The Case That Could Test The Lengths Of Trump’s Military Power

The latest test of President Donald Trump’s powers starts next week in California.That’s when a federal judge will weigh whether the Trump administration violated a nearly 150-year-old law when it deployed thousands of National Guard and 700 active-duty Marines to Los Angeles this summer against the wishes of the state’s governor and the city’s mayor. The bench trial will begin Monday in California, where Senior U.S. District Judge Charles Breyer will be asked to decide whether Trump had overstepped the Posse Comitatus Act of 1878, which forbids the U.S. military from acting as a domestic law enforcement arm except under the most extraordinary circumstances. The judge is also expected to hear arguments from both sides about the definition of a “rebellion.” The stakes in the case are high, and not just for California: It will test the lengths to which Trump — or any future president — can use military force to quash unrest or sidestep local officials, as well as how they could plan to handle demonstrations or other crises in a given state.The suit was brought by California Gov. Gavin Newsom and the state’s attorney general, Rob Bonta, who called the administration’s actions “an unmistakable step toward authoritarianism.” Trump, the governor argued in his lawsuit, did not have the constitutional authority to send in troops or take over the state’s National Guard without his express consent. The administration had “manufactured [a] crisis,” the governor said in a June 9 statement.“This is him intentionally causing chaos, terrorizing communities and endangering the principles of our great democracy,” Newsom said. The case stems from Trump’s deployment of troops to respond to protests against immigration raids carried out in downtown Los Angeles’ Fashion District in June. Protesters unsuccessfully attempted to stop those raids, with demonstrators gathering outside of a federal courthouse the night of June 6. Skirmishes broke out between protesters and police, and the courthouse was vandalised. Local police declared an unlawful assembly, and as rumours of more raids spread, other demonstrations cropped up, including one where a car was set on fire. The next evening, June 7, Trump issued a memo authorising the deployment of 2,000 California National Guard troops for up to 60 days, ostensibly to respond to riots. “If Governor Gavin Newscum, of California, and Mayor Karen Bass, of Los Angeles, can’t do their jobs, which everyone knows they can’t, then the Federal Government will step in and solve the problem, RIOTS & LOOTERS, the way it should be solved!!!” Trump wrote on social media the same day.It was the first time in over 50 years that the federal government opted to haul in the National Guard without a governor’s approval, which is usually required: Neither Newsom nor Bass had made the request. In fact, both vocally opposed it. Newsom slammed it as little more than an opportunity for Trump to escalate tensions between law enforcement and protesters and manufacture a crisis.“This brazen abuse of power by a sitting President inflamed a combustible situation … putting our people, our officers, and the National Guard at risk. That’s when the downward spiral began,” Newsom said in a statement, calling the deployment “dangerous” as well.Just days after the initial deployment, the chief spokesman for the Pentagon Sean Parnell announced the Defense Department would mobilise another 2,000 California National Guard troops to support ICE and “enable federal law enforcement to safely conduct their duties.” The Marines were also deployed. As California officials publicly decried the administration’s conduct, Trump suggested they should be arrested: Newsom, Bass and any other “officials who stand in the way of law and order, yea, they will face judges,” Trump saidon June 8.The Posse Comitatus Act was passed, as the Brennan Center for Justice noted in its study this year, after the end of the Reconstruction Era and as white supremacists were ascending to power in Southern states as well as in Congress. The idea for the act wasn’t noble: Congress wanted to ensure that the military would not be able to step on the toes of states that were trying to keep Jim Crow laws in place even after the Confederacy had fallen.According to a report from the Congressional Research Service on the law, the act “outlaws the willful use of any part of the Army or Air Force to execute the law unless expressly authorised by the Constitution or an act of Congress.” There are, however, questions over the act’s “context of assistance to civilian police.” “At least, in this context, the courts have held that, absent a recognised exception, the Posse Comitatus Act is violated when (1) civilian law enforcement officials make ‘direct active use’ of military investigators; or (2) the use of the military ‘pervades the activities’ of civilian officials; or (3) the military is used so as to subject ‘citizens to the exercise of military power which was regulatory, prescriptive or compulsory in nature,’” the report reads. “The act is not violated when the Armed Forces conduct activities for a military purpose.”Under posse comitatus, the National Guard is only able to support other federal law enforcement officers or conduct enforcement on federal property. They are not allowed to assist local law enforcement in performing their local duties. The statute also declares that these deployment orders “shall be issued through the governors of the states” — a pretty big point for Newsom, who, again, openly disavowed the deployment. It is unclear if that point will stick, however, since the language of the statute does not explicitly state that consent must first be granted.However, Trump invoked an obscure federal code, Section 12406, which states that whenever the U.S. is “invaded or is in danger of a foreign nation” or if “there is a rebellion or danger of a rebellion against the authority of the Government of the United States,” if it cannot be resolved through regular means then the president may “call into Federal service” members of the National Guard of any state in any numbers he sees fit. Newsom and Bonta argue that Trump’s invocation of Section 12406 was illegal because it didn’t expand those limits, and further, that there was no actual “rebellion” to quell. In court records, lawyers for the Trump administration have argued that protests against ICE amounted to a rebellion in California. Breyer will likely preside over an intense debate over the legal definition of the word “rebellion” since there is no agreed-upon legal definition of it. U.S. code does lump rebellion in with “insurrection,” however, and it is generally understood as an organized uprising against established laws. The bench trial will last just three days, through Aug. 13.Up to this point, success for California’s suit on the issue has been a mixed bag. Judge Breyer first sided with Newsom when he agreed on June 12 to issue a temporary restraining order that would block Trump from commandeering the California National Guard. But within days, an appellate court halted Breyer’s order and sided with Trump. On June 19, Judges on the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled unanimously that Trump could retain control and found it was likely that he exercised his authority as president lawfully. The appellate court said that since protesters had damaged federal buildings, caused at least one federal building to be closed and vandalized a federal van, the interest of the government to prevent those incidents from happening again was “significant,” the judges wrote. And, in another helpful decision for Trump, the court also found that even if Newsom wasn’t notified that the National Guard in his state was being federalized, as governor, he lacked any power to veto Trump. A drawdown of the troops in Los Angeles got underway at the end of last month, just a week shy of the 60-day deadline laid out in Trump’s memo. Lawyers for the Trump administration emphasized in court records, however, that had Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth wanted to extend that deadline, he had the right to do so based on the “situation on the ground.”A Pentagon spokesperson said there are still 300 National Guard troops left in Los Angeles.

