"Most important case ever": Supreme Court to decide fate of Trump's tariffs

The Supreme Court will hear a case on Wednesday that will decide the fate of President Trump's signature economic policy, the tariffs he has leveraged to reshape the global order.Why it matters: It is the latest instance of the high court deciding the fate of Trump's agenda, but this time with consequences that transcend the containers full of toys and electronics at the nation's ports. "The stakes of this case reach far beyond trade policy," Elizabeth Goitein, a senior director at the Brennan Center, a nonpartisan policy institute, wrote in a blog post.The "decision could shape whether the use of emergency powers to bypass Congress becomes a tool of routine governance."The big picture: Trump calls the suit "[t]he most important case ever."A loss could hugely curb his powers in imposing tariffs. It could set off a potentially chaotic tariff refund process, result in a loss of revenue that has somewhat brightened the nation's fiscal outlook, and possibly undermine key trade deals.Catch up quick: The lion's share of Trump's global tariffs were imposed under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. At issue is whether the 50-year-old law, which has never before been used to impose import taxes, justifies the levies.An appellate court struck down the tariffs in August. How judges ruled then reveal the complexity of what might come next.The majority said Trump's IEEPA tariffs were illegal, but for different reasons. Four said that the law doesn't authorize tariffs, while three others said only that the tariffs in question could not be imposed under the law.The dissenting group, which included two Obama-appointed judges, said IEEPA does extend tariff power to the president.What they're saying: "This is a major confrontation between the executive branch and Congress," says Michael McConnell, a former appellate judge appointed by the latter President Bush, who is among the lawyers representing the group suing Trump."It is practically what the American Revolution was fought over: the principle that taxation is not legitimate unless it is adopted by the representatives of the people," McConnell says.Neal Katyal, who served as the acting solicitor general in the Obama administration, will argue the case before the Supreme Court next week — the result of a literal coin flip. The other side: Department of Justice lawyers have argued, at least in part, that the courts should not question what Trump says constitutes a national emergency.In July, the lawyers said the trade deficit had "reached a tipping point" and the tariffs give the "president leverage to address the emergency.""Imagine if someone had held their hand up in 2006, 2007 and said 'we're on the verge of a housing crisis,'" Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told Fox News yesterday."Well President Trump raised his hand and said, 'we are on the verge of a ... trade crisis, and I'm going to use IEEPA.' That is what emergency powers are for," Bessent said.The bottom line: Trump claims the nation will fall into ruin if IEEPA tariffs are struck down — even as the White House says it will replace the levies using other, more process-heavy trade laws.But that would all but destroy the Oval Office "tariff switch" — the ability to impose tariffs quickly without much notice.

Comments

World news

Saskatoon to host 2027 Brier, marking 100 years of curling championship

Global News

Comments

World news

Saskatoon to host 2027 Brier, marking 100 years of curling championship

Tylenol maker Kenvue will be bought by the company behind Kleenex

Corus Entertainment announces recapitalization transaction

Shaping Saskatchewan: Axelson family

Tylenol maker sells to Kimberly Clark for $48B weeks after Trump and RFK Jr targeted drug

Class-action lawyer Stan Chesley dies in Ohio

Trump’s nuclear weapons tests won’t include explosions ‘right now,’ official says

Microsoft to ship 60,000 Nvidia AI chips to UAE under US-approved deal

The names of 5 million Jews killed in Holocaust have finally been recovered. AI could help find remaining 1 million

Sudan’s paramilitary investigated over ‘war crimes’ as tens of thousands flee

How British teenager Bella Culley’s dream holiday to Thailand turned into a prison nightmare in Georgia

Trump readies US troops for ground invasion in Mexico to go after drug cartels: report

America’s top 10 richest saw their wealth grow by $700 billion combined under Trump: report

Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade lineup announced: Here’s who is performing and hosting

Ukraine military using video game-style reward system earning points killing Russians with drones

As Trump’s Gaza plan unravels, what’s next for the Middle East? Join live Q&A with Bel Trew

Prosecutor reveals why pregnant British teenager was freed from Georgia prison early

Born after 2007? You’ll never be able to smoke in the Maldives

Irish sporting legend jailed after faking cancer using iPhone cable up his nose

All the ways you can still cut your income tax bill if Reeves scraps salary sacrifice

Don’t be shocked by Trump’s excesses – he isn’t the first dictator president

Can the Gulf Rebuild the Middle East?

Does my health insurance cover therapy?

Dental insurance isn’t a scam — but it’s also not insurance

The subtle privatization of Medicare

Ben Shapiro blasts Tucker Carlson over Fuentes interview

Federal government rejects $28,000 raise proposal for judges

Gut microbiome tests are everywhere. Should you get one?

ANALYSIS: Captain Adam Lowry to return from injury as Winnipeg Jets continue to soar

Halloween display depicts municipal politicians hanging from a noose in Manitoba

Tylenol, Kleenex, Band-Aid and more put under one roof in $48.7 billion consumer brands deal

A mysterious object crashed outside of Area 51 weeks ago. Now people are claiming there’s been a cover-up

Major air base hit by suspected drone ‘spying operation’

Top prosecutor denies allegations he leaked confidential documents

Chipotle demand is cratering as Gen Z struggle to make ends meet

‘I think I’m a much better-looking person’: Trump’s comments on Mamdani take a weird turn into appearance

‘On it!’ Trump vows to help cancer-stricken Dilbert creator after public plea to ‘save my life’

Trump says it’s ‘terrible’ that Andrew lost royal titles over Epstein scandal

Three dead and eight remain missing after avalanche on Himalayan peak

GOP congressman calls Tucker Carlson the ‘most dangerous antisemite in America’

Ex-CIA chief John Brennan jabs activist in the chest after being confronted over Hunter Biden laptop claim

Pregnant British teen arrested for drug smuggling in Georgia released after guilty verdict

New York is facing a tougher tax on the rich than the UK – and millionaires support it

Paul McCartney’s inside story of Wings, the world’s most misunderstood band

UK has ‘lost momentum’ for war readiness – and ‘relies on enemies to leave us alone’

The joke’s over. Farage badly wants power – and believes he can get it

Average mortgage rate drops back below 5% – here are the best deals

ICC prosecutor warns Sudan’s paramilitary forces may be committing war crimes in Darfur

Spanish regional leader steps down over his handling of last year's Valencia flash floods

Africa’s latest elections end with crackdowns on opposition and disputed results

In Uganda, where Zohran Mamdani was born, NYC mayoral hopeful is recalled with pride

Famine spreads to two more areas in Sudan, the top global hunger authority says

A medieval tower in Rome partially collapses during renovations, injuring a worker

Man charged after Saskatchewan woman killed by stray bullets on Highway 39

Best deals to shop from the Our Place Black Friday Sale 2025

Father and daughter among five people killed in avalanche in Italy's Dolomites

Both sides say democracy is at stake with Prop. 50 — but for very different reasons

Tanzania’s President Hassan sworn in after election sparks deadly protests

Spain's top prosecutor stands trial over allegations of leaking confidential information

Pregnant British teenager Bella Culley freed from Georgia prison after ‘drugs mule’ ordeal