End Of The Keir Show: How Senior Labour Figures Now Believe Starmer Is Already Toast

Time appears to be running out for Keir Starmer.Morgan McSweeney, prime minister Keir Starmer’s most trusted adviser, was sent out to bat for his boss this week.The No.10 chief of staff went to committee room 4A in the House of Lords to face Labour peers, field their questions and explain how he and the PM plan to dig the government out of the deep hole in which it finds itself.More than 80 of them turned up, including party grandees like former leader Neil Kinnock, George Robertson and Margaret Hodge.As one peer present pointed out to HuffPost UK, they are not generally the toughest of crowds.“We listen to what people have to say and politely applaud afterwards,” he said. “It’s not exactly Friday night at the Glasgow Empire.”Nevertheless, it did not go well for McSweeney or, by extension, Keir Starmer.One peer said: “It was like a car crash in slow motion. If you’re going to come down from No.10 to see us, you need to come out fighting, say this is the mess we inherited, this is what’s going wrong and this is how we’re going to fix it.“But there was no energy, no ideas and he didn’t have any answers to our questions. It was really very damaging.”Another Lord in the room said: “McSweeney might be a good political campaigner, but he isn’t a chief of staff because he’s not getting things done.“He just kept saying he noted our concerns and would report back. It was a really depressing meeting.”Barely 24 hours later, the already-sulphurous mood in the Parliamentary Labour Party (PLP) got even worse when the result of the Caerphilly by-election confirmed their worst fears.Plaid Cymru won with 47% of the vote, bringing to an end more than a century of Labour dominance in the constituency.Labour’s Richard Tunnicliffe trailed in a miserable third place with just 11% of the vote, well behind the second placed Reform candidate Llyr Powell.“By any objective assessment, it’s an absolute disaster,” said one senior Labour source.“If it had happened under Jeremy Corbyn, the party would be in absolute meltdown, and rightly so. It was even worse than our most pessimistic scenario.”One Labour frontbencher summed up the gloom which has now descended on the PLP and shows no sign of lifting.“It’s just added to the toaster-in-the-bath mood among MPs,” he said. “If there is any attempt to blame party staff, the campaign, Welsh Labour or the candidate, it will backfire badly.”Increasing numbers of Labour MPs and peers have long since come to the conclusion that the blame lies with one man – Starmer himself.“It’s not working, it’s not going to work and the sooner he goes, the better,” said one veteran peer.While next May’s elections in Wales, Scotland and across England – where Labour are on course for another drubbing – are still seen as the most likely time for the PM to be removed, a growing number now believe he may not even see in the New Year in Downing Street.“I think people are now in a place where they believe this can’t continue and we can’t go into massive midterm elections with him in charge,” one insider told HuffPost UK.“The chances of him being gone my Christmas is massively under-priced. People will let the Budget happen at the end of November, and then there could be a move against him.“If a new leader comes in then and puts 5% on the polls, suddenly things look a lot better. We don’t get utterly decimated in Wales, the Scottish result is a bit better and you save a whole load of councillors.” It's not working, it's not going to work and the sooner he goes the betterLabour peerA Labour peer said: “I get the argument about leaving it till May and letting a new leader come in and pick up the pieces, but that’s easy for MPs to say because it’s not their jobs on the line.“What about all the poor councillors who’ll lose their seats? Those are the foot soldiers we’re going to need come the next election.“Even those who I would describe as loyalists think he can’t last, and the rest of us have made up our minds as well.”If he does end up being ousted, Starmer’s critics say he will only have himself to blame.Never the most clubbable of politicians, the PM is rarely seen in the Commons, where many of his predecessors could be seen chatting to their MPs, listening to their concerns and getting a feel for the mood within the party.In the past two months he has only taken part in four parliamentary votes, all of which happened on the same day. Starmer’s decision to delegate sackings in his recent reshuffle, rather than deliver the bad news himself, also went down badly among MPs, and swelled the ranks of the disaffected.It has not gone unnoticed that health secretary Wes Streeting, tipped by many as a potential successor, has been particularly active in recent months, including doing the raffle at a Labour Friends of Scotland event last Tuesday night.“He’s regularly in Strangers Bar chatting to MPs and doing favours for them – and he’s right to do so,” said one former minister.Wes Streeting is seen by many as a PM-in-waitingLucy Powell, one of those sacked in the reshuffle, is expected to defeat education secretary Bridget Phillipson to become Labour’s deputy leader when the result is announced on Saturday.That will be seen as the party membership passing a damning verdict on the government’s performance so far, and therefore another blow for Starmer.One experienced Labour figure did offer a glimmer of hope for the embattled PM, however.He said: “The thing that’s keeping him there is that they’ve not changed the rules by which you elect leaders and deputy leaders. It’s still in the hands of members, who by definition are not representative of the wider electorate.“The person who would probably win at the moment is Ed Miliband or Angela Rayner, neither of whom are up to it. Wes might be in five or ten years, but he’s not match fit yet. There is no viable alternative.“I think he’ll probably be in there longer than people think, unless he says I can’t take any more of this and just decides to go.”Whatever the timing, it is becoming increasingly clear that it is a matter of when, rather than if, Starmer’s ill-starred time as PM comes to an end.

