Trump's "big, beautiful bill" has Republicans squabbling over math

President Trump's "big, beautiful bill" will either spur unprecedented economic growth or blow up the national debt by trillions depending on which congressional Republican you asked Sunday.Why it matters: There are enough Republican budget hawks in the Senate to scuttle Trump's premier legislative accomplishment if the optimists can't rally their votes.The Congressional Budget Office and others estimate the legislation will add trillions to the deficit over the next decade. But House Speaker Mike Johnson argued Sunday that Congress' own analysts are wrong.What they're saying: Johnson, who predicts the bill will be signed by July 4, said his "friends" concerned that the bill spends too much — including billionaire Elon Musk — are "missing ... the tremendous and historic level of spending cuts that are also in the same package."He dismissed the CBO projection on NBC's "Meet the Press," arguing it assumes "anemic economic growth."Office of Management and Budget Director Russ Vought also argued on CNN's "State of the Union" the bill lowers the deficit by $1.4 trillion.Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on CBS News' "Face the Nation" the CBO score misses "substantial tariff income.""We are going to bring the deficit down slowly," Bessent said.The other side: Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.), responding to Bessent, contended the math "doesn't really add up," saying new spending eclipses cuts identified by the Department of Government Efficiency."I think they're asking for too much money, and in the end, the way you add it up to see if it actually is going to save money or add money is how much debt are they going to borrow?" he continued. "5 trillion over two years. Enormous amount."Musk, who recently departed DOGE, said in an interview that aired Sunday with CBS News' "Sunday Morning," "I think a bill can be big or it can be beautiful.""But I don't know if it could be both," the richest man in the world said.Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.), who wants steeper cuts, called for a return to pre-pandemic spending levels on Fox's "Sunday Morning Futures," arguing, "we cannot continue to mortgage" future generations.By the numbers: The bill is projected to add $3 trillion to 5 trillion to deficits over the next 10 years, dwarfing DOGE's cuts.But the White House argues that tax cut extensions shouldn't count as new costs in the CBO analysis.The bill would expand Trump's 2017 tax cuts, raise the debt ceiling and include significant new spending on border security and the military.Friction point: Bill supporters faced irate crowds at town halls and events last week.Republicans were battered with questions about changes to Medicaid under the guise of curbing waste, fraud and abuse and reductions to SNAP.During questioning at a Friday town hall, Sen. Joni Ernst's (R-Iowa) comment that "we all are going to die" in response to Medicaid concerns drew particular ire. Johnson, pressed Sunday on the millions projected to lose coverage under new work reporting requirements included in the bill, said those people would not lose Medicaid "unless they choose to do so."Go deeper: Scoop: Johnson privately cautions Senate GOP on Trump's budget bill

Comments

World news

Cooler weather, light rain helping some provinces in fight against wildfires

Global News

Comments

Similar News

Will Musk's explosive row with Trump help or harm his businesses?

Kash Patel has live ‘WTF’ moment on Joe Rogan as he learns of Trump vs. Musk mid-interview

Elon Musk’s crash-out killed conservatives’ momentum — and likely guaranteed passage of Trump’s ‘big beautiful bill’

The Economics of Trump’s Budget and Policy Bill

Elon Musk and Donald Trump’s fallout, explained

Buyer With Ties to Chinese Communist Party Got V.I.P. Treatment at Trump Crypto Dinner

You can now bet on the next steps in the Trump-Musk fallout and when they will have their first meeting

Trump administration scrambling to rehire workers cut by DOGE to fill critical government roles

Linda McMahon says Harvard and Columbia making ‘progress’ to meet Trump’s demands to stop antisemitism

Kash Patel has live ‘WTF’ moment on Joe Rogan as he learns of Trump vs. Musk mid-interview

JD Vance silence on Musk may be the most Game of Thrones tactic ever — and Trump might not even notice

Trump announces US-China trade talks in London next week

"He's a lunatic": Democrats shut down idea of Musk alliance after break with Trump

Trump brings the BOOM! New order opens skies across US to supersonic flights

‘Big Balls’ and other Musk DOGE proteges could see payback from Trump-Elon feud after mass firings

Trump sends Bessent and Lutnick to haggle with Chinese on tariff war after Xi chat

The Latest: Trump-Musk relationship appears to implode

Trump's bill is floundering in the Senate as Musk attacks intensify

Why Trump probably can’t cut Musk loose

"He's a lunatic": Democrats shut down idea of Musk alliance after break with Trump

