Trump loses 3rd case over targeting of law firms: Judge calls executive order "absurd"

A federal judge struck down on Tuesday President Trump's executive order that targeted WilmerHale and criticized the top law firm for its association with former Russia investigation special counsel Robert Mueller.Why it matters: It's a blow to Trump's push to target law firms that had employed or represented people he regards as critics and marks the third such ruling by a federal judge against the administration this month.Driving the news: Trump said in his March order targeting WilmerHale that his administration was "committed to addressing the significant risks associated with law firms, particularly so-called 'Big Law' firms, that engage in conduct detrimental to critical American interests."Trump accused WilmerHale of being "bent on employing lawyers who weaponize the prosecutorial power to upend the democratic process and distort justice."The order criticized the law firm for "rewarding" Mueller, who led the investigation into Russian interference in the 2016 election before returning to WilmerHale in 2019 for two years.U.S. District Judge Richard Leon on Tuesday blocked the administration from enforcing the order that he found to be unconstitutional in a ruling that was punctuated by exclamation points in many places.What they're saying: "The cornerstone of the American system of justice is an independent judiciary and an independent bar willing to tackle unpopular cases, however daunting. The Founding Fathers knew this!" wrote the George W. Bush-appointed D.C.-based judge in a scathing opinion on Tuesday.The judge took issue with Trump administration attorneys argument that the law firm's alleged injuries were speculative and said to "dispute the causal relationship between the Order and any client's decision to terminate its relationship with WilmerHale" was "absurd!"Zoom in: Leon said that taken together, sanctions outlined in the order that included suspending any security clearances for federal buildings for WilmerHale staff would "constitute a staggering punishment for the firm's protected speech!"He noted that other firms facing similar executive orders had "capitulated" to Trump."The order shouts through a bullhorn: If you take on causes disfavored by President Trump, you will be punished!" Leon said."I have concluded that this Order must be struck down in its entirety as unconstitutional. Indeed, to rule otherwise would be unfaithful to the judgment and vision of the Founding Fathers!" he added.What we're watching: The Trump administration had yet to appeal the rulings striking down the president's orders against WilmerHale, Jenner & Block and Perkins Coie as of early Wednesday.Representatives for the White House and Justice Department did not immediately respond to Axios' request for comment in the evening.Read the order in full, via DocumentCloud: Go deeper: Trump's agenda meets broad resistance from American institutionsEditor's note: This article has been updated with further context.

Comments

World news

On-the-run knifeman arrested in Spain after being given away by his love of yoghurt

Express

What the cluck?! 20,000 Christians condemn 'blasphemy' after cathedral art performance sees half-naked actors dance with plucked chickens in nappies

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

Fears for missing British holidaymaker who vanished just hours after arriving in Portugal with friends - as family make emotional plea

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

Ban on child marriage is deemed 'un-Islamic' by Pakistan's religious leaders

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

Grandmother, 66, crushed to death by bulldozer while sunbathing on holiday as heartbroken ex-husband reveals agony of finding her

about 1 hour ago

Dailymail

Shocking pictures show Tory Lanez covered in blood after being stabbed 14 times inside California prison where he is serving ten years for shooting Megan Thee Stallion

about 1 hour ago

Thames Water fined £123m over sewage – but not £1 of it earmarked for clean-up

The i Paper

Comments

Similar News

Donald Trump doubles down on Canada threats hours after King Charles speech

Elon Musk bemoans DOGE being used as a ‘whipping boy’ by Trump admin as he reveals the agency’s next target

US official claims Trump tariffs brought China to table and halted India-Pakistan conflict

Canada reminds Trump that it already has a King

Trump claims Canada is considering becoming 51st state in exchange for free Golden Dome protection

Bono hits back at Trump over ‘illegal campaign contribution’ allegations during 2024 presidential election

Ukraine pummels Moscow in revenge strike after huge Russian blitz – as Zelensky wants talks with Trump AND ‘crazy’ Putin

Trump warns ‘playing with fire’ Putin that Russia has avoided ‘really bad things’ — thanks to him

Trump halts international student visa applications

Trump’s frustration with Putin boils over with no Ukraine peace deal in sight

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Trump warns Putin he is ‘playing with fire’ with unprecedented drone bombardment

Donald Trump grows angrier as Vladimir Putin exposes his impotence

How Trump Is Helping Washington’s Foes in Africa

Trump’s tariff war will cause global damage, says Grosvenor boss

Noem urges Poles to elect Trump ally as CPAC holds its first meeting in Poland

Outrage erupts after Trump’s Chrisley pardon as critics condemn what it says about president’s regard for the law

NATO set to commit to five percent defense spending goal amid threats from Trump

Trump pledges Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac guarantees will continue

