iran letters israels israel trump attack letter government cartoon trumps

Russia adviser Fiona Hill’s alarming conclusion | Letter

Robert Skidelsky, Richard Balfe, Anthony Brenton, Thomas Fazi, Anatol Lieven, Ian Proud, Geoffrey Roberts, Richard Sakwa and Brigitte Granville respond to Fiona Hill’s assessment of the current Russian threat to the UKFiona Hill’s assessment of the Russian threat to Britain is a classic example of how a seemingly rational argument based on a false premise and scanty evidence can lead to a mad conclusion (Russia is at war with Britain and US is no longer a reliable ally, UK adviser says, 6 June). It is especially alarming that this conclusion was reached by one of the three principal authors of the recent strategic defence review.The false premise is that Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine is the first step to make Russia “a dominant military power in all of Europe”. Evidence that Britain is already under attack is provided by “the poisonings, assassinations, sabotage operations … cyber-attacks and influence operations ... sensors … around critical pipelines, efforts to butcher undersea cables”. It follows that Britain’s economy and society must be geared up to resist the Russian menace. Deny the premise and the argument for a “whole society” mobilisation against Russia collapses. What it reveals is the strength of the warmongering mood of official Britain. Continue reading...

Comments

Similar News

Is Russia’s slow, endless grind really a recipe for victory?

Russia says it’s winning. The data says otherwise.

Wishing won't work against Russia, Iran and China's global aggression

Yes, we should stand firm, but let's not make Russia our implacable foe

Is There a Pattern in Ukraine’s and Russia’s Big Attacks and Talks?

How Putin will respond to “Russia’s Pearl Harbour”

Drones: the newest twist in warfare — as Ukraine’s hit on Russia just showed

Ukraine’s surprise strike deep in Russia — an excellent way to push Putin to talk peace

Russia’s war in Ukraine must end, here’s how it could happen

Graham has a good bill on Russia. Why don’t these senators support it?

China and Russia gain African influence while America ignores Western Sahara sovereignty crisis

The Guardian view on Russia sanctions: a brittle economy is Putin’s weakness | Editorial

Trump has brought Ukraine-Russia peace talks back to square one – just where Putin wants them | Olga Chyzh

Trump is getting the Ukraine-Russia war all wrong — and he’s making it even harder on himself

To end the war in Ukraine, make Beijing’s bankrolling of Russia’s war machine hurt

Europe must not allow Russia to chip away at energy security gains

Who can stop Russia’s war against Ukraine? I’m answering your questions.

The USSR occupied eastern Europe, calling it ‘liberation’ – Russia is repeating the crime in Ukraine | Sergei Lebedev

The futility of the Russia-Ukraine peace talks

The Guardian view on Russia-Ukraine talks: a performance for the US president | Editorial

Opinions

BEL MOONEY: As a British Jew, I have never felt so terrified as I do now

BEL MOONEY: As a British Jew, I have never felt so terrified as I do now

about 2 hours ago

The Club World Cup is a grubby, contrived vanity project of Gianni Infantino that was neither needed nor asked for - it's a LIV Golf paradox and proves football has a saturation point, writes RIATH AL-SAMARRAI

The Club World Cup is a grubby, contrived vanity project of Gianni Infantino that was neither needed nor asked for - it's a LIV Golf paradox and proves football has a saturation point, writes RIATH AL-SAMARRAI

about 2 hours ago

The Herald cartoon on Edinburgh Festivals and the BBC

The Herald cartoon on Edinburgh Festivals and the BBC

about 4 hours ago

Father's Day: When we all pretend that dads are just as important as mums

Father's Day: When we all pretend that dads are just as important as mums

about 4 hours ago

No more Edinburgh Book Festival for me – where did it all go wrong?

No more Edinburgh Book Festival for me – where did it all go wrong?

about 4 hours ago

Do the Scottish Conservatives have any reason to exist?

Do the Scottish Conservatives have any reason to exist?

about 4 hours ago

I'm not sure Edinburgh Council's biggest problem is too many Christmas parties

I'm not sure Edinburgh Council's biggest problem is too many Christmas parties

about 4 hours ago

We're drifting into a deadly arms race. Why can't we curb this Cold War thinking?

