Would a written constitution save Britain from the far right? | Letters

Readers respond to George Monbiot’s article calling for a constitution to guard against the rise of Reform UK and autocracyGeorge Monbiot is right that having a written constitution would be better than not having one if the far right takes power (We must act now: without a written constitution, Reform UK will have carte blanche to toxify our nation, 23 October). But, as he points out, it’s not a guarantee of sane government. At least 75% of what Donald Trump is doing is unconstitutional, but it’s permitted by a compliant Congress and a rubber-stamp supreme court that is suddenly discovering presidential powers in the constitution that its framers never intended. The true problem is that a large proportion of the US electorate is content to let this happen.Marina Hyde noted the same trend here – too many people are so dischuffed (some with good cause, some not) that they are willing to press the “F you” button and smash the system. In 1795, as the first US government was getting under way, the writer Samuel Miller commented that “political prosperity resides, not in the words and letters of the constitution; but in the temper, the habits, and the practices of the people”. With or without a constitution, there needs to be peaceful civic resistance to a future extremist regime until more people are persuaded that a humane and tolerant government is worth having.Peter Loschi Oldham, Greater Manchester Continue reading...

Comments

Opinions

Gifted & Talented programs are what true progress is all about

Newyork Post

William is now King! It's an extraordinary power grab that will leave Harry and Meghan quaking... but Diana predicted it all along: MAUREEN CALLAHAN

about 3 hours ago

Newyork Post

NYC mayoral election looms: Letters to the Editor — Oct. 29, 2025

about 4 hours ago

Dailymail

Rachel Reeves is ignoring all the experts and pressing ahead with her insane wages plan. This is why it's going to trigger a jobs bloodbath: ALEX BRUMMER

about 5 hours ago

QUENTIN LETTS: As one peer took a post-nosebag snooze, I wondered why do clever people join the Lords?

Dailymail

The truth about Barnaby Joyce's very public walk-out and how he has used the EXACT same strategy to get ahead his entire career: PETER VAN ONSELEN

about 20 hours ago

Dailymail

The tiny Melbourne pizza shop named in world's BEST - and superstar chef Josh Niland spills his 'death row' meal: THE DETOUR

about 20 hours ago

Dailymail

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Once Upon A Time In Space: Sexism, drugs, tragedy... a gripping look at astronauts and their families

about 22 hours ago

Kathy Hochul’s pander to Zohran Mamdani and his socialists is beyond pathetic

Newyork Post

Shut up everyone! Here's the unfunny truth about Kristen Bell's 'cry for help' that will settle this domestic violence scandal once and for all: KENNEDY

1 day ago

Newyork Post

Basel Accord’s expanded banking rules could tank Trump’s economy — unless he acts fast

1 day ago

Dailymail

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: No doubt I'll be called racist for this, but ethnic minorities ARE absurdly over-represented on our screens... and this is the reason why

1 day ago

Dailymail

'A common medication sent my sex life roaring back... it's definitely not a "rare" side effect': Surprising ways women revived their flagging libidos - including a Netflix show dubbed 'female Viagra'

1 day ago

Should NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch serve under a mayor Mamdani? Yes, if …

Newyork Post

The public will recoil at a mansion tax. Unlike the unpopular Labour Party, most voters don't want class warfare: STEPHEN GLOVER

2 days ago

Zohran Mamdani’s new low: pretending HE’S a victim of 9/11

Newyork Post

The expert-backed secrets I swear by for the best beauty sleep EVER - and why it's the most important part of your routine: POLISHED with Elise Wilson

2 days ago

How Winston Churchill’s work impacted six monarchs: ‘Advised a whole dynasty’

Newyork Post

I've uncovered my husband's filthy Viagra habit: But, warns DEAR JANE, one thing YOU are doing is making it so much worse

2 days ago

Georgia Harrison MBE: I’m a revenge porn survivor - having women-only tube carriages is essential'

Mirror

Comments

Similar News

Would Term Limits for Congress Help or Hurt?

Letters to the Editor: What would truly save MacArthur Park? Readers have differing thoughts

Yes, I’m in Saudi for the money. Why else would I go?

Would Kathy Hochul have the guts to boot Zohran Mamdani if his plans wreck NYC?

Virginia Governor Candidates: Who Would Be Best?

I thought Labour would fix everything. I was wrong

Beef, pork, chicken: the world loves cheap meat. If people knew what really goes in it, that love affair would be over | Devi Sridhar

Letters to the Editor: Closure of popular Echo Park charter school would be 'a tragedy'

Let’s take a closer look at the sentencing of Kavanaugh’s would-be killer

For all Blair's faults, he presided over growth Reeves would die for. So why won't she take his advice and lower the top rate of tax? STEPHEN GLOVER

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews ITV1's Romesh Ranganathan's Parents' Evening: Good game? Brucie would never have gone near this boring show

Mamdani’s plan to strip the NYPD’s boss of disciplinary power would threaten public safety

MAIL ON SUNDAY COMMENT: The prince wriggled and squirmed... but a free and fearless Press would not let him off the hook

How a Mayor Mamdani’s Israel hate would twist the entire city

New Jersey Governor Candidates: Who Would Be Best?

Here’s what you need to know about Starmer’s illiberal protest curbs: they would have killed the Labour party at birth | George Monbiot

Would your speech make a professional’s top 10?

