Chaos at the FDA leaves staffers disturbed, ready to leave

The weekend's chaos at the Food and Drug Administration is prompting questions around how much more the agency can take before its functionality is seriously impaired.Why it matters: An agency is only as good as its workforce, and after months of high-profile departures and open hostility from top health officials, some argue the FDA's performance is already deteriorating.Text messages from current FDA staffers shared confidentially with Axios show people disturbed by the turmoil and increasingly motivated to leave the agency — a threat heightened by how many experienced career officials have already left."If they could get enough money elsewhere, if they could get remote jobs, if they could get as much vacation, they would just leave," a former FDA staffer told Axios, speaking of current staffers."I don't know that I've talked to anyone who's happy there."Driving the news: The agency's top drug regulator resigned over the weekend amid a lawsuit alleging he used his position to get revenge against a former business associate.The official, George Tidmarsh, denied the allegations and told The New York Times he believed he was being retaliated against for raising concerns with a new agency program to speed certain drug approvals.He told Endpoints News he'll fight his ouster.Between the lines: "Good people leave and the other problem is, because of all of this perceived chaos, it becomes even harder for the FDA to recruit new employees," said Peter Pitts, a former associate FDA commissioner and president of the Center for Medicine in the Public Interest. "And it's never been easy."The upheaval came on the heels of explosive reporting about the agency's biologics and vaccines regulatory arm, with Stat writing that the division has become "rife with mistrust and paranoia" under the leadership of Vinay Prasad.Prasad made headlines earlier this year when he left the agency under criticism from right-wing activist Laura Loomer, only to return a couple of weeks later. The big picture: The pharmaceutical and biotech industry depend on the agency being predictable and reliable to shepherd millions of dollars in investments."When pharmaceutical companies on their own or smaller companies with their venture capital partners see that you can't predict what the FDA is going to do from day to day, they simply take their investment dollars and place them elsewhere," Pitts said.The latest turmoil comes on top of the agency facing thousands of layoffs earlier this year as part of the Trump administration's downsizing of the federal government.Where it stands: Even before the latest drama, Raymond James analysts wrote in a note in mid-October that the FDA's 32 drug approvals so far this year are a "bit behind" the rate from 2023 and 2024."Eventually the staffing shortfalls will lead to significant challenges for companies pursuing FDA approvals," the analysis stated. "FDA will likely face a choice of dramatically slowing the approval process, or decreasing thoroughness of reviews, which could endanger the public."A recent RBC Capital Markets analysis found that third-quarter FDA approval rates dropped while rejections and review delays rose. The other side: "The FDA continues to carry out its mission to protect public health with the same rigor and independence the American people expect," said Health and Human Services spokesperson Emily Hilliard. "The agency's work to review and approve safe and effective medical products remains fully operational and guided by science, not politics."The bottom line: There's already concern about what effect the Trump administration will have on the nation's standing as the world leader in biopharmaceutical innovation.Its hostility toward pharmaceutical companies, hollowing out of the federal workforce and cancellation of federal research dollars have all rung alarm bells throughout the research and development pipeline.How much companies and investors will tolerate an underperforming and dysfunctional FDA — and for how long — before looking to other markets remains a key question.

Comments

World news

Food safety fail: The hidden risks in Alberta restaurants

National Post

Scores dead, thousands homeless and billions in damage: The bleak numbers that reveal Hurricane Melissa’s scale of destruction

about 5 hours ago

Former minister issues extraordinary apology for trusting Israel over killing of Palestine’s ‘angel of mercy’

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Documents reveal chaos and confusion behind government shutdown layoffs

Pet monkey in diaper sparks chaos in Texas Halloween shop

Chaos at Orlando International Airport as lack of air traffic controllers causing mass delays

‘They killed civilians in their beds’: chaos and brutality reign after fall of El Fasher

Humanity is on path toward 'climate chaos,' scientists warn

DHS is using old videos of chaos and protest to push the Trump-Noem takeover of cities like Chicago: report

Trump and Xi talks could end months of global economic chaos

‘Stable chaos’: — Ukraine’s fortress city of Pokrovsk holds out, barely

Factionalism, farce and chaos dogs Reform UK in the garden of England

The happiness hack especially for times of chaos and anxiousness

Morning Joe host fears Trump-Canada tirade will plunge World Series into chaos: ‘American national anthem will likely get booed’

Why Jess Phillips is in the firing line in the grooming inquiry chaos

Trump’s poor attention span is sending the US into chaos

Dozens of Labour MPs warn of chaos for firms over gender recognition advice

New York officials condemn Manhattan Ice raid: ‘This creates fear and chaos’