We're drifting into a deadly arms race. Why can't we curb this Cold War thinking?

about 4 hours ago

Israel's blow against Iran

washington times

Israel's blow against Iran

about 9 hours ago

No quarter can be given in the war against Iran's deadly ambitions

washington times

No quarter can be given in the war against Iran's deadly ambitions

about 9 hours ago

After Trump restores fort names, it’s time to end the silly renaming wars

After Trump restores fort names, it’s time to end the silly renaming wars

about 11 hours ago

DAILY MAIL COMMENT: Israel's enemies are Britain's enemies

DAILY MAIL COMMENT: Israel's enemies are Britain's enemies

about 12 hours ago

ANDREW NEIL: Israel holds the cards. Trump has been squared. The mullahs in Tehran must now fear for their existence

ANDREW NEIL: Israel holds the cards. Trump has been squared. The mullahs in Tehran must now fear for their existence

about 12 hours ago

Has the curse of Meghan struck again? The smart set's latest whispers about her once closest confidante, revealed by RICHARD EDEN

Has the curse of Meghan struck again? The smart set's latest whispers about her once closest confidante, revealed by RICHARD EDEN

about 12 hours ago

ANDREW PIERCE: Is Angela Rayner's hard-Left boyfriend plotting to put her in No 10 as revenge for his sacking by Starmer's ruthless right-hand man?

ANDREW PIERCE: Is Angela Rayner's hard-Left boyfriend plotting to put her in No 10 as revenge for his sacking by Starmer's ruthless right-hand man?

about 12 hours ago

How Ballymena boiled over: After horrifying riots sparked by two Romanians being accused of raping teen, RICHARD KAY meets the victims - and locals furious at 'endless stream of migrants' they had no say over

How Ballymena boiled over: After horrifying riots sparked by two Romanians being accused of raping teen, RICHARD KAY meets the victims - and locals furious at 'endless stream of migrants' they had no say over

about 12 hours ago

US appeasement of Iran made Rising Lion inevitable — but Israel’s strikes may transform the Middle East

US appeasement of Iran made Rising Lion inevitable — but Israel’s strikes may transform the Middle East

about 13 hours ago

Beyond Father's Day: The public institution we can't afford to ignore

washington times

Beyond Father's Day: The public institution we can't afford to ignore

about 14 hours ago

How tariffs are shifting economic power between generations

washington times

How tariffs are shifting economic power between generations

about 14 hours ago

Help your children fulfill their potential, every day

washington times

Help your children fulfill their potential, every day

about 14 hours ago

Why Iran may back down after Israel’s devastating attack

Why Iran may back down after Israel’s devastating attack

about 15 hours ago

LA riots against immigration raids: Letters to the Editor — June 14, 2025

LA riots against immigration raids: Letters to the Editor — June 14, 2025

about 15 hours ago

The dads we should honor — like ‘Calvin Duper’ Munerlyn — but sadly . . . don’t

The dads we should honor — like ‘Calvin Duper’ Munerlyn — but sadly . . . don’t

about 15 hours ago

Anti-ICE rioters are just as out of line as anti-black racists in ‘62

Anti-ICE rioters are just as out of line as anti-black racists in ‘62

about 15 hours ago

ALEX BRUMMER: Iran attacks pile agony on economy

ALEX BRUMMER: Iran attacks pile agony on economy

about 15 hours ago

Has Emma Raducanu found a love match with dashing fellow-teenage prodigy she has known since she was six?

Has Emma Raducanu found a love match with dashing fellow-teenage prodigy she has known since she was six?

about 15 hours ago

Learn not to burn, Dems must take border issue seriously and other commentary

Learn not to burn, Dems must take border issue seriously and other commentary

about 16 hours ago

Israel has struck. Now Trump must lead.

washington times

Israel has struck. Now Trump must lead.

about 18 hours ago

Israel’s Iran slam tells ALL dictators: The free world will defend itself

Israel’s Iran slam tells ALL dictators: The free world will defend itself

about 18 hours ago

Letters to the Editor: The 'hypocrisy' in senator's threatened investigation into immigrant advocates

Letters to the Editor: The 'hypocrisy' in senator's threatened investigation into immigrant advocates

about 18 hours ago

BORIS JOHNSON: Starmer's leading the most abject and craven British government of the past 100 years. They are so weak they make Neville Chamberlain look positively robust

BORIS JOHNSON: Starmer's leading the most abject and craven British government of the past 100 years. They are so weak they make Neville Chamberlain look positively robust

about 18 hours ago

Letter to the editor: To left, freedom means absence of morality

washington times

Letter to the editor: To left, freedom means absence of morality

about 19 hours ago

Letter to the editor: Padilla's not above the law

washington times

Letter to the editor: Padilla's not above the law

about 19 hours ago

Letter to the editor: Jew haters, pure and simple

washington times

Letter to the editor: Jew haters, pure and simple

about 19 hours ago

Government has unfinished business on college reform

Government has unfinished business on college reform

about 19 hours ago

AMANDA PLATELL: It's not MY fault you're fat... so why should I pay for it?

