The Guardian view on the BBC under siege: Britain must defend its own truth | Editorial

With Donald Trump circling and Labour ministers wavering, defending the corporation’s independence is now a test of national willThe chair of the BBC, Samir Shah, struck a defensive tone in his interview to explain the mess the broadcaster has found itself in. The impression was of an organisation under siege rather than one confidently self-correcting. Mr Shah will be busy. He must find a new director general after Tim Davie resigned. Gone too is the CEO of news, Deborah Turness. Both resigned after an exhausting rightwing campaign which cried bias at every turn and was energised by an absurd transatlantic attempt to paint the BBC as part of a global liberal conspiracy.A giant like the BBC will make mistakes. The failure is not owning them fast enough and moving on. The corporation remains one of Britain’s few genuinely national institutions – and ministers say it is a “light on the hill” for people here and abroad. The BBC is the most trusted source of news in the UK, and among the top five worldwide. Yet awareness of that value has faded as the broadcaster struggled to articulate a clear civic mission. This is a strategic blunder in the face of competition from US big tech, which wants to monetise outrage rather than the truth. Viewed from that perspective the current row over the editing of Donald Trump’s speech for Panorama is a sideshow. The real fight is over what impartiality means – and who gets to decide.Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here. Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

If your city’s too pricey, move — it’s the American way

Newyork Post

Liberal leadership bombshell: Sussan Ley's key allies are ready to ABANDON her and throw their support behind Andrew Hastie - PETER VAN ONSELEN on an explosive leak

about 23 hours ago

Comments

Opinions

If your city’s too pricey, move — it’s the American way

Centrist Democrats can beat the socialists at their own game — and win their party back

Albany Republicans’ $20B shame: state spending madness is their fault, too

The end of the longest gov’t shutdown: Letters to the Editor — Nov. 17, 2025

I was blackmailed and forced to do the unthinkable. DEAR JANE, how do I hide it from my wife?

My cough just won't stop... how long should I wait before seeing my GP? DR ELLIE has the answer

Liberal leadership bombshell: Sussan Ley's key allies are ready to ABANDON her and throw their support behind Andrew Hastie - PETER VAN ONSELEN on an explosive leak

Michael Goodwin: Gov. Hochul flip-flops her governing principles to accommodate Mayor-elect Mamdani’s agenda

SARAH VINE: Hidden real reason behind Adam Peaty and Holly Ramsay marriage meltdown everyone's missed. It's not about money, snobbery or status - but a much more subtle betrayal

SIR CLIVE WOODWARD: Why Steve Borthwick must ignore the clamour to start Henry Pollock, the England try that typified his clever coaching - and two criminal mistakes that hurt New Zealand

ALEXANDRA SHULMAN'S NOTEBOOK: Why I've had to go cold turkey with a Nokia phone

MAIL ON SUNDAY COMMENT: More proof the biased BBC needs radical change to survive

FLOURISHING AFTER 50: We're mortgage free - but should we risk our home to help our son buy his?

I'm desperate to help you defend your wealth from the Budget, says money guru JEFF PRESTRIDGE. I fear the Chancellor's about to destroy our pensions - this is what you must do

Zohran Mamdani setting up NYC for violence with resistance to immigration enforcement

DAN HODGES: Reeves' Budget U-turn excuses? They're less believable than if I claimed to have a date with Margot Robbie

PETER HITCHENS: Why is the BBC backing a bitter, biased film that paints British troops as little better than Nazis?

The BBC’s shameful edit and more: Letters to the Editor — Nov. 16, 2025

Organized sports must cut off EVERY tie to gambling — or their brands are toast

I didn't think I'd see a bigger loser after the rotten Reynolds vs Higgins saga. Now there's been a court bombshell - and it exposes our broken legal system: PVO

'My husband won't stop ranting about politics... what do I do?' He's boring, selfish and obsessed, says BEL MOONEY. He's ruining your life and I bet I know what's really to blame

I only realised what my phone was doing to me when my screen time crept up to seven hours a day - thanks to Instagram, WhatsApp and Candy Crush, says ALEXANDRA SHULMAN. There's one solution...

