When the president does, and doesn't, own the economy

It's usually a mistake to attribute economic conditions in the weeks after a presidential inauguration to the person in the Oval Office.Right now is not one of those times.The big picture: The U.S. economy is a mighty tanker ship, slow to turn. So much so that presidents usually don't affect its short-term course. The exception is when they take sweeping, rapid action on a massive scale.Both the last two presidents have done that, resulting in economic data that can be directly mapped to policy choices.President Trump's aggressive tariff agenda led companies to front-run import orders over the first three months of the year, the major cause of a contraction in Q1 GDP.Former President Biden implemented a $1.9 trillion pandemic relief bill in early 2021, far larger than most estimates of the size of the hole the economy was in. That contributed to the high inflation that followed, though economists disagree over how much.Driving the news: On Wednesday, Trump said of Q1's GDP contraction that "that's Biden — that's not Trump."He later added, "You could even say the next quarter is sort of Biden."Between the lines: In most presidencies, that would be a pretty reasonable way to think of it. Most presidential actions that affect the economy — taxes and spending, regulatory stance, appointments to the Federal Reserve and other agencies — do so with long and uncertain lags.For example, former President George W. Bush took office in January 2001 and a recession began in March 2001. But by any reasonable accounting, that recession was caused by the popping of the stock market bubble that developed under former President Clinton.When former President Obama took office in January 2009, he inherited an economy that had already been in recession for a year. The recession did not end until that summer.In other words, it's misguided to tell a story in which the 2001 recession was due to Bush's policies, or that the economic contraction in the first half of 2009 was Obama's doing.Reality check: By contrast, there is a crystal clear line between Trump's policies and this week's economic data.A rise in imports by companies looking to get ahead of the new tariffs caused a surge in Q1 imports, which subtracted 5 percentage points from reported GDP growth. (That will likely reverse itself in Q2, as importers pull back due to the tariffs and the excess inventories they accumulated in Q1.)The trade war's more aggressive phase began right after Q1 ended, with the April 2 "Liberation Day" tariff announcement. That set off stock market gyrations and a plunge in business and consumer confidence that will shape economic results for the second quarter.The bottom line: It's absolutely true that popular discourse attributes too much about economic outcomes, especially in the short term, to the person in the Oval Office.But when presidents make big, splashy moves in economic policy, and the data moves as you might expect based on those moves, the cause and effect is hard to ignore.

Comments

World news

Musk plans for billions of humanoid robots, personal R2-D2s and C-3POs

washington times

‘I am completely dead now’: Pilot, 72, who died in a crash penned his own obituary detailing his close brushes with death

about 3 hours ago

EPA weakens regulations aimed at curbing forever chemical pollution in drinking water

Independent

Comments

World news

Musk plans for billions of humanoid robots, personal R2-D2s and C-3POs

Dem Sen. Reed criticizes Trump plan to cut Pentagon personnel

DIA predicts China will have 4,000 hypersonic missiles by 2035

Ryanair blow as Spanish court issues £123 order over hand luggage charges

POLL: Should Russia be punished if Putin doesn’t meet Zelensky?

The 1 reason 'failing' Vladimir Putin is unlikely to meet Zelensky tomorrow

The celebrities mentioned during Diddy’s sex trafficking trial

Trump admin officials pen NYT op-ed describing welfare restrictions as an ‘opportunity’: ‘Work is transformative’

Donald Trump praises ‘young, attractive’ ex-terrorist Syrian leader Ahmed al-Sharaa

USAID looking for lawyers to target employees who spoke to media

Texas continues to restrict the care women receive - but hey, moms could soon use the carpool lane

Kristi Noem won’t say if Trump’s photo of Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s tattoos was ‘doctored’

Albania's prime minister thanks voters for landslide win and pledges EU membership by 2030

Only a fool would dismiss Kim Kardashian’s trauma – she’s built an empire on it

Rose West now: Everything we know about serial killer’s life in prison

Inside ‘degrading’ Georgian prison where British teen could spend the rest of her life

Nova Scotia electric utility says stolen customer data includes bank account numbers

Finance minister says no 2025 budget, while government focuses on fall update

Canada’s telecoms say roaming revenue is down as U.S. travel drops

Concerns raised as 2 Metro Vancouver transportation mega-projects face delays

Newcomers feeling Canadian during playoff hockey

Vancouver Canucks tap assistant coach Adam Foote as new bench boss

Should you move up plans to buy a home? Gauge the risks and rewards

Toronto mom charged with attempted murder after 4-year-old falls from condo balcony

B.C. premier set to provide update on trade diversification

Peel police investigate after man dies in daylight Mississauga shooting

U.S. overdose deaths fell 27% in 2024, a new 1-year record

Calgary high school put on lockdown after student attacked with a weapon

Modi Has Changed India’s Military Doctrine

Saudi Arabia brings in mobile McDonald's truck for fast-food loving Donald Trump

Putin mocks West and Ukraine by refusing to confirm if he's attending peace talks

Trump's meeting with Sharaa, unthinkable just months ago, boosts Syrians' hopes

US Lining Up More Countries to Take Its Deportees

Top moments from Axios' Future of Health summit

Merz vows to keep the U.S. on board on Ukraine and strengthen Germany's military and economy

Israeli airstrikes in Gaza kill 70 people, including 22 children, health officials say

Brazil's Lula says he will urge Putin 'go to Istanbul and negotiate' with Zelenskyy

A French mining company sues Niger after its director disappears and offices are raided

France's premier facing questions from an inquiry on a Catholic school abuse scandal

An explosion at a chemical plant near Spain's Seville leads to warnings for thousands

Thai officials seize over 200 tons of illegally imported electronic waste from the U.S.

What would lifting U.S. sanctions on Syria mean to the war-torn country?

Bombshell Noah’s Ark discovery could prove Bible story is true

Russian economy nightmare as Putin panics over inflation with stockmarket in freefall

Inside Putin and Zelensky's last meeting 6 years ago - and the ceasefire they discussed

Clerk in Alex Murdaugh double murder trial is arrested on misconduct and obstruction charges

White House backed down on China’s tariff after president was told they would hurt ‘Trump’s people’ the most

Baby oil, sexual desires and violence: What are Diddy’s ‘freak offs’ that have become a key part of his trial?

Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs left ex-girlfriend with a ‘fat lip’ and bruises after infamous 2016 hotel attack, Cassie testifies

‘I am completely dead now’: Pilot, 72, who died in a crash penned his own obituary detailing his close brushes with death

EPA weakens regulations aimed at curbing forever chemical pollution in drinking water

Job hunter realizes he’s being interviewed by AI when the script starts glitching

Newsmax host defends Qatar’s gift to Trump then admits he’d ‘definitely criticize’ Biden for the same thing

Montana man killed wife, and kids, 6 and 7 months, in murder suicide, police say

Cassie tells Diddy trial that rap mogul trapped her in abuse with threat to release 'freak off' sex videos

Price of butter, chocolate, coffee and potatoes soars – and costs will go higher

How the UK state pension compares to the rest of Europe

Staff blame BBC for ‘enabling Lineker’ as anger over Zionism post grows

Owner sentenced to house arrest after Ontario child mauled by 3 dogs

Wildfires raging in northwestern Ontario trigger evacuation alerts