The best joke award has gone. Is the Edinburgh fringe taking all the pun out of comedy? | Anya Ryan

I will miss the lighthearted award, but often it overlooked the art of standup in favour of celebrating groan-inducing one-linersAnya Ryan was a member of the Edinburgh Comedy Awards judging panel in 2023 and 2024So long, pun of the year. The best joke of the fringe award – the lighthearted, groan-inducing staple of the Edinburgh festival – has been scrapped after 17 years. The award’s retirement may not prompt national mourning, but it does bring to an end a curious fringe tradition – one that delivered easy headlines as well as endless debate.Launched in 2008, the award set out to distil the spirit of the festival into a single one-liner. Longlisted by a panel of critics and then voted on by the public, it aimed to showcase the sharpest bite-size humour from that year’s fringe. Still, the announcement was never without controversy. In 2023, when Lorna Rose Treen took the title with the joke “I started dating a zookeeper, but it turned out he was a cheetah”, she was met with a wave of online criticism (the Sun claimed her win had “killed comedy”). Last year, an article in the Herald deemed the award Edinburgh’s “most heated controversy”.Anya Ryan is a freelance journalist. She was a member of the Edinburgh Comedy Awards judging panel in 2023 and 2024 Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

Wednesday star Jenna Ortega teases season 2 and hints at deeper Addams family dynamics

Independent

Comments

Culture

Wednesday star Jenna Ortega teases season 2 and hints at deeper Addams family dynamics

MasterChef contestant edited out of new series after objecting to it being broadcast

17 acting careers ruined by a single role: ‘I lost everything’

Fantastic Four star Ebon Moss-Bachrach says he would ‘throw fascists into space’ if he was given superhero powers

Guillermo del Toro praises ‘perfect’ Jacob Elordi for replacing Andrew Garfield in Netflix’s Frankenstein

Walton Goggins says ‘spicy’ new ad is ‘closest to a porno’ he’ll ever get

Rob Schneider shares whether he’s tired of repeating his catchphrase in Adam Sandler movies

Taron Egerton explains why he doesn’t want to play James Bond

Harrison Ford reveals how Michael J Fox has been ‘essential’ while filming Shrinking

If Edinburgh Fringe wants more hits like Fleabag and Baby Reindeer, it needs a complete overhaul

Ade Edmondson joins Bergerac cast

Director Mendes helps launch creative venue

Jamie Lee Curtis says she is ‘self-retiring’ after seeing how Hollywood treated her superstar parents

Sneaking Into the Spy Museum’s New Vault

Foo Fighters reveal identity of new drummer

Al Calderon exits Days of Our Lives in latest casting shake-up

Wednesday fame was overwhelming, says Jenna Ortega

Love Jack Kerouac? Read These Great American Road Trip Books Next.

The Enduring Power of “The Rules of the Game”

Destination X on BBC One review: Rob Brydon show offers fresh thinking, but can’t beat Race Across The World

England's Birmingham bids farewell to Ozzy Osbourne, its homegrown heavy metal hero

Destination X should be as big as The Traitors

Destination X proves competitive reality shows are the hottest thing on TV right now

Ncuti Gatwa heavily teases he ‘might’ return to Doctor Who

Comedian Aparna Nancherla on middle-age rage

Getting in Marc Maron’s Head

Watch the first look at Zootopia 2 in new trailer

Shannon Sharpe not returning to ESPN after settling rape lawsuit

Zootopia fans react to ‘savage’ therapy scene in trailer for new sequel

BBC releases its ‘new Race Across The World’ – don’t judge episode 1

Netflix show boss fires back after raunchy TV series is labelled ‘vulgar’

Harrison Ford reveals how Michael J Fox has been ‘essential’ while filming Shrinking

Walton Goggins says ‘spicy’ new ad is ‘closest to a porno’ he’ll ever get

Watch this terrifying film tonight – it might change your life

I interview celebrities – but Rob Brydon’s sweaty bus tour was utterly surreal

The great Oasis ticket war rocked the industry – but has anything changed since?

TikTok removes video by Huda Beauty boss over anti-Israel conspiracy theories

Theatre school founder and ‘true visionary’ Sylvia Young dies aged 86

Two Titans of the Gilded Age, Entwined in Art and Life

Senator John Fetterman to Publish a Memoir in November

BBC returns to Met Office for weather forecasts – but will accuracy improve?

Epstein Island Revealed

Ozzy Osbourne’s cortege makes touching detour past his childhood home

2000 Meters to Andriivka review: this documentary from the frontlines in Ukraine is 2025’s most essential film

Dekmantel: who’s on the line-up as the festival kicks off?

Liam Neeson and Pamela Anderson had the ‘strangest sex scene’ in Naked Gun reboot

Taron Egerton explains why he doesn’t want to play James Bond

Urgent warning to Lollapalooza ticket holders ahead of music festival

Robin Roberts reveals the reason for her GMA absence

David Attenborough left ‘horrified’ while narrating gruesome spider footage in new series

The Osbournes ‘changed TV forever’ and no reality show will ever compete

Ozzy Osbourne gets final tour of Birmingham - with fans flooding streets to pay their respects

BBC reunites with Met Office for weather forecasts

Ozzy Osbourne gets raucous and emotional send-off

Jason Momoa Prefers to Be Called a ‘Sensitive Alpha Male’

Ethel Cain, Pop’s Experimental Problem Child, Will Never Be the Same

Sharon Osbourne emotional as family look at Ozzy Osbourne tributes in Birmingham

South Park: when and where can I watch the latest episodes in the UK?

7 of the best horror films of 2025 so far including ‘stomach-churning’ body horror

Liam Neeson’s Naked Gun reboot is a masterclass in buffoonery