What's different about the Charlie Kirk firings

Companies are reacting to pressure from Republican officials and right-wing activists and quickly firing anyone who attempts to justify or minimize the killing of Charlie Kirk — or even criticize the slain conservative activist.Why it matters: These firings could be legal, lawyers say, but they demonstrate fast-changing norms around free speech that many find troubling.They also signify an increased vigilance among employers when it comes to workers' social media posts.Where it stands: Dozens of such terminations have been publicly reported at media companies, airlines, sports teams and federal agencies.In the public sector, teachers, government workers and community officials have also been fired or put on leave in recent days due to their commentary on the violence.Zoom in: Delta Air Lines, United and American Airlines suspended workers over the weekend for their social media activity."Employees who promote such violence on social media were immediately removed from service," American Airlines said in a statement. "We will continue to initiate action with team members who display this kind of behavior." "We've been clear with our customers and employees that there's zero tolerance for politically motivated violence or any attempt to justify it," said United Airlines.Between the lines: Since the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel, employers have put out much more detailed policies outlining what workers can do on social media — including language that requires employees to abide by company values and restricts them from inciting violence."These situations are very fact specific and really depend on what the individual said and the context in which they said it. It also depends on what the social media policies the individual's employer has," Ellen Davis, senior managing director at August, told Axios.Davis added that condoning or calling for violence is typically grounds for termination. "And if companies don't have clear social media policies by now, they should," she said. Reality check: This isn't new — employers in the past have fired workers for social media posts, both left- and right-leaning, that were deemed unacceptable. "Lots of people have been terminated for their positions, their political positions, and speech," says Ryan Hancock, an employment lawyer at Willig, Williams & Davidson.The big picture: In the U.S., most employment in the private sector is "at will," meaning companies can fire workers for any reason that isn't clearly discriminatory — terminating someone because of their race or gender or age.Some states, including California and Colorado, have laws that prohibit companies from firing people for their political speech.Union contracts also may include some prohibitions — though in the federal government, the White House has canceled contracts for hundreds of thousands of employees."The robust free speech protections that we think of in this country are somewhat lesser in the context of employer-employee relationships," says G.S. Hans, a professor at Cornell Law School who focuses on the First Amendment. That's even true in the public sector — the Supreme Court has said that employees surrender some free speech rights to take government employment, notes David Super, an administrative law expert at Georgetown Law.Zoom out: Still, typically employers have been more hesitant to act — held back by norms around free speech. And, typically, government officials don't pressure or threaten workers — that's the most concerning piece of what's happening now, say constitutional lawyers."It seems quite at odds with what we think about as being the free speech tradition of a country," says Hans. "That's not an absolute protection, but it's certainly a cultural one."Reality check: Employers have all the power in these situations, says Hancock. Whether or not these firings pass legal muster depends on what happens after the firing — whether workers challenge these actions in court and if state protections, or others, apply.Between the lines: In the case of federal workers, challenges are going to be tough. Their complaints of wrongful firings are supposed to go before an agency called the Merit Systems Protections Board, but at the moment it can't hear cases because the White House has fired some of its members."Trump officials can fire government employees for openly political grounds knowing that their actions are not subject to review," says Georgetown's Super.More on Axios: Chesterfield School Board member to resign after Charlie Kirk postBehind the Curtain: Four ominous trends

Comments

World news

Greg Gutfeld curses at colleague live on air for bringing up Melissa Hortman during Charlie Kirk discussion

Independent

Comments

World news

Greg Gutfeld curses at colleague live on air for bringing up Melissa Hortman during Charlie Kirk discussion

New York reveals rules in bid to stop children becoming addicted to social media

Fingerprint on scope matches man accused of trying to assassinate Trump, FBI says

Man’s daring escape from Gaza where he used a jet ski to get to Europe – after trying China

Netanyahu claims trade boycotts over Gaza will force Israeli economy to become ‘super Sparta’

Whoops! Yellowstone geologists pull 300 hats from hot springs

Plane crashes near sports pitch at Toronto high school

Trump wants to be a cultural tastemaker. The CIA did it first.

Ed Davey: Why I’m boycotting Trump’s state banquet

State pension to rise by more than £500 a year from April under triple lock

I hated landlords until I became one – tenants are just ungrateful

All landlords are exploiting someone – ‘good’ landlords are lying to themselves

I was a good landlord. It ended up costing me my flat

Fears ‘draconian’ new rules will cut pension credit take-up from poorer retirees

Starmer’s Trump plan is in disarray – this is how experts think he can save it

I never had a big friendship group – now I know why

Gas leak at Sydney restaurant kills 25-year-old man and leaves 7 hospitalised

Tyler Robinson: Suspect in Charlie Kirk shooting set to face charges on Tuesday

Report claims thousands of children taken from Ukraine to be ‘re-educated’ by Russia

My evacuation from Gaza City: ‘I told my terrified toddler we’re going camping’

Luigi Mangione due in court amid double jeopardy fight in CEO killing

Israel IS committing genocide against Palestinians, says UN inquiry as IDF bombards Gaza City

Madeleine McCann ‘could have been stolen to order by paedophile network’

Australia warns social media over age checks as child ban plan moves forward

UN Commission says Israel is committing genocide in Gaza

Israel's Qatar attack was a costly failure

Israel launches fresh operation in major escalation amid warning 'Gaza is burning'

Four atrocities in horror UN report 'confirms Israel committing genocide' in Gaza

Coachella line up in full - all 132 acts performing at US music festival as Justin Bieber headlines

Russia raises tensions with NATO as Putin shows off his battlefield nuclear weapons

Charlie Kirk traveled across America. His security varied from venue to venue

Two men jailed for plot to kill president with witchcraft in Zambia

Dad threatened by ICE deportation days after being shot during robbery

‘Gaza is burning’: Israel reportedly begins ground offensive after Netanyahu threatens Hamas leaders

Donald Trump says he will sue New York Times for $15bn

Israel is committing genocide in Gaza, UN probe finds

‘Tooth-in-eye’ surgery enables man to see again after 20 years

Trump says he will sue the New York Times for $15bn

Is Keir Starmer already toast? I don’t think so

Apple TV+ swept the Emmys – these are the 11 shows to watch

Haitians yearn for home as gangs welcome them and police warn it's too dangerous

Father kills his own baby daughter on Facebook Live before taking his own life

Watch: JD Vance hosts Charlie Kirk's daily talk radio show

Why more women get cancer in India - but more men die

Malawi votes for next president as cost-of-living bites

They were shot dead for protesting against corruption in Nepal

Belarus and Russia's show of firepower appears to be a message to Europe

Google owner reveals £5bn AI investment in UK ahead of Trump visit

US Secretary of State inaugurates Israeli settler-led archaeological site in Jerusalem

Trump says he will sue New York Times for $15bn

Nigerian chef breaks world record for largest jollof rice dish

Chinese teens to pay $300,000 for urinating in soup

Report those who celebrate Charlie Kirk death to employers, Vance says

Israel escalates bombardment as defence minister says 'Gaza is burning'

Beaten and held in Russia for three years - but never charged with a crime

Trump's state visit is mired with potential pitfalls despite careful planning

Trump says the U.S. military targeted a boat allegedly carrying drugs from Venezuela

Federal Judge Declines to Intervene for Migrants Deported to Ghana

Florida attorney general says cops should stop enforcing open carry gun ban after court ruling

Russia shows off conventional and nuclear military might in drills — and raises tensions with NATO