What’s the real beef over sustainable cattle farming? | Letters

Øistein Thorsen of FAI Farms, Aidan Harrison and Nelly Trevelyan of Yorkshire Organic Millers respond to an article by George MonbiotGeorge Monbiot refers to FAI Farms’ work on regenerative beef farming, selectively critiquing one metric from our comprehensive report on adaptive multi-paddock grazing, while ignoring 54 others (New reports tell us cattle and sheep farming can be sustainable – don’t believe them, it’s all bull, 7 May).He focuses solely on the methodology behind our net zero carbon-balance estimation. This was calculated to be beyond net zero (-49.7t of CO2 equivalent) for our farm, based on modelling using the Sandy “natural capital navigator”, a Defra-recognised, scientifically robust platform. Mr Monbiot dismisses it as “a right old mess”, but his comment wrongly assumes that laboratory soil tests collected and described in the report were used to draw this conclusion. Instead, they provided a baseline and additional helpful analysis of soil health. Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Herald Diary: Fancy some new worlds to conquer, Elon Musk? Go on, please...

The Herald

Michael Goodwin: Trump recklessly accepting a plane from Qatar is the type of unnecessary risk that could ruin his presidency

about 4 hours ago

DEAR JANE: My dirty secret is that I perform favors for my therapist. But his latest request has gone too far

Dailymail

ALEX BRUMMER: The nation is in the grip of an immigration row - but this is the real story you should be paying all your attention to

about 6 hours ago

Dailymail

QUENTIN LETTS: Multiculturalism has done far more to fan racial tensions than Enoch Powell ever did

about 6 hours ago

Dailymail

SARAH VINE: I have tried all the weight loss jabs from Ozempic to Wegovy to Mounjaro... and THIS is the one that's easily the best

about 6 hours ago

Newyork Post

Judge Judy reacts to her AI baby double: ‘Hilarious and frightening at the same time’

about 7 hours ago

Dailymail

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Change Your Mind, Change Your Life: The BBC's dire new therapy series is worse than rubbish - it's dangerous

about 7 hours ago

LOVERRO: Long day's journey into never-ending night

washington times

Some of Silicon Valley’s most prominent schools have ditched honors classes in the name of equity — but it’s a terrible idea

about 12 hours ago

Labour MUST understand that voters are not anti-immigration – they simply want our borders to be properly controlled

The Sun

Why those who cherish the soul and magic of the FA Cup will be cheering for Crystal Palace to beat mighty Man City at Wembley, writes IAN HERBERT

about 12 hours ago

Newyork Post

NY AG Tish James proves yet again she only cares about her own brand, not the little guy

about 13 hours ago

Dailymail

Middle-class wives reveal the shocking secrets that could shatter their 'perfect' marriages: 'The whole village knows apart from him': SEALED SECTION

about 15 hours ago

Calum Steele: Take heed, SNP: Farage is speaking to the electorate. Why don't you?

The Herald

AMANDA PLATELL: This is exactly how Nicola Peltz followed the Meghan Markle handbook to snare the idiot son of a famous family... and the very sad future Brooklyn and Harry have to look forward to

about 19 hours ago

Contributor: My family's archive shows why Palestinians are owed reparations

LA Times

NADINE DORRIES: This is why I believe the tragic, destructive feuds between Harry, Brooklyn and their families will only get WORSE

1 day ago

Comments

Opinions

Herald Diary: Fancy some new worlds to conquer, Elon Musk? Go on, please...

Carlos Alba: The companies that drive us mad: do we only have ourselves to blame?

