Local officials grow wary of helping ICE detain immigrants

A growing number of local law enforcement officials are alarmed about their jails and prisons holding immigration detainees without warrants, saying it exposes their departments to legal risks.Why it matters: It's the latest sign of tension between local authorities and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents, whose strong-arm tactics in arresting immigrants have shocked communities across the nation. Zoom in: As part of President Trump's push to deport "millions" of unauthorized immigrants, ICE has leaned on local agencies to help arrest and temporarily detain unauthorized immigrants.Over the past decade most of ICE's arrests involved people who already were in law enforcement custody, according to a review of 10 years of data from Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC).But with ICE arrests soaring to more than 2,000 a day under Trump, local jail and prison officials are increasingly concerned about being liable for detainees' care — particularly when ICE leaves them in local facilities for lengthy periods.The officials note that in the past, lawsuits filed on behalf of ICE detainees wrongly left languishing in local jails have cost local governments enormously — $92.5 million in one New York City case involving 20,000 people who were held in prison for ICE without due process between 1997 and 2012.How it works: ICE can ask a local agency to hold someone they believe isn't legally in the U.S., using a request called a detainer. Usually there's a 48-hour limit on this request.A detainer request from ICE isn't the same as a warrant issued by a judge, which local agencies require to hold their suspects."The ICE administrative warrant is not enough to hold somebody's liberty away," Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison (D) told Axios. "It's essentially holding somebody and locking them up when there's no legal, lawful authority to do so.""The risk to the institution that's holding them is civil liability," he added. "They could end up paying a lot of money — and not just money, but injunctive relief."The National Sheriffs' Association has asked the Trump administration to clarify how long someone should be held on ICE's behalf, and has raised the issue with Border Czar Tom Homan.The group also has been lobbying Congress to pass a law addressing the issue for sheriffs, who often manage jails.Between the lines: A few law enforcement officials have spoken publicly about their concerns for ICE detainees' civil liberties under Trump's deportation push — and have faced a backlash from GOP officials for doing so.In February, Sheriff Dan Marx of Winneshiek County, Iowa, aired his concerns about cooperating with ICE detainers in a since-deleted Facebook post."The only reason detainers are issued is because the federal agency does not have enough information or has not taken the time to obtain a valid judicial warrant," Marx wrote."These detainers are violations of our 4th Amendment protection against warrantless search, seizure and arrest, and our 6th Amendment right to due process."Marx's post led Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds — a Republican who has ordered the state's local law enforcement to "fully cooperate" with Trump's deportation mission — to file a formal complaint against the sheriff.Marx was investigated by Iowa's attorney general over whether he violated a state law mandating such cooperation.He deleted his first post and issued another statement that said in part: "I do not believe law enforcement officials should have to choose between upholding their sworn duty to the Constitution and following the state statute."He declined to be interviewed because of the investigation."From a constitutional standpoint, if we're going to hold somebody in jail or detain them, we want to be doing so lawfully and have legal grounds to do so. And I think for a sheriff to ask for a judicial warrant is reasonable," Michael Tupper, a former police chief in Marshalltown, Iowa, told Axios.In a New Orleans court, the Orleans Parish Sheriff's Office is being sued by Louisiana's attorney general for not honoring ICE detainers.Orleans Parish has a policy of honoring ICE detainers only when a detainee has a warrant for a violent offense.The policy stems from has a legal settlement from 2010, when two men in the Orleans jail were held without due process for two months longer than their sentences, waiting for ICE.Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill (R) argues it amounts to a sanctuary policy, in violation of state law. The case is ongoing.Several other jurisdictions nationwide have faced similar lawsuits when people have been held on ICE detainers longer than their sentences or after their cases were dismissed. Some, like Orleans Parish, are changing their policies to limit their exposure to such suits.Montgomery and Delaware counties in Pennsylvania, for example, now require judicial warrants in addition to an ICE detainers to hold immigration detainees.What they're saying: "When a sheriff or a police chief stands up and voices concerns, they are oftentimes painted as soft on crime, or, you know, they don't care about keeping their community safe," Tupper said. "It's really the opposite. These folks are trying to do the right thing for the community."As Trump's deportation effort continues, that pressure on police chiefs and sheriffs is likely to build."If they speak up too much," said retired police chief Mark Prosser of Stormlake, Iowa, "then perhaps an immigration enforcement activity is going to come to a community near you."

