Berlioz and Ravel album review – his orchestra is responsive to Mäkelä’s every move

Orchestre de Paris/Mäkelä(Decca)It may be missing that edge-of-your-seat excitement it had at last summer’s Proms, but Berlioz’s Symphonie Fantastique is full of colour and impact, and the energy keeps fizzing on Ravel’s La ValseKlaus Mäkelä and the Orchestre de Paris gave an unforgettable performance of Berlioz’s Symphonie Fantastique at the BBC Proms last September, the electric atmosphere of which is not quite replicated on this recording, made in Paris a few months later.It’s all played with consummate skill by an orchestra who are clearly responsive to their conductor’s every move, as they were in Royal Albert Hall, and Mäkelä’s shaping of Berlioz’s music, from the gentle, vibratoless violins at the beginning to the careering witches’ dance of the finale, remains highly coloured and full of impact. Yet it all feels a little clinical; the edge-of-the-seat excitement is missing. Perhaps it has been engineered out: the sound feels over-tweaked, and although the spatial effects at the beginning of the third movement – with the cor anglais duetting with a faraway oboe – come over beautifully, elsewhere it sometimes feels as though we’re being shown exactly what to listen to. Continue reading...

Comments

Culture

The Waterfront: The true story behind Netflix drama inspired by creator’s family ties to drug smuggling

Independent

Comments

Culture

The Waterfront: The true story behind Netflix drama inspired by creator’s family ties to drug smuggling

Heston Blumenthal’s BBC documentary My Life with Bipolar ought to be a wake-up call

'This is American history': 'Caste' author Isabel Wilkerson on the meaning of Juneteenth

James Gunn confirms controversial scene from Superman trailer isn’t in the final cut

'Genetic optimization' sparks outcry: Critics say embryo ranking treats children as marketable goods

Woman sues former employer Truist Bank, citing fear of Chucky doll left on her chair

Rachel Zegler serenades the crowd for free in a new London production of 'Evita'

March and rally to be held in Glasgow to mark World Refugee Day

Prince of Wales and Cate Blanchett don lab coats to see eco brand at work

Veteran rocker, 90, shockingly turns down Rock and Roll Hall of Fame induction

Hackers say they wiped out $90 million from Iran cryptocurrency exchange

'The Hydro isn't real': Deacon Blue star on upbringing, career, and giving back

This extreme metal album blew up over a weekend – now it's accused of being AI

Cutting edge virtual production at Belfast studio ‘most advanced in the world’

Jurassic World Rebirth embraces hardcore horror: ‘I waited for the studio to say no’

Johnny Marr turned down ‘eye-watering’ Smiths reunion offer because the ‘vibe’ wasn’t right

Batman Begins writer reveals why Nolan didn't want him working on Affleck's Batman

Two vibrant new exhibitions opening at the Strathearn Gallery this summer

Nostalgia was once a disorder – now it's Holly Johnson in a sparkly jacket

How to watch ‘captivating’ true crime series A Body in the Snow after Karen Read’s trial

Vanessa Feltz guest apologises after ‘disgraceful’ remarks spark almost 2,000 complaints

You can now watch all 6 episodes of ‘brilliantly seductive’ period drama for free

From Tesco tills to 28 Years Later: Jodie Comer’s rise from shop floor to global stardom

Anoushka Lucas on her astonishing theatrical tour-de-force Elephant

Fans ‘cannot believe their luck’ as sun shines on Isle of Wight Festival

Nine Inch Nails at the O2: 'Trent Reznor is the last great art rock star'

Coldplay perform hit song for first time in 9 years

Google hits setback in bid to overturn multibillion EU antitrust fine in Android case

Hurricane Erick makes landfall in western Mexico state as a Category 3 storm

Sean 'Diddy' Combs trial takes a day off due a juror's illness

Iran's Arak heavy water reactor, hit by an Israeli airstrike, was part of Tehran's nuclear deal

SpaceX rocket explodes on platform during routine testing in Texas

Stephen Fry calls out ‘radicalised’ JK Rowling over ‘cruel’ trans views

Hulk Hogan representative addresses rumors that wrestling legend is on his death bed

James Prime: Deacon Blue star dies following cancer battle

‘Mind-bending’ horror film available to stream for free as sequel wows critics

OpenAI scores $200 million contract from Pentagon

Spider-Man cliffhanger to finally be resolved nearly 30 years later

Silent Witness star Emilia Fox’s ‘divisive’ true crime documentary now available online

Deacon Blue announce death of founder member Jim Prime after short cancer battle

Ruth Jones TV return confirmed after Gavin and Stacey with ‘irresistible’ period drama

Georgia Tennant: ‘The Pride flag feels heavier this June’

Ralph Fiennes warns new Voldemort in Harry Potter TV series of danger

4.48 Psychosis is still an agonising portrait of depression

The Waterfront true story: The real events that inspired Netflix drama

28 Years Later falls at the final hurdle

First Avengers: Doomsday teaser will be released sooner than you think

Aaron Taylor-Johnson playfully fuels speculation over new James Bond role

Race Across The World star emotionally reflects on the show after competing alongside her ex-husband

Trump, the world's No1 ignoramus, is out to destroy the rules-based world order

Stormzy: Lead acting role was uncomfortable but I loved it

Blake Lively and Taylor Swift messages can be included in legal case

Photos: How torn pictures and trusted herbs create healing in Colombia

James Bond favourite adds fuel to fire as he ‘can’t talk about’ next film

EastEnders star Michelle Collins admits to rocky start with co-star Adam Woodyatt: ‘We didn’t always get on’

Gary Oldman ‘would’ve fancied a go at Dumbledore’ after not being cast in Harry Potter TV series

28 Years Later boldly changes 28 Weeks Later plot twist within minutes

Netflix drops all 8 episodes of dark TV series ‘compared to Ozark’

Heston Blumenthal breaks down in tears as son admits: ‘Talking to you was horrible’

Aggie MacKenzie reveals ‘awful’ backstage scuffle with Kim Woodburn that started 16-year feud