Against Identity by Alexander Douglas review – a superb critique of contemporary self-obsession

A philosopher challenges us to forget about ourselves in this powerfully strange counterblast to identity fetishismIdentity is something socially negotiated, both claimed and given. I cannot be French if that nation does not exist; I can’t be a doctor if no one will grant me a medical degree. Social media, however, promises that we can don or doff identities like so many digital masks. We may become persuaded that identities are private goods over which we have rights of ownership and choice, that we can freely select what we “identify as”. The heightened salience of identity in modern political discourse thus represents an unwitting internalisation of the neoliberal view of humans as atomised individuals who navigate life purely by expressing consumer preferences.The idea that the identity of the speaker should count when assessing his or her argument is what the right used to denounce as “identity politics” (now subsumed under the general concept of “wokeness”), though it is in this way a logical outcome of Thatcherite and Reaganite economics. One strong critique of the critique of identity politics, on the other hand, points out that privileged white males, of the sort who make such complaints, don’t have to worry about their identity because theirs is the default one of power and influence – whereas for various minorities identity might matter much more, not least in how it influences the ways in which privileged white males will treat them. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

‘Raw’ thriller with unbelievable twist shoots to the top of Netflix chart

Metro

Comments

Culture

‘Raw’ thriller with unbelievable twist shoots to the top of Netflix chart

Amanda Seyfried claims she is owed money from Mean Girls 21 years later

D.C., Georgetown University, National Park Service announce waterfront land swap

Dutch beach beasts find a final resting place in a new exhibition

CDC finds more mental health complaints among white-collar workers than skilled tradesmen

2 men plead not guilty in New York crypto kidnapping and torture case

Disney and Universal sue AI firm Midjourney for copyright infringement

Judge won't halt execution in South Carolina over lethal injection concerns

$2M price tag for VIP tickets to 'Les Miserables' with Trump at Kennedy Center

Trump says U.S. gets rare earth minerals from China and tariffs on Chinese goods will total 55%

Brian Wilson, Beach Boys visionary leader and summer's poet laureate, dies at 82

Tulane scientist resigns citing university censorship of pollution and racial disparity research

'A Knight's Tale: SteelBook Edition' 4K Ultra HD movie review

EPA says power plant carbon emissions aren't dangerous, contradicting years of scientific consensus

What to know about Harvey Weinstein's conviction on a top sex crimes charge at his #MeToo retrial

Trump says Kennedy Center fundraiser raised $10 million as performers skip in protest of policies

In 'Youth Group' comic, evangelical kids sing songs about Jesus, fight demons

With reporters shot and roughed up, advocates question whether those covering protests are targets

OpenAI's Altman: ChatGPT 'already more powerful than any human who has ever lived' in some aspects

Jury convicts Harvey Weinstein of top charge in the retrial of his landmark #MeToo sex crimes case

‘Best vampire movie in history’ added to Netflix to celebrate 40th anniversary

A-list heartthrob new favourite to play next Bond villain

Countryfile presenter declares ‘end of an era’ as he prepares to leave his farm

Explainer: Why has the Edinburgh International Book Festival moved in recent years?

Why is Gen Z getting more religious? We asked them.

Fans can’t wait for this wild rom-com about BDSM and ‘toxic situationships’

Jason Isaacs supports Tom Felton amid pile-on over JK Rowling remarks

East 17 star Terry Coldwell baptised by former Kray twins associate

Mia Farrow says Joan Crawford was ‘scary in person’ and she gave off a ‘strange vibe’

'Felt like enormous ton of bricks': GMB reporter hit by rubber bullet in LA protests

Jeremy Clarkson reveals truth behind savage Clarkson’s Farm ‘editing mistake’

The completely free streaming service that’s ‘like DIY Netflix’ with 25,000,000 users

Love Island 2025: Meet the cast of the ‘bigger’ and ‘bolder’ new summer series

Love Island contestant Sophie Lee praised for ‘inspirational’ revelation about facial burn scars

Strictly Come Dancing 2025 line-up rumours

The need for awards to ditch male and female categories has never been starker

Rising country star Conner Smith ‘co-operating with police’ after woman killed in car crash

Chris Evans says he’s ‘sad to not be back with the band’ for Avengers: Doomsday

Harry Potter actor challenges JK Rowling over trans views after signing up to new series

New sponsor Ian Rankin helps Edinburgh International Book Festival bounce back

Killing Eve, Games of Thrones and Succession stars head for Edinburgh book festival

One-off events with Scottish stars at the Edinburgh International Book Festival

Netflix fans say ‘wrestling is saved’ after shock WWE championship win

Good Morning Britain star reveals painful injury after ‘rubber bullet hits him’ at LA protests

Jeremy Clarkson explains Clarkson’s Farm ‘mistake’ after viewer confusion

Brit Awards to be held outside London for the first time in its history

HBO and CNN owner to split streaming and cable businesses

Jurors in Harvey Weinstein trial reportedly fighting among themselves

From festivals to weddings: Why drone shows are booming

Questlove

The summer blockbusters we finally watched

The end of the world as we know it: why the climate apocalypse genre is still on fire

Hamilton fans react as key cast member ‘cut out’ of Tonys performance

Blake Lively vs Justin Baldoni: A timeline of the feud and lawsuit between It Ends With Us co-stars

Harry Potter fans tear into Tom Felton’s response to JK Rowling’s anti-trans views

When a Glasgow teacher gives a young scholar dietary advice...

Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni: What you need to know

Tate Liverpool gets £12m for redevelopment project

Sly Stone: A funky life - in pictures

Despair to delight: lost Rodin 'copy' sells for $1m