Florida shouldn't have been ordered to dismantle Alligator Alcatraz, appeals court finds

A federal judge was wrong to order Florida to dismantle its Alligator Alcatraz immigration facility, an appellate panel ruled Thursday.Why it matters: The ruling pauses last month's order, which prohibited state and federal officials from bringing new detainees to the site and demanded it be dismantled within 60 days.It's a victory for Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis and President Trump, who championed the site, and a defeat for migrant and environmental advocates.Catch up quick: After the state opened the facility, environmental groups and the Miccosukee Tribe sued, arguing its construction violated the National Environmental Policy Act.Last month, U.S. District Judge Kathleen Williams ruled in their favor, finding the state failed to evaluate the impact of turning an airstrip in the Everglades into a detention facility.Shortly after the ruling was issued, Florida appealed to the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals.Friction point: The Trump and DeSantis administrations have argued the facility has had zero impact on the environment because it was built on an existing but long-defunct airstrip.Environmental groups have cited newly constructed portions of the site, relying on expert testimony that repurposing the airstrip had already resulted in major risks to its sensitive surroundingsDriving the news: In its ruling, the appeals court dismissed Williams' findings, arguing she was wrong to determine that the environmentalists were likely to succeed in their lawsuit.Even had she been right, the appellate panel suggested, she went too far in ordering the facility to be dismantled rather than "at most" directing a halt to any further construction.What they're saying: "We said we'd fight [Williams' ruling]; we'd said the mission would continue," DeSantis said in a video statement after the ruling."Like we've always said, Alligator Alcatraz is open for business [and] we're going to continue leading the way" on immigration enforcement.The other side: The Center for Biological Diversity and Friends of the Everglades, two environmental groups that spearheaded the lawsuit, decried the ruling."This is a heartbreaking blow to America's Everglades and every living creature there, but the fight isn't even close to over," said Elise Bennett, Florida and Caribbean director and a senior attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity. "While disappointing, we never expected ultimate success to be easy. We're hopeful that the appeal of the preliminary injunction will be affirmed when it's reviewed on its merits during the appeal," said Eve Samples, executive director of Friends of the Everglades.Between the lines: The crux of the environmental groups' argument was that the facility violated the National Environmental Policy Act because officials failed to conduct environmental studies required by that law.Williams agreed, finding that officials "consulted with no stakeholders or experts and did no evaluation of the environmental risks.""Here, there weren't 'deficiencies' in the agency's process," she wrote. "There was no process."Yes, but: The 11th Circuit noted that a recent Supreme Court ruling limited that law's scope, describing it as "a procedural cross-check" and not "a substantive roadblock" to government action.They also disagreed with Williams that the facility's construction constituted "major federal action," which is what triggers the environmental review requirement.What's next: Thursday's ruling only paused Williams' earlier decision while the appeal filed by the government continues.

Comments

World news

Court stops Trump’s attempt to fire Fed Board Governor Lisa Cook

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Florida man arrested at job interview after allegedly impersonating a nurse to apply for work at at least 10 clinics

Trial of man accused of attempting to assassinate Trump while he played golf in Florida begins

Florida plan to drop school vaccine mandates won’t take effect for 90 days

Florida surgeon general says he didn’t study whether ending vaccine mandate would increase diseases

Florida surgeon general Ladapo's vaccine mandates opposition goes against medical mainstream

Despite ethical concerns Trump says next year’s G20 Summit will be held at his Florida resort

Florida grandma reprimanded for yelling ‘oh my god’ as she was found guilty of masterminding family murder-for-hire plot

Dramatic moment Florida senior citizen tackles jewelry thief fleeing cops through supermarket

West Coast states join together to lead vaccine defense as red Florida ends mandate and DC skepticism grows

Florida to end all vaccine mandates, state officials say

Florida to eliminate all childhood vaccine mandates in the state

Florida to end vaccine mandates for children as state’s surgeon general likens them to ‘slavery’

DeSantis to make Florida first state to end all vaccine mandates for schools

‘Extremely bizarre’: Florida man ran over his date after she refused to allow him to smell her feet, police say

Eight-year-old loses ‘significant amount of blood’ after shark attack in Florida

Shark bite leaves eight year-old boy severely injured in attack off Florida coast

