Supreme Court rejects challenge to gay marriage decision

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a long-shot request that could have given the justices a chance to overturn the landmark decision recognizing same-sex marriage nationwide.The big picture: The high court's rejection signals, for now, that same-sex marriage remains settled law.Driving the news: The Supreme Court rejected the application without explanation, as is custom.The case was brought by Kim Davis, a former county clerk in Kentucky who refused to issue a gay couple a marriage license in 2015. Her appeal claimed the court's decision in Obergefell v. Hodges was "egregiously wrong" and "deeply damaging."Davis was ordered to pay $360,000 in damages and fees, and she has been unsuccessful in her attempts to challenge that judgment.Jim Obergefell, the lead plaintiff in the historic case, said in a statement provided to Axios that the court did the "right thing" in rejecting the request, saying he hopes this "is the last we hear from" Davis.He said marriage equality "has given couples and families the rights, protections, and dignity they deserve. Queer kids can dream of a future, married to the person they love in the place they call home."While he said today warrants celebration, Obergefell added "we should not assume marriage equality will stand forever" and that there could be "continued efforts to bring another case before the Supreme Court, a court that has proven that precedent is not always safe."Between the lines: LGBTQ+ rights advocates, like Obergefell, have stressed that marriage equality must still be defended. However, legal experts previously told Axios the high court was likely to deny review in this case.Unwinding years of protections for same-sex marriage would create a complicated legal quagmire. But the Supreme Court's 2022 Dobbs decision — and Clarence Thomas' concurring opinion suggesting the court should revisit Obergefell — raised alarms that marriage equality could be the next right to fall.More than two dozen states have trigger laws that would limit marriage equality if the Supreme Court ever overturned its 2015 decision. What they're saying: Mat Staver — the founder of Liberty Counsel, which represents Davis — described the high court's decision as "heartbreaking" for Davis and for "religious freedom."He added, "We are committed to overturning Obergefell."Yes, but: Mary Bonauto, GLAD Law's senior director of civil rights and legal strategies, said in a statement that today, "millions of Americans can breathe a sigh of relief."Bonauto, who argued Obergefell in 2015, said that "the only thing that has changed" since it was decided is that "people across the country have seen how marriage equality provides protection for families and children, and that protection strengthens communities, the economy and our society."Brian K. Bond, the CEO of PFLAG National, said in a statement that the "freedom to say 'I do' is more than just love and commitment.""It's also about the right to visit your spouse in the hospital or to make medical decisions. It's about both parents having legal rights to raise their children. It's about having access to financial benefits for buying a house or car," Bond said.Catch up quick: Davis turned to the Supreme Court after the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected her appeal. The court, citing Obergefell, said that while people can be opposed to same-sex marriage, they "do not have a right to transform their 'personal opposition' into 'enacted law and public policy.'"Davis' application to the Supreme Court argued the Obergefell decision was "grounded in the erroneous fiction on substantive due process" and should be overturned.Go deeper: A decade after Obergefell, LGBTQ+ rights remain under threatEditor's note: This story was updated with additional context.

Comments

World news

USask Huskies capture Mitchell Bowl at home, advance to 2025 Vanier Cup

Global News

Marjorie Taylor Greene casts doubt on Trump‘s MAGA credentials and suggests he is being pressured to cover up Epstein files

about 23 hours ago

Independent

Marjorie Taylor Greene tells Trump to ‘refocus’ on MAGA and tamp down divisive rhetoric as feud over Epstein files intensifies: Live

about 23 hours ago

Group of five in early twenties die in Co Louth car crash ‘while heading to a party’

Metro

Comments

Similar News

Supreme Court urged to block California laws requiring companies to disclose climate impacts

The Supreme Court is about to rule on whether Trump can use troops against Americans

Supreme Court upholds impaired driving convictions based on breathalyzers

Mexico's Supreme Court rules against magnate's $2.6B tax debt challenges

Rastafarian asks Supreme Court if he can sue prison for shaving his dreadlocks

The Supreme Court just might save Trump from himself

US supreme court extends Trump pause on $4bn in food aid benefits

US supreme court extends pause on Trump administration paying full November Snap benefits – as it happened

Supreme Court extends order blocking full funding for SNAP benefits with shutdown nearing end

Trump asks Supreme Court to throw out sex abuse verdict in latest attempt to rewrite legal turmoil

Supreme Court rejects call to overturn its decision legalizing same-sex marriage nationwide

Supreme Court dismisses long-shot challenge to right to marry for same-sex couples

Supreme Court blocks order for Trump administration to cover SNAP benefits — for now

