If Britain recognises a Palestinian state, it will be a gesture. That doesn’t mean it is pointless | Simon McDonald

A two-state solution is the only solution. Starmer should be honest about this, and get on with the hard work it will requireSimon McDonald was the British ambassador to Israel from 2003 to 2006The idea that if you really, really believe something you can make it happen seems to be the best explanation for Britain and France’s recent statements that they will recognise a Palestinianstate. No matter how fervent Keir Starmer and Emmanuel Macron are, their fervour will not make an impossible thing happen. There is no Palestinian state, and there certainly won’t be one by September.For mostly domestic political reasons, they have decided to set aside that fact. Recognition is an understandable gesture, but it will do nothing to solve the current famine, and is doomed in the short term because there is no real state to recognise. But there’s also a clear reason why some sort of action – even if it’s purely symbolic – is needed. The situation in Gaza is appalling. If Starmer and Macron proceed with recognition, how can we manage the short-term disappointment of recognising a state that does not exist, while moving towards a two-state solution in the long term?Lord McDonald of Salford was the British ambassador to Israel from 2003 to 2006, and permanent secretary at the Foreign Office from 2015 to 2020. He is now a crossbench peerDo you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here. Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Letters to the Editor: California can't take all the blame for Las Vegas' tourism decline

LA Times

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: £4million mansion on a Caribbean island, favoured by Princess Margaret for hosting lavish parties, is set to be transformed

about 12 hours ago

Dailymail

PETER VAN ONSELEN: The truth about Victoria's WFH law - and why it's all but certain to fall apart

about 12 hours ago

Dailymail

We must have transparency over migrants and crime. The politicians who lose control of our borders cannot be allowed to hide the consequences from us

about 12 hours ago

Babbling Biden’s claims of Trump trashing the constitution are straight hypocrisy

Newyork Post

Get more sex in your marriage: Throw out the rulebook with these tried and tested methods that will help you go from 'I'm too tired' to getting it at least twice a week

1 day ago

LA Times

Letters to the Editor: Is duplex backlash in Pacific Palisades fire prevention or NIMBYism?

1 day ago

Dailymail

Cynical reason why Albo may lower Australia's voting age to 16 - and why it would be a colossal mistake. PETER VAN ONSELEN

1 day ago

Newyork Post

My awakening: How Gen Z’s relationship with religion is changing

1 day ago

Dailymail

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: Why Alison can no longer cast Sussexes' lookalikes...

1 day ago

Dailymail

I've been forced to move in with my daughter after my third property sale fell through. The housing market's collapsing... and my removal man's terrifying words show exactly why: NADINE DORRIES

1 day ago

Don’t whine about federal budget cuts, lefties — put your money where your mouths are

Newyork Post

There is more to Mohammed Siraj than England's nickname for him - he is a born entertainer with skill, heart and passion, writes NASSER HUSSAIN

2 days ago

Dailymail

How to stop paying for Mounjaro and Wegovy and get them free on the NHS, reveals DR ELLIE... and the two steps you should take if you've slimmed down too much to be eligible

2 days ago

How the ‘social justice’ movement distorted what Kyle Rittenhouse really did

Newyork Post

STEPHEN GLOVER: Starmer is signing his political death warrant with his futile 'smash the gangs' policy. Deterrence is the only solution

3 days ago

Zohran Mamdani’s views on Palestine are embarrassing

Newyork Post

I've worked in beauty for 16 years. These are the makeup tricks every woman should know - but hardly any do: POLISHED with Elise Wilson

3 days ago

To keep NYC as a leader in world medicine, the City Council must OK Lenox Hill Hospital’s expansion

Newyork Post

Comments

Opinions

Letters to the Editor: California can't take all the blame for Las Vegas' tourism decline

Contributor: They survived the bombing of Hiroshima, and then they saved the world

Contributor: The true cost of abandoning science

Michael Goodwin: Sen. Warren backing Mamdani is the latest example of Dems floundering — and their zany agenda

My drunken mistake ruined my best friend's wedding... she has no idea I'm to blame: DEAR JANE

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: £4million mansion on a Caribbean island, favoured by Princess Margaret for hosting lavish parties, is set to be transformed

PETER VAN ONSELEN: The truth about Victoria's WFH law - and why it's all but certain to fall apart

We must have transparency over migrants and crime. The politicians who lose control of our borders cannot be allowed to hide the consequences from us

Babbling Biden’s claims of Trump trashing the constitution are straight hypocrisy