Time to trash our pandemic playbook — making people healthy again may be the best medicine

Gavin discovers men, Canada’s tortured talk on killing and other commentary

Gavin Newsom’s pathetic reasons for pulling SOME illegal truckers’ licenses

Democrats’ Epstein email release: Letters to the Editor — Nov. 15, 2025

Smirking Mamdani’s scorn for business will not help NYC prosper

Bill Maher has a revolting sex problem. He thinks he can hide it... but he's a sleazy pig and it's time someone exposed him: MAUREEN CALLAHAN

My Montecito mole tells me why Me-Me-Meghan 'threw a fit' after Kris Jenner's birthday party... this Kardashian drama just won't go away: KENNEDY

DAILY MAIL COMMENT: This Budget shambles proves Chancellor is out of her depth

'He knew they weren't his': The extraordinary vintage wine row tearing apart one of Britain's most prominent aristocratic families as the Earl of Bradford threatens to sue his son and glamorous daughter-in-law

AMANDA PLATELL: How can Adam Peaty be so cruel to a loving mum who made him a champion?

ANDREW NEIL: The Chancellor looks haunted, distraught, even helpless. This is why I now believe there's every chance of a financial crisis - perhaps even before Christmas

The real culprit in the Masculinity Crisis. I've seen first hand the difference between today's girls and boys. And no, women aren't to blame - there's a far less obvious culprit, writes SARAH VINE

Don’t be fooled by Kathy Hochul’s latest pause of another toxic law

ALEX BRUMMER: Chancellor is wreaking fiscal havoc

China’s kicking our butts in warship-building — here’s how we can catch up

How dare Dems claim moral superiority over those enforcing immigration law

Ford needs workers, but American schools aren’t giving them the education needed

JANA HOCKING on the bizarre new sexual trend doctors are warning against

BORIS JOHNSON: This is the one thing Reeves can do that'll cost British taxpayers nothing, save lives, and make the world better and happier

Letters to the Editor: L.A. has long had rent control. It's the newcomers who are pricing others out

Letters to the Editor: Electrical safety is a responsibility for all of us, not just Edison

'Reeves is looking terrible. I'm worried for her': Damning verdict of Labour insiders who tell full story of Budget chaos to DAN HODGES, the new money-squeezing wheeze - and the one thing everyone's saying

'Maybe they will both realise it's better to box than brawl' - British boxing heroes Carl Froch, George Groves and Tony Bellow deliver their verdict on Eubank-Benn II

How the GOP can push true health care ‘affordability’ — and win

College kids’ math skills worse than ever, California finds — blame our pass-the-buck public schools

We need a Marshall Plan to tackle America’s housing crisis

Trump is right to drop the ‘Housing First’ Rx for homelessness

JAN MOIR: The hangover from the Kardashian party may not be fatal, but Harry and Meghan have made utter fools of themselves. Again

BRIAN VINER reviews The Running Man: A deadly game of traitors and faithfuls (with a billion dollar prize)

A porch pirate nabbed every parcel in our street - then police swooped on our neighbour and you'll never guess what happened next: TOM UTLEY

QUENTIN LETTS: The minister was like my wife when she has a clear-out... then goes to buy new knick-knacks

Trump’s ‘hemp ban’ shut down backdoor legal weed — and the pot industry is howling

President Xi’s freedom-stomping thugs are targeting speech in NYC

Gov. Hochul’s $11B Micron economic-development gambit is looking like a bust

Here’s why America needs to win the AI war: Palantir CEO

Can Jack Schlossberg take internet trolling all the way to Congress?

UK sparks nuclear ambition: Miliband is right to embrace Rolls-Royce's new mini reactors, says ALEX BRUMMER

Pelosi’s exit from Congress: Letters to the Editor — Nov. 14, 2025