AMANDA PLATELL: It's not MY fault you're fat... so why should I pay for it?

about 19 hours ago

Trump must stand firm with Israel to slam the door on Iran’s nukes — and achieve Middle East peace

Trump must stand firm with Israel to slam the door on Iran’s nukes — and achieve Middle East peace

about 21 hours ago

A power for good?

A power for good?

about 21 hours ago

BORIS JOHNSON: The bombers Ukraine destroyed with their brilliantly audacious Operation Spiderweb helped Putin blow up babies in their cots. So why hasn't Labour issued one word of celebration or congratulation?

BORIS JOHNSON: The bombers Ukraine destroyed with their brilliantly audacious Operation Spiderweb helped Putin blow up babies in their cots. So why hasn't Labour issued one word of celebration or congratulation?

about 21 hours ago

Letters to the Editor: Harsh charges against protesters are meant to 'foment fear and anxiety'

Letters to the Editor: Harsh charges against protesters are meant to 'foment fear and anxiety'

about 21 hours ago

Loyalist supremacy, hatred, racism and poverty: I know elements of Ulster riots well

Loyalist supremacy, hatred, racism and poverty: I know elements of Ulster riots well

about 22 hours ago

Letters to the Editor: No one brought in the Marines to quell sporting event chaos, so why protests?

Letters to the Editor: No one brought in the Marines to quell sporting event chaos, so why protests?

about 22 hours ago

In Japan, education puts the emphasis on teamwork. Could Scotland follow suit?

In Japan, education puts the emphasis on teamwork. Could Scotland follow suit?

about 23 hours ago

Restricting ticket resale empowers fraudsters

Restricting ticket resale empowers fraudsters

about 24 hours ago

Letters to the Editor: We cannot allow a U.S. senator to be handcuffed for asking questions

Letters to the Editor: We cannot allow a U.S. senator to be handcuffed for asking questions

about 24 hours ago

Unseen pictures of King Charles that show him as never before: ROBERT HARDMAN reveals what really happens to the artists that go on royal tours - including the odd brush with disaster

Unseen pictures of King Charles that show him as never before: ROBERT HARDMAN reveals what really happens to the artists that go on royal tours - including the odd brush with disaster

about 24 hours ago

Caring for the future: how can Scotland fund the care home capacity it needs?

Caring for the future: how can Scotland fund the care home capacity it needs?

Hypocrisy and double standards taint the West’s view of Israel

Hypocrisy and double standards taint the West’s view of Israel

L.A. was first. Now it's your move, America.

L.A. was first. Now it's your move, America.

Calm down, Mr Sarwar - don't get too enthusiastic over Hamilton result

Calm down, Mr Sarwar - don't get too enthusiastic over Hamilton result

A Grand Coalition between SNP and Labour may go from unthinkable to inevitable

A Grand Coalition between SNP and Labour may go from unthinkable to inevitable

Finding yourself in one of Glasgow’s less than salubrious watering holes

Finding yourself in one of Glasgow’s less than salubrious watering holes

What's our collection of Manchester United shirts worth? DAN HATFIELD replies

What's our collection of Manchester United shirts worth? DAN HATFIELD replies

Edinburgh Airport chief and the big Glasgow question

Edinburgh Airport chief and the big Glasgow question

Israel is serving the entire world — taking huge risks to stop Iran from going nuclear

Israel is serving the entire world — taking huge risks to stop Iran from going nuclear

Enforcing immigration law is not cruel or inhumane

washington times

Enforcing immigration law is not cruel or inhumane

Stop the lawsuit lottery: how foreign cash hijacks America's courts

washington times

Stop the lawsuit lottery: how foreign cash hijacks America's courts

The makers of this puff piece should have read the Mail... CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews The Savoy: Great Hotels Through Time

The makers of this puff piece should have read the Mail... CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews The Savoy: Great Hotels Through Time

Any pride women felt about Rachel Reeves being the first female Chancellor has been flushed down the U-bend of spend, spend, spend

Any pride women felt about Rachel Reeves being the first female Chancellor has been flushed down the U-bend of spend, spend, spend

How Mounjaro weight-loss jabs mean I'm wearing a bikini at 68, reveals NADINE DORRIES. I've covered up for 6 years but now I'm ready to show off my body - here's how I did it

How Mounjaro weight-loss jabs mean I'm wearing a bikini at 68, reveals NADINE DORRIES. I've covered up for 6 years but now I'm ready to show off my body - here's how I did it