Florida State linebacker in ‘critical but stable’ condition after being shot

Florida State linebacker Ethan Pritchard in intensive care after being shot

Two Florida pastors arrested after praying on top of ‘Black History Matters’ mural to stop crews from removing it

Florida man driving a special truck designed to safely absorb the impact of crashes killed after car plows into the vehicle

World news

Court stops Trump’s attempt to fire Fed Board Governor Lisa Cook

Wellington Bridge closure worries small business owners in west-central Edmonton

Recreate our favourite beauty looks from TIFF 2025

Lethbridge first responders celebrate 1 year of youth initiative

Bridgeland business speaks out about street being ripped up 3 times in a year

Alberta takes teachers’ union to labour board over accusations of false claims

Schwarzenegger decries polarization, criticizes Newsom's gerrymandering effort

Face-to-face with Zelenskyy, his frustration is clear

Zelenskyy makes demand of Trump - and issues warning to NATO

Republicans dare Democrats on avoiding government shutdown

Trump nominee Miran confirmed to Fed ahead of rate decision

Scoop: A group of House Democrats has a steep demand list to stop a shutdown

Republicans scramble to kick Ilhan Omar off committees over her Charlie Kirk comments

SEC "prioritizing" Trump bid to change public company reporting rules

Thousands flagged to face "consequences" for cheering Charlie Kirk's death

Appeals court rules Fed governor Cook can continue to serve

Queer advocacy group asks mayor, council to declare Calgary a sanctuary city

California man steals ambulance from paramedics attending fatal stabbing near high school, say cops

As Charlie Kirk crisscrossed the country, security levels varied from venue to venue

Elon Musk piggybacks Tommy Robinson and brings his troll show to Britain after being banished from the White House

SC lawmaker wants to pull funding from major college over three faculty members’ alleged Charlie Kirk comments

Trump hints at how he could arrest flag burners despite free speech protections

Lone survivor of East Vancouver triple stabbing dies in hospital

Trump deploys U.S. troops to Memphis in ‘replica’ of D.C. crime crackdown

Saskatchewan family demands action after 2-year-long murder investigation

Israel, U.S. show unity as other allies condemn attack on Qatar

The US and China have a new TikTok “deal”

First deportation flight to France ‘stalled after last-minute challenge’

Historically Black colleges see funding boost despite Trump's war on DEI

Trump sending National Guard to Memphis, says Chicago's "probably next"

US Army reveals Typhon missile system in Japan as tensions rise with China

B.C. company takes Saskatchewan government to court over firefighting aviation contract

Riders unveil Co-op Community Zone at Mosaic Stadium with more than 2,000 low-cost seats

Three dead babies found in a Pennsylvania home weeks after a woman was evicted: cops

Why Trump blimp won’t make an appearance at this week’s UK state visit

Trump sends National Guard to Memphis after DC takeover and eyes Chicago next

New Mexico man shot and killed two workers at auto parts store over free oil cans, cops say

MTG calls for a ‘national divorce’ and for left leaners to split from the conservatives in wake of Charlie Kirk shooting

Democratic lawmaker wants drones at public events to scope out and stop assassinations

Southern resident orca mother seen pushing deceased calf

27 sickened by salmonella in outbreak linked to dog food and treats

Police issue arrest warrant for Ontario mother who allegedly fled to Russia with child

Blue Jays select Yesavage to big-league roster

Could passenger-only vessels be part of BC Ferries’ future?

Indian Activist Passes Five Years in Pretrial Detention

The Age of the Meme Shooter Is Here

U.S., China Reach ‘Framework’ TikTok Deal

Israel launches offensive to occupy Gaza City

Trump backs Patel amid MAGA divide over FBI director

Mummies found in southeast Asia could be world's oldest, scientists say

Trump says three killed in US strike on alleged Venezuelan drug vessel

DC-style crackdown on crime coming to Memphis, Tennessee, Trump says

A look at the pomp and pageantry that will define Trump's U.K. summit

Trump World’s Deals With the U.A.E.

Canadiens’ Hutson says he’s a ‘USA Hockey player’ after dad’s comments spark stir

Who really wins as companies continue loyalty program push?

Trump announces new strike on Venezuelan boat and death of three ‘narcoterrorists’