Why A Former Labour Councillor's Acquittal By A Jury Is Not 'Two-Tier Justice'

Ricky Jones was found not guilty.A former Labour councillor who called for far-right activists’ throats to be cut at an anti-racism rally in the wake of the Southport murders has been found not guilty of encouraging violent disorder.Ricky Jones was acquitted this morning following a trial at Snaresbrook Crown Court.A video showing Jones addressing crowds on Hoe Street in Walthamstow, east London, on August 7 last year went viral on social media after the protest, which had been organised in response to plans for a far-right march outside Waltham Forest Immigration Bureau.The councillor, who was suspended by his party in the wake of the incident, said: “They are disgusting Nazi fascists. We need to cut all their throats and get rid of them all.”He also drew his finger across his throat as he spoke to the crowd.Jurors deliberated for just over half-an-hour and found him not guilty on Friday.But, despite what some very senior Conservatives would have you believe, this is not an example of so-called “two-tier justice”.Shadow housing secretary James Cleverly was the first Conservative to condemn the outcome of the case, which he said was “unacceptable”.“Perverse decisions like this are adding to the anger that people feel and amplifying the belief that there isn’t a dispassionate criminal justice system,” he posted on X.This unacceptable. Perverse decisions like this are adding to the anger that people feel and amplifying the belief that there isn’t a dispassionate criminal justice system. https://t.co/dhnenxWKSO— James Cleverly🇬🇧 (@JamesCleverly) August 15, 2025Shadow home secretary Chris Philp went even further by comparing Jones’ acquittal with the case of Tory councillor’s wife Lucy Connolly, who was jailed for 31 months for a tweet she posted during last year’s Southport riots.She called on people to “set fire to all the... hotels [housing asylum seekers]... for all I care”.Philp said: “It is astonishing that this Labour councillor who was caught on video calling for throats to be slit is let off scot-free, whereas Lucy Connolly got 31 months prison for posting something no worse.“The development of two-tier justice is becoming increasingly alarming. It cannot have been a question of uncertain evidence as the man was on video clearly calling for violence.“The government must come forward with plans to ensure justice is handed out equally, regardless of the background or views of the perpetrator - but as far as I can see this Labour government seems to be quite happy with two-tier justice.”However, Philp failed to mention the key difference between both cases: Connolly pleaded guilty to inciting race hate and was therefore sentenced by a judge, whereas Jones denied the charge he faced and was found not guilty by a jury of his peers after due consideration of the evidence against him.It is also unclear what Philp is proposing governments should do in such cases. Is he suggesting that ministers should have the power to intervene when a jury returns a not guilty plea they do not like?Attempts by HuffPost UK to clarify with the Conservatives what he meant have so far been met with silence.Interestingly, Robert Jenrick, the not-normally-silent shadow justice secretary, has remained silent on the Ricky Jones case.Could this possibly be because, barely a month ago, he stood up in the Commons to defend jury trials amid fears Labour is trying to restrict them.Jenrick said: “Jury trials have been a central part of our constitution for centuries – in Magna Carta, indeed before it. They are a gift that we have given to the world. “For too many on the government benches it seems they want to scrap jury trials ... because they don’t trust the British public’s instincts on justice. They say judges know best, we say the public know best.”Starmer is considering limiting jury trials.That’s a slippery slope to losing an ancient liberty. pic.twitter.com/ygQ447Oxod— Robert Jenrick (@RobertJenrick) July 9, 2025Social media users – including former Tory MP Jacob Rees-Mogg – were also quick to point out the bizarre logic being pursued by Cleverly and Philp.This is self-evidently not an example of two-tier justice as this Councillor was cleared by a jury. Lucy Connolly offered a guilty plea so did not have a jury trial, although she probably could have done had she pleaded not guilty. https://t.co/hctpSG6nCB— Jacob Rees-Mogg (@Jacob_Rees_Mogg) August 15, 2025Juries are randomly selected members of the public. Men and women from all walks of life and all political backgrounds. Only a moron of irredeemable proportions would even think of suggesting that a jury verdict represents some deep state “two-tier justice”.— The Secret Barrister 🦋 (@BarristerSecret) August 15, 2025Has everyone gone mad. It was a jury trial. There's nothing anyone can do, unless they're advocating the abolition of juries. https://t.co/c94vvqcbKF— (((Dan Hodges))) (@DPJHodges) August 15, 2025Someone being jailed after pleading guilty in one case and someone else walking free after trial in front of a jury in another is a sign of nothing more than a system working as it should.— euan mccolm (@euanmccolm) August 15, 2025Basically, had Lucy Connolly not been persuaded to plead guilty and gone for a jury trial there's a good chance she would not be in prison now. A jury is unlikely to find someone guilty if it means they are locked up for almost 3 years for a stupid mistake. https://t.co/nJ6ZPStxoe— David Maddox (@DavidPBMaddox) August 15, 2025Regardless of his not guilty verdict, it seems unlikely that Jones will be allowed back into the Labour Party any time soon.The internal investigation into his behaviour is still ongoing, and party sources pointed to the statement they put out at the time of his suspension: “This behaviour is completely unacceptable and it will not be tolerated.”Related...A Year On From The Southport Riots, Is The UK Really On The Edge Of Mass Civil Disobedience?Keir Starmer Calls For St George's Flag To Be 'Reclaimed' From Southport RiotersSenior Minister Responds To Calls For Law Reform After Southport Killer Sentencing