Prague to ban e-scooters after residents complain of chaos on pavements

Mystery drone at Majorca Airport sparks chaos as flights diverted

Political chaos in France could derail E.U. security initiatives

Hazrat Shahjalal Airport fire chaos as travellers stranded and flights suspended

American Airlines chaos as flight returns after 'fumes' fill cabin leaving 7 sick

World news

Food safety fail: The hidden risks in Alberta restaurants

Skates, other hockey gear stolen from B.C. team for players with developmental disabilities

After bonding over Jays, fans find ways to cope

On eve of UN climate talks in Brazil, a call for less talking and more doing

Dick Cheney, former U.S. vice-president to George W. Bush, dead at 84

BBC accused of doctoring Trump January 6 speech in bombshell whistleblower's report

He's 28. And doesn't expect we'll hit net zero this century

Here’s how to set up your bedroom for better sleep

8 best holiday inflatables for 2025

Man accused in emergency room stabbing in Halifax chooses trial by judge and jury

Ford government can’t say if it will fast-track conservation authority legislation

Former US Vice President Dick Cheney dead at 84

What is job hugging? The new term behind a morbid careers reality

Mona Ziade, who helped shape the AP's Middle East coverage in the 1980s and '90s, dies at age 65

End of The Line? Saudi Arabia pauses plan for wildly ambitious 100-mile long megacity in the desert

A California woman put her face on giant billboards searching for love. Then ‘next-level hate mail’ rolled in

Dick Cheney, George W. Bush’s vice president, dead at 84

The US hurricane season that wasn’t: Experts explain why we’ve had a lucky break

Dubai launches coffee that costs $1,000 a cup

Dick Cheney death latest: George W Bush’s influential vice president and architect of the ‘War on Terror’ dies aged 84

Dick Cheney: The most influential vice president in modern American history

Pope settles decades-long Catholic debate on role of Virgin Mary

Fresh lead in Meredith Kercher murder as Italian prosecutors ‘search for mystery woman’

Election Day 2025: What to watch out for in key test for Trump and Democrats

Chinese fashion giant Shein bans all sex dolls after French investigation into ‘child-like’ appearance

JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon breaks ranks with fellow execs and says he will ‘offer to help’ Mamdani

Majority of Ontarians say their province is heading in the wrong direction: poll

Jeep owners issued urgent ‘do not charge’ warning as 320,000 EVs recalled

Australian households to get three hours of free solar energy every day: ‘There is so much power’

Lauren Boebert blasted over ‘racist’ Halloween costume mocking migrants amid ICE crackdown

Scores dead, thousands homeless and billions in damage: The bleak numbers that reveal Hurricane Melissa’s scale of destruction

Former minister issues extraordinary apology for trusting Israel over killing of Palestine’s ‘angel of mercy’

China blames Netherlands for chip supply tensions amid Nexperia standoff

Putin has two options – a war of attrition or getting Trump to do his dirty work

£20bn taxpayers’ cash lost to Covid fraud and debt… that might never be recovered

Thermos or Stanley? What your water bottle says about you

Nuclear weapons are stopping us becoming the next Ukraine

We’re living under a daily threat – but it’s not from nuclear weapons

I’ve seen what radiation does to us – it’s impossible to see an upside to nuclear

Trump and Musk back long-time rival Cuomo for NYC Mayor with threat against ‘communist’ Mamdani: Live updates

The Budget is already hitting us where it hurts – our pockets

Centrist D66 party takes home win in Dutch election

Hegseth praises South Korea's plans to boost defense capabilities

Ukraine military using video game-style reward system earning points killing Russians with drones

House of Dynamite warning on flawed nuclear missile defence is accurate – top general

My honeymoon in San Francisco was miserable. Going back alone changed everything

I’m a Russian living in London – this is what people back home think of Putin

How an income tax hike could mean faster interest rate cuts and cheaper mortgages

I got £340 back after overpaying my student loan – all it took was a phone call

Haaland, Kane or Mbappe? Our football experts rank the world’s best strikers

Indonesia’s Belt and Road Railway to Nowhere

I moved to New Zealand – it’s wonderful for kids, but housing is so expensive

I ditched eight hours sleep a night – I’m less tired and hungry

Rescuers in Nepal search for climbers' bodies after deadly avalanche

Education Department sued over new student loan forgiveness rule

Watch: Netflix drops "Sesame Street" trailer for iconic show's first season on platform

Three key races, California's map and the Trump factor - what to watch in US elections