Labour MP Leaves Former Tory Minister Speechless By Pointing Out Obvious Fact About Trans Ruling

Dawn Butler and Simon ClarkeA Labour MP left a former Conservative minister tripping over his words during a clash over trans rights last week.After the Supreme Court ruling earlier this month that a woman is defined by biology – and not gender – questions have been raised over exactly how that will impact the trans community.The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) said last week that trans women should not be “permitted to use the women’s facilities” in workplaces or public-facing services like shops and hospitals – and the same applies to trans men.The watchdog did acknowledge that trans people still need access to public facilities, but is yet to explain how that would work in practice.Meanwhile, the government has insisted trans women should use the men’s toilets, and trans men use the women’s toilets.But, as backbencher Dawn Butler pointed out on Sky News last week, this decision does not exactly help boost women’s safety, despite the government’s promises.She said: “Trans women, in my opinion, should of course, continue to use women’s bathrooms.”Former chief secretary to the Treasury Simon Clarke began to protest, pointing out this went against the Supreme Court’s ruling, but the Labour MP cut in.“I do not police people in public toilets,” Butler said. “I think that’s where we are getting to as a society, in policing what a woman looks like.“I have a butch lesbian friend who gets hounded out of women’s toilets and it is heartbreaking to the point where we have to escort her into the women’s toilets because she’s going to be hounded out.”She continued: “If trans men then have to use women’s toilets, that’s going to make women less safe, because how are you going to stop a man – a ‘normal’ man – going into a women’s toilet and saying, ‘I am a trans man.’”“I don’t follow that logic,” the former MP – who lost his seat in July – said. “The point is, we’re saying that people who are biologically men shouldn’t be using the women’s toilets, that’s the point of this ruling.”Butler reminded him: “A trans man is biologically a woman, so they would then have to use women’s toilets.”There was a long pause, before Clarke, looking completely flabbergasted, said: “I.. I think this...”“That’s the problem. That’s what concerns me!” Butler said.The debate came days before senior Cabinet Office minister Pat McFadden told the BBC there would be no policing of public toilets."Trans women should of course still continue to use women's bathrooms... I do not police people in public toilets."@DawnButlerBrent sets out the practicalities around the Supreme Court ruling that the definition of a 'woman' is a 'biological woman'.#PoliticsHub ⬇️ pic.twitter.com/Jhc6oy2PHM— Politics Hub with Sophy Ridge (@SkyPoliticsHub) April 23, 2025Related...Supreme Court Ruling Is Anything But Clear – And Endangers All Women's Rights, Trans Group WarnsBridget Phillipson Still Can't Say Which Toilet Trans People Are Meant To Use'He Doesn't Have The Balls': Kemi Badenoch Hits Starmer With Low Blow Over Trans U-Turn

Comments

Breaking news

Lidl to invest £500m in its expansion as it eyes new sites in Scotland

Inside Prince William and Kate Middleton's private wedding reception - including Prince Harry's unforgettable throne room party

about 3 hours ago

The real reason Kate and Wills' marriage has endured while Charles and Diana's ended in bitter divorce

about 3 hours ago

How Diana Spencer and Kate Middleton were 'very different' on their wedding days, according to royal biographer

about 3 hours ago

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney sends blistering message to Donald Trump just moments after being re-elected in shock comeback

about 3 hours ago

Meghan reveals Archie and Lilibet's classic British trait despite their all-American upbringing in California

Irish rap trio Kneecap break their silence with apology to families of Jo Cox and Sir David Amess after furious backlash over 'kill your local MP' jibe

about 3 hours ago

Prince William and Kate Middleton return to Isle of Mull on their wedding anniversary - 20 years after they first visited beautiful Scottish island as university students in love

about 3 hours ago

Alleged poison mushroom killer Erin Patterson is cleared of three attempted murders against her estranged husband Simon

Comments

Similar News

Reform extends poll lead as Tories brace for hammering in local elections on Thursday - with Labour fears mounting over Runcorn by-election

Tory fury as Labour's asylum block on foreign sex offenders leaves human rights loophole

TOM HARRIS: I was a Labour minister - here's why greedy trade unions could BANKRUPT the country and Starmer is powerless to make them see sense

Now Labour is facing a summer of discontent: Nurses, teachers and council staff issue strike threats as Tories say Rachel Reeves is soft on unions

Exclusive: Senior Labour Minister Accuses Tories Of 'Gifting' Crunch By-Election To Reform UK

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: Labour's lying to us about migration. They're planning to flood the country with EU 'youths' and it's freedom of movement by the front door

Labour freezes NHS prescription charges in England amid calls for 'sickness tax' to be scrapped

Senior aide to Labour’s Wes Streeting AVOIDS jail after he flashed girl, 13, then followed her in terrifying ordeal

Ex-Labour candidate in 'racist' tweets storm given prized speaking slot at union event

Tories 'face losing 500 seats' in Reform local elections surge as Keir Starmer 'stays away' from Runcorn by-election after Labour suffers worst poll plunge EVER for a new government

Ed Miliband's GB Energy project is branded a 'betrayal' by Labour's trade union backers over 'bonkers' curbs on North Sea oil and gas

