The Voice of Hind Rajab review – docufiction is fierce, vehement and heart-shattering

In an audacious move, director Kaouther Ben Hania reconstructs the killing of the five-year-old in Gaza using her real voice as she is bombarded by the Israeli armyThere can be no doubt about which movie has set the Venice film festival ablaze – it is this one, from Tunisian film-maker Kaouther Ben Hania. The Voice of Hind Rajab is about the horrifying ordeal of the five-year-old Palestinian girl Hind Rajab, who was killed in 2024 by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) in Gaza in her uncle’s car along with six family members, and two paramedics who tried to come to her rescue. Rajab herself, who survived the original assault by the IDF which killed those around her, stayed on the phone for hours to the Palestine Red Crescent Society (PRCS), desperately begging for help. With startling audacity, Ben Hania has used the real audio recording of Rajab’s heart-wrenching voice, while fictionally reconstructing the drama of the emergency responders in their call-centre office, with real people played by actors, talking, shouting and emoting in response to Rajab’s actual voice.The result was greeted with a 23-minute standing ovation at Venice, about a quarter of the film’s running time, with journalists and festival attenders reportedly sobbing in the auditorium. Since that passionate reception, others have wondered if there is not something questionable or exploitative in presenting this authentic shattering recording in a Hollywoodised suspense drama, getting actors to cry and rage alongside a kind of docufictional hologram, almost instructing the audience in how they too should be responding. I wonder. Perhaps Ben Hania’s high-concept idea is debatable, and it might have been just as moving to present this extraordinary real-life recording in the straightforward documentary context of interviews with the responders and emergency workers. This might have made clearer what happened from their point of view, why they were impeded from helping Rajab and what continues to hinder them. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

Steve review – Cillian Murphy drama exposes the perils of novel-to-film adaptations

Independent

Comments

Culture

Steve review – Cillian Murphy drama exposes the perils of novel-to-film adaptations

Anthropic settles with authors in first-of-its-kind AI copyright infringement lawsuit

The Testament of Ann Lee is the most radical film I’ve ever seen

‘I was a secret drinker’, singer Lulu says as she reveals battle with alcoholism

Mitchell and Webb Are Not Helping on Channel 4 review: not quite numberwang

James Corden and Ruth Jones ‘sign £8,000,000 deal’ for Gavin and Stacey follow-up

Gogglebox cast gasp as they watch ‘biggest curveball ever’ for new series

Coffee-fueled dance parties give Seattle's Latino community a place to connect

LA's booming gothicumbia scene mixes goth counterculture and traditional cumbia music

20 years after 'Twilight,' Forks' vampire economy is still booming

Mitchell and Webb Are Not Helping is ushering in a new era for sketch comedy

Stevie Nicks and Lindsay Buckingham fuel new reunion speculation with cryptic post

60s rock band guitarist Mark Volman dies aged 78 after ‘unexpected illness’

Darth Vader's lightsaber sells for £2.7m at auction

Anthropic to pay authors $1.5B to settle lawsuit over pirated chatbot training material

Mark Volman, Turtles co-founder who sang on ‘Happy Together,’ dies aged 78

‘I grew up watching Mitchell and Webb – now I’m the star of their new sketch show’

10 Novels We’re Looking Forward to This Fall

Jeff Tweedy on His New Triple Album, “Twilight Override”

Anna Wintour’s Interview About Appointing a New Editor of American Vogue

Hayley Williams clarifies Paramore’s future following new solo album

Major Hollywood studio sues AI generator Midjourney over copyright theft of iconic characters

Steven Spielberg ‘turned down by Call of Duty film’ after demands

Sabrina Carpenter album sees biggest opening week for non-UK artist in 2025

After years of avoiding the ER, Noah Wyle feels 'right at home' in 'The Pitt'

Watching a neighbor's cat turns lethal in 'Caught Stealing'

The Political Trickery of “Eddington”

‘Scariest horror film’ that won’t ever join streaming gets rare UK screenings

Netflix viewers can now watch ‘nerve-shredding’ Australian thriller based on unsettling true story

Hayley Williams shuts down Paramore break up rumours

Performers unveiled for Ozzy Osbourne tribute at the VMAs

How Taylor Swift became a lucky charm for the soccer team hosting the Chiefs-Chargers game in Brazil

One of David Bowie’s final unrealised musical projects to go on display

Linehan tells court trans activists made his life 'hell'

Actor John Alford guilty of sex assaults on girls

Prestigious painting prize picks youngest ever winner

Post Malone postpones London shows over Tube strikes

Anthony Roth Costanzo Wears Maria Callas’s Heels in ‘Galas’

“I Who Have Never Known Men” Is a Warning

‘Ridiculous and gory’ dinosaur film finally has streaming release date

Drama hailed ‘best movie of the last 20 years’ streaming for free on BBC

Why The Paper might be better than The Office

Charlie Sheen claims he was extorted by male sexual partners during the height of his drug abuse

Sheinelle Jones makes emotional Today show return after husband’s death: ‘I’m fighting for my joy’

The Truth About Jussie Smollett is madder than anyone expected

Suede: Antidepressants review — an electrifying, life-saving record

Autograph book with signatures from the Beatles and the Stones to be sold

New Sky series The Paper gave me an existential crisis – but I want more

Cancel your weekend plans to binge series that’s left viewers ‘wanting more’

Is AJ Lee coming back to WWE on SmackDown tonight? What we know

Former London's Burning actor John Alford guilty of sexually assaulting girls aged 14 and 15

Four Democratic senators urge Smithsonian to resist White House attempts to 'bully the institution'

Horror, rom-coms and 'Hamilton' are all in theaters this weekend

Sting Is Sued by His Former Bandmates in the Police

Worried about the new Wuthering Heights? Stream ‘the best adaptation’ for free instead

Actor Zachary Hart names the comedy series which felt like it came from ‘aliens’

Charlie Sheen issues public plea to Jon Cryer after documentary appearance

The US Open is hotter than Coachella. That’s what makes it awful.

Cardi B ‘denied’ herself a Super Bowl Halftime performance

Darth Vader’s lightsaber breaks Star Wars record during film prop auction