NYC Council must ignore partisan politics and fight on against a Bronx casino rezoning OK’d by Mayor Adams

The dam is breaking on Britain’s illegal immigration crisis — and the results could be ugly

AI version of Parkland massacre victim isn’t the answer to any of our problems

Pitiful justice from the FCA: It took far too long to put Woodford in the stocks, says ALEX BRUMMER

Adams, Tisch and the NYPD have crime headed firmly down — but Mamdani would send it back up

Hysterical Hochul vowing to flout law to redraw voting map

Democrats howling at Texas redistrict push should take a look in the mirror

Jew hate is surging in public schools and teachers’ unions lead the way

Mayor Adams’ misguided answer to gun violence: Letters to the Editor — Aug. 6, 2025

DAVID 'BUMBLE' LLOYD: Why Rehan Ahmed is England's golden ticket to win the Ashes

Shame on those who don’t care about starving Israeli hostages

Letters to the Editor: Neither wildfires nor ICE can take Los Angeles' joy for good

Letters to the Editor: Edison's shareholders, not its customers, should be replenishing wildfire fund

Letters to the Editor: There are still too many questions facing hydrogen energy projects

Get more sex in your marriage: Throw out the rulebook with these tried and tested methods that will help you go from 'I'm too tired' to getting it at least twice a week

Letters to the Editor: Is duplex backlash in Pacific Palisades fire prevention or NIMBYism?

Cynical reason why Albo may lower Australia's voting age to 16 - and why it would be a colossal mistake. PETER VAN ONSELEN

My awakening: How Gen Z’s relationship with religion is changing

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: Why Alison can no longer cast Sussexes' lookalikes...

I've been forced to move in with my daughter after my third property sale fell through. The housing market's collapsing... and my removal man's terrifying words show exactly why: NADINE DORRIES

Don’t whine about federal budget cuts, lefties — put your money where your mouths are

California, here we come: A new Post is racing to the rescue

‘Club Fed’ is no place for a certified sicko like Ghislaine Maxwell — she deserves hard time

Blaming ‘the system,’ Kamala Harris falls for the oldest temptation

OF COURSE New York’s bungled weed legalization fueled a wave of addiction

Stephen Colbert is just the latest in a long line of CBS hosts to bite the dust

Palestinians’ unrealistic two-state solution: Letters to the Editor — Aug. 5, 2025

Lenders deserve a pasting over the motor finance misselling scandal, says ALEX BRUMMER

Who’s afraid of the big, bad New York Post? Zohran Mamdani

‘Luigism’ is a threat to all, Dems’ clown show and other commentary

Don’t trust the ‘influencers’ — Trump’s base isn’t breaking over Israel

There is more to Mohammed Siraj than England's nickname for him - he is a born entertainer with skill, heart and passion, writes NASSER HUSSAIN

How to stop paying for Mounjaro and Wegovy and get them free on the NHS, reveals DR ELLIE... and the two steps you should take if you've slimmed down too much to be eligible

How the ‘social justice’ movement distorted what Kyle Rittenhouse really did

Letters to the Editor: City council meetings exist to address the issues, not for profanity or racism

My Suits Me bank account was hacked and I lost £4,200: TONY HETHERINGTON investigates

If you cash in your pension early can you qualify for council tax benefits later? STEVE WEBB replies

Dear President Trump: ‘Don’t let my little brother die like this’

Miranda Devine: Russiagate lies are being exposed — and everybody is watching, even the Dems

STEPHEN GLOVER: Starmer is signing his political death warrant with his futile 'smash the gangs' policy. Deterrence is the only solution

Zohran Mamdani’s views on Palestine are embarrassing

Active shooter training instructor on what you can do to stay safe: ‘First step is situation awareness’

MPs who want to show the door to Keir's pal Powell: ANDREW PIERCE

Punters denied fitting finale as cricket shoots itself in the foot - NASSER HUSSAIN

KEVIN O'LEARY ranks the most expensive, rare and outlandish watches worn by your favorite athletes, actors and musicians

ALEX BRUMMER: Bank under populist siege

I've worked in beauty for 16 years. These are the makeup tricks every woman should know - but hardly any do: POLISHED with Elise Wilson

To keep NYC as a leader in world medicine, the City Council must OK Lenox Hill Hospital’s expansion

Beyond Trump’s trade deals, consolation for the little guy and other commentary

NYC shooting would never have happened if mental illness were handled properly

After blacks in Cincinnati beat white adults, why was there no nationwide, racial outrage?