Letters: I didn't think Starmer could stoop any lower. Turns out I was wrong

Alison Rowat: In Scotland we don't make political jokes, we elect them

Why George Osbourne still runs Britain

Michael Goodwin: Trump recklessly accepting a plane from Qatar is the type of unnecessary risk that could ruin his presidency

DEAR JANE: My dirty secret is that I perform favors for my therapist. But his latest request has gone too far

Breaking European socialism will solve America's drug pricing gap

Gerard Depardieu's sex assault convictions deliver a shameful reckoning for all France: JANE FRYER

ALEX BRUMMER: The nation is in the grip of an immigration row - but this is the real story you should be paying all your attention to

QUENTIN LETTS: Multiculturalism has done far more to fan racial tensions than Enoch Powell ever did

SARAH VINE: I have tried all the weight loss jabs from Ozempic to Wegovy to Mounjaro... and THIS is the one that's easily the best

Judge Judy reacts to her AI baby double: ‘Hilarious and frightening at the same time’

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Change Your Mind, Change Your Life: The BBC's dire new therapy series is worse than rubbish - it's dangerous

LOVERRO: Long day's journey into never-ending night

Trump's drug deal

During National Police Week, urge Congress to support bills that equip law enforcement properly

To dodge a recession, congressional Republicans should speed Trump's tax cuts

Why cutting the Energy Department's budget is a good thing

Trump halts the Indo-Pakistani conflict

I’m a Yale free-speech champion — arrested for words I never said

Virginia GOP’s gay-porn disaster a lesson to Republicans: primaries matter

Trump just laid out a grand vision for the troubled Middle East — pray he makes it a reality

Pope Leo XIV can minister to world desperate for spiritual healing

NY’s justice ‘reforms’ claim another innocent child’s life — and also failed her alleged teen shooter

How shady Democratic Party lawyer Marc Elias is thwarting voters’ will

How Byron Donalds found Jesus in a Cracker Barrel parking lot

Zuckerberg's free speech charade

The best move Trump can make for the economy

AOC’s district neglect: Letters to the Editor — May 14, 2025

NYC’s poised for delirious joy with the Knicks on the brink of historic triumph

Spring break for M&S: Warm weather provides some relief as cyber attack debacle drags on, ALEX BRUMMER

Letter to the editor: Illegals don't same due process rights

Letter to the editor: Can't we do better than this?

Letter to the editor: Maryland reparations bill won't help anyone

Letter to the editor: Thankful to Trump for Alexander's release

Some of Silicon Valley’s most prominent schools have ditched honors classes in the name of equity — but it’s a terrible idea

Labour MUST understand that voters are not anti-immigration – they simply want our borders to be properly controlled

‘Woke’ toy firm removing St George’s flag from kid’s jigsaw puzzle is nonsense – why is our national flag so offensive?

For too long, tolerant, hard-working Brits have been gaslit on immigration and branded ‘far right’ – enough is enough

Why those who cherish the soul and magic of the FA Cup will be cheering for Crystal Palace to beat mighty Man City at Wembley, writes IAN HERBERT

NY AG Tish James proves yet again she only cares about her own brand, not the little guy

Middle-class wives reveal the shocking secrets that could shatter their 'perfect' marriages: 'The whole village knows apart from him': SEALED SECTION

Calum Steele: Take heed, SNP: Farage is speaking to the electorate. Why don't you?

Letters to the Editor: The LAPD is already stretched thin. It can't afford to shrink even more

Democrats cheer for China to beat Trump in trade war

AMANDA PLATELL: This is exactly how Nicola Peltz followed the Meghan Markle handbook to snare the idiot son of a famous family... and the very sad future Brooklyn and Harry have to look forward to

Contributor: My family's archive shows why Palestinians are owed reparations

Contributor: My neighborhood, Skid Row, is not exactly what you think it is

Letters: We won't be fooled by the smoke and mirrors conjured up over the ferries

Why Scotland needs a second phase of growth deals – and fast

Letters: I'm so grateful for the SNP when I think of the harm Tories and Labour did

Kevin McKenna: Fake liberals wage war on Scotland's poorest and most vulnerable folk

Donald Macaskill: Behind the rhetoric, it is lives — not numbers — that should matter

Herald Diary: How hot is this sauce? Please be seated...

Herald Cartoon on Michael Matheson

Cut taxes on made-in-America products

U.S.-Saudi alliance now more important than ever

The cure for America's drug crisis is made in America

NADINE DORRIES: This is why I believe the tragic, destructive feuds between Harry, Brooklyn and their families will only get WORSE