Trump's "big, beautiful bill" has Republicans squabbling over math

President Trump's "big, beautiful bill" will either spur unprecedented economic growth or blow up the national debt by trillions depending on which congressional Republican you asked Sunday.Why it matters: There are enough Republican budget hawks in the Senate to scuttle Trump's premier legislative accomplishment if the optimists can't rally their votes.The Congressional Budget Office and others estimate the legislation will add trillions to the deficit over the next decade. But House Speaker Mike Johnson argued Sunday that Congress' own analysts are wrong.What they're saying: Johnson, who predicts the bill will be signed by July 4, said his "friends" concerned that the bill spends too much — including billionaire Elon Musk — are "missing ... the tremendous and historic level of spending cuts that are also in the same package."He dismissed the CBO projection on NBC's "Meet the Press," arguing it assumes "anemic economic growth."Office of Management and Budget Director Russ Vought also argued on CNN's "State of the Union" the bill lowers the deficit by $1.4 trillion.Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on CBS News' "Face the Nation" the CBO score misses "substantial tariff income.""We are going to bring the deficit down slowly," Bessent said.The other side: Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.), responding to Bessent, contended the math "doesn't really add up," saying new spending eclipses cuts identified by the Department of Government Efficiency."I think they're asking for too much money, and in the end, the way you add it up to see if it actually is going to save money or add money is how much debt are they going to borrow?" he continued. "5 trillion over two years. Enormous amount."Musk, who recently departed DOGE, said in an interview that aired Sunday with CBS News' "Sunday Morning," "I think a bill can be big or it can be beautiful.""But I don't know if it could be both," the richest man in the world said.Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.), who wants steeper cuts, called for a return to pre-pandemic spending levels on Fox's "Sunday Morning Futures," arguing, "we cannot continue to mortgage" future generations.By the numbers: The bill is projected to add $3 trillion to 5 trillion to deficits over the next 10 years, dwarfing DOGE's cuts.But the White House argues that tax cut extensions shouldn't count as new costs in the CBO analysis.The bill would expand Trump's 2017 tax cuts, raise the debt ceiling and include significant new spending on border security and the military.Friction point: Bill supporters faced irate crowds at town halls and events last week.Republicans were battered with questions about changes to Medicaid under the guise of curbing waste, fraud and abuse and reductions to SNAP.During questioning at a Friday town hall, Sen. Joni Ernst's (R-Iowa) comment that "we all are going to die" in response to Medicaid concerns drew particular ire. Johnson, pressed Sunday on the millions projected to lose coverage under new work reporting requirements included in the bill, said those people would not lose Medicaid "unless they choose to do so."Go deeper: Scoop: Johnson privately cautions Senate GOP on Trump's budget bill

Comments

World news

Putin’s horror plan to send 10k troops into European country as WW3 fears soar

Express

'I thought the plane would break apart': Ryanair flight makes emergency landing after turbulence throws passengers into ceiling

about 4 hours ago

In Quebec, opposition mounts against a pipeline project that doesn't exist

National Post

Comments

Similar News

Trump slams BBC for ‘taking Hamas’ word as truth’ in alleged Gaza misreporting

Four key reasons for the downfall of Trump and Musk’s presidential bromance

Trump’s 50% tariffs on foreign steel and aluminum take effect | First Thing

Trump’s 50% Tariffs on Steel and Aluminum Imports Go Into Effect

Elon Musk and Rand Paul appear to join forces against Trump and the ‘big, beautiful bill’

Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene roasted for not reading Trump’s ‘big, beautiful bill’

Derek Burney: Is Trump being gamed by Putin in Ukraine ceasefire efforts?

Surging Canadian pride in face of Trump's insults sags after Canada's federal election, poll finds

Elon Musk attacks Trump’s ‘big beautiful’ tax bill as ‘outrageous’ and says it will cause deficit to grow to $2.5tn – US politics live

How will South Korea’s new president engage with Trump’s White House?

As Trump’s Tariffs Nudge Canada Toward Free Interprovincial Trade, Gerard Comeau Gets His Revenge

As Trump Wavers, Europe Is More Optimistic About Defending Ukraine

Musk explodes at Donald Trump branding key bill 'disgusting abomination'

Intruder, 23, storms Trump’s resort ‘looking for teen granddaughter' to marry her

What Trump's fixation on 'white genocide' in South Africa tells us about the U.S.

"White genocide" isn't a thing. Trump disagrees.

Trump's 50% tariffs on steel, aluminum take effect — raising ire of Canada, Mexico and the EU

South Korea's new president has a Trump-shaped crisis to avert

China Really Wants to Attract Talented Scientists. Trump Just Helped.

