HS2 should be stopped in its tracks | Letters

Bruce White says more thought should have been given to the question ‘What is the business need?’, Alan Peabody says stop throwing good money after bad and Tanya Firth thinks there should be a public inquiryNils Pratley’s summary of governmental incompetence regarding HS2 is stark (HS2: a complete failure by the British state and its politicians, 18 June). However, it is the lack of application of a basic procurement principle that is the underlying cause of the HS2 debacle.On a major project like HS2, the first question a procurement professional should ask is: “What is the business need?” The time spent establishing a clear need, signed off by all stakeholders, is time well spent. My experience is that quality procurement expertise is not sought before the project specification is defined and this question is fudged. Why scupper a glamorous ill-defined (and therefore inevitably costly) project for a dull and precisely defined one? Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

A decade of helping people to keep their homes warm

The Herald

Yes, Anna Wintour could be brutal. But like me she'll surely feel a deep sense of loss to walk away from the cashmere nest that is the editor's chair at Vogue: ALEXANDRA SHULMAN

about 10 hours ago

Glastonbury proves that I was right to try to reform the BBC: NADINE DORRIES

Dailymail

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews 24 Hours In Police Custody: The Butcher Of Suburbia: Armchair sleuths will have cracked this case before the first ad break...

about 12 hours ago

Dailymail

Avocado suites, a bullet hole in the dining car - and never more than 15 seconds late!: ROBERT HARDMAN reveals the secrets of the Royal Train

about 12 hours ago

QUENTIN LETTS: Lisa flew into a prolonged riff tearing into Glastonbury and the BBC... Nandy was jammin'!

Dailymail

The real reason why Brad Pitt's embarrassingly bad, inauthentic donut of an F1 movie was doomed from the start, writes OLIVER HOLT

about 19 hours ago

The Herald

There is an alternative to massive defence spending: it means a new kind of security

about 21 hours ago

Dailymail

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: The BBC says it 'regrets' beaming a pig-ignorant tattooed moron preaching death to Jews into millions of living rooms. That's big of them

about 21 hours ago

Dailymail

How Ben Stokes can turn the tables on his nemesis Ravindra Jadeja - including the clever trick Ben Duckett pulls to dominate spinners: NASSER HUSSAIN

about 21 hours ago

Letters to the Editor: Fair pay for L.A. County employees isn't a burden on the public's resources

LA Times

DOMINIC LAWSON: Why Putin has been denied a propaganda 'triumph' by the Mail's gripping revelations about the brilliant new boss of MI6

1 day ago

Dailymail

ALEX BRUMMER: Labour has trapped us all in a doom loop of ever higher taxes and welfare spending. Things are bad now but, with four years to go, this is how much worse they can get

1 day ago

Democrats’ push to ban ICE agents’ masking shows whose side they’re really on

Newyork Post

Comments

Similar News

How bad is the HS2 fiasco now? So bad it's time to listen to Nigel Farage | Simon Jenkins

The Guardian view on HS2 delays: a chance to break the cycle of costly failure | Editorial

Labour had the chance to finally kill off HS2. Instead, it’s throwing more money into the pit | Simon Jenkins

Opinions

A decade of helping people to keep their homes warm

Is it time for a change of name for this Glastonbury performer?

Bob Vylan right to express rage against the IDF. And Bob Dylan would agree

Be grateful to Labour rebels: they have shown our democracy remains strong

We are being softened up to no longer believe in the sanctity of life

The Herald cartoon on the ferry latest

Scale of SNP Government climate change failings underlined by experts

I’ve listened to families across Scotland — this is what they really need

Yes, Anna Wintour could be brutal. But like me she'll surely feel a deep sense of loss to walk away from the cashmere nest that is the editor's chair at Vogue: ALEXANDRA SHULMAN

Glastonbury proves that I was right to try to reform the BBC: NADINE DORRIES

DAN HODGES: The most cack-handed, incompetent welfare Bill in living memory

I fled NYC for Florida — Sorry, Mamdani-fearing Democrats, we’re full!

