Critics warn of loyalty test in new White House hiring guidelines

New White House hiring guidelines sent out to federal agencies last week include what looks like a presidential loyalty test, say current and former federal employees and Trump administration critics.Why it matters: Meant to serve as guidelines to focus hiring on merit, the memo is the latest move from the Trump administration to politicize the civil service, eroding, more than a century of law and tradition meant to insulate career employees from politics, critics say.Where it stands: Candidates for civil service jobs — including janitors, nurses, surgeons, engineers, lawyers and economists — are to be asked four questions on their level of patriotism and support for the president's policies.They are to answer in essay form, at a maximum of 200 words, and certify that they did not use help from artificial intelligence.How it works: "How would you help advance the President's Executive Orders and policy priorities in this role?" reads the third question, which is garnering a lot of attention.It continues: "Identify one or two relevant Executive Orders or policy initiatives that are significant to you, and explain how you would help implement them if hired."Zoom out: These questions have nothing to do with a candidate's merit or skills, says Jeri Buchholz, a former chief human capital officer who led HR at NASA and ran HR at other federal agencies for decades."When you're doing hiring, traditionally by law, you have to focus on the knowledge, skills and abilities required for the position," she says.The questions "are philosophical. They're not even aptitude related. And I'm very unclear how you score that."Dealing with these questions could slow the hiring process, running counter to the stated intent of the guidelines to speed it up, Buchholz says.Taken together these plans "will make it more difficult to hire, not less," a current federal HR official told Government Executive."A merit-based civil service that took generations to build is being dismantled via memo," writes Stanford University political scientist Adam Bonica in a Substack post on Sunday.The other side: An official from the Office of Personnel Management defended the questions as legal and within the bounds of presidential authority."The President has the power of superintendence over the Executive Branch and clear statutory authority to ask these questions of prospective employees. He is not imposing a loyalty test by doing so," they say.The law requires those who work for agencies to act consistently with the president's lawful executive orders and policy priorities, they say, making it reasonable to ask for examples that candidates are excited about.Agencies will decide whether and how to use the questions.The big picture: The White House has already fired or pushed out more than 100,000 federal workers, chasing away a lot of talent from the government.Now it looks like they'll be replacing those folks with partisans, says Max Stier, president of the nonprofit Partnership for Public Service. "They're emptying the shelves of the existing nonpartisan expert civil servants, and they're restocking with the loyalists," he says.The bottom line: Trump bristled at the pushback he received from "deep-state" federal employees in his first term, and a focus this term is ensuring that does not happen again.Read the full 30 page memo from the Office of Personnel Management.

Comments

World news

Evacuations as Guatemala’s Volcano of Fire erupts again

Independent

Trump promises ‘thundering tanks and breathtaking flyovers’ at military parade on Flag Day: ‘Like nothing you’ve ever seen’

about 2 hours ago

Putin’s desperate struggle to replace nuclear-capable bombers lost in Ukraine drone strikes

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Ivanka Trump promotes book by author who criticized her dad by saying ‘if Trump wins, we lose’

Push to reopen old mines in NSW in global race for critical minerals

Rachel Reeves just sent a pointed message to her critics

Why the White House is singling out the BBC for criticism

Iran's supreme leader criticizes US proposal in nuclear talks, but does not reject idea of a deal

Reprieve for critically ill Mexican girl, 4, who could have died within days if deported under Trump order

Environmentalists criticize Trump administration push for new oil and gas drilling in Alaska

Marjorie Taylor Greene criticized for not reading Trump’s ‘big beautiful’ bill

Rome’s taxi drivers rev up criticism of Wolff after being likened to Verstappen

Jeremy Bowen: Killings near Gaza aid centre will deepen criticism of Israel's new distribution system

‘Barbaric’: wildlife advocates criticize Florida bear hunt proposal

U.S. consulting firm quits Gaza humanitarian aid effort amid criticism

Mexico's president defends first judicial election despite low turnout and democratic criticism

Republican senator criticized for mock apology after saying ‘we all are going to die’

Reporter says she was fired from Trump-friendly outlet after criticizing Hegseth

US homeland security removes list of ‘sanctuary’ cities after sheriffs’ criticism

Ukraine's audacious drone attack sends critical message to Russia - and the West

Musk criticizes Trump’s ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ and admits tariffs have harmed his businesses

Brit woman killed and husband critical as SUV ploughs into Greek bakery

Mexico judicial elections: Government calls it essential reform. Critics say it's a farce