He claimed to be Trump's 'assassin,' officials say. SoCal man pleads not guilty to threats

World news

Putin’s horror plan to send 10k troops into European country as WW3 fears soar

‘Our hearts are scorched by pain’ – mother and baby killed in Russia drone strike

Brits to skip queues as popular EU tourist destination gives UK access to e-gates

Donald Trump's stunning 1-word verdict on Ukraine's daring raid on Russian bombers

Russia caught using China's 'Silent Hunter' laser gun in attempted invasion of Ukraine

Musk ally hints he lost top NASA job because Trump had ‘axe to grind’

Watch: Celebrating student accidentally kicks girl in the face doing backflip at graduation ceremony

Bodies of two Israeli-American hostages recovered from Gaza

Vanuatu says it has no plans to revoke Andrew Tate’s golden passport after review

Dutch queen gifts bell made from Russian weapons to show solidarity with Ukraine

New German leader plans to discuss Ukraine and trade with Trump in Oval Office visit

Mayors’ alleged drunken country club brawl under investigation as both offer entirely differing accounts of events

Diddy trial live: Combs’s ex-girlfriend and alleged victim ‘Jane’ to testify after woman ‘dangled over balcony’

Trump is ‘losing patience’ with Musk’s criticism as president reposts mogul’s leaving the White House message

Several children injured on school trip after huge branch falls from tree in Polish gorge

Outrage in Spain over new problem tourists are causing - ‘now it’s boats’

The little European country showing Keir Starmer how you can get tough on migration

Iran issued terrifying warning over nuclear programme

Furious Putin chasing Ukrainian agent who tricked drivers into delivering kamikaze drones

Portugal makes huge change to passport queue in win for British holidaymakers

Crisis on Spain holiday island as British tourists warned of major new problem

Elizabeth Warren claims Musk enriched himself to the tune of $100B during his time in the White House

Dad accused of killing three daughters exhibited bizarre behavior in months before their deaths, mother says

Now Trump’s tariffs hit America’s supply of vapes as prices set to skyrocket

Outgoing head of Europe's drug agency warns of surge of violence from stimulant trade

Bloodcurdling moment ruthless soldier cocks his gun & presses it against woman’s temple during restaurant brawl

Inside twisted crew on Greta Thunberg’s Gaza ‘Freedom Flotilla’ from terrorist sympathiser to Nazi-ranting TV presenter

Ryanair passengers injured after storm throws ‘people against cabin roof’

IDF recovers bodies of two Israeli-American hostages from 7 October attack

America’s Electric Vehicle Surrender

What Will China Do Next in Latin America?

Stablecoins Come at a Price

Am I torturing ChatGPT?

Why does Amazon want to scan your palm at the doctor’s office?

Woman accused of killing three people with death cap mushrooms denies measuring 'fatal dose'

Europe's first rover to land on moon - and it's carrying a tiny red house

Will Labour’s free school meals plan really lift 100,000 children out of poverty?

Holiday misery to finally end for Brits as new e-gates open at popular EU airport

The embarrassing truth about people who hate Meghan

AI is remaking everything

North Korean IT workers are using ChatGPT to trick companies into hiring them

Bidenworld goes scorched earth on Karine Jean-Pierre

Scoop: Dozens of congressional Democrats vow to boycott popular D.C. restaurants

Questions swirl over who's running the CDC

Iran brought to standstill as regime ramps-up nuclear missile bid

Ryanair passengers 'thrown against ceiling' during horror flight from hell

Canada wildfires: How to keep yourself safe as smoke from deadly inferno reaches Europe

Italy’s Meloni greenlights controversial laws targeting protests, squatters and cannabis

Ted Cruz leads senators in plan to designate June Pro-Life Month during Pride Month

Grenade launchers and Nazi flag found as veterans arrested for Army base hammer robbery

Who is Greg Monks? The ‘family man’ who went missing in Portugal after stag do

Russian drone strike in northern Ukraine kills five, including toddler, hours after Putin 'revenge' warning

'I thought the plane would break apart': Ryanair flight makes emergency landing after turbulence throws passengers into ceiling

In Quebec, opposition mounts against a pipeline project that doesn't exist

After former Leafs and Blue Jays players, CRA now goes after ex-Raptors star Norman Powell

Brit backpacker, 24, faces 20 years in jail after ‘mowing down dad-of-two on e-scooter following six-hour pub session’

Now Pornhub ban spreads to EUROPE in row over under-18 access – and it includes two other major X-rated sites