Comments

Breaking news

Map shows where Russian jets entered Nato airspace in latest violation

Metro

Fourth Charing Cross Met Police officer fired after BBC Panorama film

BBC News

Comments

Similar News

Hakeem Jeffries ends will-he-won’t-he mystery over endorsement in Mamdani-Cuomo NYC mayor’s race

Tougher sentences for murderers who kill at end of a relationship take effect

Tourist ends up teetering on the edge of a cliff in his Porsche after following GPS 'shortcut' through Italian farm

Prince Andrew 'in talks to leave Royal Lodge': Disgraced royal on verge of 'quitting' Windsor mansion - but could get compensation for ending lease early

Trump Ends Trade Talks with Canada over 'Fraudulent' anti-Tariff TV Ads

Is this the end of Kim Kardashian the brand? Star reveals she plans on giving up her influencer lifestyle to become a lawyer and tells Graham Norton she'll be qualified in two weeks

On the Jaw-Dropping West End Girl, Lily Allen Sets A New Bar For The Confessional Break-Up Album

Spain's strict new drink driving laws to be enforced by the end of 2025 - and they include cyclists and e-scooters

Lily Allen's New Album West End Hailed As 'Brutal', 'Gobsmacking' And 'Unflinching' In Reviews

Lily Allen's West End Girl: Pop star details 'intensely personal' journey through divorce from cheating husband David Harbour, ADRIAN THRILLS reviews her captivating breakup album

Rashford wants to stay at Barcelona when loan ends

Canada cuts tariff relief on some US cars due to Stellantis, GM ending some Canadian production

Hypemaster: Elon Musk's Tesla Earnings Call Focuses on Robots Ending 'Poverty' Instead of Selling EVs

Is this the end of 'White Van Man'?: 36% of tradespeople are carrying their tools around in car boots to deter brazen thieves

Now, end the witch hunt! Campaigners' demands after elderly ex-Para hounded over Bloody Sunday killings more than 50 years ago is cleared of ALL charges

Trump pardons Binance founder convicted on money laundering charges to end ‘war on crypto’

‘Absolutely no way’ digital ID will end up tracking Brits’ lives, says Starmer

Dem Rep. Smith: Shutdown 'May Well End' When Dems Decide to Make Deal After November 1

One in 20 churches could shut by end of decade: Up to 2,000 places of worship face closure by 2030 as repair bills soar

Mets All-Star Predicted to End Free Agency After 4-Year, $80 Million Blockbuster

Breaking news

Map shows where Russian jets entered Nato airspace in latest violation

Can Mushroom Gummies Replace Your Morning Coffee?

Hakeem Jeffries ends will-he-won’t-he mystery over endorsement in Mamdani-Cuomo NYC mayor’s race

Afghanistan and Pakistan head to Turkey for second round of crisis talks

US Secretary of State accuses UNRWA of being ‘subsidiary of Hamas’ and insists Trump Gaza plan is ‘only option’

‘Next Hall of Fame player arrested for illegal gambling’: Wagering site takes prop bets over NBA Mafia scandal

Government shutdown likely means no inflation data next month for 1st time in decades

Coffee beans pooped out by this mammal have better flavor and aromatic compounds: New study

Starmer vows Ukraine allies will take Russian oil and gas off market after Trump sanctions