Trump admin asks Supreme Court to restart South Sudan deportations

Nvidia under pressure to show growth despite Trump tariffs

World news

On-the-run knifeman arrested in Spain after being given away by his love of yoghurt

Russia economy meltdown as central bank sparks ‘high risk’ real estate fears

Highly infectious new Covid strain hits three holiday destinations with symptoms alert

UN official says Russia isn't imminently turning on Ukraine's Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant

CVS is closing hundreds of stores nationwide: Here’s where

Victoria’s Secret shut down website due to ‘security incident’

Todd Chrisley shows off his ‘prison bod’ as he makes it home after being pardoned by Trump

Everything we know about the Blatten glacier collapse in Switzerland

US is leaving open the possibility of a troop drawdown in South Korea

UK's Starmer takes aim at Nigel Farage as the Trump ally becomes a growing rival

Thai and Cambodian armies agree to withdraw from disputed area after deadly border clash

Maria Grazia Chiuri exits Dior, capping transformative era for the Paris fashion behemoth

Holiday warning as Saharan dust cloud barrels towards Brit tourist islands & will strike TOMORROW sparking health alert

Inside ‘gateway to underworld’ underneath 1,800-year-old city which holds ‘toxic’ secret that scientists ‘can’t explain’

Girl sold to ‘healer’ by her mum for £800 for her ‘light eyes and skin’

How a new ‘double-edge sword’ weapon is changing warfare in Ukraine

Experts reveal what would happen if supervolcano 1,000 miles from London erupted

The real reason DOGE failed isn’t what you think

Mum and son who flew to Tenerife 'for new life' now live in tent by roadside

Thrill-seekers stranded 50ft in air for hours as 'Top Gun' ride breaks down

Gaza nightmare could be 'stopped' by key move according to negotiations insider

What the cluck?! 20,000 Christians condemn 'blasphemy' after cathedral art performance sees half-naked actors dance with plucked chickens in nappies

Fears for missing British holidaymaker who vanished just hours after arriving in Portugal with friends - as family make emotional plea

Ban on child marriage is deemed 'un-Islamic' by Pakistan's religious leaders

Grandmother, 66, crushed to death by bulldozer while sunbathing on holiday as heartbroken ex-husband reveals agony of finding her

Shocking pictures show Tory Lanez covered in blood after being stabbed 14 times inside California prison where he is serving ten years for shooting Megan Thee Stallion

Thames Water fined £123m over sewage – but not £1 of it earmarked for clean-up

Sip the season with aesthetic drinkware

‘Stand together’: Winnipeg mayor says city ready to help wildfire evacuees

‘It’s very dangerous’: Chief of Manitoba First Nation says some residents await evacuation

7 summer-ready sandal trends you’ll love

CPAC chair plans more conservative gatherings around the world

Air Force think tank warns Chinese space attacks are difficult to deter

The 4 ways in which Trump can defy tariffs court ruling after being dealt major blow

British army veteran forced to pay £20k NHS bill for rest of his life after heart attack

Brits on stag do escorted off easyJet plane by police for 'vaping and abusive behaviour'

Putin's next target in Europe revealed as top general issues Ukraine warning

Kremlin erupts in anger as it warns European country 'being dragged into war'

Panicking Putin begs Europe's closest ally for potatoes as food crisis unravels

Gaza ceasefire talks: What we know as Trump team shares ‘good feeling’ about ending conflict

Ukraine-Russia war latest: Trump sets Putin ‘two week’ peace deadline while Russia to send missiles to Belarus

Philippine president's Cabinet revamp retains defense chief, a vocal critic of China's aggression

Tens of thousands demonstrate in Nepal seeking restoration of ousted monarchy

Pope Leo XIV visits a hilltop summer residence that Francis turned into museum

A South African woman is sentenced to life in prison for selling her young daughter

South Korean navy patrol plane crashes in country's south, police say

Long-shuttered US ambassador's residence in Damascus is reopened as Washington mends ties with Syria

China floods sea bases with nuke bombers, terrifying satellite pics show – as US warns Xi could SEIZE Taiwanese islands

Boyfriend, 19, ‘beats underage ex, 14, to death with rocks & hides her body under cement…before joining search for her’

Another Brit vanishes in Peru as Jamie Cooke isn’t seen in 3 days & family fly out for search – amid Hannah Almond case

This is the future kids want

Girl, six, sold by mother for &#163;800 was 'wanted for eyes and skin', court told

How much a heat pump could save you on heating bills – calculated

I worry I’m a sh*t dad – I’m both money and time-poor

Trump’s entire global agenda has just been torpedoed

Heartless woman caught stealing from cemetery grave to decorate her garden

Never-before-seen Bayesian yacht wreck sheds light on real cause of tragedy

Girl, six, sold by mother for £800 was 'wanted for eyes and skin', court told