OpenAI thinks it has defused its multibillion-dollar time bomb

Sam AltmanEugene Gologursky/Getty Images for The New York TimesOpenAI is giving up on its plan to free itself from oversight by its nonprofit parent organization.Under a proposed restructure, its for-profit subsidiary will convert to a Public Benefit Corporation.OpenAI believes the new plan will satisfy the terms of recent investments to restructure itself.OpenAI thinks it has found a way to diffuse the ticking time bomb hanging over its head.On Monday, red-hot $300 billion AI startup announced a new plan — one that sees the for-profit LLC restructure into a Public Benefit Corporation (PBC), and with the nonprofit parent taking a "big" financial stake and retaining legal control.Importantly for the tens of billions of dollars OpenAI has raised over the years, OpenAI believes that the new proposal will meet the requirements placed upon it by investors that it restructure itself as a condition of funding, a person familiar with the matter told Business Insider.OpenAI's most recent funding round includes a complicated investment from SoftBank, the Japanese conglomerate that invested $20 billion earlier this year, with another up to $20 billion (part coming from a syndicate) becoming available in December if it restructured as a for-profit.Similarly, OpenAI previously raised several billion from other investors last year, with a provision allowing investors to claw back funds if the company had not restructured within two years.In its current formation, OpenAI is beholden to a nonprofit parent organization — an unconventional corporate structure that some investors have rankled at, and placed stipulations on their investments requiring it to be restructured within a specific timeframe.OpenAI's first attempt to resolve it by severing the link between the for-profit subsidiary and the nonprofit parent faltered in the face of scrutiny from everyone from state attorneys general to academics to Elon Musk.If successful, the latest restructuring will provide clarity for investors and employees, also removing its convoluted "capped-profit" model that saw investor returns top out at a theoretical 100x. And it removes what had the potential to be a catastrophic hurdle for OpenAI — the withdrawal of huge tracts of funding — as it faces intense competition from Anthropic, Google, Musk's xAI, and other rival AI firms."OpenAI was founded as a nonprofit, is today a nonprofit that oversees and controls the for-profit, and going forward will remain a nonprofit that oversees and controls the for-profit," Sam Altman wrote in a letter to employees that the company also posted publicly. That will not change."'The devil's in the details'Rose Chan Loui, a law professor and expert in nonprofit law at UCLA who has previously been critical of OpenAI's plans, said she found the new proposal "encouraging.""They're saying all the right things," she said. "They're saying that the mission remains the same, that the PBC will have the same mission, and whether or not that really happens, I think depends on what processes they set up in terms of governance."She cautioned that there are still a number of unanswered questions, including the nature of how the nonprofit will legally control and practically monitor the public benefit corporation, the financial stake the nonprofit will hold, and the governance structure of the nonprofit. "I think the devil's in the details, right?"Robert Weissman, the co-president at Public Citizen, a public advocacy group, is less optimistic. Public Citizen has previously argued that OpenAI has already effectively surrendered its charitable mission in pursuit of for-profit goals and should be forced to convert to a for-profit entirely and compensate the charitable sector for its purported failures."In a lot of ways it's saying: 'we're going to keep doing what we've been doing,'" he said. "And I think what they've been doing is unacceptable, and fails to uphold their nonprofit mission."OpenAI's ongoing efforts to raise capital, he said, are indicative that the nonprofit "will not be exerting meaningful control over the now-public benefit corporation's business."He added: "There has to be some demonstration of a fundamental reorientation by the nonprofit to actually exert control and direct the for-profit in some way that reflected its nonprofit values."The attorneys general have their sayOpenAI's new structure is not a done deal.The final decision on whether OpenAI goes ahead with it will be made by the attorneys general in California and Delaware, both of whom said they planned to review the new proposal. (In OpenAI's blog post, board chair Bret Taylor wrote that "we made the decision for the nonprofit to retain control of OpenAI after hearing from civic leaders and engaging in constructive dialogue with the offices of the Attorney General of Delaware and the Attorney General of California.)In a statement to BI, Delaware Attorney General Kathy Jennings said that she was "encouraged" by the Monday announcement, saying the company is "seeking to address" her concerns."Now that the Company has a new plan, I intend to review it for compliance with Delaware law by ensuring that it accords with OpenAI's charitable purpose and that the non-profit entity retains appropriate control over the for-profit entity," she said.California Attorney General Rob Bonta was more terse in a statement to BI: "The California Department of Justice is reviewing the new proposed plan. This remains an ongoing matter — and we are in continued conversations with OpenAI."Read the original article on Business Insider

Comments

Business News

A Nebraska bill would criminalize hemp-based THC. Opponents say it could make grandma a felon

ABC News

Police Arrest Pro-Palestinian Protesters After They Occupy University Of Washington Building And Demand It Cuts Boeing Ties

about 2 hours ago

UK services sector shrinks for first time in 18 months amid tariff worries

Evening Standard

Comments

Similar News

The Stakes for OpenAI’s Plan B

OpenAI says non-profit will remain in control after backlash

OpenAI reverses course and says its nonprofit will continue to control its business

OpenAI says its nonprofit will remain in control of its for-profit business

OpenAI reverses course and says its nonprofit will continue to control its business

Sam Altman’s OpenAI ditches plan to become for-profit company after fierce pushback

What is Mistral AI? Everything to know about the OpenAI competitor

OpenAI, facing pressure, announces its nonprofit will stay in control after all. Read CEO Sam Altman's letter.

