Smash review – canceled TV drama gains new life on Broadway

Imperial Theatre, New YorkThe much-ridiculed musical TV series has been transformed into a sleekly enjoyable new stage show, complete with Easter eggs for its cult fanbaseBy most metrics, Smash, the erstwhile NBC series about the drama-filled production of a comedic Marilyn Monroe musical, was a failure. The show had high expectations – it was developed and executive-produced by Steven Spielberg, championed by the then-head of NBC, stocked with Broadway pedigree and supported by a robust network TV budget. It boasted a mix of high-wattage screen talent (Debra Messing, Anjelica Huston), new blood (American Idol alum Katharine McPhee) and established stage veterans (Megan Hilty, Christian Borle). And it featured pop music covers and original musical theater tracks, promising what should have been, as one friend loves to put it, Glee for adults.Yet after initial critical praise following its February 2012 premiere, the show quickly became a laughing stock, an appointment hate-watch for its whiplash tonal shifts, unsympathetic lead characters and bad scarves. It was canceled after just two seasons. But in our post-post-post irony world, time has been kind to the bizarre misfire. In the decade since it last aired, Smash has become a beloved IYKYK cultural artifact, the type of failure whose wild delusion and total lack of sense aged into fine camp. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

‘We don’t socialise’: Kirstie Allsopp and Phil Spencer get frank about their offscreen relationship

Independent

Comments

Similar News

The Smashing Machine: The brutal true story behind Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson’s A24 UFC biopic

The Smashing Machine: Dwayne Johnson fights for an Oscar in first trailer

6 (Genre-Smashing) New Songs You Should Hear Now

Netflix smash hit racks up 32,900,000 views and a 100% Rotten Tomatoes score

Gerard Butler’s ‘trashiest’ action thrillers somehow smash into Amazon Prime charts

Tinā: the tiny, big-hearted New Zealand movie that became a smash hit – against the odds

Walton Goggins hails ‘smashing’ SNL White Lotus sketch mocking Aimee Lou Wood amid feud rumors

Pet Shop Boys’ Neil Tennant says copy of Smash Hits inspired him to go classical

Terrifying moment Coachella performer smashes face during dangerous backflip

‘Smash’ Is Escapist Fluff and Exactly What We Need Right Now

Review: In a Musical Comedy Makeover, ‘Smash’ Lives Up to Its Name

Adolescence season 2: Brad Pitt's Plan B in talks with Netflix over smash hit sequel

Culture

‘We don’t socialise’: Kirstie Allsopp and Phil Spencer get frank about their offscreen relationship

Supergrass are great but Glasgow crowd? Well, they're 'alright'...

Andrew Gower on Gustaffson: 'Don't kill the mystery of music'

Matt Willis reveals Busted turned down offer to compete for UK in Eurovision

Jeremy Clarkson’s new farmhand breaks silence as she replaces Kaleb Cooper

$100m, no hits and a show about octopuses: what is going on with Phoebe Waller-Bridge’s Amazon deal?

David Tennant game show becomes ITV’s ‘most expensive flop in years’

What challenges are in store for Pope Leo XIV?

Critics demand their ‘therapy bills paid for’ after watching gruesome horror sequel

Shirley Ballas suggests Giovanni Pernice might return to Strictly Come Dancing

Harry Styles fans go wild as pop star spotted among Vatican crowds celebrating the new pope

Gary Lineker says BBC didn’t have ‘great desire’ to renew his contract

Suzanne Vega recalls Scotland Yard urging her to cancel Glastonbury headline slot

Here We Are at the National Theatre, Lyttelton review: should this have been staged at all?

VE Day viewers baffled after 90s one hit wonders perform for King Charles

Ranvir Singh replaced and forced to drop out of Lorraine last minute

I thought Molly-Mae Hague was self-absorbed – her documentary changed my mind

The radical remake of this 90s rom-com is guaranteed to make you cry

Andor's Elizabeth Dulau: 'An iconic hairdo is part of the Star Wars job description'

Suzanne Vega: ‘I was the first woman to headline Glastonbury – I had to wear a bulletproof vest’

The best new crime and thriller books to read in May 2025

Unseen Thomas & Friends pilot to be released

Josh Harnett's 'Fight or Flight' is just plane bonkers

The political power of Gen Z women

Christine Baranski says Stellan Skarsgård ‘hated’ Mamma Mia! filming experience

Amy Dowden makes Strictly Come Dancing return for special BBC VE Day performance

Coronation Street star says ‘something is seriously wrong’ after being left unable to walk

Russell Tovey: ‘I realised I liked men in the shadow of Aids. I’d constantly mix sex and death’

The Uninvited is pure bitchy fun

You can’t read the new Diana biography without thinking of Meghan

President Trump fires Librarian of Congress Carla Hayden

The boom in health memoirs and what they can tell us about being human

Thom Yorke and Mark Pritchard’s album Tall Tales is loaded with existential jitters

Grey’s Anatomy creator Shonda Rhimes reveals the ‘hardest’ death she had to write

Justin Baldoni’s lawyers suggest holding Blake Lively’s deposition at Madison Square Garden

Lizzo releases music video filmed after Met Gala

Weinstein accuser says he 'took her soul' during alleged sex assault

Carolina Bianchi’s Last Play Knocked Her Unconscious. ‘The Brotherhood’ Is Tougher.

Trump administration opens Title IX investigation into Western Carolina University

Review: Hugh Jackman in a Twisty Tale of ‘Sexual Misconduct’

'All good things must come to an end': The Who announce North America farewell tour dates

Tot's mom wants Loudoun County schools to act on anti-Asian slurs

Joe Biden on 'The View' blames 2024 Harris loss on sexism, racism, not concerns of his age

Virginia man accused in killing of high school student doing 'ding-dong-ditch' TikTok trend

Smokey Robinson's lawyer says rape allegations against him are 'vile' and 'false'

Challah French toast is a simple but indulgent breakfast to make Mom on Mother's Day

Trump to end spending on Biden-era digital equity law, calling it 'racist and illegal'

Future of under-threat Scottish mobile cinema service secured

The 2000s indie heroes who are back and bigger than ever

James Foley, Who Directed ‘Glengarry Glen Ross,’ Dies at 71

A Day in the Live-Streamed Life of Donald Trump

Justin Baldoni’s lawyers suggest holding Blake Lively’s deposition at Madison Square Garden

Broadway playwright reveals Sadie Sink’s criteria for first project after Stranger Things

New study finds ‘simple selfie’ can help predict patients’ cancer survival

Why did Molly-Mae take Tommy Fury back? Everything to know from Behind It All Part 2

Amazon Prime viewers warn horror TV show is ‘not for faint-hearted’

Eggs are less likely to crack when dropped on their side, according to science

Jennifer Aniston's alleged stalker appears in court shirtless and a judge orders a mental evaluation

New pope led Order of St. Augustine dedicated to the poor and service

U.S. infant mortality dropped in 2024. Experts partly credit RSV shots