Scottish Labour MP calls for Jackdaw and Rosebank oil fields to go ahead

Labour Government accused of 'closing down' Aberdeen over oil and gas jobs and 'betrayal' on GB Energy

SNP by-election candidate urges Labour rival to 'call out' UK Government disability benefit cuts

ROSS CLARK: As Labour creates 27 new quangos in eight months... How quangocracy rakes in the cash

Revealed in a new book on the Prime Minister's first months in power, a bombshell claim from senior Labour insiders... Why even Keir Starmer's inner circle want to see Wes Streeting in Number 10, writes LORD ASHCROFT

LAURA TROTT: Labour MUST issue guidance to keep our children safe

Donald Trump trade deal warning by Labour frontbencher - 'not certain'

Reeves says she wants young Brits to be able to work freely in the EU in latest sign Labour will do reciprocal deal allowing under-30s into UK

Voters deserting Labour and Tories as Reform to claim hundreds of seats at local elections, top pollster says

Breaking news

Lidl to invest £500m in its expansion as it eyes new sites in Scotland

Model finds man hiding under her bed after noticing ‘weird smell’ in hotel room

Glasgow Science Festival launches biggest-ever programme of events

William and Kate celebrate wedding anniversary on Mull

Swinney angers charity bosses over Scottish Child Payment increase warning

'Devastating': Charity boss reveals essential items children in poverty are missing

UK welfare cuts to plunge thousands of disabled children into poverty

The student housing pioneer trying to solve climate and create a better society

Number of Scots in full-time work who need debt advice on the rise – charity

Billion-year-old impact in Scotland sparks questions about life on land

Meghan Markle says she and Prince Harry were ‘in the trenches’ while dating

Donald Trump 2.0 100 days on: His boldest and most consequential moves so far

Thick smoke seen across London after fire breaks out at electrical substation

Map reveals cities affected by the power outages in Spain and Portugal

Who could be the new Pope? The cardinals who might become the next head of the Catholic Church

Vehicle attack in Vancouver devastates a vibrant and growing Filipino community

What happens after Pope Francis funeral – how the Conclave to select his successor will work

Sailor injured as $60m US fighter jet topples off aircraft carrier dodging Houthi rebel strike

Why Crimea matters so much to Putin – and now Trump

Texas megachurch pastor TD Jakes to step down after suffering heart attack during sermon

Drinking white wine and champagne could reduce risk of cardiac arrest, new study finds

Male health workers should be able to carry out mammograms, experts say

Murderer orders pizza to victim’s house after killing friend

Man suffers fractured skull and bleeding to his brain after attack outside of Hamilton pub

Toddler who died in nursery incident's selfless act as parents pay heartbreaking tribute

Blaze breaks out onboard Scots bus as fire crews race to scene

Drinking white wine and eating more fruit 'could reduce risk of cardiac arrest'

Councillors agree to allow sale of community centre in Airdrie to local church

Carney styled himself as the man to take on Trump - but another challenge looms

Soap spoilers for next week: Emmerdale revenge and danger for Coronation Street favourite

Canada election result sees Mark Carney triumph – leaving Donald Trump red-faced

London 'explosion': Chaos as flames and black smoke 'erupt' in city blast during rush hour

Nicole Kidman, 57, dances in her undergarment to drug-fuelled party song driving fans wild

Why you should run if someone says these seven words to you on a date

Man filming wife during marathon records what her family REALLY thinks after forgetting to turn camera off

Summer holidays might cost you a £500 fine for one particular motoring offence...

Inside Prince William and Kate Middleton's private wedding reception - including Prince Harry's unforgettable throne room party

The real reason Kate and Wills' marriage has endured while Charles and Diana's ended in bitter divorce

How Diana Spencer and Kate Middleton were 'very different' on their wedding days, according to royal biographer

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney sends blistering message to Donald Trump just moments after being re-elected in shock comeback

Meghan reveals Archie and Lilibet's classic British trait despite their all-American upbringing in California

Insane moment smiling tourist ziplines over valley unaware of tragedy unfolding below that left 26 dead

I'm American living in the UK - this typical British behaviour was really hard to get used to

Major mishap on US aircraft carrier as $70 million F/A-18 fighter jet goes overboard

Irish rap trio Kneecap break their silence with apology to families of Jo Cox and Sir David Amess after furious backlash over 'kill your local MP' jibe

Prince William and Kate Middleton return to Isle of Mull on their wedding anniversary - 20 years after they first visited beautiful Scottish island as university students in love

Alleged poison mushroom killer Erin Patterson is cleared of three attempted murders against her estranged husband Simon

The runner who went viral and sparked a campaign for change

Will Ferrari turn their season around?

'A reference for all of us' - how Guardiola inspires Arteta, Flick and Luis Enrique

100 Days Of Trump (Part 1)… Why Are Diversity Schemes Being Scrapped?

Hong Kong frees four pro-democracy lawmakers who completed jail terms

Some charges against alleged mushroom lunch killer dropped

Watch: How Canada's election night unfolded

India Accuses Pakistan of Supporting Terrorism. Here’s What We Know.

Power Is Largely Restored in Spain After Widespread Outage

Donald Trump Pulls Obnoxious Stunt As Canada Elects Its Prime Minister