Critics warn of loyalty test in new White House hiring guidelines

New White House hiring guidelines sent out to federal agencies last week include what looks like a presidential loyalty test, say current and former federal employees and Trump administration critics.Why it matters: Meant to serve as guidelines to focus hiring on merit, the memo is the latest move from the Trump administration to politicize the civil service, eroding, more than a century of law and tradition meant to insulate career employees from politics, critics say.Where it stands: Candidates for civil service jobs — including janitors, nurses, surgeons, engineers, lawyers and economists — are to be asked four questions on their level of patriotism and support for the president's policies.They are to answer in essay form, at a maximum of 200 words, and certify that they did not use help from artificial intelligence.How it works: "How would you help advance the President's Executive Orders and policy priorities in this role?" reads the third question, which is garnering a lot of attention.It continues: "Identify one or two relevant Executive Orders or policy initiatives that are significant to you, and explain how you would help implement them if hired."Zoom out: These questions have nothing to do with a candidate's merit or skills, says Jeri Buchholz, a former chief human capital officer who led HR at NASA and ran HR at other federal agencies for decades."When you're doing hiring, traditionally by law, you have to focus on the knowledge, skills and abilities required for the position," she says.The questions "are philosophical. They're not even aptitude related. And I'm very unclear how you score that."Dealing with these questions could slow the hiring process, running counter to the stated intent of the guidelines to speed it up, Buchholz says.Taken together these plans "will make it more difficult to hire, not less," a current federal HR official told Government Executive."A merit-based civil service that took generations to build is being dismantled via memo," writes Stanford University political scientist Adam Bonica in a Substack post on Sunday.The other side: An official from the Office of Personnel Management defended the questions as legal and within the bounds of presidential authority."The President has the power of superintendence over the Executive Branch and clear statutory authority to ask these questions of prospective employees. He is not imposing a loyalty test by doing so," they say.The law requires those who work for agencies to act consistently with the president's lawful executive orders and policy priorities, they say, making it reasonable to ask for examples that candidates are excited about.Agencies will decide whether and how to use the questions.The big picture: The White House has already fired or pushed out more than 100,000 federal workers, chasing away a lot of talent from the government.Now it looks like they'll be replacing those folks with partisans, says Max Stier, president of the nonprofit Partnership for Public Service. "They're emptying the shelves of the existing nonpartisan expert civil servants, and they're restocking with the loyalists," he says.The bottom line: Trump bristled at the pushback he received from "deep-state" federal employees in his first term, and a focus this term is ensuring that does not happen again.Read the full 30 page memo from the Office of Personnel Management.

Comments

World news

D-Day veterans return to Normandy to mark 81st anniversary of landings

washington times

Comments

Similar News

Trump administration scrambling to rehire workers cut by DOGE to fill critical government roles

Australia’s critically endangered alpine tree frogs sidestep deadly fungus with sexual plan B

Trump is ‘losing patience’ with Musk’s criticism as president reposts mogul’s leaving the White House message

Cancer patients facing critical treatment delays due to UK’s workforce crisis

Ivanka Trump promotes book by author who criticized her dad by saying ‘if Trump wins, we lose’

Push to reopen old mines in NSW in global race for critical minerals

Rachel Reeves just sent a pointed message to her critics

Why the White House is singling out the BBC for criticism

Iran's supreme leader criticizes US proposal in nuclear talks, but does not reject idea of a deal

Reprieve for critically ill Mexican girl, 4, who could have died within days if deported under Trump order

Environmentalists criticize Trump administration push for new oil and gas drilling in Alaska

Marjorie Taylor Greene criticized for not reading Trump’s ‘big beautiful’ bill

Rome’s taxi drivers rev up criticism of Wolff after being likened to Verstappen

Jeremy Bowen: Killings near Gaza aid centre will deepen criticism of Israel's new distribution system

‘Barbaric’: wildlife advocates criticize Florida bear hunt proposal

U.S. consulting firm quits Gaza humanitarian aid effort amid criticism

Mexico's president defends first judicial election despite low turnout and democratic criticism

Republican senator criticized for mock apology after saying ‘we all are going to die’

Reporter says she was fired from Trump-friendly outlet after criticizing Hegseth

US homeland security removes list of ‘sanctuary’ cities after sheriffs’ criticism

World news

D-Day veterans return to Normandy to mark 81st anniversary of landings

As U.N. climate talks loom, Brazil's Amazon forest loses in May an area larger than NYC

Gaza marks the start of Eid with outdoor prayers in the rubble and food growing ever scarcer

Transgender troops face a deadline and a difficult decision: Stay or go?

