Lucy Letby: Who to Believe? review – just when you thought this case couldn’t get any more confusing …

Panorama’s new investigation into the convicted nurse is muddled and stuffed with conflicting theories. It feels more like radio phone-in bickering than serious journalismIn May 2024, the New Yorker published an article with the headline “A British nurse was found guilty of killing seven babies. Did she do it?” Access to the online version of Rachel Aviv’s piece was banned in the UK due to reporting restrictions, with Letby’s retrial on an additional count of attempted murder then imminent. Rules aside, asking whether Letby was in fact innocent also felt taboo at the time, a pursuit for social media conspiracy theorists. Fast forward 15 months, and “did she do it?” is merely par for the course when it comes to the case, with even experts cited by the prosecution apparently unconvinced of Letby’s guilt.This new Panorama comes hot on the heels of an ITV documentary that aired earlier this month, Lucy Letby: Beyond Reasonable Doubt?. That programme focused on holes in the evidence that was presented to the jury who found Letby guilty of killing seven babies and attempting to kill seven more at the Countess of Chester Hospital between 2015 and 2016. Hers had been, said Neena Modi, a professor of neonatal medicine, a “deeply disturbing” trial based on flawed evidence. Claims made in the trial were roundly rubbished by a panel of specialists who reviewed the case, and by experts found by the programme makers, making the evidence sound more like a series of sad anomalies than conclusive proof of wrongdoing by Letby. In any case, one would be unlikely to come away from that programme without at least a measure of doubt about her convictions. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

Celebrity SAS fans praise ‘brave’ Lucy Spraggan for opening up about X Factor sexual assault

Metro

Comments

Similar News

Celebrity SAS fans praise ‘brave’ Lucy Spraggan for opening up about X Factor sexual assault

TV tonight: unpicking all the questions about the Lucy Letby case

Standing in the Shadows of Giants review – Lucie Barât looks back at spiral during Libertines’ rise

Lucy Letby: Beyond Reasonable Doubt? review – one of the most meticulous documentaries in years

Lucy Foley: ‘Angus, Thongs and Full-Frontal Snogging didn’t talk down to teenage girls’

Singer Lucy Spraggan reveals she ‘clashed’ with boxer Conor Benn on Celebrity SAS

‘A novel to be swept away by’: Lucy Steeds wins Waterstones debut fiction prize for The Artist

A new Irish writer is getting rave reviews – but nobody knows who they are. That gives me hope | Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett

Culture

Celebrity SAS fans praise ‘brave’ Lucy Spraggan for opening up about X Factor sexual assault

Dave Franco and Alison Brie had to ‘take stock’ of co-dependent relationship for Together

Only Murders in the Building showrunner teases big changes ahead of season five

New War of the Worlds film named one of the 100 worst movies ever

Strictly Come Dancing full lineup 2025: Meet the celebrity contestants announced so far

Musicologist says the secret to Taylor Swift’s success is hidden in her songs

K-Pop Demon Hunters song ‘Golden’ tops charts in US and UK

Netflix users’ Wednesday theory ‘confirmed’ after Jenna Ortega debunks ‘body swap’ theory

BBC cancels Sara Cox’s ‘much-loved’ chat show after eight series

Jimmy Kimmel says second Trump term is ‘so much worse’ as he reveals he has Italian citizenship

Cate Blanchett gives verdict on potential David Fincher Squid Game spin-off

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry sign new Netflix deal to create ‘thoughtful’ content

Brian Cox says Donald Trump is a ‘very good example of a villain’: ‘No empathy whatsoever’

The uniquely American panic over adultery

The surprising origins of the “wellness” boom

Rap icon cancels gig one hour before performance after ‘unforeseen illness’

Sziget 2025 review – Post Malone is a lively, unserious showman, while Chappell Roan is at the top of her game

South Park shares ‘unaired scene’ doubling down on Kristi Noem mockery

The enduring appeal of Moomins as cartoon celebrates its 80th birthday

Sandra Bullock says she was told she couldn’t ‘like’ Jennifer Aniston: ‘No one wanted the ladies to be friends’

Flow Festival 2025, review – Charli xcx, Burna Boy and FKA Twigs headline but Finland’s own hold their ground

Princess Andre ‘thought she’d be killed’ with mum Katie during terrifying carjacking

Taylor Swift announces 12th studio album

Alan Tudyk says he was removed from I, Robot publicity after early viewers preferred him to Will Smith

‘I hate it’: 11 movies that actors regretted saying yes to, from Harry Potter to Blade Runner

Simon Pegg says Quentin Tarantino’s idea for Star Trek would have been ‘crazy’

Taylor Swift unveils first glimpse of 12th album cover on Travis Kelce’s podcast

Strictly Come Dancing announces EastEnders star Balvinder Sopal as fifth contestant for 2025 series

Taylor Swift announces new album with major milestone in Travis Kelce relationship

Seth Rogen and Rose Byrne make great pals in 'Platonic'

Martin Scorsese ‘threatened to get gun’ after request to cut iconic film

‘Masterpiece’ horror film with 100% Rotten Tomatoes rating streaming on Amazon Prime

Netflix fans rush to binge ‘funniest British TV comedy ever made’

KPop Demon Hunters goes Golden with Billboard chart-topping hit

MasterChef contestant's joy at seeing series on TV

Taylor Swift reveals new album during surprise Travis Kelce podcast appearance

Freddie Mercury’s closest friend throws doubt on ‘secret child’ claims as woman speaks out for first time

Taylor Swift announces new album Life of a Showgirl during Travis Kelce podcast appearance

Dance with a Stranger at 40: Miranda Richardson on playing Britain’s last hanged woman

'There is no more time': Madonna urges the Pope to go to Gaza

Taylor Swift announces 12th studio album

Taylor Swift Announces New Album, ‘The Life of a Showgirl’

Sheila Jordan, Fearless Vocal Improviser, Is Dead at 96

What we learnt from Nicola Sturgeon's memoir

Brian Cox says Donald Trump is a ‘very good example of a villain’: ‘No empathy whatsoever’

Brian Cox touts Peaky Blinders star Cillian Murphy to be next James Bond: ‘He’s very real’

Sheila Jordan, a singular voice in jazz, has died

Succession star Brian Cox: Cillian Murphy would make an ‘interesting’ James Bond

New Books About Iran and the Middle East Offer Warnings on Leadership

WWE world champion pulled from Raw ‘on medical grounds’ just hours before show

Celebrity SAS viewers slam lying recruit kicked out for ‘cutting corners’

Cate Blanchett reveals how her Squid Game cameo was kept secret – and teases spin-off

Christophe de Menil, Art Patron and Designer, Is Dead at 92

How the Bonds Among Virtual-Reality Furries Saved a Life, in “The Reality of Hope”

Cate Blanchett gives verdict on potential David Fincher Squid Game spin-off

Country music star unexpectedly cancels upcoming shows after ‘tough’ several weeks

Some call the Sussexes' Netflix deal a demotion - but the company still sees them as a power couple

Bill Maher claims The View is not ‘the best advertisement for women’

Jimmy Kimmel says second Trump term is ‘so much worse’ as he reveals he has Italian citizenship

Kelly Clarkson’s ex-husband Brandon Blackstock’s cause of death revealed