Comments

Breaking news

Man dies after car and lorry crash on A12

Metro

Comments

Breaking news

Man dies after car and lorry crash on A12

Red Arrows flight path: Where and when to see this weekend’s displays

I went inside the Navy’s secret battlespace barely anyone knows about

UK Holidaymakers Warned To Not Use Wheeled Suitcases This Summer

These Dragons' Den Backed Towels Are A Total Beach Day Game Changer – And They're On Sale

Food Sequencing: Why The First (And Last) Thing You Eat At Dinner Matters

Zelenskyy rejects formally ceding Ukrainian territory, says Kyiv must be part of any negotiations

South Korea's military says North Korea is removing speakers from their tense border

UK to send more aid for Gaza amid Israel takeover plans

Zelensky warns he won’t give up land ahead of Trump-Putin meeting

Strict post-Brexit rules for British tourists travelling to EU set to come into force

‘A failed surgery on my ribs has left me unable to eat solid food for years’

Former Israeli PM says Netanyahu’s plans to takeover Gaza would be ‘historic disaster’

Trump reveals where and when he will meet Putin for Ukraine peace talks

Driving instructor says one unlucky scenario can't be taught during lessons

Oasis at Murrayfield LIVE as Gallagher brothers set for night 2 in Edinburgh

Noel Gallagher's daughter Anais shows allegiance to Scottish football team at Oasis gig

Noel Gallagher’s daughter spotted sporting Celtic tracksuit at Murrayfield Oasis gig

Canary Islands given rare red weather warning as tourists brace for extreme heat of 40C

Full Saturday forecast for Oasis at Murrayfield as fans to face showers

Police handling of Cole Cooper's disappearance to be probed after family complaint

Probe launched after 'hundreds' of Oasis fans sneaked into Wembley gig without tickets

Second arrest after man found dead on bench near canal

Lifting sanctions on Putin for Trump meeting is a massive victory for Moscow

Mystery of man who vanished after being lured into sick child sex ring from 13

Ibiza Final Boss Jack Kaye relationship bombshell as girlfriend 'dumped him' over partying