World news

Cooler weather, light rain helping some provinces in fight against wildfires

Spencer Carbery named winner of NHL’s Jack Adams Award

Israel retrieves body of Thai hostage as 95 people are reported killed in Gaza

U.S. immigration authorities extend activity in Los Angeles area amid street protests

Munich shooting: Woman, 30, shot dead by police after 'attacking two people with knife'

Trump: 'Not my decision' to bring Kilmar Abrego Garcia back from El Salvador

Vladimir Putin frontline shambles as deserters ‘gun down’ official

Panic in Spain as it announces new crackdown on overtourism

Polling on Elon Musk glaring red light for Republicans

Man killed wife and son, 7, before turning gun on himself after becoming depressed over ‘unemployment,’ family says

Stephen Miller calls mass LA protests against ICE raids an ‘insurrection’ as unrest continues

The tiny sport stirring up a big controversy in Spain

Police officer accidentally shot and killed by her colleague in Chicago

Small sport stirs up controversy in Spain as Basque Country makes its international debut

More bodies of executed civil war-era prisoners uncovered under Greek city park

Chaos erupts at Paramount Home Depot as protesters confront immigration agents

Britain is ALREADY at war with Russia and ‘we are in pretty big trouble’ admits defence expert in bombshell warning

Woman, 30, shot dead by armed cops after ‘attacking two people with knife’ in square used for Oktoberfest

Eight-year-old boy found starved and murdered in loft and left in a rubbish bag

What to know about counterprotests to Trump's June 14 parade

U.K. judge warns of risk to justice after lawyers cited fake AI-generated cases in court

‘He’s a battler’: Veteran Corey Perry playing key role for Oilers in Stanley Cup final

Trump says Musk could face ‘serious consequences’ if he backs Democrats

Six killed by Israeli gunfire near Gaza aid site, Hamas officials say

Death row inmate's final meal so controversial it's now banned

Humiliation for Putin as £74m fighter jet erupts in fireball after new Ukraine's attack

Trump National Golf Club in Bedminster responds after receiving devastating health department grade

Musk may indeed have won Trump the election. But his Wisconsin cheesehead humiliation proved he’d lost the juice

Chicago cop shot and killed by fellow officer in friendly fire incident during tactical operation

Chabria: ICE arrested a California union leader. Does Trump understand what that means?

Teen, 19, dies after viral TikTok ‘dusting’ challenge went wrong leaving family ‘utterly devastated’

Deadly Russian strikes condemned as 'savage' - as dozens more injured in Ukrainian city

Carney says Canada to focus on peace, energy security and new partnerships at G7 meeting

Kilmar Abrego Garcia back in U.S., charged with human smuggling as lawyers vow ongoing fight

Alberta buying U.S. alcohol again, months after pause meant to fight tariffs

Police investigate possible poisoning after man dies, woman hospitalized north of Montreal

Trump says relationship with Musk is over

Hamlin undeterred by ruling siding with NASCAR in lawsuit filed by Jordan-owned 23XI and Front Row

Bucharest gay pride march turns 20 as LGBTQ+ Romanians face growing hostility from right-wing groups

Vegetable sculpture contest features a squash Donald Trump and a papal 'cornclave'

American father wanted for allegedly killing his three daughters may be trying to flee to Canada

Parents of Brit backpacker, 24, facing 20 years in prison over fatal e-scooter crash fly to Australia

England player ratings as 4/10 Palmer sums up Tuchel’s muddled tactics

England jeered as Roy Keane criticises ‘bored’ players in laboured Andorra win

Murder suspect 'marries teen model girlfriend in secret wedding' while on run from police

Stanley Cup final: Marchand plays hero for Panthers in Game 2 win over Oilers

Prairie wildfires having air quality impact on several provinces

Russian attacks on Ukrainian city of Kharkiv kill 4

Health Canada warns consumers not to inhale ‘laughing gas’ recreationally

Gender stereotypes shape reactions to Trump-Musk outburst

Elks open regular season against Lions in Vancouver on Saturday

Calgary Stampeders set to start new CFL season with Vernon Adams Jr. at QB

Liberia's ex-speaker charged with arson over parliament fire

Russian attack on eastern Ukrainian city of Kharkiv kills 3, wounds 21

Why were so many Thai farmers among the hostages held by Hamas?

New powers demanded to tackle Russia's 'shadow fleets'

Donald Trump issues stark warning to Elon Musk as furious row continues