Comments

World news

Andy Beshear confirms he’s eyeing 2028 as he polls high with Republicans in deep red Kentucky

Independent

Comments

Similar News

U.K. F-35B Jet Takes Unplanned Vacation in India, Is Embraced by Locals

World news

Andy Beshear confirms he’s eyeing 2028 as he polls high with Republicans in deep red Kentucky

Trump hopes to align with Netanyahu on Gaza war endgame during visit

'We'll never yield': Millions of Iranians unite in mourning

Blue Jays catcher Kirk named to all-star game

Blue Jays catcher Kirk named to all-star game

Police, family of Edmonton teen killed in hit-and-run seek help to ID driver

Next Up: Different Blue Jays helping Toronto win

Palma airport in crisis as 'sewage water' floods in from burst pipe

The Dalai Lama turns 90 amid reaction to succession announcement

Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visits White House to discuss Gaza ceasefire

Israel’s Deadly Assault on Iran Prison Incites Fury, Even Among Dissidents

RCMP investigate assault of woman in Chestermere on Canada Day

Toronto’s Olivia Chow heads to U.K., Ireland on trade mission

At least 70 have died after catastrophic flooding in Texas - as officials warn ‘wall of water’ could batter region

Brit, 22, ‘falls off boat and gets caught by propeller’ in Magaluf

How Government could fast track Heathrow third runway – by avoiding Nimbys

Live Aid at 40 doesn’t go easy on Bob Geldof

Suriname's parliament elects the country's first female president amid economic turmoil

Boko Haram militants kill 9 people and injure 4 in northeastern Nigeria, authorities say

Israel says it has attacked Houthi targets at three ports and power plant in Yemen

Bo Bichette leads Blue Jays to eighth straight win

Tourist 'nearly sliced in two' by boat propeller in Bahamas holiday hit-and-run

IDF says it killed Hamas commander in cafe strike that killed dozens of civilians

Gaza ceasefire talks begin in Qatar as Netanyahu heads to Washington

Monday Briefing: Floods in Texas Killed nearly 80

Israel’s Deadly Assault on Iran Prison Incites Fury, Even Among Dissidents

Lac-Mégantic marks 12th anniversary as calls for improved rail safety mount

Environment group warns against repealing federal electric vehicle mandate

Man recovering from injuries after ‘defensive’ grizzly bear attack in B.C.

A glimmer of hope in Gaza? Inside the fragile ceasefire push as Trump hosts Netanyahu

Other GOP-led states are considering ‘Alligator Alcatraz’ knock-offs, according to survey

What are the challenges to launching Musk’s new ‘America Party’?

Scott Bessent spars with CNN host over whether Trump’s tariffs count as trade deals

Tesla’s historic decline under Elon Musk in seven charts

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs got a standing ovation from inmates after acquittal on some charges, lawyer claims

New details emerge on Gaza ceasefire proposal as Netanyahu heads to White House

New details emerge on Gaza ceasefire proposal as Netanyahu heads to the White House

U.S. ramps up pressure on countries ahead of deadline for trade deals

Chantal weakens to a tropical depression but raises concerns of flash flooding in North Carolina

A girls' summer camp cut short by deadly disaster

Major DeSantis contributor was awarded Alligator Alcatraz contract

Chicago woman charged with murder after kids are stabbed inside burning home

Race on to rescue 11 campers still missing in rising Texas floods

‘We thought we’d done our last gig of the year. Then we played the Eurostar’

Ben Stokes cost England this Test

Cam Norrie is the last Brit standing at Wimbledon – and has Alcaraz in his sights

Bessent casts some shade over Musk's new political party

Lion owners arrested after an attack on woman and her 2 children in Pakistan

What is the possible Gaza hostage and ceasefire deal - and what challenges could lie ahead?

Best early Prime Day Deals you don’t want to miss

Elks look for first win of the season at home against the Redblacks

Pope Leo resumes papal tradition of taking summer vacation

Ukraine inks deal to boost drone production as Russia, Kyiv trade strikes

Brit tourist sliced open by boat propeller in Magaluf after 'heavy drinking session'

NATO chief issues chilling WW3 warning over 'Russia and China twin attack'

Hamas security officer says group has lost control over most of Gaza

Explosion rips through Domino's restaurant after car crashes into building

Convicted murderer Lori Bill Germa escapes from Archambault Institution in Quebec

What Canadians’ options are as companies push a return to office

Search for 27 missing girls continues after Texas flash flood kills at least 51