Queen Esther by John Irving review – a disappointing companion to The Cider House Rules

The once-great author revisits St Cloud’s orphanage all too briefly, in a novel that begins with an adopted girl but wanders all over the placeIf some writers have an imperial phase, where they hit the heights time after time, then American novelist John Irving’s ran through a series of four fat, satisfying novels, from his 1978 breakthrough The World According to Garp to 1989’s A Prayer for Owen Meany. Those were generous, funny, big-hearted books, tying characters he calls “outliers” to social issues from feminism to abortion.Since Owen Meany, it’s been diminishing returns, except in page length. His last novel, 2022’s The Last Chairlift, was 900 pages of subjects Irving had explored better in earlier books (mutism, dwarfism, transgenderism), with a 200-page screenplay in the middle to pad it out – as if padding were needed. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

Can’t let go of Halloween? Stream these 7 spooky not-quite Christmas films

Metro

Comments

Similar News

Book Review: ‘Queen Esther,’ by John Irving

The “welfare queen” stereotype is back — and it’s going viral

Queen’s Bohemian Rhapsody voted favourite song of Greatest Hits Radio listeners

‘We stick two fingers up at Henry VIII’: can the riotous all-Japanese Six out-Tudor-queen the original?

Queens of the Stone Age at Royal Albert Hall: '2025's best gig?'

God Save the Queens: The rock and the roll of Josh Homme

Queens of the Stone Age headlined Glastonbury — but their London show was better

‘The Queen made us reunite’: Felicity Kendal on The Good Life at 50

Alexandra Burke to play Queen of Funk in I’m Every Woman The Chaka Khan Musical

Lily Allen has always been the queen of the confessional – West End Girl is a perfect exercise in unsparing honesty

Artist sues for co-author credit on Chris Levine’s queen portraits

‘Queens of the Dead’ Review: Club Kids vs. Zombies

Freddie Mercury’s ‘alternative versions’ of Queen hits revealed in new book

Argentina: The queen of bailanta

V. R. Lang, a Forgotten Queen Bee of Modern Poetry

From Annie Hall to Something’s Gotta Give: Diane Keaton was the quintessential comedy queen

Queen recalls Jilly Cooper wish to 'get plastered'

A drag queen stands at a site of violence: Lee-Ann Olwage’s best photograph

Queen named the UK’s most played rock act in the 21st century

‘Jilly Cooper was the absolute queen’: writers pay tribute to the beloved author

Culture

Can’t let go of Halloween? Stream these 7 spooky not-quite Christmas films

Grateful Dead singer Donna Jean Godchaux dies aged 78

Lidl Christmas advert 2025 review: festive ad, or dire social commentary? You decide

When is Stranger Things season 5 coming out following David Harbour ‘harassment’ claims?

When is The Celebrity Traitors 2025 finale – and can you watch it in the cinema?

When is Celebrity Race Across The World on and who’s in the cast?

‘One of the greatest crime films ever made’ streaming on Prime Video

Rapper sues Spotify, claiming Drake’s streams are inflated by bots

Top Gear co-creator says Ofcom breach was because team got ‘giddy on their own popularity’

Celebrity Race Across the World is back: Who will be competing?

All the biggest 2025 Christmas adverts so far ahead of John Lewis

I’m a Celebrity 2025 line-up rumours, from Jack Osbourne to Ruby Wax

Seven revelations from Anthony Hopkins’s moving new memoir

Celebrity Traitors’ Cat Burns: How the stealthy singer’s quiet confidence got her to the final

Jennifer Aniston has just gone official with her new boyfriend – now read between the lines

Paddington pandemonium: How to buy the hot tickets to the new musical

TV fans can’t resist bingeing Sean Bean’s medieval drama despite calling it ‘terrible’

‘I took the fall for the biggest robbery in British history after going on the run’

Wicked: For Good director confirms he’s cut the franchise’s biggest song from sequel

John Oliver eviscerates Trump over Gatsby-themed Mar-a-Lago party as SNAP benefits lapse for millions

Dancing on the edge: Figures in Extinction captures a disconnected world in climate crisis

Britney Spears deletes Instagram after clash with ex Kevin Federline

After the vibe shift, Ford ads got weird

Why peanut butter is back on the kids’ menu

Sainsbury's Christmas advert 2025: BFG returns to save online food deliveries from thieving rotters

Ant McPartlin and wife Anne-Marie ‘move out of £6,000,000 home losing battle with neighbours’

Strictly star Amy Dowden announces second mastectomy after breast cancer recovery

Dawn French is back for M&S 2025 Christmas advert with former MasterChef favourite

Reese Witherspoon says career success linked to having had ‘so much anxiety’

Andrew Lloyd-Webber says lesson of Evita ‘more important’ now due to extremism

Madrid will give Woody Allen £1.3m for his next film – but only if it bears city’s name

Diplo claims he dated both Katy Perry and Justin Trudeau

Asda Christmas advert 2025 review: how the Grinch survived the cozzy livs

Olivia Bowen reveals terrifying moment she suffered major haemorrhage during traumatic birth

Dancing on the edge: Figures in Extinction captures a disconnected world in climate crisis

George Clooney says it was a ‘mistake’ to replace Biden with Kamala Harris without primary

Daniel Day-Lewis hits back at method acting being attached to ‘some kind of lunacy’

Strictly’s Vito Coppola delivers emotional message to Ellie Goldstein after elimination

Claudia Winkleman’s BBC chat show ‘being fast-tracked’ after quitting Strictly

First look at Paddington The Musical ahead of its West End opening

Jesse Eisenberg speaks out after being replaced as Mark Zuckerberg in The Social Network sequel

Margaret Atwood opens up about heart condition and medication that turns her ‘blue’

Morrissey cancels two tour dates due to ‘extreme exhaustion’

Curb Your Enthusiasm’s Cheryl Hines says ‘politics’ behind estrangement from Larry David

Anthony Hopkins: We Did Ok, Kid review – A memoir that falls short of capturing the depth his career deserves

Bryan Cranston ‘not closed’ to idea of bringing back Breaking Bad’s Walter White

The Witcher fans name one problem with Liam Hemsworth’s performance as Netflix series returns

Dave Franco talks down ‘nepo-sibling’ status: ‘If I sucked, I would’ve disappeared’

Audience reduced to tears by Paddington Bear reveal for new West End musical

Quentin Blake illustration centre reveals opening date

Lucy Liu star of the show at Belfast Film Festival

Sir Anthony Hopkins: It's such a miracle being alive

‘All’s Fair,’ Plus 7 Things to Watch on TV This Week

True story hailed as ‘edge of your seat movie’ soars up Prime Video chart

Ellie Goldstein becomes fifth celebrity eliminated from Strictly Come Dancing

Strictly viewers react to Ellie Goldstein’s exit: ‘She should be proud’

Leonardo DiCaprio sheds new light on Tarantino scene branded ‘one of the great pieces of acting’