Trump firing of BLS head imperils trust in economic data

This is what the alarmists — the people who have worried that President Trump may seek to undermine the collection of economic data — feared.The big picture: The president's abrupt firing of the Bureau of Labor Statistics commissioner Friday makes clear that any federal data collector who delivers unwelcome news could lose their job in an instant.Economists of all stripes fear a chilling impact.The removal "presents risks to the conduct of monetary policy, to financial stability, and to the economic outlook," wrote JPMorgan chief U.S. economist Michael Feroli.Catch up quick: Friday morning, data came out showing much weaker job growth in the May-through-July period than previously estimated. Friday afternoon, the president fired Erika McEntarfer via a social media post.His appointees later argued that this was not punishment for delivering bad news, but driven by a desire for "more transparent and more reliable" data, as National Economic Council director Kevin Hassett put it Sunday on "Meet the Press."He said on Fox News Sunday that the data "have become very unreliable with these massive revisions over the last few years."The president's own comments on social media evoked more darkly conspiratorial ideas, such as Friday's claim that "today's Jobs Numbers were RIGGED in order to make the Republicans, and ME, look bad."Reality check: McEntarfer is a two-decade civil servant who was confirmed as BLS commissioner last year with 86 votes in the Senate, including that of now-Vice President JD Vance.Yes, but: It is true that Friday's revisions were very large by historical standards. That is often true at economic turning points.Data revisions are the BLS's commitment to both get its first estimates of what's going on in the economy out promptly, and to make them as accurate as possible once fuller information becomes available.What they're saying: "These revisions reflect the commitment of statistical agencies to accuracy, transparency, and methodological rigor—not failure or bias," leaders of the American Economic Association said in a statement Friday.By the numbers: News coverage usually focuses on the change in payroll employment. So when BLS announced Friday that June job growth was 14,000, not the 147,000 originally reported, it looks like a massive failure.But what they're really trying to do is estimate the total number of payroll jobs at U.S. employers in that month.Turns out, there were 159.466 million jobs in mid-June, not the 159.724 million first reported.The intrigue: There are ironies in Trump's claim that the data is rigged, in that the numbers Friday affirmed that key parts of the Trump agenda are working.It showed that federal government employment has declined by more than previously reported, consistent with DOGE-driven attempts to shrink federal payroll.It also included lower job growth in some sectors known to employ many immigrants with uncertain legal status, namely construction, leisure and hospitality.Of note: The negative revisions weren't particularly surprising to anyone who had followed a quarterly Census data series based on state employment data. Fed governor Christopher Waller flagged the likelihood of big negative revisions in a speech on July 17.Moreover, Trump has argued both that negative revisions to jobs data last year reflected a rigging of the numbers to help former President Biden, and now that negative revisions this year amount to an attempt to damage Trump.Zoom in: If the president's nominee to lead BLS is widely viewed as a partisan actor who will seek to bend data to the president's will, there are big stakes for markets and policy.Consider, for example, the $2.1 trillion market for Treasury Inflation Protected Securities. Its returns to investors are determined by the Consumer Price Index, generated by BLS.Countless private contracts are indexed to CPI inflation as well.What's next: The president said Sunday that he expects to name a new BLS commissioner this week. That person will be subject to Senate confirmation.

Comments

World news

Stop. Repo time! MC Hammer sued for allegedly failing to make $2,000 monthly car payments

Independent

Comments

Similar News

Trump team officially ends Musk’s ‘five things’ DOGE email that drew ire and led to thousands of resignations

Trump’s agriculture secretary doubles down on suggestion people should work on farms to avoid losing Medicaid

Trump calls RFK Jr ‘three or four times a week’ with the same question

‘We will work collaboratively’: Big Pharma admits it is discussing Trump’s plan to lower drug prices

How a Texas showdown could reshape Congress - and Trump's presidency

Zelensky thanks Trump for 'productive' talks ahead of ceasefire deadline

Spike Lee, Adam McKay and over 2,000 writers decry Trump’s ‘un-American’ actions in open letter

Trump is nearly halfway through Project 2025 agenda in just the first six months of his presidency

94-year-old Rupert Murdoch to provide Trump regular health updates in deal to delay deposition

Trump’s chilling assault on economic data

Trump readies fresh US sanctions against Russia’s shadow fleet

Trump administration to reinstall Confederate statue toppled in Black Lives Matter protests

Lobbyists have spent over $2M on TV ads in Palm Beach hoping to catch Trump’s attention at Mar-a-Lago

Trump says Texas is ‘entitled to five more seats’ as DNC chair readies for ‘knife fight’: Live updates

‘Has to sting’: MTG turned on GOP after Trump snubbed her ambitions to be governor, expert says

