The Guardian view on Labour’s welfare mess: attempting to hide its cuts triggered a rebellion too big to punish | Editorial

The bill’s passage through the Commons exposed moral fault lines in Labour and revived hard questions about the nature of the benefits changesIn 2022, Liz Truss’s mini-budget collapsed under the weight of its own ideological haste, destroying her government’s credibility in days. Whether the debacle over Labour’s welfare reform bill will leave a similarly lasting mark on the Starmer administration remains uncertain. But the signs are familiar: rushed legislation, party unrest and proposals out of step with expert advice and public sentiment. The bill passed on Wednesday night bore little resemblance to its original version – it was so different, in fact, that even the title had changed. Yet MPs were asked to approve it with minimal scrutiny. The rebellion of 47 Labour MPs carries more weight than the numbers suggest – because it taps into questions of moral judgment.Some who voted against the bill’s third reading may be driven by factional grudges. Many think poverty is a national crisis to be ended. Rebels identified the sting in the tail of the new welfare bill: halving the universal credit health element for 90% of new claimants from April 2026. The government, rattled by party dissent, had already removed the most provocative clause – targeting personal independence payments – and rebranded the bill to gain Commons assent.Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here. Continue reading...

Comments

Business News

Here Are The All Star Home Run Derby Participants

Forbes

In our 50s, we moved to a remote Pacific island. We know we'll need better healthcare someday, but for now, it's paradise.

about 3 hours ago

Tesla makes moves to expand robotaxis in the Bay Area and Phoenix

insider

White House financial watchdog rips Jerome Powell over $2.5 billion revamp of Fed HQ — warns construction could be halted

about 6 hours ago

Skynews

Comments

Business News

Here Are The All Star Home Run Derby Participants

Kendra Bulluck-Major Is Building An Empire With Legacy Sports

Trump threatens 35% tariffs on Canadian goods

In our 50s, we moved to a remote Pacific island. We know we'll need better healthcare someday, but for now, it's paradise.

Tesla makes moves to expand robotaxis in the Bay Area and Phoenix

Bitcoin Hits Record High Ahead Of ‘Crypto Week’

How 'Jaws' Redefined Movie Tech And Ocean Awareness

‘Dexter: Resurrection’ 100% Rotten Tomatoes Critics Score Sets Record For Franchise

June heat and thunderstorms spell tough month for high street

Vital investment in Heathrow is a gateway for growth for the whole of the UK

June heat and thunderstorms spell tough month for high street

Tennis legends Andy Roddick, Martina Navratilova sneer at Bill Ackman for playing in pro match: ‘The biggest joke’

Jamie Dimon lashes out at ‘Marxist’ Zohran Mamdani, left’s DEI push: ‘Big hearts and little brains’

Interest will restart for 8 million student loan borrowers after year-long pause

Rattled NYC elite try to tame Marxist Mamdani

Popular car in urgent safety recall due to lethal flaw still being sold online

Job-seeking platforms Indeed and Glassdoor to slash 1,300 jobs as parent company bets on AI

My family of 4 moved to Germany for my husband's job. We've become closer, but miss our relatives back home.

Edgar Berlanga Vs. Hamzah Sheeraz Fight Prediction, Odds And Picks

What Has Been Most Decisive In Stopping The Spread Of Nuclear Weapons?

Today’s ‘Wordle’ #1483 Hints, Clues And Answer For Friday, July 11th

‘Virgin River,’ Netflix’s Longest-Running Series, Renewed For Season 8

This Palestinian Olympian Continues To Chase After Her Dream On The Track

Lena Dunham Talks About Obsession After Heartbreak In Netflix’s ‘Too Much’

Atlanta Whataburger Transforms Into ‘Wittaburger’ Celebrating All-Star Bobby Witt Jr.

Caleb Downs On Key To Ohio State Buckeyes Repeating As National Champs & Being An NCAA Football 26 Cover Athlete

Texas AG Ken Paxton’s Wife Files For Divorce—Citing ‘Biblical Grounds’ And ‘Recent Discoveries’

Port of Vancouver seeks bidders for massive Roberts Bank terminal expansion

'Autofocus' specs promise sharp vision, near or far

Asia is reeling from Trump's tariff salvo – is anyone winning?

Missouri governor repeals paid sick leave law approved last year by voters

Watchdog slams OpenAI with IRS complaint — warning CEO Sam Altman is poised for windfall in violation of US tax law

Record-high rents and bidding wars leave NYC house hunters scrambling for shelter this summer

New York lost many construction jobs during the pandemic — and still hasn’t recovered: report

Don Lemon’s lawsuit against Elon Musk for axing X show gets green light

White House financial watchdog rips Jerome Powell over $2.5 billion revamp of Fed HQ — warns construction could be halted

Handbag sells for &#163;7.4m at auction

Blackstone ups ante in £489m battle for British property firm Warehouse REIT

FTSE shrugs off tariff fears to hit new high as investors bet Trump will U-turn on 50% copper levy

'Too hot to shop': Misery for High Street retailers as UK heatwave sees shopping trips melt away

Perils of share volatility: Private equity sees Britain's second tier public firms as easy pickings, warns ALEX BRUMMER

Handbag maker Mulberry raises £20m from shareholders as sales plunge

Windfall for CofE as fund manager in which it holds majority stake is sold to rival Jupiter in £100m deal

Why the next app for relationships won't look like a dating app, according to a VC

I tried McDonald's long-anticipated Snack Wraps, and they were completely worth the wait

That new Jack Dorsey messaging app? He vibe-coded it

Linda Yaccarino lost her blue checkmark… but now it's back

'A little numb' to tariffs and 'very resilient': How CEOs are describing American consumers

Jensen Huang's net worth is $142 billion. Here's how the Nvidia CEO built his fortune and spends his money.

The Bigger Economic Meaning Of Amazon Prime Day

One Of The Best Action Movies Ever Made Lands On Netflix Today

Mahmoud Khalil Sues Trump Administration For $20 Million Over Alleged False Imprisonment

Justin Bieber Announces Music Comeback: New Album Reportedly Drops Friday

Just Before Blackpink Returns, One Of Its Members Charts A New Top 40 Smash

What Is ‘Squid Game’ Season 3 Really About?

Stray Kids Member Scores His First Solo Smash With A Major Duet

Trump’s New Tariffs Could Cost Households $2,400 This Year, Analysis Finds

Denver Nuggets’ 3-Time MVP Jokic Opts Against Extension ... For Now

How AI And Technology Are Reshaping The Oil And Gas Workforce

European Court: Russia Accountable For Widespread Abuses Of Human Rights In Ukraine

Handbag sells for £7.4m at auction