KENNEDY: Obama's bitter post about Trump's Gaza peace deal proves what I've long suspected about Barry... and it would make Sigmund Freud blush

US might dragged Netanyahu to the table. The real prize for Trump would be keeping him there | Jonathan Freedland

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: This deal would never have flown without the force of nature that is Donald J. Trump - he created the weather that made it happen

Opinions

Gifted & Talented programs are what true progress is all about

American adventure for Barclays: It is good to see a British bank on Wall Street, says ALEX BRUMMER

Leftist madness infected my Connecticut town council — now I’m at risk

A Mayor Mamdani would OBVIOUSLY be far worse than Bill de Blasio

Bill Gates sees the light on global warming — but will lefty climate warriors follow suit?

A Mamdani win will be a victory for NYC’s victimhood culture — and the Gen-Z faux working class

William is now King! It's an extraordinary power grab that will leave Harry and Meghan quaking... but Diana predicted it all along: MAUREEN CALLAHAN

NYC mayoral election looms: Letters to the Editor — Oct. 29, 2025

Rachel Reeves is ignoring all the experts and pressing ahead with her insane wages plan. This is why it's going to trigger a jobs bloodbath: ALEX BRUMMER

QUENTIN LETTS: As one peer took a post-nosebag snooze, I wondered why do clever people join the Lords?

Letters to the Editor: Santa Monica homeless project is 'a tragedy waiting to happen'

Letters to the Editor: What would truly save MacArthur Park? Readers have differing thoughts

Is Britain a high-tax country?

Contributor: Social media sexualized children's dance. We need a return to form

The truth about Barnaby Joyce's very public walk-out and how he has used the EXACT same strategy to get ahead his entire career: PETER VAN ONSELEN

The tiny Melbourne pizza shop named in world's BEST - and superstar chef Josh Niland spills his 'death row' meal: THE DETOUR

CHRISTOPHER STEVENS reviews Once Upon A Time In Space: Sexism, drugs, tragedy... a gripping look at astronauts and their families

Kathy Hochul’s pander to Zohran Mamdani and his socialists is beyond pathetic

Mamdani’s main victims, trans demands warp reality and other commentary

EDEN CONFIDENTIAL: Nobody likes a successful woman, says Shirley Ballas

NADINE DORRIES: What really happened off-screen after my TV clash with Mariella Frostrup

QUENTIN LETTS: Deputy PM David Lammy laughed theatrically but he was seething, his voice now near castrato

Trump inspires a new wave of nationalism — from Japan to Argentina

President Trump’s extravagant ballroom: Letters to the Editor — Oct. 28, 2025

US aid to Israel more than pays for itself — don’t buy the lefties’ lies

Curtis Sliwa is all talk — he can’t be the next mayor of New York

Shutdown puzzle: When will Democrats get back in touch with reality?

Trump-haters’ White House ballroom tantrums get even more ridiculous

Get out and vote, New Yorkers — it’s the only way to prevent the Zohran Mamdani nightmare

New Jersey’s Jack Ciattarelli getting grass roots push from Citizens Alliance to clinch governor’s race

Don't cry for Argentina - the truth is we have a bloated public sector of our own to sort out, says ALEX BRUMMER

Shut up everyone! Here's the unfunny truth about Kristen Bell's 'cry for help' that will settle this domestic violence scandal once and for all: KENNEDY

Basel Accord’s expanded banking rules could tank Trump’s economy — unless he acts fast

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: No doubt I'll be called racist for this, but ethnic minorities ARE absurdly over-represented on our screens... and this is the reason why

'A common medication sent my sex life roaring back... it's definitely not a "rare" side effect': Surprising ways women revived their flagging libidos - including a Netflix show dubbed 'female Viagra'

Should NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch serve under a mayor Mamdani? Yes, if …

National Women’s Soccer League must adopt gender standards to keep growing

Even Bernie Sanders admits Mamdani won’t have all the answers if elected —and called on New Yorkers to assist him

ANDREW PIERCE: Did Charles back Keir over inquiry into Andrew?

Miranda Devine: Trump Derangement Syndrome has morphed into something far more lethal — Trump Projection Disorder

Zohran Mamdani’s incoherent education policies will destroy NYC’s fragile progress

Beware Democrats’ election skullduggery in a key NJ gov-race county

Zohran Mamdani is toying with NYC –– his campaign promises are make believe

The public will recoil at a mansion tax. Unlike the unpopular Labour Party, most voters don't want class warfare: STEPHEN GLOVER

Zohran Mamdani’s new low: pretending HE’S a victim of 9/11

Four city ballot proposals this year deserve to pass — one doesn’t

Ben Stiller’s new doc is a touching tribute to his parents — comedy legends Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara

City Hall dropped a ball and 150,000 school kids may get stranded

RUTH SUNDERLAND: A costly war is being waged on women

Bernie befuddled on Amazon, a smelly crypto pardon and other commentary

The expert-backed secrets I swear by for the best beauty sleep EVER - and why it's the most important part of your routine: POLISHED with Elise Wilson

How Winston Churchill’s work impacted six monarchs: ‘Advised a whole dynasty’

Canal Street ICE raids weren’t pretty — but something must be done to clean up a promising NYC block

Iraqi pols grapple with Israeli and Iranian relations as country prepares to vote

Foreign adversaries are weaponizing the intelligence revolution

Georgia Harrison MBE: I’m a revenge porn survivor - having women-only tube carriages is essential'

I've uncovered my husband's filthy Viagra habit: But, warns DEAR JANE, one thing YOU are doing is making it so much worse