The Supreme Court will decide whether to toss out thousands of ballots

A Supreme Court case about dreadlocks could end up gutting Medicaid

SNAP payment decision gets quick review from Supreme Court

Supreme Court extends SNAP payments freeze as lawmakers near shutdown vote

Order to fund SNAP overstepped judge's power, DOJ argues to Supreme Court

Two ways countries could respond to the Supreme Court ruling on Trump's tariffs

Trump administration’s passport sex designation policy backed by U.S. Supreme Court

World news

USask Huskies capture Mitchell Bowl at home, advance to 2025 Vanier Cup

Danko Jones on new album ‘Leo Rising’ and what it takes to grind it out on the road

Call of the Wilde: Montréal Canadiens fall to the Boston Bruins

La Nina weather system could bring more deadly storms to Southeast Asia, scientists warn

Hunt for gunman after boy, 10, and 21-year-old woman killed and three others injured in mass shooting in Newark

Marjorie Taylor Greene casts doubt on Trump‘s MAGA credentials and suggests he is being pressured to cover up Epstein files

Marjorie Taylor Greene tells Trump to ‘refocus’ on MAGA and tamp down divisive rhetoric as feud over Epstein files intensifies: Live

Group of five in early twenties die in Co Louth car crash ‘while heading to a party’

The militias battling to form a breakaway coastal state in the Middle East

Christmas is cancelled as shoppers cut back on festive supermarket baskets

Trump wants to crush the BBC. Time for Labour to take a stand

Nearly 70 schools to close in Australia over fears of asbestos in play sand

'Deep sadness' as extensive search off Ireland's coast for missing Royal Navy crew member ends

Arrest over deadly car blast in New Delhi

The cities Trump is targeting with ICE crackdowns next

Trump's $2,000 tariff checks requires legislation, Bessent says

Tragic update in hunt for missing UK Navy crew member after distress call

Five week old baby drowned in bath 'after argument between mum and dad'

B.C. Premier David Eby survives leadership review as NDP delegates signal support

'Fury from Alberta and Saskatchewan': Western patience wearing thin over lack of Alberta pipeline plan

10 necessities for fighting the cold and flu

Bruins hand slumping Canadiens third straight loss

Gun theft lead to shelter-in-place order in Alta.

Vilardi nets shootout winner, Jets down Flames

Forsberg shuts down Senators in return to Ottawa

A rare nugget of bipartisanship: How data farms’ water-gobbling and rate hikes have communities fighting back

How Budget could hit you if you earn over £50k – and what you can do about it

Lorde live in Manchester was a confirmation of her status as a pop star

Cold snap to bring -7°C temperatures and possibly snow as health alerts issued

Iran says it's no longer enriching uranium at any site in the country

Behind the Curtain: MAGA's metastasizing mess

Twilight of the star CEO

Ontario town ends boat rescue service sparking concern among water safety advocates

Naturalized citizens gripped by fear as Trump’s immigration policy shifts

Five people dead after crash on ‘very dangerous’ road

At least 13 injured in ‘freak accident’ as demolition derby car crashes into crowd

Sending licence fee money to Mar-a-Lago not ‘smart’, shadow minister suggests after Trump threatened to sue BBC

Hundreds of thousands rally in Manila against flood-control corruption scandal

Commentary: Front-runner or flash in the pan? Sizing up Newsom, 2028

Noughties diet culture destroyed our girls. I can’t believe it’s back

The cars still available on the Motability scheme if luxury models are cut

Everything we know about the Home Office’s radical asylum overhaul

Is AI being shoved down your throat at work? Here’s how to fight back.

Why are there so many billionaires nowadays?

Five young adults dead after car crash

Photos of the treasures in Rome's exclusive Colonna Palace

Zelenskyy says Ukraine is working on a prisoner exchange with Russia

Foreign minister says Iran is no longer enriching uranium at any site in the country

Co Louth crash: Three men and two women killed in horror car accident

Tragic twist of Disney fan who died in front of resort staff as hidden details emerge

YouTuber Jack Doherty arrested in Miami on drug possession charges

China Escalates Japan Feud With Island Patrols and Warnings to Citizens

'Dear Canada, we miss you': What these U.S. cities and states are doing to woo Canadians back

Despite Trump's cane sugar activism, Canadian Coke drinkers should get used to high-fructose corn syrup

Two-year-old boy dies after falling from 20th-floor apartment window in New Jersey

Border Patrol agents question Christmas light workers as crackdown escalates

Trump turns on Marjorie Taylor Greene in explosive feud that could shatter MAGA movement