The most important lesson from OpenAI's big ChatGPT mistake: 'Only connect!'

OpenAI rolls back ‘sycophantic’ ChatGPT update after bot sides with users in absurd scenarios

The danger of relying on OpenAI’s Deep Research

OpenAI’s new fundraising is shaking up Silicon Valley

What does the OpenAI exodus say about Sam Altman?

What if Microsoft let OpenAI go free?

Elon Musk’s xAI goes after OpenAI

Elon Musk’s $97bn offer is a headache for Sam Altman’s OpenAI

OpenAI’s latest model will change the economics of software

Publisher of PCMag and Mashable Sues OpenAI

Sam Altman's resignation from the Oklo board could pay off with a major OpenAI deal

Meet Mira Murati, the former OpenAI CTO raising $2 billion for her secretive AI startup

Business News

A Nebraska bill would criminalize hemp-based THC. Opponents say it could make grandma a felon

7.2 million could invalidate home insurance by delaying key task

Halifax explains £500 limit rule for ISA savers

Best savings accounts and Cash ISAs for May paying up to 7.5% interest

Fury as HMRC delays force people to wait months for tax refunds

Brian Cox says Trump’s tariffs would be ‘absolute disaster’ for upcoming film

Deliveroo takeover: What is DoorDash and what will the sale mean for customers?

Asos has made a huge change to deliveries after hiking fees – and it’s good news for shoppers

B&M slashes price of stylish home furniture to just £1 instead of £10 – plus how you can find more bargains

How YOU can swap jobs and get a £20k pay rise – as professions with the most transferable skills revealed

Keir stands firm & refuses to budge on loathed Winter Fuel Payment cuts – everything you need to know

DWP benefits and pension payment dates for May 2025

Poll of the day: Should Labour reverse the cuts to winter fuel payments?

OVO Energy to offer free electricity every week to customers for 16 weeks

Pensioners may have to wait up to eight months for DWP payment increase

Bank of England could make huge interest rates step this week due to Trump chaos

Desperate Rachel Reeves needs a miracle – and she might just get one on Thursday

Barclays, HSBC, Santander and NatWest in mortgage price war - savings worth over £1,000

DWP one-off payment worth up to £812 for emergencies

DWP 'working hard' as it issues update on Pension Credit processing times

UK services sector shrinks for first time in 18 months amid tariff worries

Pontins in court over death of grandmother at resort

The reasons why new car sales across UK dropped

Shoppers baffled as Lidl discontinues everyday fridge staple in ALL stores

Lloyds and Halifax down as thousands of customers locked out of online banking

M&S and Co-op cyber attack update as shoppers hit with empty shelves, payment issues and meal deals chaos

Millions of households hit by changes to rubbish bin collections this month

Police Arrest Pro-Palestinian Protesters After They Occupy University Of Washington Building And Demand It Cuts Boeing Ties

UK services sector shrinks for first time in 18 months amid tariff worries

Pontins parent company accused of corporate manslaughter

Huge £1.3 billion development at Mortlake goes ahead after 10-year planning battle

Tesla global backlash 'hits UK' as sales in Elon Musk's luxury electric cars plunge 62%

'I tried Peugeot's new salt mill and it's changed my approach to food'

'Amazon beauty must-haves I use to stay cool in heatwave and perfect for commute'

Charlotte Tilbury’s new lip liner is the secret behind Aimee Lou Wood's pouty Met Gala look

Carpetright closure update issued as four new stores to open this month under new name

Apple fans can pick up an iPhone 16 Pro for less in cost-splitting deal at Sky

Molly-Mae's mint green suitcases with EasyJet-approved cabin bag are ideal for summer holidays

McDonald’s is axing 5 items from its menu today including popular burger

Brits urged to act now to stop your pension going to someone you hate

Supermarket's 'beautiful' six for £10 plants 'smell like vanilla' in your garden

Shopper 'couldn't go a day without a spot' until they found this dermatologist-approved serum

Should I max out my cash Isa NOW in case the £20,000 allowance is cut?

HMRC rule changes for thousands of drivers who earn more than £30,000

Hovis and Kingsmill owners in takeover talks about historic merger

BP shares rise amid reports Shell considering takeover offer

New car market declines by 10.4%

How parents on Universal Credit can get a £1,769 boost towards childcare

McDonald’s axing five items from menus TODAY including first ‘adult Happy Meal’

Popular Poundland store to shut TODAY – with more closures to come in huge blow to shoppers

Popular restaurant chain to close location in UK airport as bosses say it’s time to ‘shake things up’

Exact way Sainsbury’s new self-checkout change tracks shoppers as they pay in urgent store bid to crackdown on thefts

Major stationery retailer with 138 branches to shut store in weeks as it launches 70% off closing down sale

Kuok Scion, Tycoon Edwin Soeryadjaya Back Indonesian Waste Management Startup

Why Convergence-Of-Evidence That Predicts AGI Will Outdo Scientific Consensus By AI Experts

Singapore’s Mega Airport Project Pushes Forward With $3.7 Billion Contracts Awarded

BP shares rise amid reports Shell considering takeover offer