‘Big beautiful’ AI rule means feds must act NOW to stop Big Tech’s abuses

SCOTUS’ slap at lower courts: Letters to the Editor — July 1, 2025

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews 24 Hours In Police Custody: The Butcher Of Suburbia: Armchair sleuths will have cracked this case before the first ad break...

Avocado suites, a bullet hole in the dining car - and never more than 15 seconds late!: ROBERT HARDMAN reveals the secrets of the Royal Train

QUENTIN LETTS: Lisa flew into a prolonged riff tearing into Glastonbury and the BBC... Nandy was jammin'!

JEFF PRESTRIDGE: Rachel's raid on the tax-free Isa will plunge financial dagger into the hearts of millions

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: Clarkson set to launch OnlyFarmers

Zohran Mamdani’s ‘no billionaires’ dream fits HIS goal — to make us all live in equal… misery

Zohran Mamdani’s anti-billionaires declaration is anti-New York City and so many of the things that make it great

Nixing visas is a wise US response to Bob Vylan’s naked Jew-hate

Between Mamdani and Fetterman, flailing Democrats seek a populist agenda that works

Letters to the Editor: Cudahy vice mayor's gang comments 'are not misunderstood. They are unacceptable'

What happened to the media's coverage of the Ukraine war?

Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton: A victory for children, a black eye to the pornography industry

The South Korea-U.S. alliance is now in peril

Senate moves closer to unscamming Medicaid

CDC committee should fix misplaced vaccine priorities

Trump's 'beautiful bill' gives steelworkers a big raise

AI regulation's state-by-state chaos shows the need for federal leadership

When deterrence works: How Israel and the U.S. just changed the game with Iran

With Mamdani's victory, New Yorkers are seeing red

The perils of sloppy advice: It's hard to forget Hargreaves Lansdown's role in the Woodford scandal, says ALEX BRUMMER

Mamdani’s privileged path, liberals’ Supreme Court hypocrisy and other commentary

Letter to the editor: Their characters aside, illegals cost too much

Letter to the editor: Powell needs to get out of the way

Letter to the editor: Weekly reporting enables left's most loathed policy: honesty

The real reason why Brad Pitt's embarrassingly bad, inauthentic donut of an F1 movie was doomed from the start, writes OLIVER HOLT

There is an alternative to massive defence spending: it means a new kind of security

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: The BBC says it 'regrets' beaming a pig-ignorant tattooed moron preaching death to Jews into millions of living rooms. That's big of them

How Ben Stokes can turn the tables on his nemesis Ravindra Jadeja - including the clever trick Ben Duckett pulls to dominate spinners: NASSER HUSSAIN

Letters to the Editor: Fair pay for L.A. County employees isn't a burden on the public's resources

Why Scotland needs a clearer metric for renewables and environmental protection

We must address the massive problem of over-management if we are to succeed

This pernicious legislation is fatally flawed

DR SCURR reveals how to control shaking hands as he reveals the worrying disease tremors can herald

Do not believe the middle-class moaning about private schools

'Stupidest' and 'unhinged' seem like measured descriptions amid destruction

A genuine opportunity to spark growth but risk of stalling

There's a parliament for the Central Belt. But what about the rest of us?

Miranda Devine: How the Biden admin ‘weaponized’ the justice system against Trump aide Peter Navarro

ANDREW PIERCE: Reeves loses her remaining Whitehall fan

DOMINIC LAWSON: Why Putin has been denied a propaganda 'triumph' by the Mail's gripping revelations about the brilliant new boss of MI6

ALEX BRUMMER: Labour has trapped us all in a doom loop of ever higher taxes and welfare spending. Things are bad now but, with four years to go, this is how much worse they can get

Democrats’ push to ban ICE agents’ masking shows whose side they’re really on

With code words and dog whistles, Zohran Mamdani puts a pretty face on hate

Globalism is dead, Zohran Mamdani too extreme and other commentary

Pelosi’s prime profits prove it’s time to ban Congress’ stock trading

ALEX BRUMMER: 'Genius Act' in US compared to Free Banking Era