Police arrest 19-year-old for stabbing two people – one fatally – hours apart at Chick-fil-A

Attorney says electrocardiogram at Tennessee execution was active after inmate was pronounced dead

New York Knicks slap Mamdani with cease-and-desist over mayor’s race ad and say NBA team does ‘not endorse’ him

Inspector Clouseau? The mystery man in an AP photo after the Louvre jewel heist creates a buzz

A Black woman was fatally shot in her home by a cop after calling 911 for help. He’s now on trial for her murder

‘Disappointed’ Starmer in firing line over historic by-election defeat for Labour in Caerphilly

Good Samaritan thwarts suspect trying to grab 2-year-old from her mom on Pennsylvania street

Jon Bon Jovi talks first tour since vocal cord surgery, new album and Bruce Springsteen

As Israel returns bodies, Palestinians face a grisly search through corpses for lost loved ones

Stirlingshire carer takes home top award after work on poverty and disability

Sex attacker strangled and raped woman in Edinburgh street attack after house party

'Devil monster' woman who raped and murdered French schoolgirl jailed for life

Dramatic images of Shark found dead on rocks at Scottish coastline

Arctic air to bring first significant cold snap of season - with snow possible

China 'enemy' reference removed from key witness statement for collapsed spy trial

US sends its largest aircraft carrier to South American waters

Clown mask killer stabbed gang rival to death and hunted others with shotgun

Asylum seeker jailed for sexual assault of woman and girl, 14, freed by mistake

Manchester student died after 'ambulance call workers said just take paracetamol'

Horror moment woman screams for help in Paris 'train attack' before hero jumps in

Claudia Winkleman reveals she planned to quit Strictly with Tess Daly in 'pizza pact'

Keir Starmer urges allies to 'finish the job' on using frozen Russian assets to strengthen Ukraine's defences - as Coalition of the Willing meets in London

Amy Schumer, 44, has 'lost at least 40lbs' thanks to Mounjaro as she flashes tiny waistline in selfie

Hannah Waddingham looks elegant in a burgundy coat at Cheltenham Showcase after being tipped as future host of Strictly Come Dancing

Moment armed police arrest ringleader outside B&Q for torching Ukraine-linked warehouse for 'easy money' from Russian spies - as gang is jailed for total of 65 years

Horse-riding instructor who 'had threesome with underage girl' is jailed for five years - as his showjumper girlfriend avoids prison

Footsie races to record high as investors bet on interest rate cuts in US

Jeremy Clarkson warned charity boss and Tory peer Baroness Monckton not to open a pub giving her 'a list of things that could and would go wrong', she tells Parliament

Influencer HSTikkyTokky pleads guilty to driving offences almost a year after police launched manhunt to find him

Hebrew words torn down in prayer room at London university where pro-Palestine activist 'threatened to behead' Israeli academic

Inside Andrew's family summit: How Fergie wailed and 'melted down' at title loss, Beatrice and Eugenie were 'blindsided' and now daughters' assets face 'ethics check' to avoid more scandal: BARBARA DAVIES

Fourth Charing Cross Met Police officer fired after BBC Panorama film

Manhunt after jailed Epping hotel asylum seeker mistakenly released

Reeves refuses to rule out income tax rises in Budget

Asylum seeker guilty of hotel worker's savage murder at railway station

Windrush victims to get 75% compensation upfront in scheme shake-up

Speed Limits Are Taking the Wind Out of Cyclists’ Exhilarating Commutes

Hakeem Jeffries Gives Mamdani Last-Minute Endorsement for N.Y.C. Mayor

A Woman Self-Deported, Hoping to Shield Her Son. He Was Detained Anyway.

U.S. Flies Drones Over Gaza to Monitor Cease-Fire, Officials Say

Inflation Edged Higher in September as Fed Prepares to Cut Rates Again

Republicans Who Have Rarely Opposed Trump Raise Questions About His Drug War

FDA Approves New Menopause Drug to Treat Hot Flashes and Night Sweats

How Does the U.S. Decide Which Boats to Target? Here’s What We Know.

Tougher sentences for murderers who kill at end of a relationship take effect

‘Surveillance society’: Will you be signing up for a digital ID?

Epping hotel asylum seeker who sexually assaulted girl ‘freed by mistake’

Prince Andrew could soon move out of the Royal Lodge in Windsor