Texas families offered just $3,000 by the government in exchange for building Trump’s wall on their land

Watch Donald Trump walk on top of White House roof: ‘Taking a little walk’

Putin’s nuclear sabre-rattling is hard bargaining – Russia has seen through Trump’s bluster

Trump plans to "take over" Gaza aid effort, U.S. officials say

Trump ceded leverage over Putin by pausing sanctions, Democratic report says

World news

Stop. Repo time! MC Hammer sued for allegedly failing to make $2,000 monthly car payments

Suspect, 88, accused of sexually assaulting 6-year-old girl after offering her candy

Tennessee man executed while his defibrillator remained active cried out in pain as he died, witnesses say

Family claims 73-year-old patient died after sexual assault that happened while in the hospital

Trump team officially ends Musk’s ‘five things’ DOGE email that drew ire and led to thousands of resignations

Maine cop arrested by ICE transferred to second detention center, report says

Trump’s agriculture secretary doubles down on suggestion people should work on farms to avoid losing Medicaid

British tourist arrested and accused of trying to drown daughter-in-law at Florida resort

Denmark to remove ‘ugly and pornographic’ mermaid statue after complaints, reports say

Trump calls RFK Jr ‘three or four times a week’ with the same question

‘We will work collaboratively’: Big Pharma admits it is discussing Trump’s plan to lower drug prices

Chikungunya virus: How bad is the China outbreak and could it spread to the UK?

Netanyahu Pushes for Full Israeli Occupation of Gaza

Nigerian customs seize over 1,600 parrots and canaries in major wildlife trafficking bust

FBI reports hate crimes hit 2nd largest record in 2024

Philippines condemns China's rocket launch after suspected debris sparked alarm

Cameroon's constitutional council bars main opposition candidate from presidential race

Chilling moment flash flood wipes out town leaving least 4 dead and 50 missing

Police shame British drugs mules by making them pose for photos with suitcases

Comedian Matt Rife is now the legal guardian of ‘haunted’ Annabelle doll

B.C.’s top court tosses mink farms’ bid for damages after COVID-era ban

Confirmed case of measles in Banff prompts AHS to issue public alert

Dog left in hot vehicle had to be put down, owner facing charges: Durham police

Ion Iliescu: Romania's first democratic leader with a divisive legacy

How a Texas showdown could reshape Congress - and Trump's presidency

Great Barrier Reef suffers worst coral decline on record

Zelensky thanks Trump for 'productive' talks ahead of ceasefire deadline

A Famous Palestinian Activist Killed in the Occupied West Bank

The story behind one grim image of a mother and child in Gaza

British Opera Company Cancels ‘Tosca’ Collaboration in Israel After Criticism

Wednesday Briefing: Netanyahu’s Next Steps in Gaza

WestJet cyberattack will be investigated by Canada’s privacy commissioner

Montreal Pride organizers have reversed ban on Jewish community group in parade

94-year-old Rupert Murdoch to provide Trump regular health updates in deal to delay deposition

America’s Most Wanted: Texas senator calls on FBI director Kash Patel to hunt down ‘fleeing’ Democrats

Democrats have early edge over Republicans in 2026 midterm election poll

Elon Musk is the least popular public figure in America

ICE agents flee arson attack in Washington state

Hezbollah threatens to restart firing missiles at Israel if it intensifies operations in Lebanon

Trump is nearly halfway through Project 2025 agenda in just the first six months of his presidency

Daycare worker accused of making kids fight and throw chairs at each other

Laura Loomer’s MAGA critics accuse her of being funded by Big Pharma

Wife of man convicted in ‘Delphi murders’ speaks out for the first time: ‘My husband’s not a monster’

Ozzy Osbourne died of a heart attack, report says, citing death certificate

ICE arrests dropped in July as backlash to raids and mass deportation plans stalled operations

80 Years After Hiroshima, Nuclear Risks Are Rising

Calgary police charge 17 people in series of overnight break and enters

NDP, BC Greens to provide update on co-operation deal

Iconic Banff sign to be relocated for safety reasons

Winnipeg police investigate 5-vehicle Monday morning crash on Ellice Avenue

Texas governor orders arrest of ‘delinquent’ Democrats who fled to block vote

Man charged in 2 Vancouver stranger assaults, 1 involving tourist

Drayton Valley woman, 21, killed in crash with gravel truck on Highway 16

Mum and kids left stranded at airport for 15 hours after Jet2 'deny boarding'

Tragedy as couple drown in flash floods while holidaying in Majorca with friends

Inspector, 65, dragged beneath train after jumping on tracks to save teen girl

Big Tech’s Net-Zero Goals Are Looking Shaky