Comments

Breaking news

Full list of Claire’s shops that could close as retailer falls into administration

Metro

Comments

Breaking news

Full list of Claire’s shops that could close as retailer falls into administration

Unruly flyer is ‘picked up like a child’ and restrained by fellow passenger

Trump lands in Alaska for crunch Ukraine summit

Feds say migrants at ICE facility in Manhattan can’t have toothbrushes because they can be ‘improvised as weapons’

Verdict and sentencing for Brazil's Bolsonaro is set for early September

Photos of mourners and searches for the missing from flash floods in Pakistan and India

Brooklyn construction magnate gets probation for funneling illegal donations to NYC Mayor Eric Adams

Firefighters still battling North York Moors blaze with houses 30 miles away affected

OAN’s Matt Gaetz apologizes for using AI-generated fakes of women soldiers in female military recruitment segment

Putin stops off at fish factory on way to Alaska for crunch Trump meeting

Deadly ‘sloth virus’ detected in UK for first time as health watchdog issues urgent warning

Hero fisherman pulls woman to safety after she jumped from Louisiana bridge

Afghans brought to safety in UK have personal details leaked in fresh Ministry of Defence breach

Influencer ‘XenaThe Witch’ arrested after shooting stranger with a paintball gun for live stream prank

Hours before interviewing Patel and Bondi, Hannity bragged he wouldn’t ask about Epstein. He stayed true to his word

Dramatic video shows hiker airlifted to safety after two days trapped behind waterfall

Bioethanol plant deems lack of Government support an ‘act of economic self-harm’

Lawyers say immigrants battling medical emergencies and disease at Alligator Alcatraz: ‘I don’t want to die in here’

FTSE eases on weak US data as Ukraine peace summit looms

Who is Gavin Newsom? The trolling Democrat feuding with Donald Trump

Russia-linked DHL warehouse fire in Birmingham left Amazon container ‘100% destroyed’

One dead and another missing after boat crashes near Portsmouth

Russia Experts Worry KGB Agent-Turned-Murderous Dictator Putin Will Play Trump

Why A Former Labour Councillor's Acquittal By A Jury Is Not 'Two-Tier Justice'

And Just Like That Boss Explains Why The Finale Had To Include That 1 Gross-Out Scene

Parts of Manhattan covered in black smoke after apartment fire leads to massive emergency response

Homeland Security chief Kristi Noem gets sizzle reel of her cosplay stunts to mark 200 days in office

New Hampshire man accused of fatally shooting his sister-in-law and nephews pleads guilty

Michelle Yeoh brings Chinese blockbuster 'Ne Zha 2' to life in English dub

Richard Thomas dons wig and mustache to play icon Mark Twain in one-man play touring the US

Trump officials wanted to give Musk’s xAI a huge contract. Staffers had to explain Grok had just praised Hitler

Ministers spent £2.4m fighting to keep huge Afghan data breach a secret

Trump team has created a secret list ranking companies on how loyal they are

Queen Camilla wipes away tear as veteran pays tribute to King’s cancer battle

Bioethanol plant deems lack of Government support an ‘act of economic self-harm’

Florida mom ‘lucky to be alive’ after miscarrying due to raw milk consumption, she says in lawsuit

Michigan football fined 10s of millions of dollars, Moore suspended 3 games in sign-stealing scandal

How to get your AT&T settlement

Watch live: Trump and Putin hold high stakes Ukraine summit in Alaska

Desperate search underway for missing Arkansas teen as family fears foul play

Hillary Clinton says she’d nominate Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize if he helps broker a deal to end Ukraine war

Serbia's protesters accuse police of brutality as they prepare to rally again on Friday

Far-right Israeli minister confronts long-imprisoned Palestinian leader

What is a sonic boom? Loud bang heard over Essex

Shoppers left 'pleasantly surprised' by budget Android phone as it drops to £89

Stirling Highland Games set to open doors on traditional family fun event

Free September gardening workshops for all ages at Dobbies Sandyholm

French family are 30,000th visitors to Trossachs attraction in just one year

Man struggled to eat sandwich at work and only has six months to live

Bridge of Allan street to close again for final repairworks after reopening following two year closure

Man charged with attempted murder after 'gunshots fired' on Edinburgh street

New York 'explosion' horror as black smoke surrounds Manhattan after 'blast'

Special Bannockburn rugby fundraiser aims to spread message of inclusivity

Thugs caged for 101 years after 'gangland' attacks left man with hand 'hanging off' and prison cars torched

Predator who sexually assaulted two women as they lay next to him in his bed jailed for 16 months

Major search after man goes missing in river

Second suspect appears in court charged with man's murder and robbery

Manhunt for perv who hurled 'sexualised comments' at female jogger as she ran down road

Heatwave wildfire hell for UK sees firefighters hit back over lack of resources

I tried custard creams from Lidl, Asda, Sainsbury's and more — one is a 10 out of 10 winner