Interpol issues red notice for Ghana's ex-finance minister over corruption claims

Arise Sir David! Beckham to be awarded a knighthood by King Charles, according to media reports

A British TV art expert who sold works to a suspected Hezbollah financier is sentenced to prison

Spanish Muslims retrace ancient Hajj travel route on horseback from Andalusia to Saudi Arabia

Mass deportations from Trump’s Big, Beautiful Bill could quietly cost U.S. over $1.4 trillion

Calgary woman loses $800k in romance scam: ‘I have nothing left’

Lost for over a century, Heiltsuk Nation celebrates return of bentwood box

Saskatoon Berries star slugger Beck returns to WCBL after standout collegiate season

Artists craft unique Edmonton Oilers pieces during Stanley Cup final

Mackenzie the stowaway porcupine flown home for release in northern B.C.

Madeleine McCann suspect ‘told police decisive questions can never be answered’

Diddy's ex-girlfriend testifies about pressure to participate in 'hotel nights'

Valley Line LRT West construction, road closures enter Phase 2

Sailor missing from Naval Station Norfolk in Virginia

Migrants and ICE officers contend with heat, smog and illness after detoured South Sudan flight

Escaped murderer known as ‘Devil in the Ozarks’ captured after massive manhunt

Diddy still paying ex-girlfriend’s $10,000 rent as part of ‘love contract,’ Jane Doe testifies

Family & friends of 3 Brits facing death penalty in £300k Bali coke smuggling plot reveal horror as trio’s fate awaits

The Gold season 2 cast, filming locations and episode guide

State Department considers giving $500 million to the new Gaza Humanitarian Foundation

Saskatchewan Rattlers aim to break franchise attendance record against Bandits

BC NDP take more heat from opposition over contracts for consultants, advisers

Appeals court allows White House AP ban to continue

DOGE given access to Americans' Social Security data by Supreme Court

Giant human spiderweb at Calgary school hopes to strengthen community

Calgary woman loses $800k in romance scam: ‘I have nothing left’

Will Musk's explosive row with Trump help or harm his businesses?

On board the driverless lorries hoping to transform China's transport industry

Boy fell to death after slip at Cliffs of Moher - inquest

US brings man mistakenly deported to El Salvador back to face charges

Proud Boys sue US government for $100m over Jan 6 prosecutions

What is covered under wildfire home insurance?

Const. Daniel Woodall School honours 10th anniversary of EPS officer’s death

Norwegian doctor raped dozens of women and girls during medical examinations

Police struggling to find survival expert accused of killing 3 daughters

Crisis in Croatia as Italian and German tourists abandon country

Escaped killer known as ‘Devil in the Ozarks’ has likely fled Arkansas, say US Marshals

Kash Patel has live ‘WTF’ moment on Joe Rogan as he learns of Trump vs. Musk mid-interview

Five Proud Boys leaders sue DOJ for $100 million over their Jan 6 prosecution

Elon Musk’s crash-out killed conservatives’ momentum — and likely guaranteed passage of Trump’s ‘big beautiful bill’

Transportation chief seeks to weaken fuel economy standards, calls Biden-era rule 'illegal'

Possible mass shooting targeting graduation ceremony thwarted, police say

Man accused of killing ‘King of the Hill’ voice actor Jonathan Joss ‘maintains his innocence’ lawyer says

Madeleine McCann prime suspect gloats he will never be charged without a body in chilling letter

Wildfires force another 1,000 residents from their homes in the Canadian province of Manitoba

Why is the air quality so bad? What to know about the health dangers of wildfire smoke

Relatives of Angel Delight ‘drug smugglers’ in ‘shock’ as they face firing squad

The Economics of Trump’s Budget and Policy Bill

Russia Launches Massive Aerial Bombardment of Ukraine

The big reason why Republicans should worry about an angry Elon Musk

Elon Musk and Donald Trump’s fallout, explained

Man wrongly deported to El Salvador has been returned to US to face criminal charges

Scoop: Treasury officials defend "revenge tax" from wary GOP senators