces For Trump’s Military Parade—And Nationwide ‘No Kings’ Protests (Live Updates)

Celebrated, then disparaged: mRNA’s promise is tarnished under Trump

Trump signs executive order to clear way for Nippon-US Steel deal

Rare earth minerals are the biggest card China can play in its negotiations with Trump

Trump wants to cut federal housing funds in half, and even Republicans are questioning it

Trump clears path for Nippon investment in US Steel, so long as it fits gov't terms

Business News

Is Father's Day getting more respect? Depends on who you ask

'How to Train Your Dragon' soars in box office debut with $83 million

Fast-casual food places conquering Midtown as workers return to office

Canada agrees to ratify Britain’s accession to major trans-Pacific trade pact

‘A Minecraft Movie’ Debuts On Streaming On Max This Week

Why The Desmond Bane Trade Makes Sense For Both The Grizzlies & Magic

2025 NBA Finals: Pacers Beat Themselves, Have To Own Late-Game Failure

Desmond Bane Traded To Orlando Magic For Multiple First Round Picks

Israel-Iran War Can Alter Middle East Power Balance More Than Gulf War

Western Supply Chains Tainted By Uyghur Forced Labor

Netflix’s New #1 Movie Is An Overlooked, Must-Watch Action Thriller

G7 leaders gather in Canada for a summit overshadowed by Israel-Iran crisis and trade wars

Spaniards packing water pistols blame impact of mass tourism for housing crunch

'Multi-decade' future of nuclear base in Scotland secured with major commitment

Four beauty writers tried this £34 SPF and it's the ultimate holiday foundation-alternative

Plane spotters in Calgary hope for glimpse of Air Force 1 at G7

The CEO of British telecom giant BT warns AI could lead to further job cuts at the firm

HS2 reports subcontractor over alleged fraud

Daniel Suarez’s Xfinity Series Win At Mexico Could Create Job Security

Meta teams up with defense-focused tech companies for AI future

Thousands of jobs lost to Scotland because of SNP nuclear opposition, says minister

Progress on lifting Trump’s tariffs on Canada ‘not fast enough’: LeBlanc

Grow strawberries in your own garden this summer with plants now reduced to £1

Maya Jama’s favourite skincare duo is now available for less than £3 with this deal stack

Farewell to the 'Mad Men' era: Advertising's biggest bash of the year will showcase the industry's seismic changes

I'm a chef. Here are 10 ways I upgrade instant noodles to make them tastier and more satisfying.

I regretted giving my daughter her dad's last name. I changed it to include mine also.

France’s CAC 40 Is Another Nail In The “Fed-As-Market-Opium” Narrative

Newcastle United Already Facing Challenges In A Pivotal Summer Window

Northern Lights Forecast: 10 States May See Aurora Borealis Tonight Amid Geomagnetic Storms

Why Sally Ride’s Legacy Still Challenges The Culture Of STEM

Why NBA Star Dwight Howard Joined Ice Cube’s BIG3 League

Tree House Brewing Company— The Largest Brewery You’ve Never Heard Of

Trump Claims Peace Between Israel And Iran Coming ‘Soon’

G7 leaders gather for summit overshadowed by Israel-Iran crisis and trade wars

Findlay hits out at SNP in Korean 'moob' row: 'They don't know where money is going'

Portable shower that has ‘better pressure than the one at home’ is perfect for camping trips

Primark fans say 'woohoo' as eagerly awaited £7 item 'finally' available

My father and I work at AT&T together. On our hourlong commutes, he teaches me valuable lessons about life and my career.

21 times real-life fathers and sons played family on-screen

I waited an hour in line for Tokyo's famous soufflé pancakes. I felt like a total tourist, but I have zero regrets.

Radiohead’s Decades-Old Song Finally Becomes A Rare Chart Hit For The Band

Morgan Wallen’s New No. 1 Song: An Odd Journey To Becoming A Bestseller

Post Malone’s Country Era Continues — But Fans Haven’t Forgotten His Musical Roots

187,000 Ukrainians Get A Reprieve From U.S. Deportation as War Rages

‘Politically Motivated Assassination’ In Minnesota: Manhunt Enters Second Day (Live Updates)

Tate McRae Keeps Her Winning Streak Going With More New No. 1 Hits

Miley Cyrus Scores A Career First With Her New Album

Minister ‘hopeful’ for ‘positive’ announcement on Grangemouth soon

Minister ‘hopeful’ for ‘positive’ announcement on Grangemouth soon

I pay $2,800 every month toward my student loans. Although I only have $200 left each week to spend, I'll be debt-free this year.

Reeves vows to shield UK from Israel-Iran price shock

Addressing The Intergenerational Effects Of Conflict-Related Sexual Violence

This Indian GenAI Startup Is Reshaping Dubbing and Lip Sync

Bruno Mars Makes His Decade-Old Single A Global Smash Again

Be The Most Loved In Your Community

These Patriot Missiles Are Israel’s Trash And Ukraine’s Treasure