Woman's brave final act to save unborn baby after footballer lover had her gunned down

Forgotten resort frozen in time with drinks still waiting on tables 30 years later

'My husband could still be alive if we got him the vaccine - I'm so angry'

Times Square shooter was a child who opened fire into busy New York crowd with multiple hit

British combat medic found dead in Ukraine bed with murder probe 'ongoing'

Met Office warns Storm Dexter to hit within HOURS but it's great news for heatwave

Evil dad kills daughter, 5, for wetting herself and carries body parts around for months

Serial rapist claimed he'd killed girl, 14, but reality was even more harrowing

Emma Willis gives update after undergoing heart surgery and shares the secret to her happy marriage with husband Matt

Transgender woman who dumped soiled nappies outside nurseries and smeared excrement on milk bottles is spared prison - after judge hears of 'difficult time' on remand in men's jail

Zelensky warns on 'decisions without Ukraine' after Trump and Putin announce 'peace summit' in Alaska next week - as Russia keeps on killing

The evolution of Abbey Clancy: How stunner went from failed singer and reality star wannabe to WAG before transforming herself into £30M TV and podcast titan alongside beloved husband Peter Crouch

Naga Munchetty's 'Marmite meltdown': Under-fire BBC Breakfast host 'scolded intern over how they spread her toast', sources claim amid review into 'rudeness' and 'bullying'

'My kids have had to deal with so much death at such a young age': Kelsey Parker on how she's told her children she will never leave them following the death of her baby three years after her husband Tom died

Six-bedroom 17th century manor with walled gardens on sale for just £150,000 - but there's a BIG catch

Ulrika Jonsson, 57, strips down to sheer lacy underwear in sultry mirror snaps and makes cheeky jibe at critics over 'ageing' comments

Amanda Holden, 54, dazzles alongside her youthful husband Chris Hughes, 51, in stunning snap 22 years after meeting... as fans marvel at the couple's aged-defying looks

Our lives changed forever after my husband had the Covid jab...a stroke left him blind and paralysed - and the stress has broken our marriage

Holiday tragedy as British girl, five, dies after being pulled unconscious from a swimming pool in Fuerteventura tourist complex

Princess Eugenie wishes 'big sissy' Beatrice a happy birthday in sweet Instagram post as she calls her 'the best in the entire world'

Powerful antidepressants taken by millions 'linked to more than 1,000 deaths - including children under ten'

Inside 'haunted' 100-year-old cinema uncovered by urban explorer in Eastbourne

Big Brother stars Grace Adams-Short and Mikey Dalton are the ONLY couple still together after meeting on the show - and you won't believe what their family look like now!

As Keir Starmer's UK government loses grip of the small boats crisis, here's how one Spanish resort deals with migrants

Where is Wife Swap's foul-mouthed Lizzy Bardsley now? How life went south for the reality TV star after her stint in the spotlight

We ditched the UK to buy a three-bedroom house in Bulgaria - our property cost us less than a train ticket in Britain and we save loads on bills

Where did it all go wrong for The Saturdays? Why the band are at odds over a reunion and haven't been seen together in YEARS - as fans suspect Frankie Bridge and Rochelle Humes have fallen out

Don't give me granny's ring! How young brides are following A-listers like Billie Eilish with their choice of diamonds as they kill off traditional billion-pound engagement jewel industry

Model mother was about to embark on a new life with her son... before warped food blogger boyfriend tied her to a lapdancing pole, hammered her to death, chopped her into pieces and BARBECUED her

Gladiator star Steel and wife reveal they want to try for another baby four months after tragic death of their premature son - as they voice need to 'fill void' left by the loss

Rachel Riley stalker hell: Countdown star targeted by convicted stalker who accused her of being the 'ringleader of a cult of celebrities'

The French farmer who said 'non' to gypsies: When travellers invaded his field and gendarmerie did nothing, Pierre Richard climbed into his tractor and sprayed them in merde!

Ryan Reynolds vs Tom Brady - the race to cash in on British football! Documentaries, brand new stadiums and a £100MILLION jackpot... why American superstars are desperate for a slice of the pie

Brain surgeon who 'raped woman' and posed for series of selfies with an arsenal of weapons including knives in a Snapchat post with the message 'Who wants to play?' is struck off