Fresh discoveries are rewriting U.S. history amid backlash from conservatives

New voices and previously hidden stories have been reinterpreting U.S. history and reshaping museums for the last 20 years, drawing conservative criticism that President Trump is now wielding against the Smithsonian. Why it matters: The U.S. is more diverse than ever, and since the Cold War ended, pressure to promote a mythic, triumphalist national story has given way to a history of multiple views and complexities.The big picture: The bubbling change was mainly fought in local school boards as some white parents revolted against demands by parents of color and teachers to include Black and Latino history and books in K-12 curricula. It is now being waged against some of the nation's most prestigious museums and historians over discussions of patriotism and national pride.Scholars say the battle risks gutting the field of history, pushing museums and historians to ignore research and revert to a 1950s version of U.S. history.Catch up quick: A White House official told Axios last week that Trump intends to expand his review of American museums for "woke" ideology beyond the Smithsonian Institution.Trump said that the "Smithsonian is OUT OF CONTROL" on Truth Social, then directed his attorneys to conduct a comprehensive review of the museum system, similar to the process officials have conducted at colleges and universities.Meanwhile, the U.S. Department of Education is threatening to pull federal funding from public schools that maintain their DEI programs and keep books on Black history, per a Trump executive order.That order alleged that "Americans (had) witnessed a concerted and widespread effort to rewrite our Nation's history, replacing objective facts with a distorted narrative driven by ideology rather than truth."Zoom in: Trump's criticisms have drawn strong reactions from scholars like Pulitzer Prize-winning authors Annette Gordon-Reed and David Blight, who say it's all part of a larger assault on historical scholarship."In the authoritarian playbook, rewriting collective memory is just this critical strategy for controlling the masses," Hajar Yazdiha, author of "The Struggle for the People's King: How Politics Transforms the Memory of the Civil Rights Movement," told Axios.Yazdiha said if any administration can dictate how we remember the past, it will define the present and the future, including dismissing documented cases of discrimination like enslavement."With truth comes reckoning, and they don't want to reckon," Yazdiha said.State of play: In recent years, the field of history has witnessed a surge in new books that challenge some of the long-held myths surrounding pivotal figures and events.For example, Erica Armstrong Dunbar's 2017 book, "Never Caught: The Washingtons' Relentless Pursuit of Their Runaway Slave, Ona Judge," tells a story about George Washington trying to keep a woman in bondage while he spoke about freedom.Some museums, under pressure from tribal nations, have returned remains of tribal members and artifacts linked to tribes, while retelling the story of Indigenous people based on new research.Red states in reaction have enacted laws aimed at limiting classroom discussions of slavery and Native American removal, while pushing a positive, nationalist version of U.S. history.Between the lines: The gradual transformation began in the 1970s as a new generation of Black historians entered the field and college campuses opened Black and Latino studies programs, Beth English, executive director of the Organization of American Historians (OAH) told Axios."History interpreted in museum and other public spaces has (since) shifted from celebration to complexity."New works and voices didn't erase or "cancel" figures like Thomas Jefferson, but added to the story, English said."It is possible to say…this guy did a lot of things that are great, and he raped the women. He enslaved people and enslaved his children," Michael Harriot, author of "Black AF History: The Un-Whitewashed Story of America," told Axios."This history is uncomfortable, because it should be uncomfortable," Harriot said. Context: Trump's challenges follow the administration's dramatic change to the government's interpretation of Civil Rights-era laws to focus on "anti-white racism" rather than discrimination against people of color.It also follows missteps by the Trump administration, erasing — then restoring — websites dedicated to Black historic figures such as Jackie Robinson and Harriet Tubman amid the DEI purge.Go deeper: Historians take on misinformation in U.S. history

Comments

World news

Russia raises tensions with NATO as Putin shows off his battlefield nuclear weapons

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Starmer facing fresh questions over Mandelson emails to Epstein – UK politics live

Utah campus concealed carry permit under fresh scrutiny after Kirk shooting

New alleged Jeffrey Epstein emails cast fresh light on financier’s dealings with Ghislaine Maxwell

Mandelson scandal raises fresh doubt about Starmer’s political judgment

Starmer’s judgment under fresh scrutiny after Mandelson sacking

Starmer under fresh pressure to sack Mandelson as MP claims parliamentary party ‘100%’ against letting him stay – UK politics live

Mandelson predicts fresh revelations about Epstein friendship

France in fresh political crisis after MPs oust prime minister

Polish president’s meeting with Trump prompts fresh tensions with Tusk

Olympic legend sells off his gold medals and flees US for fresh start

Strike fears hit B.C. cannabis industry, with 2022 disruption still fresh in mind

UK hit by fresh sell-off in government bond markets as pound weakens

Olympic legend sells off his gold medals and flees US for fresh start

Man Utd launch fresh bid for new goalkeeper after another Bayindir blunder

Latest Drax inquiry will raise fresh questions about its billions in subsidies

Fresh bid to rescue climber, 47, stranded at 25,000ft peak – as chilling new video reveals he was ‘not afraid to die’

Trump and his team - who paved over the Rose Garden - have new pitch for DC residents under takeover: Fresh grass!