World news

Evacuations as Guatemala’s Volcano of Fire erupts again

Trump and Musk’s spectacular split minute-by-minute: How president and First Buddy’s friendship unraveled online

Musk shares footage of Trump partying with Jeffrey Epstein as feud intensifies

Red Cross confirms office closures in Niger and the departure of its foreign staff

Why Trump and Musk’s spectacular feud could be a disaster for space travel

Australian woman accused of mushroom poisoning admits possible online search for deadly fungi

Human remains found in search for missing teen Pheobe Bishop hours after housemates charged with murder

Pope meets with child protection advisory board as survivors call for zero tolerance of abuse

Hajj attendance falls to 30-year-low excluding the COVID-19 pandemic period

Modi inaugurates ambitious rail project connecting Kashmir to Indian plains

Jury finds 2 men guilty of supplying the bomb used to kill Maltese journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia

Red Cross confirms office closures in Niger and the departure of its foreign staff

Hilarious moment Brits sprint for best sunbeds the second pool opens at Spanish hotel

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Kremlin bristles at Trump after he compares war to ‘kids fighting in a park’

Diddy trial live: Combs’s ex-girlfriend ‘Jane’ to return to stand after judge threatens to remove rapper

Australian engineer freed on bail after four years in Iraqi prison

Three New Zealand MPs suspended for performing haka in parliament

Trump promises ‘thundering tanks and breathtaking flyovers’ at military parade on Flag Day: ‘Like nothing you’ve ever seen’

Putin’s desperate struggle to replace nuclear-capable bombers lost in Ukraine drone strikes

Iranians react to new Trump travel ban as tensions are high between nations

Terrifying moment bouncy castle takes off in freak wind flying 40ft into air sending children plunging back to earth

12 injured at DHL depot & hazmat cops deployed after ‘suspicious package’ found following spate of Putin parcel attacks

Watch determined tourists wear sprint shoes & even STRETCH before dawn dash for Magaluf pool spot…having queued for 1hr

Pregnant teacher, 36, who had ‘sex with pupil, 15, after she groomed him’ breaks down in tears in court

Sunbed Wars 2025 arrives in Benidorm after holidaymakers ‘stampede’ for best loungers

Spanish police cause uproar over photo of older women enjoying alfresco chat

The Ukrainians’ New Way of War

What today’s new college graduates are up against

Ketamine is suddenly everywhere

Minister 'not going to speculate' on alleged UK involvement in Ukrainian drone attack

Bournemouth refusing to budge on £45m fee for Liverpool target Kerkez

Israel is winning the war in Gaza – a two-state solution is becoming impossible

Ignore the dictators! It’s time for Club World Cup to unite the world

US economy meltdown in Living Nostradamus’ chilling predictions for next 3 years

JD Vance breaks silence on Musk-Trump row leaving one of them in stitches

Madeleine McCann update as bombshell new 'police tip-off' claim revealed

Husband killed, castrated and then cooked and eaten by his own wife

Soldier killed pregnant wife with a machete, then dumped her in the trash

‘Send her home’: Son of Irish woman, 70, in Israeli detention pleads for her release

Tesla shares rebound on news of Musk and Trump talks after explosive feud cost firm $99bn in a day

‘World War Douche’: Late night shows ruthlessly torch breakup of Trump-Musk bromance

Steve Bannon calls for Trump to seize SpaceX now and deport Musk as feud spirals

Trump tells Putin: ‘It might be better to let Russia and Ukraine fight for a while’

Interpol says 20 arrested in child sexual abuse operation across 12 countries

Hong Kong activist Joshua Wong charged under Beijing-imposed security law

Body found in search for missing Pheobe Bishop as police bodycam video shows her flatmate being arrested for her murder

In pictures: How the D-Day landings unfolded on June 6, 1944

How Britain might use tactical nuclear weapons – and why

Reform ‘wildfires’ can be put out by Labour – for now

Do 80% of women only desire 20% of men? I found the truth behind the incel myth

Ukraine’s spectacular drone strikes rattled Trump and Putin – what happens now

Madeleine McCann UPDATES: Bombshell new theory over disappearance of toddler

Pheobe Bishop UPDATES: Human remains found in search for missing teenage girl

Blink and your AI security playbook is out of date

Store brands become retail's secret weapon against Trump tariffs

POLL: Who are you backing in the Donald Trump and Elon Musk spat?

Please tell us, Mr Swinney: how exactly would you defend Scotland?