Fresh off another court loss, Alina Habba says judges should be ‘respecting the president’

Russia launches fresh wave of strikes on western Ukraine

"Threat to Americans and Israelis": Trump admin imposes fresh sanctions on ICC officials

World news

Russia raises tensions with NATO as Putin shows off his battlefield nuclear weapons

Charlie Kirk traveled across America. His security varied from venue to venue

Two men jailed for plot to kill president with witchcraft in Zambia

Dad threatened by ICE deportation days after being shot during robbery

‘Gaza is burning’: Israel reportedly begins ground offensive after Netanyahu threatens Hamas leaders

Donald Trump says he will sue New York Times for $15bn

Israel is committing genocide in Gaza, UN probe finds

‘Tooth-in-eye’ surgery enables man to see again after 20 years

Trump says he will sue the New York Times for $15bn

Is Keir Starmer already toast? I don’t think so

Apple TV+ swept the Emmys – these are the 11 shows to watch

Haitians yearn for home as gangs welcome them and police warn it's too dangerous

Father kills his own baby daughter on Facebook Live before taking his own life

Watch: JD Vance hosts Charlie Kirk's daily talk radio show

Why more women get cancer in India - but more men die

Malawi votes for next president as cost-of-living bites

They were shot dead for protesting against corruption in Nepal

Belarus and Russia's show of firepower appears to be a message to Europe

Google owner reveals £5bn AI investment in UK ahead of Trump visit

US Secretary of State inaugurates Israeli settler-led archaeological site in Jerusalem

Trump says he will sue New York Times for $15bn

Nigerian chef breaks world record for largest jollof rice dish

Chinese teens to pay $300,000 for urinating in soup

Report those who celebrate Charlie Kirk death to employers, Vance says

Israel escalates bombardment as defence minister says 'Gaza is burning'

Beaten and held in Russia for three years - but never charged with a crime

Trump's state visit is mired with potential pitfalls despite careful planning

Trump says the U.S. military targeted a boat allegedly carrying drugs from Venezuela

Federal Judge Declines to Intervene for Migrants Deported to Ghana

Florida attorney general says cops should stop enforcing open carry gun ban after court ruling

Russia shows off conventional and nuclear military might in drills — and raises tensions with NATO

Tyson Foods to eliminate high-fructose corn syrup in brands like Jimmy Dean and Hillshire Farm

A new Ebola outbreak has been declared. Here’s what we know

Luigi Mangione due in court amid double jeopardy fight in UnitedHealthcare CEO’s killing

How hands-off investing could have made you six times more than saving this year

‘I fought in Afghanistan but faulty earplugs left me with physical and mental scars’

Birmingham City and the battle of ambition vs tradition

I’m a first-time buyer – why does being self-employed mean I can borrow less?

Canada’s friendly seafood capital with a road trip and vineyards nearby

Sorry book snobs – Richard Osman’s The Impossible Fortune is a delight

Trump’s Tariffs Start to Bite in Vietnam

ADHD and bipolar patients face medicine delays – even when drugs are in stock

My Man Utd XI to save Amorim’s job – with three major changes

Please stop suggesting a date night – I’d rather you unblock the drain

DWP imposes ‘gagging order’ on disability experts ahead of PIP review

"Not welcome": Rubio says U.S. is deporting visa holders who celebrated Kirk's death

What to know about the US deportations to non-citizen African countries

Photos show how an Indonesian motorbike mechanic became a macaw trainer

Polls open in Malawi’s presidential and parliamentary elections

Trump World’s Deals With the U.A.E.

‘Squid Game’ Star Lee Jung-jae Talks About Korean Fan Culture

President Trump’s State Visit to the UK: What to Know

National park to remove exhibit of famed photograph showing former slave’s scarred back, says report

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Poland asks Nato to impose no-fly zone over Ukraine to stop Putin’s drone incursions

Drills in Belarus and drone incursions into Romania: How the war in Ukraine has already become a European conflict

E-bike battery fire displaces 11 people from Vancouver home

Drought level in the Okanagan increases under new provincial system